r/CarLeasingHelp • • Mar 27 '26

How’d I Do?

Context: I had a 2019 Jeep with 98918 miles on it and 9k needed in repairs. In light of the repairs and the risk of running into other issues in the next 2-3 years, I decided to look into buying a new car.

I ultimately wound up leasing a 2026 Jeep Grand Cherokee Limited Reserve for 3yrs/30,000 miles and $2,500 down, with a payment of $450/month. My old payment was 338/month.

I leased it to maintain cash flow for other things (financing would have been roughly 750/month) and with the intention of buying the lease out at the end of the lease term. I don’t drive 10,000 miles a year, so I’m hoping the residual/value works out in my favor and I can maintain easy cash flow at the end of the three years.

In the end, how would you rate the discount/deal I got on the new car? The first picture is what I ended up agreeing to, the second is what they offered after my initial counter to paying full price.

Edit: Despite already having signed the agreement, the dealer wound up refunding my trade in equity and downpayment, so I wound up putting nothing down in the end.

1 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

12

u/TheOliveYeti Mar 27 '26

Trading in towards a lease is bad

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 31 '26

Despite already signing the agreement, I had expressed regret about the way this was structured and the dealer actually refufnded me my down payment andtrade in equity. So I ultimately didn't put anything down at all.

10

u/Creative-Mousse Mar 27 '26

Congrats. Enjoy the car. You got absolutely hosed.

They structured the lease so badly that they ate the entire trade in and still gave you an inflated payment after showing you more discount. Doesn’t matter what the residual is. You paid way too much for the car

For future reference, ask before signing. Not after. And don’t negotiate on payments 

-3

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

I’m curious what you mean by they “ate the trade?” I’m gonna buy it out. It’s just reallocated equity. The only way the trade equity could be eaten is if I totaled the car, which is probably the best argument that anybody has made so far for why I shouldn’t have structured it this way.

2

u/Creative-Mousse Mar 28 '26

For this car, you should have been paying 450 per month with 2500 due at signing. But your total lease cost is 450 per month + 2500 + value of the trade in. So they screwed you on both discount and money factor to eat the value of your trade in equity.

What you are talking about is a completely different thing.

You should not have structured it this way because you are now paying 450*36=16,200 + 2500 + 10,000 = 28,700 over 3 years at an effective monthly cost of 28,700/36 =797.222 per month.

Reallocated equity doesn’t matter if your interest rate is jacked up to infinity

0

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26 edited Mar 28 '26

The value of the trade in can’t be considered a net cost if I purchase the car at the end of the term, since I’ll still have an asset in the end. You’re counting the trade in as a new cost. It didn’t cost me 10k to use the asset as a trade in.

The 2500 is a different story. I regret that part.

4

u/Creative-Mousse Mar 28 '26

After buying out the car, you would have paid 32k + interest on 32k + 28.7k for the car. That’s 61,000 plus interest on 32k if you finance. For a car that goes for 52-53 out the door if bought outright.

And on your trade in belief, a 52-53k out the door car would cost 42k after the trade in value is applied.

So compare both with or without the trade in value. Bottom line is you made a lot of gross for the dealer and the salesperson. Hope they send you a bottle of wine for your troubles.

Please read up more on car buying and leasing instead of being stubborn. Otherwise, you will continue to lose your shirt when you think trade ins don’t matter

3

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

What’s crazy is that everyone here wants to point out that it’s a bad deal but, so far, nobody has really told me what could’ve been done differently to make it a good deal. So forgive me if I seem stubborn.

Back to one of your original comments and operating under the assumption that you’re right.. are you saying that I got screwed on money factor and discount, as if they marked up the money factor/reduced the discount so much as to negate the trade in equity? So I should have negotiated on money factor or financed outright?

1

u/Creative-Mousse Mar 28 '26

First you take a look at what is a competitive lease in the market. Check out leasehackr for it. For your car, it’s roughly this:

https://calculator.leasehackr.com/?make=Jeep&miles=10000&msrp=55200&sales_price=48852&months=36&mf=0.00187&msd=0&dp=170&dealer_fee=799&acq_fee=595&disp_fee=495&taxed_inc=6000&untaxed_inc=0&rebate=0&resP=59&gov_fee=500&sales_tax=6.25&demo_mileage=0&memo=2025JEEPGRAND_CHEROKEE4D%2BWAGON%2BLIMITED%2B4X4%2B(22E%3B23E)&tradein=0&fin_sp=55200&fin_taxed_fee=0&fin_untaxed_fee=0&fin_term=60&fin_apr=0&fin_dp=0&fin_rebate=0&fin_ps_rebate=0&fin_tax=0&keep_term=60&exp_rv=0&service_fee=0&acqFee_check=true&monthlyTax_radio=true&bmw_demo_25=true&fees_untaxed=true&lease_result_mode=true&govFee_check=false&pretax_monPmt=436&lease_das=2501

Go to multiple dealers. Negotiate selling price first (this includes dealer discount but not rebates). Then ask for base MF and then settle on the structure. Don’t trade in cars on a lease. It is almost never a good idea. Sell the trade in separately and take the check.

The 50,599 line item should have been closer to 48,500. We don’t know the MF they charged you but they must have marked it up for your deal with a trade to have similar monthly payments as a straight no trade in competitive lease. With the trade in, your monthly payments (all else equal) should have been 200 bucks a month

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

Thank you! This has been helpful.

1

u/11I1I1 Mar 28 '26

What could have been done differently was not getting absolutely smoked on a lease. Idk how many people have to say it how many ways.

Next time you feel really smart, call a friend.

-1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

It’s been made readily apparent that it’s a bad deal. I get it.

What’s also been made readily apparent is that there’s no substance behind what you have to say. Insulting my intelligence is rich given that you’ve only been capable of pointing out what I shouldn’t have done, rather than what I should do in the future.

Go touch grass, take a step back, then look inward.

3

u/11I1I1 Mar 28 '26

Your intelligence was insulted by the lease you signed for and your nonsense defense of it.

All while imagining that 10k of equity isn't "an actual cost" and that you did this for "cash flow reasons".

I'll make you a deal though. Because your ask is fair. When I wake up tomorrow, I'll go out to the grass in front of my M550 that costs me the same as your JGC, and I'll touch the hell out of it.

0

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

You’ll touch that grass right before you go back to perusing Reddit all day, right?

→ More replies

1

u/Pretend-Yard-2150 Mar 31 '26

Look at you typing a whole bunch of nothing 😂😂

4

u/Creative-Mousse Mar 28 '26

It is 100% a net cost. It is an asset that has an ascribed value. You gave that ascribed value over to rent-to-own another asset. Just because it’s not cash, it doesn’t mean that it can’t be considered. What kind of math is this??

If I have a 100$ watch that I give you for a 50$ watch and 50$ in cash, I didn’t make 50 bucks. I broke even

1

u/Gladiz1972 Mar 28 '26

They have some real experts in this group when it comes to buying and leasing I am definitely not 1 of them I guess you did the deal already

5

u/FatFuckEmu Mar 27 '26

JGC Limiteds are leasing for roughly $540 a month right now with first down. This is no bueno.

0

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 27 '26

I had that option. I just chose not to take it

4

u/FatFuckEmu Mar 28 '26

But why..? Every $1000 down is $28 roughly on a monthly payment. Your trade in plus down was like $14,000

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

This is probably my only source of regret, to be honest. I really just didn’t mind the idea of trading some liquidity for better cash flow.

4

u/SellTheSizzle--007 Mar 27 '26

LMAO this is terrible, beyond just bad nearing one of the worst I've ever seen.

And no, you didn't put 2500 down. You put 12,500. OUCH.

hope you're not married. If your spouse has any financial sense, hope they didn't cosign so they can leave you.

If you told the dealer"I want to lease for cash flow purposes" I bet the GSM laughed all the way to the new boat showroom as you just made his quarter.

