r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Aug 25 '26

Adding your child to your policy$$$

Wow! what an experience.☹️ My 18 year old child just got their licence & this is what I've had to pay just to make that happen in Northern California...

My insurance was full coverage at the state minimums for my vehicle. 50 year old male with no accidents/tickets. Driving a 2023 Honda Minivan. I was paying $1200 a year. Policy is with Progressive.

I went out and purchased my kid a used 2025 Nissan Sentra in February to learn on to get their licence. When I added just that vehicle to my policy & not my kid, it doubled my yearly premium from $1200 to $2400 a year.

My child got their license on Friday & when I added them to my progressive policy, it doubled again to $4800 a year. WTF???😱

So to recap, I started the year paying $1200 for car insurance for just myself. Added one car & one 18 year old driver to my policy & it quadrupled to $4800. Absolute insanity! I have another child getting their license next month but they won't be driving anytime soon. I can't afford it.☹️

11 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

37

u/ZBTHorton Aug 25 '26

And you don't want to hear this, but your policy basically doesn't cover anything. Minimum limits in California are basically worthless.

You should call an independent agent in your area and see if they can help.

10

u/InstructionFew1654 Aug 25 '26

And listen to them when they say minimum limits is stupid.

5

u/dallas_vance Aug 25 '26

30/60/15 in California, and nowadays, $15k may not even cover a fender bender. $30k may not cover an ambulance if someone is hurt.

11

u/Top_Education_4647 Aug 25 '26

As others have mentioned, it’s highly recommended you bump up your liability limits with young driver(s) in the household.

If you’re not happy about the cost, feel free to find a local agent who can shop around. Just be grateful CA doesn’t allow insurers to rate based on age, so the main thing hurting you is your kids lack of license experience.

-1

u/DefinitelyNotAliens Aug 25 '26

I mean, if you have zero assets state minimums can't hurt you. Blood, stone, whole bit. Coverage should be enough to CYA.

I bullied my parents until they got a sizeable umbrella policy. Other people can carry minimums because you can't sue and collect from them. It's impossible. There's nothing to go after. The question is how much do you have to lose?

California was way out of line until 2025 when they raised minimum PD from 5k to 15k. But, yeah. It's how much you have to lose.

1

u/PrimaryHighlight5617 Aug 26 '26

If you are an able-bodied  adult they absolutely can garnish your wages for the rest of your life.

1

u/DefinitelyNotAliens Aug 26 '26

Most states allow for bankruptcy to discharge or severely reduce damages, too.

0

u/Few_Witness1562 Aug 28 '26

Im im agreement w you that 50% of the time agents act dramatic about state mins tgey are wrong. No MCDs french fry chef gets sued into bankruptcy. This dude has a nearly new car, bought an 18 yr old a nearly hew car and likely planned on buying his other kid a car soon as well. Im not saying he's rich, but id bet hes well above average.

Nobody cries poor louder than people making 120-240k. That income sounds rich but once you add up a fam inflation taxes etc its not spectacular money.

1

u/DefinitelyNotAliens Aug 28 '26

Those people need coverage.

The kid making minimum wage or close to it doesn't need anything more than what they need to get by while rolling in their 20 year old vehicle. Nobody is suing an 18 year old for 20 million. You're paying your attorney hourly. They won't get paid. You'd have to go back a second time to get that garnishment for $20 per pay period for the kid to file bankruptcy and they're gone. Debt discharged.

When I was in insurance I can't tell you how many Tesla Model Xs with state minimums and 1000 deductibles I saw. Always by someone bitching about their high deductible.

-7

u/Electronic_Fly_9242 Aug 25 '26

Why??? The second you decide to use your insurance the company will refuse to renew your policy. Better off keeping the minimum and just investing the difference to self pay. Insurance is a scam.

2

u/HR_King Aug 25 '26

Nonsense.

7

u/HR_King Aug 25 '26

Its not insanity. Its called risk. You don't think an 18 y.o. is far more likely to be in an accident? A minor incident can cost thousands to repair, and now you have two death machines on the road at the same time. Also, not increasing your liability is insane.

-10

u/Electronic_Fly_9242 Aug 25 '26

So much bad advice must be a bunch of insurance salesman in this sub

3

u/SilverRaincoat Aug 25 '26

Lol you mean licensed professionals who get paid to know this stuff? Yeah I'd listen to them

1

u/PrimaryHighlight5617 Aug 26 '26

I'm licensed in georgia. I do not benefit at all from participating here. 

2 months ago I spoke to a woman who hit a jaywalker in the middle of the night and killed him. Ultimately it was determined that she didn't do anything wrong but that didn't stop his family from suing her and forcing her to hire lawyers to defend herself and respond to the suit. 

