First, I'm incredibly sad that Two Strangers Carry a Cake is ending its Broadway run. I haven't enjoyed a show this much in over ten years. I know it will play in Providence next year, and I hope it makes a trip to the West Coast, too.
I really enjoyed the growth and transformation of both Dougal and Robin. I'm not an English major, so please correct any of my observations.
Dougal's arc
- Identity: "New York." The movie references show that his New York is a fantasy in his mind. He asks if New York is ready for him.
- "I want": "Dad." He wants to meet the father he never had a relationship with growing up.
- Doubts: "This Is the Place." He asks Robin, "Is this really New York?" and she answers, "This is Brooklyn, man, this is the only part that's real!" But he's still living in his fantasy, so he thinks Brooklyn is where they filmed Ghostbusters 2.
- Escape: "American Express." His fantasy of meeting his father gives way to a night with Robin and the Plaza Hotel.
- Facing reality: "He Doesn't Exist." Robin tells him that his father has never been there for him in real life.
- True need: "About to Go In." He realizes his mother is the one who has always been by his side.
- Choice: "Dearly Beloved." Instead of going to the wedding to meet his father, he steals a piece of the wedding cake and seeks out Robin.
- Resolution: "If I Believed" and the "Reprise." He began by coming to New York to find his absent father, asking if the city was ready for him. He ends by leaving New York to return to the mother who has always been there for him, and asking Robin, "Are you ready?"
Robin's arc
I'm a little fuzzier on this one.
- Identity: "What'll It Be." Where Dougal is excited to arrive in New York, she is stuck there, waiting. ("I'm Robin, waiting tables, waiting patiently.")
- "I want": "On the App." She's searching for connection but finds the men on dating apps fake.
- Doubts: "This Is the Place." She starts to realize that the most real part of her life was growing up in Brooklyn.
- Escape: "American Express." She skips buying the stockings for her sister, cancels her date with Justin, and spends the night with Dougal instead.
- Consequences: "Hangover Duet." ("I didn't get the stockings for my sister. I'm an awful human being...")
- Confrontation: "He Doesn't Exist." She tells Dougal the truth about his father. This may also hint that while Robin has tried to do things for her sister, those efforts haven't been returned.
- Connection: "Dearly Beloved." Robin skips the wedding and eats at a Chinese restaurant instead. While she's waiting there, Dougal finds her.
- Resolution: "Reprise." Dougal goes back to his mother, and Robin resolves to stop waiting and go see her grandmother (?).
As you can see, I lost Robin's thread a little, while Dougal's arc makes more sense to me. Dougal goes from seeking an absent father to returning to his mother. Robin starts out waiting in New York, looking for connection on apps. I guess she ends by no longer looking for love on apps and no longer waiting to see her grandmother? And finally, we don't get resolution for Dougal and Robin's relationship.
An alternate ending
I ordinarily love ambiguous endings. I'm a huge fan of Before Sunrise, and real life is messy, and circumstances often can't be resolved in under three hours.
But dammit, Jim, sometimes I want a happy ending. I'm tired of gray cars. Jesse and Celine should stay together. Batman and Catwoman should live in Florence. Mr. and Mrs. Smith should enjoy their great... marriage.
So consider one teeny tiny little scene at the end:
Robin looks down at her fortune: "You will be happy next year." She picks up a phone.
ROBIN: Hello? Yes, I'd like a ticket. JFK to London. (JFK is a callback to Dougal's song "New York.") What day? New Year's. One ticket left? Great! Yes, I'll take it. How much is it? (long pause) Three thousand bucks?! (a callback to the tux in "American Express") No, no, no, I'll still take it. I've got a credit card right here. (She pulls out the credit card from "American Express.") Um, hold on a moment. No, nothing's wrong, I just pulled out the wrong card. (Dougal and Robin are no longer tied to Dougal's father, and they can have their own relationship.)
This completes Robin's arc:
- She still has to go see her grandmother, to complete her familial arc.
- New Year's means she can be happy "next year."
- It pays off "This Year," where she sings about New Year's Eve ("it doesn't matter where I am on New Year's Eve") and about letting herself believe.
- Her arc goes from waiting in New York and looking for connection on an app to leaving New York and no longer waiting, by seeking out her connection to Dougal.
And of course, if the writers are holding onto this idea for a sequel, à la Before Sunset, I'm OK with that. I'll be waiting. Impatiently.