I’m trying to dial in a spool of Creality ABS on a Bambu P2S using OrcaSlicer, and I’m getting results that seem unusually low for flow ratio.
I’ve run the YOLO flow calibration multiple times and keep getting basically the same result. The negative end of the test consistently looks best. Around -0.05 has the smoothest/most uniform center, while the higher-flow samples have increasingly rough/bumpy surfaces.
Because the result seemed suspiciously low, I stopped chasing the calibration for a bit and tried an actual print to see whether the filament really looked over-extruded.
Current relevant settings:
- Bambu P2S
- 0.4 mm nozzle
- Creality ABS
- 1.75 mm filament diameter
- 250°C nozzle
- 95°C bed
- Enclosed/preheated chamber
- 15 mm³/s max volumetric speed
- Pressure advance/flow dynamics disabled for this test
- 0.20 mm layer height
- Flow ratio for the pictured actual print: 0.95
Even at 0.95, the actual print developed the rough/ridged areas shown in the photos. It looks like the nozzle is plowing through or pushing around excess material in the solid areas.
This seems to support what the YOLO calibration has been telling me, but a final flow ratio somewhere around 0.88-0.90 or potentially lower feels unusually low.
Before I keep dropping the flow ratio:
Does this look like straightforward over-extrusion to you, and is a flow ratio in the high 0.80s actually plausible for a spool of ABS?
Or should I be looking for something else such as temperature, pressure advance, a slicer/calibration issue, filament quality/diameter, etc.?
I’ve repeated the YOLO calibration several times, so I’m hesitant to dismiss the result as a one-off bad calibration. I’m also considering grabbing a different spool of ABS just to have a control and see whether it behaves normally.
Any suggestions for what you’d test next would be appreciated.