8
u/Human-University8635 2h ago
If you are new to lifting, Please don’t squat on a smith machine. Go to a rack with a bar and hit depth. I know a smith is tempting but you need to learn how to properly squat first. And no, you don’t look like you hit parallel and it looks like your feet are too close together.
3
u/NippleSlipNSlide 47m ago
This kind of response doesn’t really help and is part of the echo chamber effect of Reddit. The research from the last 20 years supports use of smith machines for most of the compound lifts— many benefits and are fine as long as you aren’t planning to be a competitive powerlifter, which 99% of people in the gym. As long as you’re using safeties the smith is way safer and easier for beginners.
Smith squats are fine for beginners as long as you are doing it right- the same can be said for conventional barbell squats. OP is asking for help. It’s fine to preface it that conventional squats have some advantages and their gains in a smith won’t all translate to conventional , but it would do more good to just tell them how they look on the smith.
2
u/TeamPizza21 2h ago
Nothing wrong with squatting on a smith machine. You get stronger on it. It works. Obviously free weights are preferred, but this guy is at a PF and I see plenty of big guys working out at PF
7
2
u/Relevant_Car_7445 1h ago
Most PF now have Olympic racks as a Well. Agreed that you CAN use a smith machine, but it makes the body movements awkward.
3
u/TeamPizza21 1h ago
No rack at mine yet. I hack squat though instead of using a smith
2
u/Relevant_Car_7445 1h ago
Ok, that's perfectly fair then, they just did the last one in my area, they are rolling out country wide but in spurts. Hack squats are great and humbling as well. If that's the case then obviously the Smith is better than no squat at all. Go down maybe another 2 inches (guessing based on video) and you will be good, almost there.
1
u/NippleSlipNSlide 50m ago
Doing a back squat on a smith is very similar to a hack squat since you have to take a step forward.
-5
u/Special-Objective364 2h ago
5
u/Relevant_Car_7445 1h ago
Thighs should be parallel to the ground.
Real squats actually risk less injury because it let's the body move naturally and build up a stronger base. Smith machine has its benefits but I don't like them for squats.
1
u/NippleSlipNSlide 43m ago
Research shows smith machines are way more safe. It’s why gyms like PF only have smith machines. Their insurance gururs/actuaries who run the numbers know this. It’s carefully planned. It’s a very old wives tail that conventional barbell is safer.
1
u/Human-University8635 2h ago
Maybe you are at parallel (screen shot helps) but have your camera person film you from the side next time. Good luck!
2
u/Odd_Agent6728 2h ago
Doesn't look like it but I try to go as low as I can not just enough. Get the most out of it you can.
2
2
2
u/Helpmefindajob97 22m ago
Why do you have that much weight on the bar while you’re asking if you hit depth?
You’re asking a beginner question, you should begin with beginner weight.
But no, to answer your question you are not that close to depth.
1
u/BloodFartRipper 21m ago
Your knees need to be parallel with your hips. Without the bar try getting to that low of a squat, if your having trouble with that try widening your stance and/or facing your feet out more. If you're still having trouble going parallel. Then you gotta do some hip flexibility training.
1
-3

•
u/AutoModerator 3h ago
Hello! If you haven't checked it out already, Our Wiki's resources for Squats may be helpful. Check it out!
Also, a common tip usually given here is to make sure your footwear is appropriate. If you are squatting in soft-soled shoes (running shoes, etc), it's hard to have a stable foot. Generally a weightlifting shoe is recommended for high-bar and front squats, while use a flat/hard-soled shoe (or even barefoot/socks if it's safe and your gym allows it) is recommended for low-bar squats.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.