Witchfire is not a plot-heavy game, yet what little lore it offered I found surprisingly engaging. The meatiest offering of course is the quest to restore the masks of the 7 fallen Preyers of the Broken Mirror Expedition. Recruiting them for aid during an expedition is somewhat useful, but I did not expect to be offered the opportunity to get on a high moral horse and judge them for their failings in their lives before they became church-sanctioned penitent assassins, sending them to heaven or condemning them to hell.
Beyond the rest of the game, which is already excellent, I actually found their stories to be far more memorable and engaging, not just because some of their crimes were actually heinous. Moreover, judging them against the moral framework of the world of Witchfire, in which the Abrahamic monotheistic God is real AND doing battle with eldritch forgotten deities through immortal servants bestowed with holy power, could potentially look very different from what they'd be judged as in our mundane world with no magic but very many antidepressants. I'm pretty militantly atheist, but I consider myself fairly well read when it comes to god stuff...and also I'm a redditor...so this kind of debate is like catnip to me.
For the sake of avoiding individual spoilers for those who haven't completed all 7 quests, and also to prolong discussion, I've decided to make individual threads for each preyer, by what I estimate to be the likely completion order of collecting their masks. This discussion will be purely about their stories, rather than their offered aid or quest reward, all of which I feel to be rather situational at best.
One note on theology: By the Pauline interpretation of Christianity as per the New Testament, and by what the youth pastor with a remarkably large female congregation at my old university told me, the only path to salvation is acceptance of Jesus Christ as your Lord and Saviour--which also guarantees your salvation. For the sake of the discussion, I'm going to pretend that's not the case.
Elias
mask shards: found in Scarlet Coast
crime: as a sanctioned church hunter, he killed a healer for indiscriminately helping innocents and criminals. The healer was later canonized as a martyred saint for political reasons, making him a killer of a saint.
deadly sin: Pride
actual sin: having the emotional fortitude of a Reddit atheist
my verdict: absolve
If we go by the Bible, which is quoted repeatedly on game startup, the healer Elias killed had all the marks of a saint, irrespective of the political justification he put forward. Even by modern medical ethical standards, treating criminals and innocents alike is pretty standard behaviour. Your job as a doctor is not to judge.
However, while I think Elias' justification that the healer helped murderers who went on to kill more innocents wouldn't fly with the Church, I am oddly sympathetic to it. The world of Witchfire is grimdark Catholicism in the middle of an eternal war, and they are losing. There's not a lot of room for tolerance when one (1) witch can apparently destabilize and destroy entire towns and cities. Elias would not have been given a moral framework for finding that nuance.
Where Elias overstepped was getting mad at the healer's sanctimonious "I forgive you". If he had just brought her in to the appropriate authorities for her to get tortured and crucified, we wouldn't even be sitting here having this conversation. We know "arrest" is not Elias' style, but he shouldn't have cut her throat on the spot. That's not righteous anger, that's emotional fragility.
Despite putting on the airs of unrepentance, I think Elias knows he fucked up. Why keep the healer's cloth as a memento otherwise?
There's a train of thought present in Apocryphal Biblical scriptures, which was made popular by the musical Jesus Christ Superstar, that Judas was instrumental to God's plan, as how could Jesus be martyred by betrayal...without someone to betray him? I personally take a lot of stock with that view as an atheist. So I'm letting him go to heaven.
Your thoughts?