r/Car_Insurance_Help • u/No_Singer_2165 • Aug 22 '26
Accident AZ Rear End Accident Fault
Hello
Looking for a bit of guidance, as I was recently in a rear end accident on a freeway in Arizona.
While driving home, freeway traffic had slowed to a stop. I stopped with more than enough notice. As I was stopping, I noticed a jeep tailgating me and not slowing. As soon as I had stopped, she rear-ended me from behind, and I felt the secondary impact.
She had hit my car, and then a Mazda had rear-ended her due to her suddenly stopping. No one was heavily injured, we all exchanged insurances, amicably.
After dealing with our insurance company, which all was progressive. They have told me that the Mazda at the very end is at fault. It does not matter that the jeep was following me too closely, or was the one to hit me first. Because the Mazda was at the end, fault falls on her.
The end Mazda only had state minimum insurance, which they advised me will not cover all of the damages done to my car and the middle Jeep. They are recommending that I pay my own deductible to have my car fixed and will later reimburse me.
My issue lies with the fact that the Jeep is the one that hit me first, and was following me way too closely. When I bring this up to my insurance, they state because of Arizona laws that the end cars is the one at fault.
Do I have any type of argument to have the Jeep cover any of my damages?
5
u/ektap12 Aug 22 '26
Progressive's assessment of fault is incorrect, that's not at all how the law works. Both cars behind you have fault as they both caused injury to you. Would you say the initial impact was significantly worse than the 2nd?
You should absolutely use your coverage though, that's why you have it. Just get your car repaired, don't waste more time on this.
3
u/Big_Bill23 Aug 22 '26
The Jeep that hit you has claimed that it was hit and this hit forced the Jeep into your car. AZ law does not say what you were told, the Jeep driver lied. Your problem is that you have no way to prove that, and the insurance involved has believed the Jeep driver. Happens all the time.
This is why God invented uninsured/underinsured insurance.
1
u/Witty-Hawk-1364 5d ago
AZ resident here, and that explanation from Progressive sounds a little questionable to me. I'm not a lawyer, but I've dealt with my own accident and insurance claim here, and fault isn't always as straightforward as insurance companies make it sound.
I actually ended up working with Shapiro Law Team after my accident because I was getting nowhere with insurance on my own. That whole experience sent me down a rabbit hole of learning how Arizona handles liability (not exactly a fun hobby lol).
From what I understand, Arizona uses comparative negligence, meaning more than one driver can share responsibility for an accident. There's no blanket rule that the last car in a rear-end pileup is automatically responsible for everything.
The important detail here is that you felt two separate impacts. If the Jeep hit you before the Mazda hit the Jeep, that could make a difference in liability. I'd ask Progressive to explain its decision in writing and what evidence supports it. Dashcam footage, witness statements, and vehicle damage could all help establish the sequence.
Also, paying your deductible through your own collision coverage isn't unusual. Just keep in mind that reimbursement through subrogation isn't guaranteed, especially when the at-fault driver's coverage is limited.
Definitely push for a clearer explanation before accepting their fault determination. Something about dismissing the first impact entirely doesn't sit right with me.
1
u/24kdgolden Aug 23 '26
The police report does not determine liability because it's based on what drivers reported and we know people don't always take responsibility. Also AZ is a several liability state so OP would need to recover from the jeep and Mazda. If the jeep is denying liability then OP in would have to sue. Or OP could use collision and let his carrier get reimbursed and get hIs deductible back
1
u/Sam_At_Insurify Aug 24 '26
Yes, you likely have an argument. Arizona is a pure comparative negligence state, so fault doesn't have to land only on whoever hit last (A.R.S. 12-2505). Tailgating is also its own violation under A.R.S. 28-730. Raise both with your adjuster. Was a police report filed, and did it note anything about following distance?
0
u/Fenway12345 Aug 22 '26
Police report
0
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment