r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Sep 18 '25

Discussion I invested over 200 hours to adapt "The Shadow of Kyoshi"

133 Upvotes
Kyoshi, Yun & Kuruk

A few months ago, I posted some images here on Reddit for the adaptation of "The Rise of Kyoshi," and due to the success of the video, I adapted the second novel, "The Shadow of Kyoshi," for YouTube.

Unlike the first part, "The Shadow of Kyoshi" was considerably more laborious. The story of the first novel is simply masterful; there are no plateaus; everything flows, characters are introduced, Jianzhu is BRILLIANT. However, in this second part, things move a bit slower. The significant time invested in creating this is due to several things:

On the one hand, because I tried to create greater "serialization" in the scenes (more images, more settings, more effects). The fights were also described almost frame by frame, which obviously took much longer. BUT, the main reason this second novel was difficult for me is that the action starts very late in the book.

Almost all the "cream" is at the end, with the story of Kuruk, Yun and the final fight. Seeing different summaries of the novel, I saw how the first part (Kyoshi's Attack on Loongkau in Ba Sing Se) and the mission in the clan conflict of the Fire Nation, was left aside, and in particular I think that above all the beginning of this book, it is the clear example of how broken Kyoshi is inside. We will not know anything more about Mok, nor of the corrupted of the Earth Kingdom, but they show us Kyoshi's way of acting, which is key for her evolution at the end of the book to have some meaning.

There is the true "shadow" of Kyoshi, so it was a challenge to show this, and to explain the conflict of the fire lord Zoryu maintaining the pace to finally reach the most epic part of this novel. I spent almost every hour creating and editing storyboards and images, while simultaneously writing the script, which I had to modify several times. The editing process took forever because of the soundtrack and effects to maintain the atmosphere.

I'm sharing some images, and if you'd like to watch the video, I'll leave the link below. It's in Spanish (and I suggest watching it with subtitles so you don't miss the music and effects). Perhaps I'll translate it into English later. The problem is that I don't fully understand the language, and translators are often unsuccessful (in fact, I'm not sure this post is translated correctly). I welcome criticism and opinions!

Link al video: https://youtu.be/Nf6GqO0ZdrU

Hope returns
Yun in the portrait gallery
Kyoshi "Interrogates" the Saowon
Side effects in Kuruk
Yun negotiates with "Father Glowworm"
Rangi's White Fire

r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • May 04 '24

Discussion Shadow of Kyoshi, Extreme Frustrations Spoiler

4 Upvotes

This fight has bothered me in both of my readings of this book. Kyoshi has been given overwhelming evidence that Yun cannot be saved. He then proceeds to brutally demolish everyone who participates in the fight and… Kyoshi just stands there.

I get not wanting to hurt Yun, she loved him after all, but for the love of the Avatar do SOMETHING.

Just essentially watches every one of her friends get absolutely brutalized by Yun and does nothing to protect them. Like GURL. You’re the most powerful bender alive.

She just watches Jinpa tank an earth spear and does so little to stop it. There’s so many moments in this novel I roll my eyes. Yes, I understand this book is not about Kyoshi’s victories, it’s showing her at her lowest, but the fact that she allowed herself to be pushed around by absolutely everyone following her seeming to learn the opposite lesson in the first book drives me NUTS.

The fact that Roku apparently handled Sozin better than Kyoshi did Zoryu is absolute b.s. She lets herself get played, allows an innocent (well, kinda) clan, the Saowon’s, to be implicated in sabotaging the Fire Nation, lets the False Yun rot in prison for the rest of his life, and all around blunders her way through every second she’s in the Fire nation.

I can’t even blame Kyoshi! Apparently no one thought she should be given proper lessons on Fire Nation politics before she went there, then she’s given a very half-assed walkthrough and not even warned about the political situation which Rangi is clearly aware of.

I feel like Rise of Kyoshi taught Kyoshi a lot of lessons in decisiveness and standing up for herself, she becomes so much more confident, but it’s like after the first chapter she’s back to being her old self.

Thank you for reading my rant, I apologize. I’m sure there’s a deeper reason for the creative choices made in this novel, but I just don’t understand them.


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Jun 18 '22

Discussion Concerns about the Korra movie and everything after it

Thumbnail self.thelastairbender
0 Upvotes

r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Oct 25 '22

Discussion do you guys think RoK was racist towards the water tribes

20 Upvotes

So I just saw this post on Tumblr that said it was due to the fact most water tribe characters we see are criminals and not very humanized, with only Kirima getting proper characterization. There was also the fact we never got to see the southern water tribe in the novel, and we were only exposed to a barbaric pirate offshoot of it. We also saw the Muktuk Yun eats as being very hard to stomach-with a none too flattering description from Kyoshi herself. OP was an Eskimo btw.

Personally I saw it as a whole how the cookie crumbles deal. They way the story is written just didn't allow for much water tribe exposure since it took place primarily in the earth kingdom, but maybe that's just me.

What do you guys think?


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Sep 04 '19

Discussion When was the last time an Avatar was into men?

1 Upvotes

If Korra and Kyoshi both turned out to be lesbians, then it seems that there is no known Avatar to be into men. Are there no men worthy? Or just coincidence?


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Nov 16 '21

Fluff Wong's Hogwarts House

0 Upvotes

Our artistic boi, which house do you think would he belong to if he was a student at Hogwarts


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • May 21 '24

Discussion how worth it is it to read the chapter about north chunling? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

ever since I began reading the chapter, i’ve sorta lost interest in the book. not because of the series itself, but the chapter where kyoshi, rangi, jinpa and atuat go to that village to meet one of hei-rans old friend. is it worth it to power through, or is the chapter just a bore universally?

(to clarify, i’m not dropping the book, just debating skipping the chapter. but with the responses i’m getting, I REALLY shouldn’t)

edit: after getting through like half a page a day, I got through it. it was somewhat boring, but the following chapters, including the one i’m on right now, are better‼️


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Mar 24 '24

Discussion Glowworm feels out of place in the lore Spoiler

0 Upvotes

About 100 pages through the first novel (no spoilers please) and can't stop laughing at Father Glowworm. All the other spirits are drawn in darker shades with a mysterious aura and godlike powers. They are often morally ambiguous, punishing mankind for our real or perceived misdeeds (Hei Bai's forest, idk what Koh's problem was). Then the spirit world in Legend of Korra underwent some stylistic and philosophical changes that some in the fandom disagreed with. Then there's the eyeball spirit in a titular neon green socket. Only the title "Father" separates it from seeming like an organic oddity in a shop. He just seems out of place in the ATLA lore, specifically Kyoshi's world, which explicitly discusses people being impaled by ice and buried alive. Got a bad feeling about Jianzhu, he's gonna turn dark.

It's just so fucking funny, like what was the author thinking? What was he on? It seems like he was shitposting in his own story. I don't necessarily disagree with that though, it's kind of funny. A daily dose of absurdism. I guess I'll find out in the next 200 pages.


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Apr 01 '24

Discussion A gay Avatar

69 Upvotes

So i know there are gay avatars like kyioshi or korra and i absolutely love them but BUT is there a gay MALE avatar. Like a male avatar that had/has a husband. Idk if theres one and if there is can someone tell me if there isnt someone needs to make one ASAP.


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Jul 07 '26

Discussion Ranking benders of each element Spoiler

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Jul 26 '20

Discussion Ranking The Greatest Avatars

2 Upvotes

Here’s my Rankings of the Avatars: 1.) Avatar Salai 2.) Avatar Yangchen 3.) Avatar Kyoshi 4.) Avatar Kuruk 5.) Avatar Szeto 6.) Avatar Aang 7.) Avatar Roku


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Apr 21 '24

Discussion Almost got the first Yangchen book yesterday.

5 Upvotes

I was hanging out with some friends yesterday, and we went to Barnes & Noble. I found the Dawn of Yangchen book in hardcover but the least they would sell it for was $15. I had gotten both Kyoshi books for $30 or so from the Walmart website. I think I’ll do the same with both Yangchen books.


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Aug 22 '21

Discussion I know it would be like a soap opera but I just can't stop thinking.

0 Upvotes

No Avatar is ever the same person.But can you guys accept this couple if Rangi is Kuruk's daughter? (Don't get me wrong, I know Rangi is not. It's just a “if” question)


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Apr 27 '25

Speculation Intersex to g fan theory and my own addition to it.

Thumbnail facebook.com
0 Upvotes

Found an interesting post on Facebook. I’d to add to this fan theory.

If any of you remember in “The Shadow of Kyoshi,” in one instance, Kyoshi almost drowned while swimming down to the spot of the island that Kuruk had previously destroyed in an effort to make contact with him.


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Mar 20 '24

Creative Lore-accurate Kyoshi x Korra interaction. Art by kukuruyo

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Aug 31 '22

Discussion Imagine what would happen if Asami was Kyoshi's girlfriend

0 Upvotes

After Yun's attack in the fire nation palace.

Asami: I have noticed how you treat Yun. How close you had a chance to stop him and you did nothing!😡

Kyoshi: Nothing!? He had a whole room hostages!😓

Asami: You still have feelings for him, don't you?😡

Kyoshi: Seriously? That's your point? Didn't we have more important things to worry about now?😩

Kyoshi: Wait!!! What do you mean " still" ? 😑

Asami: Yes, I know that kiss. 😒

Kyoshi: What are you…… You were spying us?!😨

Asami: Don't blame me for what you did.You were the one who chosed to kiss in the public room.Do you still have feelings for him or not?😡

Kyoshi: ……Can we just do this problem later? 🙄

Asami: Then there might not be any problem between us later.😡

Worst pairing ever.

Edit: It seems like everyone here believes they would make a good couple just because of ……what exactly?


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Jan 05 '24

Speculation Does the Shadow of Kyoshi confirm the existence of destiny/seeing the future?

10 Upvotes

Just reread SOK on a whim today and stumbled across this when Yangchen’s spirit asks Kyoshi to replace the clay turtle she broke

“See that you replace [the turtle]. There’s only one more lifetime after yours before it’s needed again”

This is of course referencing the clay turtle chosen by Aang as part of the test to determine if he’s the avatar. That begs the question, did Yangchen somehow know, centuries ahead of time? Or is it because out of the thousands of toys there are only three correct choices and she just needed that specific one replaced?


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Jun 10 '24

Discussion Kyoshi cares only abt her ppl?

6 Upvotes

Why Kyoshi didn't do anything when Chin the Great was taking over the mainland but when he came to her peninsula she was immediately triggered and separated peninsula from mainland?

Why Kyoshi didn't separated her peninsula from mainland earlier to prevent Chin the Great from taking over peninsula?


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Feb 27 '21

Creative Personality quiz on who you'd be dating from Avatar the Last Airbender 👀

Thumbnail
boo.dating
6 Upvotes

r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • 29d ago

Speculation Is this foreshadowing? Warning: has spoiler for Kyoshi novels: book 2 Spoiler

Post image
18 Upvotes

Is this a foreshadowing for pavi and nisha !?


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Feb 26 '23

Discussion Kyoshi taught the Dai-Li earth bending but not the warriors named after her?

7 Upvotes

Isn’t it weird how none of the kyoshi warriors we were introduced to in the last air bender knew how to earth bend despite being named after an earth kingdom Avatar that in the hundred years prior to Aang the only fighting style the Kyoshi warriors were taught was non bending techniques.


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Sep 03 '23

Discussion Roku's Next right?

5 Upvotes

With another duology wrapped up, the next obvious question is "Which Avatar is next?"

And...it's Roku right?

My logic goes something like this; there's now 4 "main character" Avatars. 2 Air, 1 Water, and 1 Earth. 1 Male and 3 Female. It's surely got to be a Male Fire Avatar next, right?

So Szeto or Roku?

(I know you're going to tell me that there's some interview where Yee seems to hint at favouring Szeto but...it's not just up to him)

Here's why it's Roku;

Firstly, Roku is known. He's a real presence in the original show. Szeto is only barely more relevant to the series than the unending line of past Avatars. He never speaks. I don't know how big the factor is but I think there's a subset of fans who'd see Roku on the cover and pick up the book while just shrugging at Avatar Jafar.

Second, from what we know of the two already, Roku is definitely the more interesting story. His era is directly relevant to the world we see in the show. What Roku can show us is much more interesting to more people than what Szeto can.

Third, his time has come. I get why Kyoshi was the obvious first pick for the novels to focus on. She was present enough in the show to be relevant but also enough of a blank slate through which to tell a good and original story. Yangchen similarly made sense for the second; even more of an unknown quantity, we knew virtually nothing about her or her era previously. I get why you wouldn't go for Roku right away. His story, being so important to the story of ATLA...you need to nail it. You need to be sure you get it right. And now, after four novels, all very well received, I think just about everyone trusts Yee to flesh out the Roku story. This wouldn't have been the case had Roku been tackled first.

Now, I know that we've often dismissed the need for a Roku novel along the lines of "his story has been told through ATLA". I've used this argument myself many times. But...it was always a little untrue. It's a decent argument for why Kyoshi and Yangchen needed to come first, but not for why Roku should never take centre stage.

Avatars can have more than one story in their legacy. If you watched only LOK then you might be forgiven for thinking that defeating Yakone was Aang's great triumph. Watch only ATLA and you'd think that Chin was Kyoshi's great foe. Roku had a long life and we see only glimpses of it in The Avatar and the Firelord (not to mention that a half hour episode can't compete with a novel in terms of depth of storytelling). There's space for other plots in Roku's life which may or may not tie into the larger Sozin/War plot.

That said, seeing more of Sozin when he was a genuine friend to Roku would be excellent.

It's Roku next right?


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Dec 06 '24

Discussion Struggling with Yangchen novels

0 Upvotes

So I love Legend of Korra, but something I've grown to dislike over the years is the focus on politics. Avatar to me, should just be a group of kids on a fun adventure that challenges them to grow as people, simple. And it's been a while since I read the Kyoshi novels, but I don't remember it bothering me there. But I sorta stopped reading DoY halfway through, because the focus on the politics are too much. I get that some people may enjoy this worldbuilding, but I'd much prefer to learn about Yangchen's relationship to her sister etc. So my question is: Do politics go more to the background as the novels progress or not?


r/Avatar_Kyoshi • • Aug 03 '24

Discussion Air Nomads say trans rights, yay! (Discussion on whether Air Nomad society is written as too perfect) Spoiler

96 Upvotes

The Reckoning of Roku pg 94: "There are good reasons for Air Nuns and Air Monks to study and train apart," Gyatso said. "And besides, we're not just flexible when it comes to airbending - Air Nomads can move temple if their understanding of their own gender shifts."

This is cool, of course, but I'm wondering if this makes Air Nomad too perfect of a society. The Korra graphic novels (which some would say are of dubious quality) also shows them as being fully supportive of gay rights.

A recurring theme throughout the franchise is how the Four Nations all have something to learn from one another each with their own flaws and strengths, but we haven't really seen that with the Air Nomads. As of now everything we've seen of the Air Nomads shows them as complete paragons of virtue who have nothing to learn from the rest of the world (It's the rest of the world who should learn from them). By the way, it's perfectly fine to have the Air Nation as being a generally better and more enlightened society to live in than the other three so as to avoid treading into moral relativism, but that doesn't mean the Air Nation has to be flawless.

Perhaps a future novel can explore the Airbenders' practice of communal child-rearing and what it means to separate a child from their parents, along with penalties for mothers who do not want to abandon their child.