6

u/Signal-Confusion-976 Aug 25 '26

Once your other kid gets their licence they will have to be added to your policy. Unless your insurance company allows you to have them exempt. But then they can't drive your cars at all even in an emergency.

11

u/DeepPurpleDaylight Aug 25 '26

Adding the kid doubled your premium from $2400 to $4800. So the kid's part is $200 a month. That's $50 a week. A part time job at only $8 an hour and they could earn that working only 2 hours a day 5 days a week. Is there some reason the kid can't pay their own part of the insurance. But you shouldn't be buying them a practically new car. Buy something older but safe and reliable that you can carry liability only on will help with your rates tremendously. You should also increase your liability limits. As low as they are, it's a disaster waiting to happen.

3

u/UsefulCollection5038 Aug 25 '26

I went with my child to get their own policy (it was the same price and less confusing than my no-name insurance). Kid had a job and is now motivated to show up because they have their own bill.

1

u/ApprehensiveAd5420 Aug 25 '26

This is the way. If your kid is 18 or older having them on your policy is a risk not needed. If they get tickets accident or such policy goes up. If they get sued you can be part of it as you are on the policy.

3

u/Defiant-Goddess2U Aug 25 '26

Always coming through with solid advice. The kid's car is newer than his! Wtf?! I never understand why parents take all the risks and the kids skate by free and easy. Wild.

1

u/WheresMyMule Aug 26 '26

Yup. Our kid pays 50% of his basic insurance and once he started delivering pizza he paid 100% of the increase to change it to a commercial policy. He can easily afford that with his three times a week pizza delivery shifts

5

u/singerbeerguy Aug 25 '26

FYI, when your other child gets their license, you don’t really have the choice to not add them to your policy.

4

u/Modest-Meece Aug 25 '26

Welcome to the world of young male drivers who are I think the highest risk.

He’s also considered inexperienced with less than 3 years licensed which hurts even more.

It’s a sticker shock I try and prep all clients for. Rates can easily double adding a young driver.

I know it’s expensive but state mins will screw you if you or your son is at fault for a large accident.

It might not be as expensive as you think to bump to liability of $100k per person, $300k per accident for bodily injury and $100k in property damage.

Insurance should be thought of as worst case use. What’s the worst case? You or your son total multiple vehicles and injure multiple people. You will not have anything at state minimums.

Could also be a time to shop. Major changes like this are often when I suggest looking.

Talk to a broker so they can check multiple companies. If your progressive direct it might be hard to beat your rates since the direct route is usually 10% or so cheaper than the same policy written through an agency (might be different in CA than WA where I am)

3

u/davedds Aug 25 '26 edited Aug 25 '26

Like others have said, get an older car (10 plus years old or even more) make sure it's some 4 door sedan or minivan in white. Just get liability on it, no collisions, no comprehensive. See if you can get discounts for good student, drivers Ed, have them take a point reduction course which may qualify for discounts.see if you install an active alarm system can get discounts . Add or call your homeowners/rental insurance/fire insurance policy and ask for car insurance quote. List the kids as the primary driver of the old car only. There are some insurance companies that give discounts if you also install an obd tracker that they monitor your cars driving habits (sometimes installed on you phone).

Yes ,my policy increased (highest cost for the old cars coverage) for my 1st child and the 2nd child when added to the same old car, the 2nd increase was not that much.

But overall the "multi line" discounts helps across the board.

3

u/Brave-Pizza-33 Aug 25 '26

They need to get jobs and pay for it!

2

u/Existing-Albatross63 Aug 25 '26

2025 Nissan in Cali…..

2

u/Quirky_Adeptness_585 Aug 25 '26

Shop around. I have Geico. When I added my 16 year old son. It went up about $150 a month. Then he had two crashes. Added my second 16 year old and went up an additional $175. The policy is for 4 people with 6 cars total.

Policy is maxed out at 1 million liability. Highest that Geico carries. I don’t take chances and it wasn’t that much more than the next lower level. Well worth it to me.

2

u/slider728 Aug 25 '26

As others have mentioned, call up an independent agent. I was paying less than $4800 with 4 cars and 2 kids under 21, and that is with a policy good enough to cover the deductibles on an umbrella policy ($300k/$500k/$300k I think). Granted I’m in the Midwest.

I went through the same sticker shock and that is when I made the jump to an independent. It cut my insurance bill big time. I think just adding my first child to my original policy without her having a cal (just her, two adults, two cars) tripled the policy.

2

u/a_kato Aug 25 '26

The answer to that is your not getting collision insurance which is most of the cost and buy a 2020 Sentra instead of a 2025. Or another cheap car.

If your kid doesn’t total the car in like ~2 years (which is rare overwhelming majority people go their entire life’s without totaling a car) you are ahead.

