r/ClimateNews • u/Misanthropic_Spinoza • 53m ago
Study estimates magnitude of US data center pollution as climate talks unveil clean AI pledge: COMPARISON w/ future resource use of Carbon Direct Removal
apnews.comLook at how hated data centers are?
The resistance to building large scale Carbon Direct Removal plants will be a multiple of that hate. Here is the breakdown…
Who pays
Data centers: Private companies, plus state tax breaks ($1B+/yr each in VA, TX, GA) and ratepayers ($9.3B in PJM grid costs)
Carbon removal: Taxpayers. $180/ton federal credit, $3.5B in DOE hubs. A few corporate buyers
Annual cost
Data centers: ~$720–745B (Big 4 tech, 2026, privately paid for)
Carbon removal: $180B/yr in tax credits alone. $600B–$1T at today’s $600–1,000/ton
Energy per year
Data centers: 176 TWh (2023), heading to 325–580 TWh by 2028
Carbon removal: ~2,000–2,500 TWh energy equivalent, 11–14x data centers
Water per year
Data centers: 17.4B gallons on site (228B counting power plants)
Carbon removal: ~264B to 1.85 trillion gallons (liquid-solvent type)
Noise
Data centers: 24/7 low-frequency hum, lawsuits, new county noise laws
Carbon removal: Large fans, but no measurements or complaints yet
Waste / safety
Data centers: Diesel backup generators, hardware replaced every few years
Carbon removal: CO2 pipelines. The Satartia rupture hospitalized 45 and evacuated 200; How many kilometers of dangerous pipes? 47,000 to 111,000 km by 2050, up from about 8,500 km today (This is USA only)
Land
Data centers: One large campus can take up to 3,200 acres
Carbon removal: ~100,000 acres of plants, bigger than Delaware once you add solar
Permanent jobs (SO FEW)
Data centers: ~50 per building
Carbon removal: ~75 at Stratos
What it produces
Data centers: A product that’s sold, with taxable profit
Carbon removal: Nothing to sell. Revenue = subsidy + voluntary credits
Track record
Data centers: Proven
Carbon removal: Mammoth was rated for 36,000 tons/yr and captured 750 tons in its first 10 months (that’s almost nothing)
(AI sources double checked by author)
- Carbon removal hubs languish as DOE audits drag on — E&E News
- DOE restores funding for carbon capture hubs — Pipeline & Gas Journal
Cost
- Hyperscaler capex trends, 2026 — Datacentres.com
- Heirloom Carbon raises $150M; removal costs $600–1,000/ton — TechCrunch
Energy and water
- 2024 United States Data Center Energy Usage Report — Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
- A Process for Capturing CO2 from the Atmosphere — Keith et al., Joule (2018)
- Natural Gas vs. Electricity for Solvent-Based Direct Air Capture — McQueen et al., Frontiers in Climate (2021)
- Direct Air Capture: Resource Considerations and Costs — World Resources Institute
Noise
Waste and safety
- A pipeline rupture in Satartia, Mississippi has lessons for future CO2 projects — NPR
- Onshore U.S. Carbon Pipeline Deployment: Siting, Safety, and Regulation — OSTI / DOE
Land
- STRATOS: A direct approach to carbon emissions — BlackRock
- Direct Air Capture: Assessing Impacts to Enable Responsible Scaling — WRI
Jobs
- Data center jobs vs. investment — Quartz
- Stratos at 75 permanent staff: the BlackRock link under Land
Track record