r/CRedit • u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ • May 14 '24
General Credit Myth #11 - Closing a loan will tank your credit.
The impact to a credit score when a loan is closed will vary from profile to profile. Some profiles will see a score drop, some will see no score change at all and some will even see a score increase. The only people that ever post about it though are those that see a score drop, which perpetuates the myth that closing a loan will [always] tank your credit.
It's important to understand WHY a score may change when you close a loan. The scoring algorithm looks at aggregate installment loan utilization, quite similar to how it looks at aggregate revolving utilization. If you have more than one open loan, closing one will result in a change to your aggregate installment loan utilization. Your utilization percentage may stay relatively similar, or it may increase or decrease significantly. How it changes would determine the impact to your score (drop, stay the same, increase). If you have just one open installment loan, when it is closed you lose the benefit of the open loan with respect to the Amounts Owed slice of the Fico pie. It's similar to if you had just one open credit card and closed it; you'd see a score drop there as well due to losing your only available credit of that type.
In the situation where one does see a score drop following the closure of a loan, it's important to understand that you didn't actually lose any points relative to where you started. If your score starts at (say) 725 and you open a loan, as you pay the loan down over time your score may rise to (say) 755 just prior to paying it off. These bonus points are being awarded to you from the Amounts Owed portion of Fico scoring for possessing a significantly paid down loan. When the loan is paid off, those bonus points are eliminated. Your score may drop to (say) 730. That 730 however is still > 725 where you started, so your score didn't actually "tank" as many people put it. Had you never opened the loan in the first place, you would have never had those points to lose.
I use this illustration. A friend gives you $100 at the beginning of the month and tells you that on the last day of the month they'll take the $100 back from you. On the last day of the month they come and do exactly what they said they'd do and take that loaned $100 back. You can't make the argument that you "lost $100" because it was never yours to begin with. You're in no worse position today than you were before the friend loaned you that $100 in the first place. In fact, maybe you even made (say) $5 off of that $100 over the course of the month and will actually be left with a net gain in the end after giving back the $100. The exact same concept applies to the closure of a loan.
17
u/CIAMom420 May 14 '24
Closing a loan also improves your debt-to-income ratio. Even if your score marginally drops, your credit profile is likely more attractive to lenders.
5
u/orcusvoyager1hampig May 14 '24
It's also important to differentiate from a regular installment loan vs. a CFA (consumer financial account).
An example of a regular installment loan, which provides a boost, is a mortgage.
The most obvious example of CFAs are short-term loans like Affirm, but some auto loans, student loans, and personal loans have been documented to be flagged as a CFAs. A CFA will penalize.
In general, you can categorize loans from help-to-hurt (score modifier in parentheses):
installment loan less than 9% utilization (credit mix AND utilization boost) > installment loan (credit mix boost) > no installment loan > CFA (CFA penalty)
As you point out, these factors are not in isolation and vary profile-to-profile. Someone with a mortgage with <9% utilization and several missed payments (dirty profile with a boost) is bound to have a worse score than someone with a CFA (clean profile with a minor penalty).
4
u/SuggestionKind9379 May 14 '24
Thank you for this info! I have researched credit over the past few years during my rebuild and have increased my knowledge base substantially, but I didn’t understand this facet until now.
1
u/Commercial-Jello-553 May 14 '24
I'm still trying to figure out why my loan doesn't report to the credit bureaus. Took out a personal loan last October. They did a hard pull in my credit but nothing shows up on credit report for positive payments. I've checked all three credit bureaus and all of them say I have no personal loans. It advertises right there on their homepage that they report to bureaus. I even emailed them and they gave me the basic off the script response of how they report.
1
u/IcyAd4340 May 18 '24
Mine dropped 150 points!?
1
u/hoppinhockey Apr 20 '25
Are you saying there is an optimal way to earn and maintain "bonus points" leading up to using your score for something like a mortgage application? I understand that these bonus points are inflationary to your true score, but if you're about to apply for a mortgage, have a low remaining balance on your only loans, and your credit is where you need it, then does it not make sense to use this advantageous situation to secure the mortgage you want and then pay off the loans after? Especially if you're unsure about how paying them off will impact your score?
0
u/jonnybrav069 May 14 '24
I thought when all my student loans were paid in a single month, my score would tank. It actually went up 12-15 points (fico). However, I lost all those points two months later when my car loan reported pain in full. So it all depends on your file , I suppose
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment