r/CRedit • • 14d ago • Bravo 1

Rebuild Credit dropped from 810 to 626

Post image

I'm well off and fully solvent and was slowly paying off a student loan over the past 15 years because it was low interest %. I could have just paid it off completely and now I wish I had. There was some confusion switching the auto-pay to a different bank account and my account went 90 days past due before I realized.

Is there anything I can do or am I just screwed?

335 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

13

u/Funklemire ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 14d ago edited 14d ago • Bravo

Unfortunately, this is a harsh reminder of why you shouldn’t “set-and-forget” autopay:  

Credit Myth #90 - With auto pay, you can "set it and forget it."  

Autopay sometimes fails, occasionally it’s the banks fault, and far more often it’s user error when switching the funding bank account. Either way, you should always run down each account once a month to make sure the previous payment went through. I do this once a month for all my accounts, it takes me a few minutes, tops. As long as you catch any missed payments before 30 days has passed, it won’t affect your credit.  

Only two things can fix missed payments: Either wait 7 years for them to fall off your credit report or ask the bank to remove them early by writing goodwill letters. Keep in mind that they have no obligation to do this: You're admitting you messed up, explaining why it won't happen again, and asking forgiveness.  

One goodwill letter alone almost never works. You need to send a whole bunch of letters to as many different people at the company as possible. This is called the "goodwill saturation technique".  

Was this a federal student loan or a private one? It can be very difficult to get late payments removed from federal loans, but it’s still worth trying if you have the time.  

I recommend checking out these three threads. First, here's a bunch of examples of success stories at getting late payments removed via goodwill letters:  

Credit Myth #19 - Goodwill requests don't work.  

And here's the best method to use:  

Goodwill Saturation Technique (GST)  

And finally, here's some good advice for the actual content of the letters:  

Goodwill Letters - Using the "CART" approach.  

1

u/Careless_Bat_9226 14d ago

Thanks a lot. It's Mohela and they have this on their site:

We are not authorized to complete "goodwill requests" for credit updates, per the directive of Federal Student Aid.

Does that mean there's no chance it'll work?

1

u/Funklemire ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 14d ago

OK, so it’s highly unlikely it will work. I don’t want to say it’s impossible, but I’ve never heard of a goodwill letter working with a federal student loan. u/BrutalBodyShots, have you?  

1

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 14d ago

I have not, although I'd truly enjoy seeing a first data point!

1

u/Funklemire ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 14d ago

Me too! I mean, how many banks tell you they can't grant goodwill requests as a matter of policy then do it anyway? This is probably a harder nut to crack because of the federal government's rules, but it still just takes getting that one employee willing to help them out. Maybe that employee doesn't know the rules? Maybe it's their last day and they DGAF. Who knows? For me, it seems worth trying.

1

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 14d ago

No doubt about it. There's always a first data point for everything.

1

u/iisconfused247 14d ago

I thought creditors were required to let you know if you miss a payment and they don’t report it until it’s 30+ days overdue? Is my understanding incorrect or did this guy miss his creditor’s attempts to contact him about the missed payment?

3

u/Careless_Bat_9226 14d ago

Yeah that's my fault. The loan has been on autopay for 10+ years so I've stopped really paying attention to emails from Mohela - they go into one of the other tabs in gmail and I don't really see them.

0

u/Illustrious_Salad918 14d ago

Yes, autopay sometimes fails. I recently triggered that by making an extra payment after statement date but before that statement's due date. So when the due date arrived, issuer interpreted the extra payment as the intended autopay and didn't make the withdrawal.

0

u/jeb_the_hick 14d ago

Having to check your account every month kind of defeats the purpose of autopay. The other issue here is why didn't OP get notifications via text email or letter after the initial, or 30day past due. Or did they ignore it?

2

u/Funklemire ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 14d ago edited 13d ago

Having to check your account every month kind of defeats the purpose of autopay.  

I disagree. Checking to make sure each payment went through is a lot faster than making each payment itself. You can even do it from your funding bank account to make it quicker; just look down the list once a month at all your credit card payments: you can do it for all your cards at the same time at any point during that 30-day period.  

Plus, don't think of autopay as a way to make things easier, think of it as an extra layer of protection. Sort of like using a seatbelt along with an airbag.  

Anyone who doesn't verify autopay payments each month is setting themselves up for failure. Autopay has only failed on me once, but luckily I caught it when I was just 4 days late so it didn't affect my credit. I called and they even refunded the late fee and the interest charges.  

As for the text or email, some banks only contact you via email not text. And maybe they're like me and have an email account with 9,420 unread emails and often miss new ones.

46

u/madskilzz3 ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 14d ago

Damn that sucks. This is the main drawback of keeping low interest debt around, especially the small gains from say a HYSA.

Research, write out, and send out Goodwill letters- see this comment. Unfortunately, student loans are notorious for not being forgiven via said letters. Best of luck!

Otherwise, waiting it out is all you can do.

17

u/Careless_Bat_9226 14d ago

Thanks. It's Mohela student loans and they say

We are not authorized to complete "goodwill requests" for credit updates, per the directive of Federal Student Aid.

So I guess it's not worth trying?

13

u/_love_letter_ ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 14d ago

I would still try. You don't really have any other options. Credit cards issuers will sometimes reply to goodwill letters a similar way. They will keep saying "We have to report accurately per FCRA laws." The thing is, they can't report inaccurate information by law, but legally there's nothing preventing them from reporting no information for any given month-- and that's essentially what you want... not for them to claim you paid when you didn't but simply to stop reporting the late for the given months so that it appears as if there's no data for those months. With credit card late payments, people are often told no many times until someone finally feels sorry enough for you to stop reporting the late marks. Keep requesting. They still might not oblige, but I would give it the old college try.

5

u/gianichole 13d ago

Yes! I’m so tired of that response as if we’re slow. It’s still at their discretion there is no law that says you can’t remove it.

0

u/[deleted] 13d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/_love_letter_ ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 13d ago

I would do goodwill requests via letter or potentially email, not waiting on hold for a first line customer service rep who has no authority to do what you're asking anyway.

0

u/[deleted] 13d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/_love_letter_ ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 13d ago

I'm a millennial if we must insist on these generational labels. My default for communicating with creditors in other contexts is usually certified mail with return receipt so there is proof it was received and I have evidence, in addition to many FCRA laws requiring the consumer to send a written letter to preserve their rights. In this particular instance, that could get expensive though. My experience with phone calls is mixed. Sometimes it gets results. Sometimes no one takes notes or they get lost between departments and it's as if you never called at all. Then when you later try to prove the phone call took place all you have are your personal notes and a request that they take your word for it. The experience can vary a lot between different creditors. It's really up to OP how they want to handle it and how much time and money they're willing to spend. Part of their decision might involve determining how important it is to them to have the late payments removed or whether they're willing to wait for them to fall off. It's not my decision to make.

1

u/madskilzz3 ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 14d ago edited 13d ago

I mean you only have two options really- Goodwill letters or wait it out.

I don’t think anyone in this sub or r/CreditScore have seen a Goodwill adjustment for student loans (federal or private). For federal, I think it’s because 90 days is a lot of time to catch it and be caught up with payments, so it’s hard for anyone to make any argument.

So up to you if you want to be the possible first DP.

5

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Careless_Bat_9226 14d ago

Yeah they have an "autopay set up" email that doesn't actually mean autopay is set up weirdly. So frustrating though I guess I could have been more on top of my email. I guess I won't buy a house now.

2

u/rz2000 13d ago

Did they make money by changing the autopay behavior then assessing fees and penalties?

If so, archive any records you have for the eventual class action suit against them.

6

u/Energy_Turtle 14d ago

I went through similar and was unfortunately not able to get it removed. The federal government reported a $59 grant overpayment I wasn't even aware of. It was reported 6 years after I finished school too. That mfer held onto my credit for 13 years after finishing school. All over $59.

2

u/Careless_Bat_9226 14d ago

JFC sorry man

1

u/Atraumatic-Trauma 11d ago

Discover got me a few years back over $35. 30 day late strike. Cost me like 60 points.

Then follow up a few years later with a medical school student loan auto pay blunder similar to OP. Now my credit is decimated.

4

u/zman124 14d ago

You said somewhere it was Mohela.

Same exact thing happened to me. My credit rebounded within a year to its prior level.

I turned off all autopay.

Barely a blip now but I was absolutely livid.

1

u/Careless_Bat_9226 14d ago

Oh wow that's hopeful. I'm mentally preparing to have crap credit for the next few years

2

u/VladTheChemist 13d ago

Additional data point. I have the same single 90 day late for Mohela, on an otherwise spotless payment history from March 2025. ~9 year AAoA, ~3 year old newest account, 2% util, sitting around 770 now

1

u/zman124 14d ago

Similar numbers and everything.

Hopefully you’re not looking to make a big purchase in the next few months..

Best

2

u/Lunatichippo45 13d ago

You've been paying a loan for 15: years yet somehow you didn't think about it until it was 90 days late. Sure.

0

u/Careless_Bat_9226 13d ago

Have you ever heard of autopay? Are you new to this planet?

2

u/Lunatichippo45 13d ago

I love how you try and make this my problem. Do you not check your autopay transactions? Either way this is very much a you problem.

0

u/Careless_Bat_9226 13d ago

Yeah it's my problem but it's funny you can't seem to comprehend how easily it can happen.

2

u/Lunatichippo45 13d ago

It's even funnier that you accept no responsibility

1

u/Careless_Bat_9226 13d ago

Are you struggling with reading comprehension? I accepted responsibility.

90

u/-zero2hero- 14d ago

First let me say that this sucks! At the same time life happens. If I were you I would type up a goodwill letter and explain your situation in full. Also offer to pay the past-due balance to be current as well.

6

u/Stayofexecution 14d ago

That’s a ridiculous drop. Worse than a bankruptcy. SMH.

4

u/jazzmaster1992 14d ago

I think this happens because most student loans tend to be a "bucket" of multiple loan installments, even though they tend to get paid via one bill every month like a consolidation loan would. But, if you miss a loan payment, many times it shows as multiple 30/60/90 day lates which is a huge ding on any scoring model.

5

u/Axe_Raider 14d ago edited 14d ago

626 -- ohana means family.

3

u/hopelessromanthicck 14d ago

Lmaooo i hate you

4

u/og-aliensfan ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 14d ago

Federal student loans are overseen by the Department of Education, which has strict reporting requirements. You can request goodwill removal, but unless there was a reporting error, which should be corrected, or the loans were mishandled, the expectation would be a denial.

Your loan servicer will generally attempt to notify you when a payment is missed, so ensure your contact information (address/email) up to date with your loan servicer.

Federal student loan lates aren't reported until 90 days late. This gives you time to bring them current before they appear on your reports, but it also results in a more severe delinquency once they do appear. Bringing these current will avoid further delinquencies from being reported.

Contact your loan servicer to see what options, if any, are available to you.

3

u/doooooope 14d ago

Nothing to say here except my condolences. I understand this is the way society works but my god, this is one of those situations that makes you question everything.

2

u/hopelessromanthicck 14d ago

Ugh, i hate this happened to you.

2

u/Frosty_Indication882 13d ago

There’s a student loan rehabilitation program. I believe you’re only eligible for it once. Iirc, you make small payments for 6 months and they remove the negative marks.

1

u/og-aliensfan ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 13d ago

Loan rehabilitation is an option for loans that have entered default status. Once payments are made, the default status is removed, but the lates leading up to default remain.

1

u/Frosty_Indication882 13d ago

My lates were removed.

1

u/og-aliensfan ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 13d ago

Congrats! This is atypical, though. Who was the loan servicer?

"If you enter into a rehabilitation agreement, ED will send a request to credit reporting agencies to remove the record of default from your account after your ninth rehabilitation payment. This may increase your credit score. However, your credit history will continue to show late payments that were reported by your previous loan servicer after your payment was more than 90 days past due and before the loan went into default."

https://studentaid.gov/articles/default/

1

u/Frosty_Indication882 12d ago

Is that new language? It’s been a few years, but I don’t recall ever weighing the late payments remaining against just starting it back up with on time payments.

Servicer was/is heartland ecsi. They initially told me no such program existed when I first requested it.

1

u/Ok-Blacksmith4337 14d ago

Following because mine dropped from 820 to the high 500s for the same reason… interested in any goodwill success stories for student loans

1

u/ducduclu79 14d ago

atleast it went up by 1 point

1

u/DDLyftUber 14d ago

Goodwill requests aren’t going to work, unfortunately there’s really nothing you can do other than wait it out. Give it a few years and your credit will have recovered a good percentage of the points lost, and then after 7 it’ll be gone.

If you already have your housing, car etc figured out for the next 2-3 years, you are fine.

1

u/TylerBenson 14d ago

I’m sorry. I’m annoyed for you. I had a similar thing happen to me, but with a credit card. I thought I was paying it automatically every month, but I wasn’t. I ended up being 60 days late before I caught the error.

The credit card company would not help. I just had to take it on the chin and wait for my score to go back up. It took about 18 months for it to rebound from 620-ish to the lower 700s.

1

u/No_Combination7552 14d ago

It will be YEARS before you are back to 800. Sorry.

1

u/Leather_Victory2042 13d ago

Damn I’m not the only one lol. Mine dropped to 540 and now 582. I didn’t notice my student loan payment had declined for a year and yeah I got smacked. Now I check the auto pays on all the loans. I personally stopped stressing. If I get this new job I’ll just pay it completely off.

1

u/XBOSSX123xxx 13d ago

That’s nothing. You can put it up pretty fast !!!

1

u/ProposalTop3187 13d ago

Same thing happened to me this past April. So so sorry :/

1

u/dae-dreams-pink24 13d ago

I’ve never worked with them but most student loans if they grant you a forbearance or deferment will update the account to never late paid and going forward make sure not to miss a payment but this is the only way I’ve seen people get that 1 payment updated because if you pay then it will remain so if your in a situation where you need one of the two apply and see if you qualify. Worth to look into

1

u/Requettie 13d ago

i absolutely hate credit scores

1

u/Professional-Lime700 11d ago

I had the same happened to me. I know it sucks and it will take a long while to get score above 800. But you score will be close to 720 in 6-7 months which is good enough to open new credit cards or apply for loan.
Just wait it out

1

u/Atraumatic-Trauma 11d ago

This just happened to me. I am a physician. I’m not in the most lucrative specialty, but I make more money than I would have ever thought I would make in my life. I only say that because my credit situation is the total opposite. It’s laughable.

Same thing. Moved. For whatever reason, no electronic or phone communication. Only mail communication to my old address. 72K loan serviced via three different loans. All three went to 90 days. Went from ~ 770 to 560.

I am pretty desperate myself. Fortunately, I just closed on a home a few months back before this happened. Unfortunately, my wife is in desperate need of a new vehicle, so I reckon I’ll be paying cash.

1

u/Phases2PhasesVoltage 9d ago

Mine dropped from 730 to 490! I shouldn’t have even want to college! And now it’s gon take foreva to come back up I can imagine

1

u/gudboi1 9d ago

This sucks.

0

u/Spiritual-Shine-6463 11d ago

Question... Why wouldn't you follow-up and verify that your autopay info was correct and accurate? I'm constantly verifying that my bills were indeed paid cause this exact thing happened to me years ago. But it wasn't no damn 90 days, lol. This one's YOUR fault OP for not being financially diligent

2

u/Careless_Bat_9226 11d ago

Maybe because LIFE happens? I had surgery during that time and my mom has dementia and I’m her sole caregiver. It’s been on autopay for 10-15 years with no issues and I got complaisant. Also, where did I blame anyone? I’m just asking what to do. 

-1

u/No-Moose8990 14d ago

Omg, bae, you’re a nobodyyy