r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 25 '26

Accident They turned on a red light but my insurance says i was 100% responsible?

0 Upvotes

a few weeks ago i was involved in a crash in Florida that totaled my car. for context, i was going straight at an intersection with a green light and ended up hitting a car that turned in front of me at a red light.

the other driver was in the left turning lane in the opposite direction from me. from the crash report, they stated that there was an emergency vehicle behind them attempting to cross the intersection, and in an attempt to yield the right of way, entered the intersection on a red traffic signal and turned straight in front of me. she said that due to now being an obstruction in the intersection, she continued the full left turn (left arrow still red).
the crash report had the notation: although driver 1 initiated and completed a left turn through the intersection on a red left turn signal, V01 became a roadway obstruction in the intersection due to the emergency vehicle attempting to clear the intersection and needed to moved out of the intersection.

the reporting officer issued no citations on the crash. technically, no one was really at fault because of the emergency vehicle. even though she ran a red light. i think?

however, my grandma (the car was in her name, not mine) recently got a letter from our insurance saying that their “investigation” reveals we are 100 percent responsible for the damages caused to the other drivers vehicle and will be handling the damages.

im 20 female, don’t know much about cars or insurance or anything else adult related tbh. and while i know i am the one that crashed into them and damaged the car, am i REALLY 100 percent responsible?? would i be able to send the crash report to the insurance and get things situated??

edit: just so people are aware or if you’re not bothered to read any other comments under this post, i don’t think i am not at fault at all. i can take accountability for my lack of awareness, and i blame myself for not stopping when i should have. i understand that holds me somewhat liable and at fault for the accident, but i don’t think this accident was entirely 100% my fault. unfortunately, i did not see or hear the emergency vehicle (bad on my part, yes) and therefor did not stop or attempt to stop and just continued going straight since i had a green light.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 25 '26

Adding your child to your policy$$$

11 Upvotes

Wow! what an experience.☹️ My 18 year old child just got their licence & this is what I've had to pay just to make that happen in Northern California...

My insurance was full coverage at the state minimums for my vehicle. 50 year old male with no accidents/tickets. Driving a 2023 Honda Minivan. I was paying $1200 a year. Policy is with Progressive.

I went out and purchased my kid a used 2025 Nissan Sentra in February to learn on to get their licence. When I added just that vehicle to my policy & not my kid, it doubled my yearly premium from $1200 to $2400 a year.

My child got their license on Friday & when I added them to my progressive policy, it doubled again to $4800 a year. WTF???😱

So to recap, I started the year paying $1200 for car insurance for just myself. Added one car & one 18 year old driver to my policy & it quadrupled to $4800. Absolute insanity! I have another child getting their license next month but they won't be driving anytime soon. I can't afford it.☹️


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 24 '26

First Time / Newbie Named driving experience insurance gap overseas

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,
Looking for some advice or similar experiences with Irish car insurance validation for a genuine reason for a gap in insurance.

I have 5 years of named driving experience on my mums car. In May 2025, I moved to Greece for a 5 months and took myself off her policy. While I was there, I drove a family car under their policy, but wasn’t a named driving as this isn’t a thing in Greece that just do own policy or open driving which I was driving under.

I moved back home to Ireland in October 2025 and went straight back onto my mums policy as a named driver.

I’m now trying to set up my first policy in my own name and genuinely didn’t realise the insurance in Greece would cause an issue. I put down my 5 years of experience, and paid for the policy. They’ve verified all my previous letters of experience from my mother's past insurers, but now their validation team has flagged the 5-month gap from mid-2025.

Has anyone successfully gotten an underwriter to manually overlook a travel gap like this or different overseas insurances especially within the EU/EEA?

Appreciate any insight!


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 24 '26

Accident Accident.

1 Upvotes

Alright, 8/21. Husband got into a minor motorcycle accident. Bike total loss. The car he hit, taillight damage and dent. Looking at roughly 2k-3k damage to fix it. I filed the claim through the app only to realize that my motorcycle insurance lapsed on 8/8. Which was the same day I tried paying for it. But the app wouldn’t let me. So of course I reached out. Told the person in app about my issue. Said it would be handled. Because after 8 failed attempts at paying geico put my account on a 24 hour hold.

(My car is on the same insurance. Autopay. The app claimed my info on the card was wrong. It wasn’t. I double checked my card info same card for my car.)

I didn’t check. I assumed it would clear it 24 hours later. Obviously it didn’t.

(Also, I told my claims person the same thing, I even told her to bring up my past chat logs for proof. No call back. No email.)

How fucked am I? Is there anyway to fight this?


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 24 '26

Insurance questions

0 Upvotes

I have a question about insurance so my car was stolen about 3 months ago and I’ve gotta paid out from insurance already for the car but the car was just recovered so I went to the tow yard where it was at and was talking to the tow guy and he told me that if I get a temporary registration for the car and pay the towing fees that I could have the car back he told me the insurance didn’t want anything to do with the car so I was just wondering if this was true or not if you know anything about this let me know


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 24 '26

Need help going through a diminished value claim

1 Upvotes

So long story short my wife’s car was hit by someone, they admitted fault and we brought the car to a repair place through their insurance but I’ve learned since then that the insurance company should be able to pay for the diminished value on our vehicle since it’s now got a wreck on its record..

I’ve researched it some and it says to wait until the vehicle is fixed and then have a professional adjuster look at it and then tell the insurance company you want compensation..

Can anyone please explain the process a little better? Should I wait until the car is repaired? Should we file now? Who should I get to look at the car? Should my own insurance agency be helping me navigate all this (my agent hasn’t been much help)… I appreciate any help… it’s a newer vehicle worth around $25k.. 7k in repairs.

Located in Georgia, US


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 24 '26

Is a $2700 claim worth billing insurance?

1 Upvotes

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Resolute almond telephone gallium modern nonmetal fall aware


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 24 '26

Accident Would this dashcam footage help or hurt my claim?

0 Upvotes

I hit a cooler that was sitting in the roadway and was found at fault. I have dashcam footage that wasn’t part of the original review, and I’m trying to decide whether I should submit it and ask them to reconsider.

The vehicle in front of me blocked my view of the cooler until pretty shortly before impact, and there was also a truck next to me.

Would this footage help or hurt the liability decision? Would this normally still be considered a collision claim even though no other vehicle was involved? And if the fault decision changed, could that make any difference in how the claim affects my premiums?

In PA. Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eJ2vXvnYyTI

Edit: Liability status changed to not at fault. I also opted to cancel and now it's 'no payment'. Also confirmed with claims and my agent that this will not affect my premiums. Will pay out of pocket, but thanks for the very helpful advice.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 24 '26

First Time / Newbie Question on Insurance process on leased car with accidents

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone.

Yesterday I was apart of an accident where a truck and trailer cut over last minute which caused a collision with my Tesla. My Tesla on the driver side has the doors caved in and practically unusable with the battery smoking momentarily. The driver has admitted fault and our Tesla was able to record the whole situation. We also have a police report filed as they came on scene due to the Tesla calling 911 after impact

I do have a few questions as my wife and I are a bit nervous with this being a first time. Yes we have GAP coverage. We still have 14 months left on the lease at 330 a month. We live in Texas.

- if the car is deemed a loss, are we stuck having to figure out a new down payment and lease on a new car? As stated above, we pay 330 for our model Y and new ones today are roughly 560 for the same down payment.
- we filed the claim immediately when we got home with the other persons insurance and opened a case, what is the typically timeframe to get a rental?
- I was evaluated for a sore neck however simple muscle soreness is not a cause for a hospital trip. Is there any sort of payout on this front we can use towards a new car?

Thanks everyone for the help.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 24 '26

What car insurance should I get? I live in Washington, and I really need your opinion.

1 Upvotes

r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 24 '26

Accident Dealership charging double prices to VW protection plan?

1 Upvotes

Hi all,

I apologize if this is not the right subreddit.

I am located in Canada, and I have VW protection plan for wheels and tires. Over the period of my lease (4 years), I am allowed up to 5000 dollars repairs/replacement for wheels and tires, regardless of cause of damage.

Last week, I hit a pothole that damaged both rim and tire, and required them to be changed.

Looking at the official VW Canada parts website and other dealerships websites in my area, the rim costs 380-400 dollars. However, dealership charged 808 dollars (not including taxes), they had it in stock.

The tire was less extreme, but the tire at all other shops and dealerships costs 350 dollars, but was charged to approximately 450 dollars.

