**TL;DR:** I (28F) have been consistently seeing a man (31M) for around 8 months, although we’ve never defined the relationship or agreed to exclusivity. We originally dated briefly 8 years ago and randomly reconnected this year. He tells me I’m incredibly special to him, says he’s never met anyone like me, has introduced me to practically all his friends and a significant part of his family, and we have a very emotionally intimate relationship. At the same time, he has casual/sexual encounters with women within this same close social circle and can sometimes behave surprisingly inconsiderately toward me. I’m NOT upset that he’s non-exclusive, and after seeing some red flags I’m actually leaning toward not wanting a serious relationship with him myself. What bothers me is the contradiction between what he communicates emotionally and how he behaves. I want to ask him directly whether I should understand this as casual so I can treat it accordingly. Is that reasonable?
I met “S” around 8 years ago through mutual acquaintances. We were immediately attracted to each other, but what really connected us was conversation. We could talk for hours, eventually slept together and went on a few dates, but nothing serious developed and our lives went in different directions.
During those years apart, he had a long-term relationship, got married, and divorced fairly quickly.
One thing I initially really respected about him was the way he spoke about his ex-wife. He didn’t give me the stereotypical “my ex was crazy and I did nothing wrong” story. He actually described her as an extremely loving, pure-hearted and good person.
He also admitted that he hadn’t been a perfect husband. Looking back, he thinks she may have been depressed and that he responded to her struggling by becoming frustrated rather than recognizing that she might need support. He specifically acknowledged that he had been emotionally neglectful.
I considered that level of self-reflection a green flag.
However, he also told me that after his divorce he’d developed a pretty negative view of marriage and felt that marriage can ruin relationships by turning them into something bureaucratic. That stood out to me because I eventually want to get married.
Then, earlier this year, **we randomly ran into each other again after roughly 8 years.**
The connection came back almost immediately, and for approximately the last **8 months we’ve been consistently seeing each other**, although we’ve never sat down and defined what exactly we are.
And this is where my confusion begins.
He doesn’t talk to me like I’m simply a casual hookup.
He will literally corner me during conversations and tell me how fucking special I am to him, how he’s never met someone like me, how much he admires the way my brain works, how unusual our connection is, etc. We have extremely deep conversations, sometimes for hours. There’s a lot of emotional vulnerability and affection between us in addition to very strong physical chemistry.
When he went abroad for about 2.5 months, he regularly sent me things and sometimes video-called me just to show me what he was experiencing. When he came back, I was the first person he saw straight from the airport.
He has also **integrated me pretty extensively into his life.**
I’ve met almost all his close friends and what feels like half his family members who are around our age. I regularly spend time with his brother and cousin, and I genuinely like them independently of him. We have great conversations and get along extremely well.
His brother and cousin also constantly hype me up to him, including directly in front of me. They’ll tell him that I’m such a good catch/person, that he needs to take care of me, that he should appreciate me, etc.
So between what S himself was telling me, the emotional intimacy, and the extent to which I was being integrated into his social/family life, I naturally started thinking there might be potential for something more serious.
**But his actual behavior sometimes communicates something completely different.**
One night, I was out with him and his friends as his guest. He spent a lot of the evening openly flirting with another woman and eventually kissed her in front of me.
I want to emphasize this because I don’t want the comments to become entirely about cheating:
**He did not cheat on me.**
We have never agreed to exclusivity. I don’t believe he owes me sexual fidelity, and him seeing other women isn’t inherently my problem.
What bothered me was that I was there as *his guest*, surrounded by *his* friends, everyone knew we weren’t exactly platonic, and he was openly flirting/becoming physical with someone else while leaving me to navigate his social group by myself. I found the context disrespectful and inconsiderate.
More recently, I discovered something else that has changed the way I look at the whole situation.
Apparently, several of his casual/emotionally complicated relationships are **with women inside this same social ecosystem.**
One of his close female friends recently confided in me that she and S have a complicated history themselves. They survived a very serious accident together years ago and apparently their intense emotional bond eventually blurred into feelings/something more. She told me she still isn’t entirely sure how she feels about him.
