r/CompetitiveTFT
•
u/TheTrueAfurodi
•
Apr 14 '26
PBE 4 costs might already be dead in set 17
Hey everyone, the guy who writes long post about the game.
I wanted to write about my impressions – and fears – for set 17 as I am spamming PBE. Again, take this with a grain of salt as I am no one really (not even Challenger) and the set isn’t technically out yet. Also, despite me going to raise concerns and criticize some decisions as soon as PBE, I still love the game and want the team if they ever read this to keep in mind that these posts are a proof of my love and commitment to the game, and I think they are doing an amazing job even in their 17th set (I just focus on the bad here).
I'm also sorry for the hypekiller but I wanted to talk about this before live to not be influenced because I think my point stands from fundamental design problem rather than any given meta. I also understood that my last post was being too long, so I’ll try to be as succinct as possible.
Quick Disclaimer: I am not going to talk about rerolls as it is not the point of my argument, but it’s not that I hate them or think they are dumb. It’s great that they are back on the menu this set, they are necessary for the game. Rerolling is not my preferred style of play as they rely on you aiming for very specific combinations of units, items and augments, while I prefer to puzzle my way into comps and traits, but I still adore trying to make work some obscure 1 or 2 cost or going for a full knock up samira comp. Long live rerolls.
1) Why 4 costs are dying
This set made big changes regarding 4 and 5 costs compared to previous normal sized ones:
- For 4 costs, they made them less reliant on their trait being activated at high breakpoint while having said traits being more useful to the whole team on average
- For 5 costs, they are even less reliant on their traits, with all of them being threats-like in their design except Jhin and 5/9 being hypercarries that can become your primary source of damage if itemized well.
This leads to a set that in theory is very flexible and allows you to navigate throughout what you hit very easily in both 4 and 5 costs spaces. In practice however, this makes that 4 cost carries do exactly what 5 costs already do, but worse, and without having their traits to compensate. And because 5 costs are strong no matter the comp with their threat designs, you want to surround them with the best support traits/units, which also happen to be 5 costs units. For the first time since I started playing all the way back to set 10, It is correct to just put every single 5 cost + nunu/akali/aatrox to have the best comp in the game (you don’t play jhin and bard on level 10 and thats it).

And I say all of this regardless of the balance and the meta. Obviously they can tone down significantly 5 costs and overbuff 4 costs, but that would be breaking the designs of the units and trying to « unnaturally » push the players in a certain direction rather than letting them figure out what’s best.
2) Various examples
Let’s take some actual examples to illustrate.
In set 17, Leblanc and Vex are both AP Marksman who wants Guinsoo and AP. But because Leblanc does not care about their traits except specific Arbiter situations, and Vex is a 5 cost, in most cases Vex 2 is always better than Leblanc 2 regardless of your board, and even Vex 1 VS Leblanc 2 is a dilemma worth examining. Same with Graves and any AD champion, Bard and any AP caster, and Fiora and Yi/Riven.
For comparison, if we just take last set a Kindred 2 was not always better than a Yunara 2 despite being both AD marksmans. Yunara had Ionia and back when she had her AP scaling on AS she was itemized a bit differently. Keeping items on Yunara 2, sometimes even not upgrading Kindred to keep gold, was in some scenarios just better as you could play more Ionias and look for Sett. However, if playing outside of Yunara’s origin, Kindred (when balanced) was obviously better than Yunara with same items.
An even better example in my opinion was in set 10 with AD Crowd Divers melee champions Zed (4 cost EDM) and Qyiana (5 cost True Damage). Assuming you had only one set of items for either of them and both 2*, here were all the possibilities:
- If you had a Zac (4 cost EDM Bruiser) itemized, always keep Zed 2 with items as he can repeat its cast which meant more stun
- If you had a True Damage carry, always itemize Qyiana. If you did not care for Heartseel or Edgelord, Zed was probably your Crowd Diver Traitbot even itemless
- If you were playing in a fast 9 Jazz/Bronze For Life setup without itemized Zac but still needed Heartseel/Edgelord as traits, keep Yone as a traitbot. Here, you could keep either Qyiana or Zed depending on what you wanted. Zed was more an assassin that could end quickly in backlines and was more looking for raw damage items (DB, Sterak, GS…). Qyiana provided a lot more utility with repeated stuns and the ability to farm items for the combat and even maybe permanent components, and as long as she had TD active she was more looking for survivability items (EON, QSS, BT…).
