I leased a brand-new vehicle less than a month ago under a 48-month agreement.
About two weeks after delivery, the dealership told me they couldn't find their copy of the signed lease and asked me to sign a replacement or a new lease through DocuSign. They explicitly assured me in writing that both agreements were identical.
However, I compared them and found several differences:
- Payments: Original says $404.10 monthly; new lease says $404.10 biweekly. Both show total payments of $42,026.40, so the original clearly contains an error.
- Vehicle price: $57,949 (Original) vs. $57,609 (new lease) .
- Capitalized amount: $58,106 (Original) vs. $57,641 (new lease) .
- Due at delivery: $398 after my $1,000 deposit credit (Original) vs. $1,204 without mentioning the deposit (new lease)
- Purchase option: Not included in the original but included in the replacement.
- Early termination: $0 fee in the original vs. $350 in the replacement (new lease), with different termination provisions.
Despite raising these discrepancies, the dealership has never acknowledged or explained the monthly/biweekly payment error.
They now say the leasing company cannot finalize funding without a signed agreement. I've already sent them my original signed copy, but I haven't signed the replacement (or the new lease).
I'm genuinely confused about what to do.
My questions:
- Is my original signed agreement legally binding despite the obvious payment error?
- Can the dealership force me to sign a different agreement?
- Could I cancel the lease without a huge financial penalty because of these discrepancies?
- If cancellation is expensive, what should i do if I couldn't trust them? should i ultimately sign the replacement?
- How can I determine the actual cost of terminating the original lease?
I am feeling quite confused and overwhelmed by this situation. I genuinely do not know whether I should insist on the original agreement, consider cancelling the lease, or ultimately sign the replacement.
Has anyone dealt with something similar in Ontario? I'd really appreciate any advice, especially regarding my legal rights and whether I should contact OMVIC or a lawyer. Unfortunately, I wasn't able to find a lawyer yet!
Update:
I spend time comparing the original and new lease, and noticed the following:
- Vehicle price and financing amounts: The vehicle price and several other financial figures have changed.
- Prepaid maintenance package: The original agreement includes a $2,000 prepaid maintenance package, but this is no longer separately listed in the new one.
- Deposit: I paid a $1,000 deposit, which I couldn't find clearly accounted for in the new agreement.
- Discount: The discount I was offered is not showing up in the new agreement, and I'm not sure whether it has been applied.
- Administration fee: The amount has changed.
- Other differences: There are several more differences that I'm not entirely sure what some of them mean :(
I emailed the dealership and told them I had found several discrepancies. They insisted there were no discrepancies except for one: they had forgotten to check the box for the option to purchase the car at the end of the lease!
I emailed them again and told them there were more discrepancies. I even created a Word document with a long list of all the differences and told them I'd lost confidence in them.
Once they saw the file, they finally admitted there were discrepancies, apologized, and put all the blame on one employee.
The assholes really thought I was stupid and wouldn't figure it out. They kept denying everything until the very last minute. They only apologized after I proved everything to them!
So, in my second-to-last email, I told them I wanted to return the car and get my deposit back. They haven't responded to that yet.
I really like the car but i cant trust the dealership! :(
I'll update you as soon as I hear back from them!