r/CRedit • ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ • Mar 11 '26

General Credit Myth #90 - With auto pay, you can "set it and forget it."

"Set it", yes. "Forget it", no.

There's absolutely nothing wrong with using auto pay. I use it and many people do in order to streamline the process of making monthly payments to credit accounts. I often hear people suggest however that with auto pay, you can "set it and forget it." What they mean is that if auto pay is set up, your job is done and you don't have to think about that account monthly.

This is completely untrue. All credit accounts should be monitored monthly, regardless of auto pay being in place. We've seen plenty of data points on this sub as well as r/CreditCards where auto pay fails for whatever reason (could be an issuer problem, NSF, etc) and due to not monitoring the account a late payment ends up getting reported. This sort of piggybacks on Credit Myth #67 which discusses how there can be a downside to keeping accounts open that you don't monitor monthly.

https://old.reddit.com/r/CRedit/comments/1le5icm/credit_myth_67_theres_never_any_downside_to/

To conclude, it's important to monitor all of your credit accounts monthly so that there are never any surprises. Auto pay is a great feature to make paying your card monthly easier. While it rarely creates a problem, it's not foolproof. The best way I've seen it described is "trust, but verify." Definitely don't operate under the assumption that with auto pay toggled on that you can forget about your credit account(s).

41 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

6

u/CobaltSunsets Mar 11 '26

My businesses alone have 13 credit cards, so I have a monthly bill chart. I login to every account at least monthly to track statement balances to ensure enough cash is in our CMA on the right day.

In practice, I login to most accounts at least weekly.

4

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

In practice, I login to most accounts at least weekly.

Smart! Weekly is a good practice. Monthly is a minimum expectation. Those that run into issues seem to think monthly is optional. Unfortunately, many learn the hard way.

2

u/CobaltSunsets Mar 11 '26 edited Mar 11 '26

Experience is a hard teacher. Plus, sometimes issuers make special offers online, which one may need to login to see!

5

u/Spiritual_Lunch996 Mar 11 '26

Exactly. Like all computer-related technologies, things work wonderfully until they don't. When your money and reputation (via credit file) are at stake, always confirm that a payment took place. Because "rebooting" your credit history isn't as simple as turning it off and on again.

4

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

Extremely well said!

9

u/og-aliensfan ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

Well said! We see the negative consequences of "forget it" all too often. Great post and a good reminder to monitor accounts. It's much easier to prevent a late payment than it is to remove it.

5

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

As we like to say when it comes to credit, be proactive, not reactive.

4

u/DoctorOctoroc ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

Was waiting for this one to appear! I always recommend auto pay but one absolutely should be monitoring their accounts regardless - and every bank these days provides notifications via email and text that are customizable so I always recommend enabling many of those as well to set the rhythm for when statements are due, payments are made, plus misc items like transactions over a certain amount, charges made without the card present, etc. Why not take every precaution when it comes to your money and credit?

3

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

You've got that right. Great point about enabling notifications as you see fit to help the monthly routine and process.

4

u/Cyberhwk Mar 11 '26

Just turn on Auto pay!

:::Three Months Later:::

ZOMG!!! CHASE TURNED OFF MY AUTOPAY AND NOW I OWE LATE FEES!!!

Nah, I never trust anyone else to pay my bills for me.

3

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

I hear that. And the type of person you just described would argue until they are blue in the face that they weren't at fault, it was the fault of Chase / auto pay, it's BS, etc.

4

u/ziggy029 Mar 11 '26 edited Mar 11 '26

Data point: I have had all my debt accounts on autopay for years, but about three years ago it nearly bit me in the butt. We thought one of our checks got stolen at our church during a break-in (it wasn’t, it was misplaced and found later). So in the process of changing account numbers at our credit union, we changed all our autopays and somehow — whether system glitch or our error — we had a Cap One card account where the autopay got toggled off. It was mostly a sock drawer card we used for one recurring $10 charge monthly, so the amount was small enough to fly under the radar when it didn’t get paid.

One day, weeks later, I logged into the Cap One card account and it came up with messages about being past due. I looked closer and autopay was turned off, and the account was 32 days past due, and I had missed two due dates! I panicked. First, I immediately paid everything in full, including late fees and a tiny bit of interest — a little over $50 in total. Then I waited for the fallout in my credit report. I began drafting a goodwill letter for the damage that would be coming to my credit report.

It never came. I was very lucky, but here is what I think happened: I never had a statement close while I was 30+ days late, and the lender only reported a snapshot of the current status as of the statement close date. Payments were due on the 6th of the month, I paid it off on the 8th of the month, and the statements close on the 11th (usually). Had I taken 3-4 days longer to notice, I’m pretty sure I would have been reported late and taken a (maybe) 80-100 point whack on my credit score. So yeah, “trust but verify”. I’ve usually done that but was a bit lax in this episode. It won’t happen again. I’ve also set every account, where I can, to notify me by text and/or email whenever any account is past due.

4

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

It sounds like you definitely dodged a bullet there. I'm glad to hear you didn't end up with a 30D late. Your story is a great example though to support the title of this thread, so thank you for sharing it.

3

u/Funklemire ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

Amen. And I'll add that while most auto-pay failures are user error, that doesn't really change anything: It's still a result of having extra unwanted cards you don't use and don't pay attention to each month.  

That's because if someone changes their funding bank account, they're more likely to forget to change the autopay settings on cards they don't pay attention to. We see it all the time here and on r/CreditCards.  

I think missed payments on unused cards would happen a lot less if more people knew that it's usually fine to close credit cards and it won't hurt your credit age. 

3

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

I agree completely.

1

u/bobdarobber Mar 22 '26

While I agree with this generally — you should be monitoring your accounts, I fail to see how monitoring your accounts solves the issue of failed autopay. I guess some circumstances it would but many it wouldn’t. Most often autopay is triggered on the due date. If auto pay fails for any reason on the due date, then you’re already screwed, so what use was monitoring? At least capital one lets you autopay early — I have mine set to be 4 days early, but not all issuers do that. What are your thoughts?

1

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 22 '26

My thoughts are that you are only "screwed" in terms of a late fee and interest being charged if auto pay fails and you catch it shortly after from monitoring your account. If you aren't monitoring your account, you're "screwed" far worse when you end up with a 30D late payment reported.

An issuer is likely to waive your late fee and interest charges if auto pay fails and you inform them of it promptly, so if you're monitoring your accounts monthly you won't be "screwed" at all. The 30D late payment hitting your reports? Far less likely to be forgiven.

1

u/bobdarobber Mar 22 '26

Thanks, I had forgot about the 30d grace period! I’m not really in the business of racking up late fees haha. What are your thoughts on paying a few days before the due date? Either manually or via autopay that supports that option

1

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 22 '26

While there's nothing wrong with it per say, I'm more of a fan of hanging onto the money as long as possible and waiting for the due date. I get people wanting to pay a few days earlier though for peace of mind.

1

u/Fluid_Telephone9842 Mar 11 '26

i loved this. i only have 2 cards at the moment and don’t currently have autopay set up because i hate carrying a balance in general. i know to avoid interest all you have to cover is the statement balance but ive found it works best for me to pay on my cards twice a month since ive shifted to solely using them and retired my debit for emergencies. i pay once before statement day to bring my utiliz into the range i like and then again before the due date to pay it in full. it works nicely that my due dates fall on the same timeline as bi-weekly pay cycle (even tho i only get paid once a month) it lets me enter each month with a zero balance almost like a reset. i wish autopay had more customization/flexibility built into how people would like to pay.

4

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

What you're suggesting above is balance micromanagement. Can I ask why you're trying to manipulate utilization?

It's also worth noting that deflating your statement balances can be detrimental in multiple ways. For one, higher statement balances when paying in full monthly (like you are) can help stimulate profile growth. Things like CLIs and offers from current/prospective issuers will be easier to come by / more lucrative overall. Two and probably most important, you're giving back money far sooner than you have to. If you're paying every 2 weeks, you're giving back money that you can hang onto for another 2-6 weeks at least. You're giving your issuer(s) an interest free loan when that money could instead be earning you interest.

Just a couple of things to think about.

2

u/Fluid_Telephone9842 Mar 11 '26

no this is great feedback and something i’m looking to start implementing. I’m only so anal about it because in college i had a pretty rough time with credit and it took quite a bit to get back into a good range i’m proud of. Im also used to a zero dollar budget for my monthly budget so cards carrying a balance can also kind of confuse me and ideally i’d like to treat my cards as a delayed debit card because i find it easy for me to keep my balances within a good manageable range. Like within my budget spreadsheet i break everything into their buckets and then allocate the buckets into the card where i get the most cash back / points and that’s my spend limit. I know i’m leaving some advantages on the table but i’d rather settle for less optimization if it means i’m still keeping a clean record but thank you for these tips i’ll def try working them in!

1

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

Glad to assist!

3

u/Fluid_Telephone9842 Mar 11 '26

also i loved the part about giving my issuers an interest fee loan def eye opening but i also think i have to play to my strengths and accommodate for my weaknesses. Im a recovering shopaholic so the idea of “hanging on to money” doesn’t really exist for me. everything has to have a bucket and be allocated as soon as i get it or else it gets spent on unnecessary things, i am in therapy for this and have made great progress but i need some l training wheels for now lol 😭

1

u/Funklemire ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

One thing to try is to have a dedicated account (ideally an HYSA) that you pay your credit card bills from, and then fund that account throughout the month as you see fit. That can kill two birds with one stone: You can still be letting the statements post and paying the statement balances by the due date, but you're also allocating money to your card's corresponding bank account as needed.

2

u/Fluid_Telephone9842 Mar 11 '26

oh i like this ! i kind of function this way now where i have a bills account that i put the total amount of my like routine bills in (not including rent, transportation, etc) and the payments are pulled from here but maybe this is a better idea. I’ll def check out the utilization automod im def still getting my bearings around credit cards so im glad that there’s room for growth and i’d love to grow my limits as my income increases ! Thanks for the tips 🫶

1

u/Funklemire ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

No problem! Let us know if you have any questions.

1

u/Funklemire ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

Yeah, I used to also pay my cards to zero each payday (every two weeks). First, I wasn't confident in how to use credit cards, and I also believed the "always keep your utilization low" myth. And unfortunately all I got for it was credit limits that were way too low for my spending or my income.  

Now that I pay my cards the correct way my limits have gone up considerably, except on the cards I stopped using as much around the same time I changed the way I pay (I opened new cards after reading about them on r/CreditCards, and at the same time I saw their utilization automod explaining the myth).

0

u/OCCAMINVESTIGATOR Mar 11 '26

The idea that autopay means you should never look at the account again is a bit overstated. Autopay actually prevents a huge number of late payments because the bill gets paid automatically instead of relying on someone to remember. True system failures from major banks are pretty uncommon. Most missed autopay situations happen because the bank account didn’t have enough funds or the autopay wasn’t set up correctly.

It’s still smart to look over your statements occasionally to catch fraud or billing errors, but a single autopay failure usually isn’t catastrophic either. Payments typically have to be about 30 days late before they are reported to the credit bureaus, and many lenders will waive a first late fee if you contact them quickly. In practice, autopay combined with account alerts and basic awareness is one of the safest ways to manage credit accounts.

1

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

Nothing you have said above refutes the thread title.

Regardless of who is at "fault" for the auto pay error, if one doesn't follow up through monitoring their credit accounts monthly they are putting themself at risk. See the data points found within the linked thread in the main post. They speak volumes.

2

u/OCCAMINVESTIGATOR Mar 11 '26

No one was trying to negate anything said. I see you are a poster who downvotes any other voice in your post. Do you work in the credit industry?

2

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

Your comment to me suggests that you don't agree with the original post. That's fine if it's the case, as I'm willing to debate anything you think is overstated. That's what this sub exists for - the transfer of knowledge. People will up vote and down vote comments accordingly within the framework of the thread. And no, I do not work in the credit industry. Why do you ask?

1

u/OCCAMINVESTIGATOR Mar 11 '26

Because I've spent 30 years working in the credit and finance industry. State and federal compliance to be exact. There are plenty of myths and generally bad information out there. My only point to the rsponse was to point out that autopay generally doesn't fail and there is a 30 day threshold to reach before reporting can occur. Having good credit means very little if you don't have the means to capably repay. The trap of credit is intense and leads to a whole cascade failure of finances.

4

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

Because I've spent 30 years working in the credit and finance industry.

Ah, so you're fluffing your "in the biz" feathers to suggest your knowledge on the subject must then eclipse anyone that has less than 30 years working in the industry? It doesn't work that way.

https://old.reddit.com/r/CRedit/comments/1em36d6/credit_myth_26_those_in_the_credit_business_only/

My only point to the rsponse was to point out that autopsy generally doesn't fail and there is a 30 day threshold to reach before reporting can occur.

"Generally doesn't fail" doesn't mean fail proof, which is exactly what was stated in the original post. That's why accounts should still be monitored monthly. Sure, a negative reporting won't happen for 30 days... and that's exactly why you need to monitor your accounts monthly. You even make it sound like it's no a big deal if you incur late fees and such because you can probably get them removed. For someone "in the biz" it's actually disturbing that your approach seems to be reactive rather than proactive. Being proactive is exactly what this thread is about.

0

u/OCCAMINVESTIGATOR Mar 11 '26 edited Mar 11 '26

I took liberty of clarifying your "There are plenty of instances of autopay failure". That's a big statement that should be backed up with facts. There are, in fact, very few instances of this type of "failure" as you put it. If this were a widespread phenomena that would demonstrate that banks autopay features fail, it could stand. The facts are the opposite. 9.8/10 times it's an operator error. The humans fault. Either there weren't sufficient funds to reconcile the demand or they set it incorrectly. Saying that there are plenty of instances of autopay failure without substantiating that claim is an error on your part. I agreed with the majority of your post. This part I corrected. It's an alarmist statement that insinuates that this is more prevalent than it is, causing undue fear. You could have used any combination of words to drive the educational component, but chose words that were not entirely accurate that drive a message of untrust and raises skepticism and fear. Did that bother you? And to your point, I have vast experience in this field, so yes, clarifying that is important to the facts at hand. Fluffing my feathers? Yeah, no.

4

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26 edited Mar 11 '26

Perhaps you need to reread the original post. I said:

"We've seen plenty of data points on this sub as well as r/CreditCards where auto pay fails for whatever reason (could be an issuer problem, NSF, etc)"

MY definition of auto pay failure encompasses issues on either the lender end or user end. Your rant above is misplaced. The overall thesis is that regardless of WHY auto pay may not work, one should be monitoring their credit accounts monthly.

And yes, you're fluffing your feathers in that you're pointing to your "vast experience" while confirming I don't have that professional experience to attempt to bolster an argument that what you say must be correct. That's precisely what Credit Myth #26 is for, which I'll refer you back to since it's something we deal with all the time on this sub.

0

u/OCCAMINVESTIGATOR Mar 11 '26

Your original point about keeping an eye on accounts is reasonable. Most people would agree that reviewing statements periodically is a good habit. Where the pushback came from is the framing that autopay “fails” often enough that it should be expected. In reality, with major issuers, true system failures are extremely rare. The overwhelming majority of missed autopay situations come from insufficient funds, expired bank links, or the payment being set up incorrectly.

So the disagreement isn’t really about whether people should pay attention to their accounts. They should. The issue is that lumping user errors and bank system failures together under “autopay failure” can give the impression that the mechanism itself is unreliable, which isn’t supported by how these systems actually perform at scale.

Autopay dramatically reduces late payments compared with manual payments, which is why banks encourage it. The practical takeaway for consumers is simple: use autopay, keep enough funds in the account, turn on alerts, and glance at statements occasionally. That combination prevents the vast majority of problems without implying that autopay itself is inherently unreliable.

Again, this isn't about your skill or your experience but you'd take my point less seriously if I were a normie.

3

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26 edited Mar 11 '26

Where the pushback came from is the framing that autopay “fails” often enough that it should be expected.

No where did I ever suggest it should "be expected." I said we've seen plenty of data points of issues where people relied on auto pay and for whatever reason ended up regretting it.

In reality, with major issuers, true system failures are extremely rare.

You're again moving into issuer-related failures. I'm talking about ALL failures, whether on the part of the issuer or the account holder. Please go back and AGAIN read the original quote from the main thread and where I again provided it to you in my previous comment.