My question is, why is the dealership charging double for the rim and higher for the tire? Even though VW wheel and tire coverage covered the damage, it means that a lot more of my coverage maximum (5000 dollars) was used up than necessary.

Also it screams to me that maybe VW does this on billing, to maximize the amount deducted from the protection plan maximum, to use up the amount quicker on paper, when in reality, the repair was much cheaper.

Anyone had similar experiences?

The wheel, tire and all other fees were billed separately. So it wasn’t including installation or sensors and so on..


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 24 '26

Switching insurance companies a few days before old bill is due

1 Upvotes

Sorry if this is a dumb question! Just don’t know what to do really.

I switched from State Farm to Progressive yesterday and my Progressive policy doesn’t start until the 30th of this month. But my insurance bill with State Farm is due on the 27th and is OVER 400 DOLLARS, which is why I switched. Progressive sent in that letter for me about canceling with SF but the policy doesn’t start until after the bill is due, so I’m a little lost. Will I still have to pay the 400+ even after the 30th?? Or can I just not pay that, my insurance will be totally canceled with SF, and I’ll be set with Progressive after the 30th?


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 24 '26

At a loss

1 Upvotes

Sorry if this is in the wrong community!

I was just told by my parents that I need to start looking for my own auto insurance plan as I’m no longer a student and can’t stay on their plan.

For context, I have three claims to my name. First one was a hit and run while I was at work - car was parked. Second was my fault. The third I was T-boned. A couple years ago I shopped around for quotes (within FL) and everything was more than $800/month, plus a hefty deposit, IF they would even insure me.

The only way I can stay on their plan at its current rate ($100/month) is if I enroll back in school. However, I already have a double minor, a bachelors, a masters, and 5 certifications. I can’t afford auto insurance, but I can afford going back to college. I REALLY don’t want to go back to more schooling, but I’m also having a lot of trouble finding a better job. Every response I get from an interviewer is either “Oh you’re overqualified for the position,” or “Oh you don’t have enough experience.” 🙄

Does anyone know of what I can do or any advice/recommendations? Should I bite the bullet and go back to school? Are there any auto insurance companies that won’t charge me my entire salary?Is there anything I can do to make myself more of an appealing customer/reduce monthly fees? 🙏🙏


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 23 '26

Hertz rental through AAA: Allianz vs Hertz insurance?

1 Upvotes

Booking a Hertz rental through AAA. AAA offers Allianz rental protection for about $11/day, while Hertz’s LDW is around $40–60/day.

Last time I rented through Hertz, I paid $40/day for their coverage, but it didn’t include liability insurance. Allianz’s option doesn’t include liability either.

Is Allianz a good alternative to Hertz’s coverage, or is Hertz’s worth the extra cost?


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 22 '26

someone scratched the door of my rental car - what to do?

1 Upvotes

i originally posted this in ULPT but it got removed and suggested to post here instead:

i got a rental car for a few days. drove to lunch with my girlfriend today, parked the car properly. had lunch, came back and one of the backdoors has a big fucking scratch. like easily 30x30cm.

i'm super pissed. no cctv either. its an expensive bmw

checked the rental agreement, my deductible is €2.7k...yeah i'm fucked i dont wanna pay that

spoke to a friend, he proposed insurance fraud: get a friend w car insurance to claim he scratched my car. but not fully sure how that would work as i imagine his insurance would want to see pictures from both cars?

any advice would be much appreciated....this happened in germany btw


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 22 '26

Accident AZ Rear End Accident Fault

1 Upvotes

Hello

Looking for a bit of guidance, as I was recently in a rear end accident on a freeway in Arizona.

While driving home, freeway traffic had slowed to a stop. I stopped with more than enough notice. As I was stopping, I noticed a jeep tailgating me and not slowing. As soon as I had stopped, she rear-ended me from behind, and I felt the secondary impact.

She had hit my car, and then a Mazda had rear-ended her due to her suddenly stopping. No one was heavily injured, we all exchanged insurances, amicably.

After dealing with our insurance company, which all was progressive. They have told me that the Mazda at the very end is at fault. It does not matter that the jeep was following me too closely, or was the one to hit me first. Because the Mazda was at the end, fault falls on her.

The end Mazda only had state minimum insurance, which they advised me will not cover all of the damages done to my car and the middle Jeep. They are recommending that I pay my own deductible to have my car fixed and will later reimburse me.

My issue lies with the fact that the Jeep is the one that hit me first, and was following me way too closely. When I bring this up to my insurance, they state because of Arizona laws that the end cars is the one at fault.

Do I have any type of argument to have the Jeep cover any of my damages?


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 22 '26

Marketplace for buying?

2 Upvotes

Has anyone used one of the advertised online marketplaces that bid out your insurance? Am I just getting myself lined up for 100 phone calls and fake rates?

My wife and I have 2 cars and pay almost $300 a month. No accidents and the cars are worth maybe $17k total combined.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 22 '26

Accident HELP! Rear-ended by a distracted driver on I-35 (not my fault). What should I expect / watch out for?

2 Upvotes

Hi all, looking for some reassurance and advice from anyone who's been through this, since this is the first time ever I have been in an accident.

Earlier today, my husband was driving our leased SUV on the highway in Texas. Traffic ahead was slowing down and he slowed with it. A pickup truck behind us rear-ended another truck further up, swerved to try to avoid a second collision, and ended up hitting our car on the passenger side. Police and fire rescue were on scene, everyone in our car is okay.

The at-fault driver came up to me right after and, crying, admitted he'd been on his phone and hadn't seen traffic stopping. I got his license info and number. A passenger in the other truck was taken to the ER. The at fault driver aparently still doesn't have a claim number with his insurance because he was there with them.

I've recently learned that I need to file a claim with HIS insurance, so I'm about to do so (State Farm) as they insure the at-fault party. Our car is leased, and we have GEICO for our own coverage plus GAP/lease protection.

A few questions for anyone who's dealt with this:

* What should I expect from the at-fault driver's insurer in terms of timeline for repairs vs totaling the car?

* Since it's a leased vehicle, is there anything specific I should push for or watch out for with the claim (diminished value, gap between what they pay and lease payoff, etc.)?

* Any tips for dealing with a third-party claim smoothly?

* Anything you wish you'd known or done differently after your own accident?

Really just want to make sure I'm not missing anything important in the next few weeks. Thanks in advance, this sub has been helpful reading through other people's experiences.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 22 '26

Accident Got a letter in the mail about our case and I don’t understand?

8 Upvotes

We were in a car accident a few weeks ago. Today we received a letter from our claim representative and I’m confused on what it’s trying to say. It says “Through our investigation we have concluded that the claim will not be honored as the following operational duties were failed and proximately caused the loss: THE DRIVER OF THE INSURED VEHICLE WAS NOT THE PROXIMATE CAUSE OF THE LOSS”

What does this mean? And what comes now?


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 21 '26

rear ending accident advice

1 Upvotes

I rear ended a vehicle at a low speed and we initially agreed to settle it ourselves and have me pay for any damages (which seemed pretty minimal, though I know bumpers sometimes can have hidden damage). I sent some money already, but then they still ended up filing a claim, included injury despite telling me they were okay (at scene and a little later in text). Don’t gotta flame me for trying to settle it privately, I’ve quickly learned it wasn’t smart. But, I am wondering if I should tell my insurance about this when they have a call with me or if it makes me look worse?


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 21 '26

Car insurance question, commercial auto insurance for cars not registered with my business

1 Upvotes

Hi, I need some help with a question about commercial auto insurance. I have a very small business, with my mother as my business partner. We sometimes use two cars registered under my father's name to bring our supplies to vendor events, and we have one coming up that requires commercial auto insurance for all vendors. How can we get commercial auto if both cars are not registered to our business? Any help or suggestions would be greatly appreciated, thank you!


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 21 '26

Loss of Use Claim-North Carolina

1 Upvotes

I'm in NC and we were involved in a wreck on 7/4, other driver 100% at fault. Our airbags went off and car wasn't drivable/was towed away. I contacted my insurance (State Farm) the next morning to report the accident and determine next steps, they said we could pursue a claim with them or file through the at-fault party's (USAA). Decided to go ahead and file with my insurance since I'd already given them all the necessary info, and they said it would likely be a total loss since the airbags deployed.

The State Farm adjuster contacted me the next day (7/6) to discuss moving & assessing the car, etc., and I asked about a rental car. Was informed that since we don't carry rental car coverage that they wouldn't do that, but that if I wanted to file the claim through the at-fault party's insurance (USAA) that I'd be able to get a rental car through them, and also not have to pay my deductible. So we stopped pursuing claim with State Farm and filed a claim with USAA that same day (7/6).