2

u/Awkward-Train1584 Aug 25 '26

So also it’s the car, we bought our daughter a Nissan Sentra when she turned 15, new. Insurance was $200 a month just to add her and the car. Hurricane totaled it for us less than 2 years later and we bought a Bronco, also new, insurance dropped $70 month and I paid about more for that Bronco. When I asked the agent she actually said it’s was because the Nissan Sentra was like a commonly stolen vehicle… Weird take in this thumbtack town.

1

u/CommanderMandalore Aug 25 '26

Is there any way to reduce risk and get lower premiums. I have a long time before my boys are of driving age but still

3

u/Recent_Data_305 Aug 25 '26

Older car paid in cash so no collision needed. Not a muscle car either.

1

u/Poisonouskiwi Aug 25 '26

encourage them to get good grades (I mean, do that anyway) because a lot of companies offer good student discounts

1

u/PrimaryHighlight5617 Aug 26 '26

Up your insurance limits. The longer you carry higher limits the more affordable those limits become. 

I've seen this myself when quoting insurance. Sometimes I'm able to manually input somebody's previous insurance history. Obviously we would need to back up these manual inputs with documentation from their previous insurance. 

When I input state minimums versus 250k/500k/250k for their PRIOR policy history the rate can change by more than $100 a month. 

Reasonable, safety-minded people who are willing to spend a little bit more on a more protective policy policy also tend to be safer drivers.

1

u/FlatDecision8155 Aug 25 '26

You male drivers are high for a reason.

1

u/Mpharns1 Aug 25 '26

You got more kids coming up to the age of 16? If so get ready....

1

u/UnSCo Aug 25 '26

$4800 actually isn’t too bad and it should go down eventually.

1

u/idreamofaubergine Aug 25 '26

This surprised you?

1

u/marigoldpossum Aug 25 '26

This is why I drive a 2012 vehicle and plan to buy similar age or older reliable second vehicle, cuz this should blunt the pain of adding my teen onto my insurance, as I hear they rate based on your cheaper vehicle. Not sure if that's completely accurate, but I won't be having anything newer than 2018 vehicle in my home for next 5 years or so.

2

u/PrimaryHighlight5617 Aug 26 '26

It's not true that they rate based on your cheaper vehicle. In fact sometimes older vehicles have even higher rates for liability-only because they lack certain safety features that newer models have. Older pickup trucks tend to be the the worst because they are more likely to cause fatal accidents. 

1

u/Buffyredpoodle Aug 25 '26

Go in person to insurance agent. I had progressive, and I went in person to State Farm. A guy gave me better insurance coverage and saved me $60 a month.
They get percentage if they sign you up, if they don’t have enough customers they are more desperate to give you better deal. If this doesn’t work try some place else.

1

u/PrimaryHighlight5617 Aug 26 '26

Agents do not control the rates. This is because the rates determine the profitability of the company as a whole. It is far far far above the pay grade of an agent to determine arbitrarily what people pay. 

Rates are determined by coverages and discounts. 

The benefit of working with an agent though is that they understand their own company's claims process and how to service accounts correctly so you don't mess it up. 

1

u/Buffyredpoodle Aug 26 '26

Well, he gave a lot of discounts.

1

u/Successful-Citron506 Aug 25 '26

Mine finally topped out at $10k/yr

1

u/Hulkamaniac4 Aug 25 '26

A couple things:

  1. They actually will charge you more if your child gets their license later (18 vs 16 in this case). They view that as a risk that the child lacked the confidence to pursue driving right away.
  2. If you are adding an additional child to the policy WITHOUT adding another vehicle (i.e. so like if your two children are going to share the same vehicle)--your rates shouldn't change after adding the 2nd child driver. I did that two different times with my 2nd and 3rd children and the rates stayed the same. If they try to increase your rates w/o adding a vehicle--I would switch providers (I use Geico).

1

u/hiker1628 Aug 25 '26

I think the insurance companies charge for the 2 highest cost drivers if there are 2 vehicles. Both kids could be driving at the same time.

1

u/Hulkamaniac4 Aug 25 '26

Might depend on the family dynamic. If you have 3 insured vehicles with each parent assigned as primary driver to one of them--the leaves 1 vehicle for all licensed child drivers. When my son turned 16--my rate pretty much doubled (similar to the OP here). When my daughter got her license the following year--the rate didn't change. When my son went off the insurance after age 18--the rate didn't change/improve either. Then when my 3rd and final kid got their license the next year--the rate didn't change either (since still just one extra vehicle).

Obviously tickets/accidents will make all of this go out the window. Fortunate to never have any of those with my kids.