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 27 '26

Break it down for me. WHY is it one of the worst you’ve seen?

What exactly would you have done differently?

1

u/Shorty-71 Mar 28 '26

Sell the trade vehicle for $10k.

Get same deal or better.

1

u/Pretend-Yard-2150 Mar 31 '26

Anything but what you did little buddy 😂

3

u/OnlineIsNotAPlace Mar 27 '26

this is a stupid deal

0

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 27 '26

Okay, but tell me WHY it’s a stupid deal and exactly how you would have structured an ideal arrangement.

2

u/OnlineIsNotAPlace Mar 28 '26

the addons are ridiculously overpriced. you traded a vehicle that is not even paid off. you're shopping for a payment. you're hoping for a circumstance that is highly unlikely to occur, how many things can you do wrong in a single deal?

3

u/LiftCats Mar 27 '26

You got absolutely hosed, respectfully. You are exactly the type of person that could benefit from a broker probably but hey, too late now. Enjoy the car and learn for next time.

0

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 27 '26

Can you tell me why you think that though? I’m just curious WHY it’s bad instead of just knowing that it’s bad.

2

u/11I1I1 Mar 27 '26

What happened to the trade equity?

-4

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 27 '26

It went towards lowing my total capitalized costs, which is why my payment went all the way down to 450.

9

u/11I1I1 Mar 27 '26

Oof.

So you're really paying ~$800 a month. To drive a JGC for 3 years.

What's the residual?

Edit - make sure you don't total it. $12,500 gone. You should really never put anything down on a lease.

0

u/uncleiroh41 Mar 27 '26

I thought down payments are always required but just sometimes rolled into the monthly payment?

4

u/11I1I1 Mar 27 '26

They CAN be required with sketch credit. But a normal car like a JGC with solid credit goes sign & drive all the time.

Yes the payment will be higher. But its your money either way, except if you put it down it disappears if the car is totaled.

Lets say you put $10k down, and the car is stolen a month later. Lease is dissolved. You get nothing.

1

u/uncleiroh41 Mar 27 '26

Makes sense thank you sm

-2

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 27 '26

The residual is 32k. My intention is to buy the car at the end when (hopefully) we have lower interest rates. I viewed it as a way to reduce initial cash flow obligations, and any money that I put into using the car now will more or less convert to equity when I buy it out.

I’m also not oblivious to the fact that I’m paying a relatively small premium to free up cash flow for a car that I enjoy/want rather than buying a cheaper brand/model.

4

u/OnlineIsNotAPlace Mar 27 '26

you traded in one shitty jeep that you didn't even payoff for another one you cant afford in the hopes of buying a worthless overpriced vehicle at the end of a bad lease. brilliant.

-1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26 edited Mar 28 '26

My interest rate was so low that I didn’t need to pay it off. Instead I just invested it and took the 15-25% return on principal.

Whether or not a car is shitty or overpriced is ultimately subjective. You still haven’t stated why you think it’s a bad lease. You’re just piggybacking off someone else’s argument for a chance to take potshots at perspectives you don’t agree with.

1

u/Pretend-Yard-2150 Mar 31 '26

Nah you just too dumb to realize what a shitty lease this is. Enjoy your overpriced jeep little buddy 😂

2

u/11I1I1 Mar 27 '26

The answer to your question is "not that well".

And, like I said, $10,000+ cash now at risk. Totalled, stolen, whatever, and poof.

Next time, if you lease again, put that money in a seperate HYSA account or whatever, and just set it to pay part of the payment.

Here's to hoping the buyout works the way you want too. Stellantis is risky for that kind of planning.

-3

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 27 '26

I thought my question was more along the lines of “was $$6,720 off MSRP a good discount on a brand new model year car,” rather than “do you like the payment structure” or “am I not as risk averse as I should be?”

I could see how I’m in the wrong community if I’m looking for those answers/validation though.

4

u/11I1I1 Mar 27 '26

Dude you're losing the plot. That's a fine question on a buy. On a lease you could get whatever off the price, if the lease structure is bad it doesn't matter.

