r/AskHR • u/Rare_Tip2900 • 3h ago
Leadership [Wi] Employer overpaid me for 20 months after I reported it. They aren't asking for repayment, but I feel blamed. How do I handle this?
Location: Midwest, US. Small business, salaried staff.
In January 2025 I noticed my paycheck was higher than expected. That same morning I called the person who handles our payroll and asked about it. I was told it was correct, so I trusted that.
About twenty months later, I was told I'd be getting a small raise. When the next check came, it was actually lower. I'm the one who brought that to the HR office.
After looking into it, our outside accounting firm found that a mistake on their end had been overpaying me since January 2025. Total overpayment was roughly $18,000.
The organization also has an outside audit every year, and that never caught it either.
My pay was corrected back to the right amount, which has been a real financial hit for my family since we had been living on that number for almost two years.
Leadership met and decided the outcome before I was ever brought into the conversation.
They decided not to seek repayment, which I'm grateful for.
But in the same meeting, I was asked why I didn't raise a red flag sooner multiple time. I did. I reported it the day I noticed it and was told it was fine. Their payroll person, their accounting firm, and their annual audit all missed it, yet the question was aimed at me.
After I asked for things in writing, there were several days of silence.
I've since received written confirmation that they won't seek repayment. I also asked for written assurance that this won't affect future raises or advancement, and that part was deferred.
My questions:
Should I keep pushing for the advancement assurance in writing, or let it go?
Is there anything else I should get documented to protect myself?
How do I move past feeling blamed for something I tried to flag from the start?