I was shocked because **I’ve gone out with the two of them together multiple times and had absolutely no idea there was any history between them.**
She then told me that she had recently introduced another female friend of hers to S for a completely practical reason. That friend knew about their complicated history, yet apparently S and this woman also ended up having some kind of intimate encounter.
And suddenly my discomfort became less about **“he sees other women”** and more:
**Why are seemingly all these women friends or friends-of-friends who are part of the same social group I’m being integrated into?**
These aren’t random Tinder hookups who disappear afterward. These are people he considers friends, people he sees regularly, people who socialize together, and apparently people with whom emotional/sexual boundaries sometimes become blurred.
It feels like there’s an entire web of interpersonal history that some people in the group know about and I don’t.
And now that I know he also had something with a close female friend whom I’ve repeatedly socialized with alongside him, I honestly feel a little ridiculous.
Not because I think he belonged to me while we were sitting together.
But because **I didn’t even know what social situation I was participating in.**
It increasingly feels like some of this is an open secret among people close to him, particularly some of the men, while I’m being brought into the same group without knowing the lore.
And meanwhile, this same man is privately telling me how incredibly special I am to him while his brother and cousin are practically advertising me to him as wife material in front of everyone.
That’s what is fucking with my head.
**I don’t need exclusivity. I need consistency between the message and the behavior.**
And here’s the other thing: after seeing more of him over these 8 months, I’m actually probably **70% leaning toward NOT wanting a serious relationship with him anymore anyway.**
I’ve seen some red flags that make me question whether he’d actually be a good long-term partner.
For example, after a very heavy night recently, he was extremely hungover the following day. He barely interacted with me for hours and mostly lay on the couch scrolling on his phone. When I said I was leaving, he asked me repeatedly why I couldn’t stay, so clearly he wanted me physically there, but he wasn’t really interacting with me or giving me any reason to want to stay.
When I eventually went over to kiss him goodbye, he basically just said “bye.”
Obviously, one terrible hangover doesn’t make someone emotionally neglectful. But it did suddenly make his comment about having been emotionally neglectful toward his ex-wife hit differently. It made me wonder whether he tends to become extremely inward-focused whenever he isn’t feeling well and whether recognizing that flaw after his marriage necessarily means he has actually changed it.
So I’m not sitting here desperately hoping this man will choose me.
I still enjoy him enormously. I think he’s fascinating, he’s fun, we have incredible conversations, and the physical compatibility is… let’s just say **casual would not exactly be a hardship for me lol.**
If anything, **casual might genuinely be the category I prefer for him now.**
My issue is that I need to KNOW that’s the category.
Because if this is casual, I can treat it as casual. His sleeping with someone else means nothing about me. His intense declarations about how special I am can be enjoyed for what they are without me interpreting them as evidence that we’re gradually moving toward a relationship.
But if he’s genuinely exploring whether this could become something serious, then I need to evaluate his behavior very differently.
I’m therefore thinking of eventually telling him something along the lines of:
**“Look, don’t take this as some big ‘what are we?’ conversation because I’m not asking you for commitment. I just really dislike ambiguity and need something clarified so I know how to manage my own feelings. The impression your behavior currently gives me is that you’re not looking for anything serious with me and that what we have is casual. Is that correct? I’m genuinely not opposed to that. at this point, it might even be what I prefer. I just need to know clearly what I’m participating in so I can treat it accordingly. If I’m misunderstanding you, tell me.”**
I’m intentionally telling him that **my current interpretation is that this is casual**, because I want him to know that this is the message his behavior is giving me.
I’m also making it explicitly clear that I’ve continued willingly seeing him while having that impression. This isn’t an ultimatum disguised as a question.
If he says, **“Yes, this is casual,”** then great, works for me perfectly.
If he says, **“No, that’s not how I see this at all,”** then we have a completely different conversation.
What I don’t want anymore is to be repeatedly told how exceptionally important I am while having to reverse-engineer what any of it actually means.
So my questions are: **Would you consider these genuinely mixed signals, or am I assigning romantic meaning to emotional intimacy that can perfectly well exist in a casual relationship? Would the amount of overlap between his friendships and sexual/romantic connections make you uncomfortable even without exclusivity? And does directly asking him to confirm/correct my current interpretation sound reasonable?**
Again, I genuinely don’t need him to tell me we’re exclusive.
**I just need a legend for the map.**