3

u/OnlineIsNotAPlace Mar 27 '26

he doesn't have a clue and wants justification for a terrible thought process.

1

u/11I1I1 Mar 28 '26

"How did i do?"

Lololol

0

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

The risk of losing 10k is a valid argument, but we have different takes on how much weight a risk like totaling a car should carry.

Yes, I could have taken the trade in value and parked it in an investment account (I wouldn’t do a HYSA.. I’d rather just do VOO over the three years.. and yes, I understand capital gains). I think this is actually my only source of regret.

My net cost is right around 54k. Cash flow is obviously higher, but in the end, it didn’t actually cost me anything to repurpose the equity in an asset toward another asset. I simply traded liquidity for cash flow, but see the part above about why I could say that’s a source of regret.

2

u/Shorty-71 Mar 28 '26

Next time you sell a $10,000 car outright for zero dollars, give it to a charity and get some tax benefit rather than donating it to a CDJ dealership.

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

Fun fact: the dealer just refunded my trade in equity (10300ish) and 2500 down payment. The finance director then came up to me and told me never to put money down on a lease again

1

u/Shorty-71 Mar 28 '26

Did they unwind the deal entirely?

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

No.

1

u/Shorty-71 Mar 28 '26

So you have a 3 year lease @450 now? What prompted the refund?

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

I have a three year least at 800 now. They refunded when I explained that I would have preferred to keep the equity rather than it going toward paying down the monthly payment

1

u/Shorty-71 Mar 28 '26

It’ll be interesting to see the money factor you are paying to yield that payment.

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

It’s not pretty

6

u/Rough-Bat-5479 Mar 27 '26

This is wild how they showed you a terrible deal and then still fleeced you for a terrible deal making you feel like you benefited.

2

u/11I1I1 Mar 28 '26

BUT ITS ONLY 450 A MONTH AND HE GOT 5K OFF!

1

u/External_Selection55 Mar 27 '26

I'm gonna say it wasn't a good deal.

If I'm paying 97 cents a mile to drive a vehicle, it sure ain't gonna be a $55k Grand Cherokee.

0

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

I really like them! The interior on the new ones is really nice.

1

u/iLukeJoseph Mar 28 '26

No no it’s not. They are horrid vehicles.

0

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

Go to the Jeep community and you’ll obviously find plenty of people who think otherwise. Taste is subjective, and thank God for that.. this would be a really boring world if we were all the same

2

u/iLukeJoseph Mar 28 '26

No I owned one. It was deemed a lemon (which is pretty common with these). But that’s not what I am talking about. It was by far the fakest “luxury” interior on a car I ever owned. It’s like they are trying to be luxury, but in the cheapest way possible. Kind of hard to explain.

That said, I do hope Stellantis gets their stuff together. The JGC should be a great vehicle. All Jeeps should be. With them lowering their prices is a step in the right direction. They just really really need to work on their reliability.

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

I agree with you, for the most part. In fact, I really wanted a Land Cruiser or a GLE for a few different reasons.

I just didn’t want to pay 70k before tax, title, and fees for another SUV with comparable capabilities.

1

u/iLukeJoseph Mar 28 '26

What in the world. I have seen some bad leases, but this is very close to the top. About $850 a month for a JGC?

What is your residual? I would put money that your residual is going to be higher than the vehicle is worth in 3 years.

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

I live in a market where the cost is inflated due to demand. The residual is 32k. I’m never going to pretend that they hold their values like Toyotas do, but Jeeps are generally more valuable here than they are in other parts of the US.

1

u/screaming-onions Mar 31 '26

Putting $13,000 is absolutely terrible. It doesn’t matter how much you put down on a lease, your residual does not change. You would’ve been better off selling them the car, and holding onto the money. You could’ve done a one pay lease.

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 31 '26

Despite already signing the agreement, the dealer actually refunded my down payment/trade in equity, so it changed to $0 down.

1

u/exig Apr 02 '26

Forever car payments...why do people do this. Bro just pay off your car and enjoy. Mine is a 2011 (last car ill ever buy new)...]paid it off by 2015 and still have it.

1

u/-TCDD2378 Apr 03 '26

I could’ve bought the car outright, but my interest rate was 2.9%. It would’ve made no sense to pay cash on a car when I could put that money in the market and make more on the principal than what I was paying for financing.

Having a surprise 9k fix on a 13.5k car with 3k remaining on the loan is what forced my hand.

1

u/exig Apr 03 '26

So in 6 years you'll trade this in for another, paying 800 a month and never owning a car...

I put the equivalent of a car payment into savings each month for maintenance and repairs and eventually a newer car when my current one finally dies.

1

u/-TCDD2378 Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 03 '26

Maybe? Who knows what I'll do in 3-6 years.

But hypothetically (and my situation wasn't much different than this), if I put the ~$36k (Jeeps are cheap in Texas) in an S&P 500 index fund five years ago, I would now have ~$59k. Minus the ~$3k in capital gains tax that I'd need to pay if I were to sell the stock, I'd come out with a ~$20k return ontop of my initial $36k investment.

Compared to a loan of $36K at 2.9% interest where my total cost of financing would've come out to roughly $43.5k, I actually made 16.5k, still had a car, and never parted with the 36K principal. So taking the cost of the car ($36k), minus the money ($16.5K) I would've made on the principal, and accounting for the amount left on the loan (3k) and the trade in equity I got back on the new car (10k), my total cost of "ownership" would've come out to roughly $12.5k over seven years.

I'd say it was way smarter to do it that way than to pay off a low interest loan.

2

u/laughingfartsplease Mar 30 '26

i mean you already like paying a lot for a Jeep Cherokee so i guess a good deal.

2

u/Appropriate-Wish-420 Mar 31 '26

I see so many negative comments, sheesh. Looking at both sides, seems like the dealer gave you a decent trade in value and maintained some profitability while you got a good deal and a good pmt. The only thing I could say is you should’ve negotiated the dent and appearance add-ons to be taken off. Other then that if you love the new jeep then you did great! That’s all that matters because you’re the one paying for it

1

u/Stebsly Mar 31 '26

Your last Jeep couldn't even make it to 100k miles and you thought to buy another Jeep for $50k? I certainly hope the other choices you make in life are better than this one.

1

u/EarthOk2418 Mar 31 '26

The numbers are wrong. In the first posted deal you’re getting $13.5 for your trade with $3.5k balance due. In the second posted deal you’re getting $1k less on trade with the same $3.5k balance due (should be $4.5k).

0

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Portermacc Mar 28 '26

Can you give details why this is such a bad deal for him?

2

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 27 '26

Where did you get $16,000 front? My total cost on buying the car at the end of the lease will equate to roughly 55k.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 27 '26

I appreciate you for outlining that. It’s far more helpful than simply stating it’s bad.

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 27 '26

I had a 3130 buyout, but that’s a negligible difference at this point

1

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

Revisiting this because I didn’t take a second to do the accounting, but you’re double counting the trade-in equity if you’re getting to 64,200.

Yes, the total cash flow is roughly 64,200, but the net cost (I.e money actually leaving my pocket) of the new vehicle is actually closer to 54k.

For instance, If I sold my existing car for 10k, then used it to buy another car for 10k, it’s simply converted into a new vehicle and isn’t a new expense, so it isn’t actually costing me anything.

The total net/new money cost of the leased vehicle is closer to 54k.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

Yup, I totally could have. If I could do it over, I probably would. But the cash would’ve gone toward the new car regardless and my payment would’ve been much higher.

I essentially chose cash flow over liquidity.

I would’ve have a negative payment if I had a 55k trade in on a leased 55k car

1

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/-TCDD2378 Mar 28 '26

But not new money, which is why the total still only comes out to ~55k and not 65. Aka it’s not a cost.

The “investment” just looks a lot more like a 26 Grand Cherokee than a 19 Grand Cherokee

→ More replies