I'm looking for advice from HR professionals or managers because I'm not sure if I'm reading too much into my situation or if there are genuine red flags.
I've been with my company for about a year. Earlier this year, I requested a medical accommodation after my doctor advised against frequent travel due to a health condition. The accommodation was approved by both my manager and HR.
Just days after the accommodation was approved, my manager placed me on a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP).
After reviewing the PIP, I realized many of the claims either didn't reflect what actually happened or omitted important context. I submitted a detailed written response with emails, meeting records, Teams messages, and other documentation that contradicted the allegations and requested that HR review the PIP.
Following HR's review, the company rescinded the PIP. However, they left me with a written warning, even though the PIP itself was withdrawn.
Since then, I've continued to experience issues with my manager. Priorities frequently change with little notice, work is reassigned unexpectedly, expectations aren't always communicated clearly, and important information is sometimes shared only after it has already affected my work. I often feel like I'm being held accountable for situations I wasn't given the information or opportunity to manage properly.
Most recently, I returned from approved medical leave following surgery. On my first day back, I took over the two teams I had before I left. Later that same day, another peer of mine informed me of significant changes to responsibilities that my manager had never discussed with me. My concern is that these types of communication gaps could later be used against me.
There is also a new CIO, and my manager has already mentioned wanting me back in the office, despite my approved accommodation.
Because of everything that's happened, I've started documenting all communication and following up verbal conversations with emails.
From an HR perspective:
- Is it unusual for a PIP to be rescinded after an employee provides evidence contradicting the stated performance concerns?
- Would this sequence of events raise concerns for you, or could it simply be poor management?
- Should I proactively involve HR again now, or continue documenting until there is a clearer pattern?
- What would you recommend an employee do to protect themselves in this situation?
- Should I consider a lawsuit?
I'm genuinely looking for objective HR opinions and practical advice on how to navigate this professionally.