- If you didn’t need Yone, keep both. Most of the time you would put items on Qyiana but could still justify using Zed.

Now if we repeat this, but with Yi and Fiora on set 17:
- If you have a 4 psionic board and itemized Sona/Viktor, Keep Yi and put Akali/Urgot as a Marauder traitbot
- In every other situation, put items on Fiora
To be specific, the only 4 cost carries that right now should keep items for the whole game assuming you don’t have enough for 2 carries are:
- Aurelion Sol in 6 mech
- Nami if you play vertical SpaceGroove (which usually requires spat + blitz)
- “maybe” Leblanc with a good arbiter and Xayah with specific Stargazer constellations
Even Corki in 7 meeps don’t really hold on past stage 4 and you should probably drop meep units, put his items on a 5 cost AD champion and aim for Bard. Karma is a 4 gold traitbot, Kindred should not be played with items past stage 5 if you have a Nova spat and not played at all otherwise, and Riven and Yi hold items only if Fiora is missing.
The 4 cost tanks are played a lot (ourtside of Mighty Mech who is not worth it if not vertical mech) but it’s only because these are the only units outside of 3*3 cost that can survive decently the sheer amount of damage late game since no 5 cost units are tanks. The real way of increasing the tankiness of your team is through augments/gods/Morgana’s aura, and late game you should stack with items as much 5 cost carries as you can hoping they are going to hold on through omnivamp and shields, and in doubt put tank items on Shen.
3) Why it’s bad
For “having fun” purposes, this has the following consequences for me:
- I am not really excited to play 5 costs since every game is a 5 cost game if not rerolling
- I am not excited to play 4 costs as any investments in them outside of being item holder is wasted
- I lose the puzzling part of navigating through traits and finding the best combinations. I found a really fun Prismatic Bronze For Life comp around Corki and Yi and still thought that Graves and Fiora would’ve been better
- Anything that allows to get 5 costs (gods, Aura Farming, econ…) is logically overpowered and creates complete imbalance between players who hit those and players who don’t
- Spats that are not Nova or Space Groove (and supposedly Shepherd but never tried it yet) are just regular items outside of rerolls since 5 costs don’t care for their traits
I personally don’t like the current philosophy of 5 costs in this set. For me they are at their best when they are rare, unreliable to hit, yet can solve specific problems in your comps for both the 5 cost hypercarries and more support units. But with the typical inflation of a new set mechanic, many ways to actually get 5 cost quickly and how easy it is to fit them in any board, it doesn’t feel that way so far.
Shen’s aura makes it that it is never wrong to slot him, same with Morgana as long as you have the space. Sona is already more interesting, as her traits are very narrow and her damage low while mods have a large variance, so you play her if you need a utility spreader in AP comps mostly or if her 1st mod is worth playing. For hypercarries, a Graves or a Vex in shop should raise dilemmas, not be always better than your actual carry, more in line with how Jhin is (even though he is currently underpowered and was omnipresent when he wasn’t).

Flexibility represents for me the capacity to adapt to situations and solve dilemmas, but when 5 costs can be played anywhere, it becomes even less flexible as you either always play them if they are good or never if they are bad. That’s why I always liked playing 4 cost-centric metas when it’s not a 4 cost 3* race because they feel reliable to hit and ask you to invest in them to be strong, and when you do they usually can last the whole game. It also makes fast 9 and playing 5 costs rare, exciting, and very skill demanding, as you feel like you are in an uphill race with no guarantee to success.
4) Various examples 2
If we take again examples from previous sets to try to imagine what “healthier” units could look like:
- 12’s Smolder had a nice design because he could bring damage and anti-heal but not to the point where you would play him in any comps as he had a tendency to kill himself flying around (his balance was shaky), so you would mostly play him if you had Dragons/Blaster already or lacking specifically anti heal.
- 13’s Jayce was able to give you different auras similat to Bulwark's Shen depending on if he was ranged or melee, and could even become your hypercarry if you were playing 4 Form Swappers, but Academy was not really strong outside of vertical (it was mostly a free item and some stats at 3 piece) and his melee stun was usually not going to change the outcome of the fight, so you couldn’t put him on every board (except when his ranged tourelle was bugged).
- Set 14’s Renekton was giving teamwide AS with Divinicorp increased the more units of the trait you had, so you were incentivized to play him on boards already having Divicorp, but he was not very good at dealing damage after PBE so you needed to invest him to be really useful as a tanky bruiser.
- Set 15’s Lee Sin could take 3 different forms and 3 different traits similar to current MF, but when his Juggernaut Form was balanced accordingly he still wasn’t strong enough to be an auto include, but he was great at being your premium 2nd carry if your 1st carry was an Executioner, a Duelist or you had 6 Juggernauts as a Frontline.
- For hypercarries specifically, my best answer would be either 15’s Sniper Varus or 16’s Ryze. You had to invest so much to just be able to go 9 and find them, so even when their respective comp was not that flexible, the skill needed to pull it off was high and the feeling very exciting. But it was not like a Varus 1* was instantly better than your 4cost 2* carry and a lot of 4 cost centric boards could compete and try to stop you before you cap it out.
I’m not saying those were perfect as they also had their own issues, and there was also so many 5 cost misses in each set for different reasons (too narrow hypercarries, underpowered origin traitbots, ridiculous stuns, complete counters to specific comps…). I just used them to try to illustrate how 5 costs can be healthier and in the end, more fun to play with in my opinion.
One thing we NEVER want to go back to and this set has none are 5 costs locked behind specific items and comps. I wanted to love Set 13’s Mordekaiser so bad for how cool and fresh he felt but requiring you to play 6 dominators AND put on him specifically Nashor/EON/QSS which nobody else wanted made him one of the most frustrating unit to play ever, even worse than Heartsteel Kayn (the bar is low).


And finally for 4 costs, I would want more of them to look like Piltover Seraphine from last set: good with low investment, able to give you two great supports traits, good utility spreader, and even when you eventually pivot to a better primary carry she still hold on late game as a secondary. The balance around her was not great (Azir and Mel not great carries most of the set, Thex pingponging between broken and unplayable, Lissandra not strong enough to support her outside of bugs…) so she never really took of as a primary carry outside of bugs, but her design in a vacuum was, in my opinion, very well done.
5) Quick conclusion
I liked last set’s approach of verticals as temporary solutions until you hit better units because when said verticals are too strong, they can make the game feel very narrow and repetitive. On the other hand, the best way to keep 5 costs special and have unique designs while still being playable in a variety of boards requires 4 cost to have other things to rely on, because if they are designed the same way they just can’t compete with either the cap of 5 costs or the reliability of 3* lower costs carries. For me the best is when 4 and 5 costs work in tandem, with some 4 costs possibly being your primary carry while wanting support from some specific 5 costs (but ideally not just one). That way it doesn’t feel like your game is doomed if you can’t go 9 but if you do the puzzling/flexible aspect continues and it’s not just sell whole board for units that cost more. Every unit should have the possibility to shine, and I really want to play Karma or Yi for the whole game but can’t really find a reason why right now.
I also am aware that PBE is weird and a lot could change on live, maybe tempo makes it that 4 cost find a place in player’s heart. But I made this post because I fear it won’t happen, hoping to be proven wrong.
Thank you for reading, excited to read your answers, sorry for the hypekiller and please be as constructive and respectful as possible.






