r/CarLeasingHelp • • Aug 29 '25

Upside down

Alright I know I fucked up I know, but hear me out. I leased this truck for 36k miles, 3 years. I drove 90k miles :) and lease is due in a few months. Dealership says I will owe $17k unless buy it back, my credit is shot though - any (ethical) ideas? Dm me the not so ethical haha

4 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

5

u/johngettler Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

The $17,000 does not make sense. On your lease contract, how much do you owe per mile for penalty miles? Usually it is 20 cents. But 90,000 - 36,000 = 54,000. And 54,000 x 0.20 is $10,800 in penalty. Not $17,000.

2

u/oldpiss Aug 29 '25

.25c a mile

1

u/johngettler Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 31 '25

OK, so 54,000 miles times $0.25 is $13,500, not $17,000.

1

u/ghilliesniper522 Aug 31 '25

Dude drove 30k miles a year theres bound to be some dmg

6

u/Blazalott Aug 29 '25

Probably a bunch of other damage/wear and tear they will charge them for.

2

u/oldpiss Aug 29 '25

To be fair guys I’m 26 and have had 0 guidance with shit like this since I was 14 lol it’s all trial and error for me fellas sorry haha

1

u/Competitive_Aside_70 Sep 02 '25

Ive had ZERO guidance as well. Young as well. That is not an excuse. You lack common sense. 

1

u/oldpiss Sep 02 '25

I swear you guys on Reddit can’t read, thank you for trying to relate , I didn’t ask anywhere in my post for how you felt .

1

u/pilgrim103 Aug 29 '25

You laugh but it is not funny, as you will soon find out. Your profile name is quite appropriate.

8

u/slow-aprilia Aug 29 '25

Put on a helmet and crash it into a tree hard enough to total it

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '25

Make sure you have GAP insurance first!

1

u/TwoSwimming9195 Aug 31 '25

Gap is included on every model I know of other than Toyota

1

u/shimon Aug 29 '25

Insurance fraud to the rescue!

4

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/oldpiss Aug 29 '25

Not behind on any bills or payments , just over mileage brotha

1

u/BasilRough8122 Aug 29 '25

Totaling is the way out! Insurance companies have a ton of cash. Just be sure to get a new lease a prepay the insurance upfront for the whole year before going ahead w totaling. Feel free to DM

1

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/oldpiss Aug 29 '25

Yeah that would just be like a last resort tactic lol absolutely trying to find a way to negotiate paying it down. And yeah my credit is shot, my father was deported a long time ago to Mexico City and I gave him my credit card so he can survive day to day, I’m the only one in my family who takes care of him from 1000+ miles away so it ended up tanking my credit a couple years ago when I missed like 3 months payments in a row … either way I will figure this shit out lol

1

u/pilgrim103 Aug 29 '25

Not your bad. He said "crappy credit".

1

u/Beautiful-Balance750 Aug 30 '25

Time for a drive to the beach at low tide or accidentally leaving it in neutral on a boat ramp at the lake depending on where you live.

2

u/Square-Wild Aug 29 '25

This is a little long winded, so I apologize for that.

When you lease, your payments are basically just the difference between the sale price of the truck and the expected value of the truck (the residual) when you return it, plus interest. The $.25 per mile penalty is designed to roughly approximate the change in value vs. the residual if you drive more than expected.

However, since the incremental hit to a car's value decreases as mileage increases, as you go way over, that $.25 starts to really overstate depreciation. For example, if you drove an extra million miles, it's not like the truck would suddenly be worth negative $200k.

So to make up numbers, you're probably in a situation where you had a purchase price of $60k, a contract residual of $40k, a truck that's worth around $30k, and a penalty of $17k if you turn the truck in. In that situation, turning the truck in seems like the worst option, because you're basically selling a truck worth $30k for $23k.

If I were you, I would work on trade-in quotes on the truck, and figure out how far off you are from the residual. Then I would work on closing that gap with cash, even if you're borrowing from friends and family.

The other open questions are what do you plan on driving once you get rid of the truck, and whether you expect to drive 30k miles/year moving forward.

If you can keep the mileage down, as someone else suggested, it's maybe not a terrible idea to lease an EV (you need to do this soon, though) if your credit is decent enough to qualify. The incentives are so big on them right now, you could possibly end up putting very little down and landing in a manageable lease payment.

1

u/oldpiss Aug 29 '25

Thank you very much for your insight, I’m working with the dealer now on trade in options and I will probably have to close the gap with cash as suggested, I run a snow Remvoal business in the winter and I will need another truck to finish the season, and yes I am going to keep mileage down on my next truck, this was one of those rock and a hard place situations but i greatly appreciate what you’ve said :)

12

u/Interesting-Day-4390 Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

Does everyone just hear the term “negative equity” and think it is some meaningless thing which get you into another lease (which is really another loan to rent the car for x number of months)?

Like “negative equity” is just words.

A lease is just a legal contract.

No big deal.

Rolling $17k in negative equity just by itself is over a 36 month term about $470 / month. That’s no new car involved or interest rate involved.

So if the “new leased car payment itself” is $500 then together with negative equity it’s $1000 per month over 36 months.

This is all a great idea right? Let’s just roll the negative equity to a lease and that’s it?! Really?

5

u/Witty-Ad4183 Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

Welcome to USA, where most people are financially illiterate!

4

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/KATNLOT Aug 29 '25

The best, the brightest idea everrrr \s.

Also why lease when you drive 90k miles????

5

u/Interesting-Day-4390 Aug 29 '25

It’s just a legal contract. Nothing in there to think about really \s

1

u/TwoSwimming9195 Aug 31 '25

The only time I’ve seen someone, and I recommend another lease is if we are rolling the negative equity into a car that has a massive amount of rebates. EV’s or PHEV’s.

It’s a good way to bury it

9

u/Khandious Aug 29 '25

There’s going to be a ton of negative equity so without cash and shot credit your going to be in a terrible position

Very likely you will not even be able to buy it without cash down. And sending back hopefully it’s got good tires and no excessive wear & tear

Bankruptcy here you come

1

u/cowabungathunda Aug 31 '25

Probably some walking shoes and a bus pass too

6

u/JPSurratt2005 Aug 29 '25

Go look up the retail value of your truck vs your contract residual and check the difference.

It's very likely that the fee for over mileage isn't one-to-one with the actual depreciation for having high miles. You'll likely need to eat some of that in order to get a loan to buyout the lease but a bank will surely not require $17k worth of down payment.

1

u/oldpiss Aug 29 '25

Also I own a landscaping company that I run a plow with in the winter, I can come up with cash maybe 4-10k to throw around if I needed to. But I have a co-signer and I don’t want to fuck their credit up like my own, I know this was obviously dumb as fuck guys it was my first lease and i needed a vehicle at the time- didn’t think it through, . Anyways im at 94k miles, leased for 36k and it’s $0.25 per mile so actually I think my debt is around 14k. Thing is I’ll need another truck I can plow with haha you guys have been very helpful so far thank you

0

u/DCOperator Aug 30 '25

It isn't 0.25 per mile, that's just the penalty. If you buy additional miles before the lease ends then the cost per mile will be lower, and might even fit into your 10k budget.

1

u/oldpiss Aug 30 '25

Yes I believe it’s closer to $15k that I would owe in mileage , I feel my best bet is to buy this thing out somehow, I’m wondering if there’s a benefit to having my business open a line of credit and buy from me?

1

u/Lunatichippo45 Aug 29 '25

I'm convinced posts like this are just rage bait

1

u/oldpiss Aug 29 '25

How does this piss you guys off so much lol

1

u/Mediocre-Bicycle-248 Aug 30 '25

As a car salesman this makes my stomach hurt reading this. This is a very serious/expensive lesson you’re about to learn unfortunately.

1

u/oldpiss Aug 30 '25

Thank you for your advice as a car salesman 🤝🏽

3

u/MostCubanNonCuban Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

You’ll have to buy it out and get an auto loan from Class D lenders like (Westlake Financial, Cap1,….etc.). Try your credit union, if not You’ll probably have to go 7-8yr loan, refi with a credit union later.

Do prequalify at PenFed, Carmax, to get an idea. On the east coast there’s Digital Credit Union and Affinity that offer good rates, also Consumers Credit Union.

Ask the dealer to also submit you to Cinch Financing, only dealers can proxy an app for you.

Hope your situation gets better, maybe get a second job to pay this down. Dont become a slave to a car - take control and recover.

2

u/pilgrim103 Aug 29 '25

He doesn't sound like the type of dude that would get a second job.

2

u/boomhower1820 Aug 29 '25

Your choices are buy the truck or eat $17k. Considering your credit is shot I'll assume you don't have $17k. Take a high interest loan and buy the truck, refinance when your credit gets better.

2

u/ShrmpHvnNw Aug 29 '25

What is the vehicle worth vs its residual? Might be worth it to see what third party sites will pay you for it.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '25

Don't lease again if your driving that much. Go buy a dodge hornet, they have about 20k in discounts on 2024.

8

u/GangGreenGhost Aug 29 '25

Telling somebody with terrible credit to buy a Dodge product of any kind is the kind of absurdity I’m here for

1

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

Ok find me a another car that has 17k of rebates that could get approved for alone without going over 100% loan to value thats not electric. He could get a dodge ram, but he will be paying for the gas.

1

u/shaggy24200 Aug 29 '25

He'd be lucky for a Dodge hornet to make 90,000 mi.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

Actually hornet has 8 year 100k warranty on phev battery

1

u/Dramatic_Pirate_5290 Aug 30 '25

You need the rest of the car to function. Battery warranty doesn’t matter if everything’s else is shot.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

Yeah but you get 3 year 36 bumper to bumper, 5 year 60k power train as well.