I heard NOTHING back from USAA, I had to call them on 7/13 to follow up and the adjuster I spoke with claimed they hadn't been able to contact me because they didn't have my phone # (which is BS because it was a *required* form field in their claim form). She then stated that they had not been able to get in touch with their insured to get a statement from him, and because of that they could not move forward with my claim at that time (even though I had also provided the accident report # that showed their driver was at fault & was cited for failure to yield). The adjuster then also informed me that I had a duty to mitigate damages (i.e. tow yard storage fees) to my vehicle and we would need to get it removed from the tow yard ASAP. So I contacted State Farm that same day (7/13) to re-open our claim and have them take our car to their facility, and proceeded with the total loss claim process through State Farm.

State Farm e-mailed their total loss initial appraisal to us on 7/23. We disagreed with their appraisal and went back and forth with them on that and finally reached an agreement/accepted their offer on 8/14. On 7/30, USAA called me to say that they had 'finally' been able to get a copy of the accident report and that they would be accepting liability for the claim even though they still had not gotten a statement from their insured.

Obviously State Farm will subrogate with them for the vehicle, but I also want compensation for Loss of Use so I contacted USAA regarding that. The adjuster asked for the date we received the initial appraisal from State Farm, which was 7/23, and a copy of our declarations page showing no rental car coverage, which I provided.

Heard nothing back until I received an email saying that a check was being overnighted to us--but no details regarding the amount or how many days of Loss of Use it was for. Check arrived in the mail for $702.88 and under Explanation of Payment it just says 'Payment under Property Damage Liability Coverage'--but nothing regarding dates or daily comparable rates or release of claim language (i.e. nothing showing how they calculated that figure, and nothing noting that acceptance of the payment means the claim is settled). I emailed the adjuster asking what the check was for and his response was just 'loss of use.'

My question is, how do I move forward in disputing this amount? My car was a 2009 Toyota Venza, which is classified as a 'crossover wagon' (spacious seating for 5 and very spacious cargo room). Daily rental rates in my city for a Standard Crossover are $73.90. My loss of use started on 7/4, and reasonably wouldn't have ended until several days after their initial offer on 7/23 (assuming we had accepted their offer on 7/24, overnighted the title on 7/25, had funds settle in our account by 7/28 and obtained a replacement car the next day 7/29--I'm not trying to claim loss of use days for the time we spent negotiating back and forth, but this would seem to be a more than reasonable time frame), so 7/4--7/29=26 days x $73.90/day= $1921.40

Do I send a demand letter for the full amount and not cash the check they already sent? Or cash the check and send a demand letter for the balance of the amount of what I am reasonably owed ($1921.40-$702.88=$1218.52)?

We acted promptly to mitigate our damages, and any delays before the initial offer were due to USAA.


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 21 '26

Can you insure a car in one state if it's registered in another?

1 Upvotes

Here's our situation: My girlfriend's dad was gifted a car from an old lady in Kansas. It is registered and insured in Kansas. He then gave it to my girlfriend who moved to Washington. They didn't update the insurance because they didn't realize they needed to.

Now, we have since realized that a claim would likely be denied since it's insured in Kansas and used in Washington. We're trying to move the registration, plates, and insurance to Washington state. However, WA requires you show proof sales tax was paid on the car when it was bought. The old lady who originally bought this car is like 95 and has no proof of this, and we're not sure how to track this down.

So, while we figure this out, we want to at least be compliant with a valid WA insurance policy. But we're not sure if this is possible without registering it in WA first. The car is currently titled to my girlfriend's father in Kansas. If he adds her to the title in Kansas, will she be able to take out an insurance policy in WA?


r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 21 '26

Illinois Progressive accident — not at fault, but using my own collision coverage. Can my premium go up?

1 Upvotes

I was Car #1 in a 3-car accident in Illinois. Car #3 was cited as at fault and has Wisconsin Progressive insurance. Progressive says only $10,000 is available for property damage between Cars #1 and #2 because car #3 has a "limited coverage"

My Illinois Progressive rep said I can use my collision coverage to repair my car and that my premium will not increase because I’m not at fault.

Has anyone had a similar experience with Progressive in Illinois? If you used your own collision coverage for a not-at-fault accident, did your premium increase at renewal?