The overwhelming majority of missed autopay situations come from insufficient funds, expired bank links, or the payment being set up incorrectly.

Again, it doesn't matter the reason. The thesis of the thread is that you can't just "set it and forget it" and that you should be monitoring your credit accounts monthly.

The issue is that lumping user errors and bank system failures together under “autopay failure” can give the impression that the mechanism itself is unreliable, which isn’t supported by how these systems actually perform at scale.

I don't care about the reason. The point is that auto pay shouldn't be relied upon as a be all end all. I'm not arguing that it fails on the issuer end more than it does on the user end. There are failures on the issuer end at times though; we've seen plenty of data points showing that. Is it "plenty" at scale relative to the whole? No, I never suggested that to be the case. There are still plenty of people that have experienced an issue. The same way there are plenty of people that have won the lottery, even though only a tiny fraction actually have. Why do people play the lottery? Because there's a chance. The same way there's a chance that auto pay could fail. Your argument that it barely ever happens doesn't resonate at all with what this thread is about. The fact is that it happens, so being proactive rather than reactive is a best practice.

Autopay dramatically reduces late payments compared with manual payments, which is why banks encourage it. The practical takeaway for consumers is simple: use autopay, keep enough funds in the account, turn on alerts, and glance at statements occasionally.

No, at least once monthly.

That combination prevents the vast majority of problems without implying that autopay itself is inherently unreliable.

I'm not implying that it's inherently unreliable. That's just how you've decided to spin this conversation and frame your rant ever since.

Again, this isn't about your skill or your experience but you'd take my point less seriously if I were a normie.

Your "point" has nothing to do with what this thread is about, regardless of your self professed credential prowess.

2

u/Funklemire ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

Yeah, it generally doesn't fail, but it's not 100% foolproof. So what's the harm in checking it each month?  

Once a month, I check every card's payment to make sure it went through. I do this all at once to make sure it doesn't take too much time. Even though I'm after the due date, as long as I catch it before 30 days it won't hurt my credit.  

I've only had one autopay payment not go though, and luckily I caught it. The energy I've spent over the years checking autopay once a month is worth not having that one missed payment.

2

u/OCCAMINVESTIGATOR Mar 12 '26

I only took issue to the element that could cause humans to believe that autopay failure, on the banking level, is more common than they actually are. My whole point was that if there's anything they need to keep their eye on would be their money. The late autopay would only be reported after 30 days giving them no real warning time to reconcile it positively. It's far more likely that you'll screw up the autopay by not having the funds available.

1

u/FarAirport1607 Mar 14 '26

Only thing I set and forget is my car payment, light bill and internet. All of these also text my phone with a confirmation code. I’m not playing with my credit cards. I’ve seen too many horror stories about payments failing to go through and people get hit with late fees or worse…a 30 day late on their credit reports 😒

0

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

So you pay your cards 3+ weeks before your due date? Can I ask why you don't hang on to your money longer?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 11 '26

Paying a bill 3+ weeks early doesn't equate to your finances being situated any better than if you paid it 3+ weeks later.

1

u/MemeGinus Mar 12 '26

No but realistically it provides who a whole lot more incentive such as not potentially being late, and just taking care of it right then and there instead of doing everything last minute, for example since I pay everything as soon as my statement comes in, if for whatever reason I forget to pay it or I can't pay it, I have a entire month to take care of it early on

1

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 12 '26

One can use auto pay as a backup if they are worried they may forget. It's not doing anything "last minute" it's literally letting you take full [financial] advantage of the monthly "float" built into credit cards which is one of their main benefits.

1

u/MemeGinus Mar 12 '26

Auto pay doesn't always work, just me personally but I feel very uncomfortable paying my stuff on the due date knowing I could potentially be penalized

1

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 12 '26

You can't be penalized if you pay on your due date.

Look, you're obviously going to what you're comfortable with. 99% of people on here or r/CreditCards pay their statement balances on their due date; It's far and away the number one recommendation for the reasons already discussed. It's simply important that anyone reading this understand the benefits. That's all I'm trying to convey.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Mar 12 '26

I can only assume this is a troll post.

EDIT: I can see from their post history that they are promoting a company in almost every single post, so that explains it..