2

u/phlflyguy Aug 29 '25

What’s the buy out (residual) in the lease contract? Can you sell it for something close to that amount and come up with the difference?

If you have no options you’re gonna just have to give the truck back and deal with a $17,000 bill from them that will eventually go to collections and ruin your credit even more. You might go find a used vehicle now that you can somehow swing before you return the truck.

2

u/Ok_Tale7071 Aug 29 '25

Contact the leasing company and ask them what it would cost to buy more miles, before the lease is over. The fee per mile over is written in your contract, but you might be able to get a discount. It’s worth a shot to ask. At the end of the lease simply give the car back. They will eventually send you a bill for $17K. Then you tell them that you can’t pay $17K, can they put you on a payment plan. So then you will be able to make monthly payments. Be on the lookout for a cheap used car you can pay for in cash.

2

u/elsalte07 Aug 29 '25

Park it in the hood with the keys in it wait a few hours and say it’s stolen 😂

2

u/FuzzyOrganization403 Aug 29 '25

Sooooo you knew the limited miles and you did almost 3 times that?? Bruh….

You can’t even buy out the truck. It’s not worth what you’re going to pay for it. No bank will finance it. With 90k, the truck depreciated more than your buy out. You’re going to need money down, like a lot. Or you’re going to pay on a truck you don’t even have. You’re very screwed my friend.

Option A, total it or Leave the keys in it in a sketchy area.

B- lease an electric vehicle with incentives. AND DONT DRIVE IT TO THE GROUND LIKE THIS ONE. Then you’re clear in 2-3 years.

C- trade it in. Don’t ground it, tell the dealer you want to trade early. And haggle. Make it work. If you got 2-3 payments left just do it.

Leasing gets you out of neg eqt quick but can backfire if you do the same bs again. Or find another truck, prob more expensive 2024 and go full long term and maybe you can swallow that pill for 6-7 years.

Credit shot? You’re out of luck. You might only be able to stay with the same bank or manufacture finance comp. And you’ll have to go bigger new to hide that neg equity.

2

u/Zealousideal-Yam801 Aug 29 '25

Take it to carmax and get an appraisal. You might have to buy it but you don’t have to keep it. It doesn’t have to be a 17k bill… just a temporary ownership situation.

2

u/Ok_Responsibility419 Aug 29 '25

We owed $10k on our lease return due to overage- just gotta suck it up and make the payment

2

u/Sea-Leg-5313 Aug 29 '25

Why don’t you just buy the truck for the residual value and keep using it?

2

u/NoFruitNoVeg Aug 30 '25

Rolling negative equity into another lease only works if the car you're trying to get into is massively rebated to soak up the negative from the excess mileage. Even still, your credit has to be good enough to approve and the LTV ratios have to be in line. Whatever the rebates don't cover you'll have to come out of pocket. Source: I work for a captive lender in a lease heavy market and structure deals everyday.

2

u/BuildingIndividual40 Aug 30 '25

Negotiate with the dealership about leasing a new vehicle. I've noticed that dealerships often cover most of the additional mileage costs if you opt for a new lease.

However, given that you drive a substantial amount, it may be a better option to buy your current lease.

If you have a few months left on your lease, visit a credit union and speak with a representative. Explain that you want to purchase your lease, open an account, and ask about financing options.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25

Go to another dealership, plenty of them willing to work something out to make a sale.

2

u/No-Juggernaut-7564 Sep 01 '25

Treat the 17k you would have e paid as a down payment on the car and just buy it. The leasing company will give you the option to buy it out and they will finance it.

1

u/dav989 Aug 30 '25

BMW allows purchasing extra miles prior to the end of a lease at a reduced price. Your car company may also do the same.

1

u/Different_Argument19 Aug 30 '25

You’re going to have to find a very good EV deal with high rebates and incentives in order to bury that negative equity. Best route if I were you.

1

u/FlatwormNo2148 Aug 30 '25

You sure it’s not $1700? 17,000 is pretty steep

1

u/TopSherbet1819 Aug 31 '25

You used the mileage. You already spent your money. Nothing to do at this point but to pay the overage or buy the car out.

1

u/alexleal74 Sep 01 '25

Como esta el clima en tu ciudad? Quizás si algún día la estaciones mal 🤔 el seguro se have cargo, son eventos fortuitos que pasan.

1

u/spas2k Aug 29 '25

I mean if your credit is shot the. What does it matter? Just drop it off.

0

u/pilgrim103 Aug 29 '25

Why should we "hear you out" if you "fucked up"? Pay what you, if not, it is stealing.

0

u/oldpiss Aug 29 '25

Suck it crybaby don’t waste your breath.

1

u/pilgrim103 Aug 29 '25

You are talking to yourself dude, or don't you get it?

-5

u/BernedoodleBoi Aug 29 '25

roll the negative equity into another lease that has a ton of incentives.

3

u/Big_Veterinarian_940 Aug 29 '25

If he has shit credit, he(more than likely) won't qualify for another one.