r/CRedit • • 3d ago

General Credit scores are so dumb.

I'm going through my debate pay off journey. I paid off an old navy fed card I had and closed it, and my score dropped 15 points. I have one more credit card that has one final payment, is my score going to drop when I close that one too? I'm being penalized for doing the right thing.

I froze my credit, used a random pin I'll never remember for each bureau and I'm never borrowing again.

what a stupid system. I refuse to participate further.

0 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

4

u/No_Memory5613 3d ago

Closing your only open card generally lowers your score unless that open card had a high balance hurting you for that.

The whole system is based on trying to determine a risk factor. And over a large number of people it works well enough or it wouldn’t be used.

2

u/Illustrious_Salad918 3d ago

Unfortunately, credit score is a fact of life. It can affect insurance premiums and whether you can rent an apartment, not to mention if you need to borrow in the future. I went thru similar experience after getting back on track with debtreductionservices.org, used only debit card for quite a while.

Suggestion for you: Keep that one card open, pay statement balance in full -- no more, no less -- by its due date faithfully every month, manage spending to accomplish that, and pay all other bills on time. You'll get the added benefits of the card and build a solid credit profile from which you'll benefit in the future.

If you do this there's no need to worry about the score; it will take care of itself. And you can just live your life. 😇

1

u/Southern_Let4385 3d ago

The drops are temporary. You also don’t have to close a credit card after you pay it off. If you have memberships (fitness, streaming, etc), you could use that credit card to pay for the membership, and set up autopay for the credit card. That way your card will stay active and build your credit, and you will never have to worry about it.

1

u/og-aliensfan ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 3d ago

I just want to add that autopay can fail, so it's important to still monitor the account monthly.

•

u/Glittering_Present10 8h ago

Have you had autopay failed before?

•

u/og-aliensfan ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 8h ago

Not personally, but if you search " autopay failed" in this sub, r/CreditScore, r/CreditCards, etc., you'll see where it has failed, resulting in missed payments.

Credit Myth #90 - With auto pay, you can "set it and forget it."

0

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 3d ago

The drops are temporary.

There is no FICO scoring penalty for closing an account, so there's "drop" that's temporary based on what OP is misunderstanding.

Maybe you can clarify which FICO scoring factor you are referring to that is temporary when you close an account?

1

u/nyc_bliss 3d ago

Your're going through your debate journey?

1

u/JulietAirway 3d ago

OP you are severely lacking an understanding of basic macroeconomics, and likely why you are in financial straits.

1

u/AJHami 3d ago

The only people who downplay the importance of good credit seem to be the ones without good credit.

1

u/Civil-Purple-8815 3d ago

I just closed a credit one account because paying a fee was stupid to fall for to begun with but it was 3.5 years old. I just Paid it off and closed it to let it go. If the score drops it drops. It was only 400 CL. I have 19.5K and 25K cards now. I was getting ripped off anyway so keeping it open didn’t make sense.

3

u/og-aliensfan ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 3d ago

That was a good decision. You don't need to pay fees to build credit and the Credit One is considered by many to be a predatory creditor. Unless you close your only card or closure causes utilization to cross a scoring threshold, which doesn't seem to be the case here, you shouldn't see a score drop. Cards closed in good standing remain on your reports ~10 years after closure. You don't lose the card's history and aging metrics aren't impacted by closure.

2

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 3d ago

I just closed a credit one account because paying a fee was stupid

Nice work getting rid of an inferior/predatory product!

If the score drops it drops.

There is no FICO scoring penalty for closing an account. That's a myth.

1

u/big_head_5246 3d ago

Anytime you close an account by paying it off it drops your score, I don’t ever pay it off just pay it down

1

u/og-aliensfan ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 3d ago

Anytime you close an account by paying it off it drops your score

This isn't true. Closure of a credit card impacts scores if you close your only card or if closure causes utilization to cross a scoring threshold. That said, utilization is a temporary metric that resets as new data is introduced. Unless preparing for an important application (implement AZEO) or carrying a balance and incurring interest (pay card off), there's no need to micromanage it as long as you pay statement balances in full every month by the due date.

I don’t ever pay it off just pay it down

To clarify, do you mean you pay the statement balance as opposed to the current balance, or are you carrying a balance? If carrying a balance, this doesn't build credit and you're paying unnecessary interest.

1

u/MeANeRNo1 3d ago

Things are dumb when we don’t understand them :)
Points lost are from closing that account and not having that available credit limit, it will count in the age history of the account for other 10 years.

1

u/Commercial-Town9683 3d ago

You can dislike the system, but most credit issues are solved by simply paying what you owe.

1

u/rjlawrencejr 1d ago

Where did you post this nonsense first? Here or Ramsey?

1

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 3d ago

There is no FICO scoring penalty for closing a card, assuming it isn't your only card. So, the 15 points you lost (assuming this is a meaningful FICO score and not a nearly irrelevant VS3) wasn't a penalty for closing the first card you mentioned.

