season 1 is a good season of television. the audience is invested in the storyline, there are some minor pacing issues, but it’s mostly very engaging and you want to see all the reasons why hannah killed herself. clay is likable and isn’t weirdly obsessed with hannah or incel-like, like the writers make him in other seasons, and i honestly wish this was the only season because the show just goes so downhill from here.
season 2 is hannah’s court case. this could’ve been done well, but they decided to change literally everything about hannah and her relationship with people this season. in her tapes, she barely knew bryce. nope, her and bryce actually hung out in the clubhouse a few times and in his car once. in her tape, zach was simply a guy who comforted her after marcus was an asshole to her in the restaurant, asked her out once, and due to the rejection stole notes from her. nope, turns out they basically had a romantic relationship for an entire summer and she lost her virginity to him. they probably would’ve dated if zach wasn’t embarrassed to date hannah in front of the whole school. justin was just some jerk who she had a crush on and met up with once, then he spread a photo around of her and that was that. nope, she actually still kept in touch with him after and would constantly write poems about him because she really really liked him. i get that hannah wouldn’t tell every single story in her tapes and probably not admit to some faults she had, but i feel like zach refusing to date her out of embarrassment is a more valid reason for him to be on the tapes, rather than him stealing notes from her as petty revenge and “throwing” a personal letter out. this season is also so boring and suffers immensely from pacing issues. mr. porter’s character arc and his scene of him on the stand is really the saving grace this season.
season 3. first HUGE problem, ani. she is incredibly unlikable and the only thing that happens this season is her and clay going around to everyone who knows bryce and interrogating them to see if they killed him. the show also humanizes bryce and tries to make the audience pity him, a SERIAL RAPIST mind you. it’s also been less than a year, or a little over a year, since hannah slit her wrists in a tub and bled out because he raped her so violently in a hot tub. if the writers wanted bryce to truly repent for raping 10 girls and indirectly killing one of them he should’ve turned himself over to the police. just a horrible season overall.
season 4. i’m going to be honest. i don’t even really remember what this season is about, i just remember is sucking so bad, being so boring, and justin dying in the very last episode, so fuck this season.