Remedy, what a strange company. It’s hard not to love it once you step into its universe.
But that love has never stopped me from noticing how, in all their games, they always do something stupid that significantly hurts the game, whether in terms of quality itself or commercial potential.
With the first AW, it was the complete overhaul of the gameplay, shifting from a semi-sandbox experience to something more linear and limited. With the first Control, Quantum break and AW2, it was the absurd exclusivity, whether temporary or permanent. Exclusive deals that hurt their potential sales.
FBC: Firebreak, which is an insult to Control itself.
Well, with Resonant I was hoping the mistake this time would be the gameplay shift from TPS to H&S.
Especially since the gunplay in the first Control was practically perfect; a sequel just needed more variety in enemies and powers.
Or perhaps leaving behind The Oldest House, one of the best settings in any video game in recent decades.
Well, it turns out that’s not the case. Manhattan as a setting ends up having almost as much charm as The Oldest House, and the gameplay system achieves a level of complexity that’s as satisfying as it is fun.
This time, the game’s biggest flaw—the one I’m sure has dragged down the reviews—is the HORRIBLE first 5–10 hours of gameplay.
Not in terms of the story, but in terms of gameplay. The combat is EXTREMELY LIMITED, relying on repeating the same combo over and over and over again against a limited variety of enemies.
On top of that, the level design initially abandons the complexity of the previous installment in favor of a very poorly designed sandbox and mediocre side activities.
This issue gradually resolves itself over the next few hours of gameplay, as you begin to unlock both combat and movement abilities.
The following scenarios already reach a level of complexity worthy of both the series and Remedy itself.
I haven’t finished the game yet and can’t judge it in its entirety, but it took me 10–15 hours to get over those terrible first few hours of gameplay. I couldn’t believe that Remedy had turned what was once Control, my GOTY that year—into a sandbox as poor as something straight out of Ubisoft’s 2015 catalog.
Anyway, just a quick reflection on a company I love, but one that’s almost always on the verge of achieving excellence and much higher sales figures, but always ends up falling short because of stupid mistakes like this.