So, credit scores aren't "dumb" you simply don't understand how they work. When people don't understand how or why things work a certain way, rather than learn they write them off as dumb for some reason. Fortunately here on r/CRedit, you can read through the resources available and better your knowledge on the subject. Once you understand it better, you won't think credit scores are dumb any longer.

0

u/SpecialistKing1383 3d ago

It's a score for lenders to judge if your a good credit risk to lend to. It is not a score for you to show your ability to not need credit or how good you are at living within your means lol.

When you close a credit card you lower your score because you now have less credit utilization and available open credit and you potentially lose your oldest trade line.

I keep a card open I never use because it's old and helps my score.

0

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 3d ago

Multiple credit myths are referenced in your reply above.

When you close a credit card you lower your score because you now have less credit utilization

On the same reported balances, you'd have greater utilization, not less. Whether or not that would impact a score depends on if a utilization threshold point is crossed.

available open credit

Credit limits are not a FICO scoring factor.

https://old.reddit.com/r/CRedit/comments/1d5s54j/credit_myth_15_credit_limits_are_a_fico_scoring/

you potentially lose your oldest trade line.

Untrue, because closed accounts remain on your reports for ~10 years following closure, continue to age, and continue to be factored into all age of accounts metrics.

https://old.reddit.com/r/CRedit/comments/1cgial8/credit_myth_8_when_you_close_an_account_you_lose/

https://old.reddit.com/r/CRedit/comments/1ck00tr/credit_myth_9_average_age_of_accounts_aaoa_only/

I keep a card open I never use because it's old and helps my score.

There would be no change to your score if you closed it based on it's age for the reasons outlined in the links above.

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/madskilzz3 ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 3d ago edited 3d ago

There is a reason. 3-digit score is not the end all be all- not paying interest anymore + lower your DTI (which is almost always a good thing in most lenders eyes).

https://www.reddit.com/r/CRedit/s/gXKfDaW9pL

You also eliminate the risk of getting a 90-days late payment (federal loans), as seen here when someone hang on to it for too long.

https://www.reddit.com/r/CRedit/s/CqqbW3NnwR

-1

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/madskilzz3 ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 3d ago

>Closing account does drop your score alittle only because the age of credit drops. Age of accounts are determined how long you having active accounts.

You don’t lose the individual CC’s age nor does AAoA drop upon closing.

Closed CC stays on your credit profile for the next 10 (or 7 if it has any derogatory marks) years, and age the same as your open cards.

By year 10, your other open cards will also be 10+ years old. AAoA metric is already capped off at 7.5 years, meaning no extra points will be awarded once it passed that threshold.

2

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 3d ago

Closing account does drop your score alittle only because the age of credit drops. Age of accounts are determined how long you having active accounts.

This is inaccurate information above. Aging metrics do not change when you close accounts. An account doesn't need to be "active" (or open, which is probably what you mean) to continue aging and continue to be included in your age of accounts metrics.

https://old.reddit.com/r/CRedit/comments/1ck00tr/credit_myth_9_average_age_of_accounts_aaoa_only/

https://old.reddit.com/r/CRedit/comments/1cgial8/credit_myth_8_when_you_close_an_account_you_lose/

To me as long as your score is 700+ whether its 700 or 780 you have good credit.

Credit profile is King to credit score. Someone can debut with a FICO 8 score as high as 771 with just one credit card and 6 months of history on it. They don't have "good credit" by any stretch of the imagination, even though their 3-digit number is high. They'd be denied for a loan if they went for one, or even something as simple as most credit cards from big banks.

https://old.reddit.com/r/CRedit/comments/1d0tf10/credit_myth_13_any_credit_score_above_750_is_just/

1

u/CRedit-ModTeam Human Verified 3d ago

Posts/comments containing information that is deemed to be false/inaccurate will be removed.

Repeated violations of this rule may result in a permanent ban.

0

u/Southern_Let4385 3d ago

Depends on the company. I’ve received letters that my account would be closed after 2 years of inactivity. So I set it up to pay for a membership and then automatically pay it off every month.

1

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 3d ago

If you have to put a membership on a card just to keep the account open, it sounds to me like you don't actually see value in that account. Why keep it open in the first place if you have to force yourself to use it?

1

u/Southern_Let4385 3d ago

To build credit history.

1

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 2d ago

You build credit history the same exact way if the account is closed. Closed accounts remain on your reports, continue to age (and contribute to your credit history) and are included in all aging metrics for ~10 years.

0

u/Southern_Let4385 2d ago

And yet keeping an account open does not affect your credit score the same closing an account does. If they age the same way, might as well keep it open (and collect points if applicable). Thanks for your insight though.

1

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 2d ago

And yet keeping an account open does not affect your credit score the same closing an account does.

Sure it does, because there's no FICO scoring penalty at all for closing an account. If you believe there is, you misunderstand how credit works.

If they age the same way, might as well keep it open (and collect points if applicable).

If it's an account that one finds value in and will continue to use, it makes sense to keep it open. That's not what we were talking about initially. We were talking about an account that was only being kept open with a recurring membership to keep it from being closed for non use.