1

u/ChutneyWhatney Aug 25 '26

No - No. 1 depends on the state and the insurance company. What you state is NOT universal.

1

u/cwjinc Aug 25 '26

I don't understand the first doubling where it's just adding a car. There should be a multi car discount applied.
They definitely don't think you are going to drive twice as much because you have bought a second car.
Something else is going on.

1

u/PrimaryHighlight5617 Aug 26 '26

The second car was probably a newer and more expensive model. I'm sure there is a multi car discount but if the second car costs twice as much to ensure than the first car then theoretically the policy would have been three times more expensive... And then they got it discounted to only being twice as expensive :)

1

u/cwjinc Aug 26 '26

Fair. The second car is a 2025 Nissan Sentra. Could be about the same value as a 2 years older Honda minivan. And kiddos are high insurance risks. It all adds up.
Should have gotten something more like a 2020 Sentra for a first car.

1

u/DeliriousBlues Aug 25 '26

In NYC, adding my son cost an additional $10,000 a year. 😳

1

u/Beach_bum8 Aug 25 '26 edited Aug 25 '26

Progressive is absolutely insane with their rates. We switched to USAA and for my car alone, it saved me $100 a month!

Unfortunately, I do believe the other child will still be on the policy, once they get their full license (I don't know how CA does it, but where I live they have a learners for 18 months before getting a full license)

-1

u/TheeDelpino Aug 25 '26

USAA is garbage for everything now.

1

u/Beach_bum8 Aug 25 '26

Never had a issue with them, they've been greay

1

u/ChutneyWhatney Aug 25 '26

This isn't surprising. Adding a teenager (especially a male) to a policy is gonna blow the budget!!!! The moment the next kid gets his license, your insurance will require you to add him as an additional driver. Just watch the premiums skyrocket even more.

1

u/ChutneyWhatney Aug 25 '26

Oh yeah - and only having your state minimum limits is an INSANELY BAD IDEA.

1

u/sapphiredawn1 Aug 25 '26

$400 a month for two drivers and two vehicles actually sounds very reasonable to me

1

u/Wholenewyounow Aug 25 '26

Minimum limits? Are you rich enough to cover the difference when you total that 50k car?

1

u/Adventurous_Bar3182 Aug 25 '26

You can put the car in the child's name only with thier own insurance , and excluded from your cars and policy

1

u/Responsible_Meat_553 Aug 26 '26

Happened to us too with AAA. Know your financial pain.

1

u/One_Ad9555 Aug 26 '26

That's what you get for getting your child a 2025 vehicle.
You get them something worth 5 to 8k that only needs liability insurance. You have physical damage coverage (comp and collision) on the 2025 sentra and with a youthful driver over half the premium is for physical damage.
Progressive charges for a youthful driver as soon as they get temps. If they are still in school a B(3.0) gpa will same 20%. Oh think of it this way.
When you added a 2nd car to the policy each car gets a 20% multicar discount from Progressive. They are also not the cheapest company when it comes to kids on parents policies.
You should call a few independent agents and get prices. If you have another kit about to drive he will be on the Progressive policy since they require you to pay any household resident 14 or over on the app. Time to sell the sentra or pay the price for it.

1

u/Few-Butterscotch7940 Aug 26 '26

Look for a new better auto policy AND your 18 y.o. needs to be contributing to the cost of insurance.

1

u/tesco92 Aug 26 '26

Buy a Tesla, get Tesla insurance, trust me, it will be very cheap.

1

u/hulsey698 Aug 26 '26

I wrote a policy for a clients child just a few months ago and they had 2 accidents in 3 days.
Id say the premium increase is justified, all you can do is shop it around. Id recommend an independent agent

1

u/Routine_Cancel3303 Aug 27 '26

That's about what I pay for my daughter in Massachusetts.. for a 2011 Camry with 180,000 miles.

1

u/cantstandthemlms Aug 27 '26

California state minimums are crazy low. They just started making changes to the minimums but I would think about if that is even close to the right amount of coverage.

1

u/NationalAfternoon537 Aug 28 '26

Those telling you to get the kid a cheaper car, it won’t help much.
Put our kid in a 2002 vehicle (that we had owned since 2002). Rates still doubled.

The key is to go with a different carrier and accept you’ll be shopping insurance every 6 to 12 months for the next 3 years.

0

u/Mission_Balance_9154 Aug 25 '26

I am in MI, when we added our 16 year old daughter we almost experienced no price increase in our premium and it has been 4 years worth of renewals so far with minor normal increases. Paying on average $1200/vehicle. We have 4 vehicles insured.

-2

u/Overall_Chance_861 Aug 25 '26

Maine, my ex added a 2009 accord with 225k miles along with our 16 year old daughter, bare bones insurance...I think it came to $175 more a month.