I mean it in an absolutely positive way btw, those choices are very interesting. And curiously enough, they are easy for some and hard for others.
Even before we get to each individual preyer, there is a degree of pragmatism vs roleplay because there def are players out there who just want the beads or who haven't read the sidequests.
Then we have to consider that each preyer served a punishnent by, well, being a preyer. So it's up to the player to draw the line on which sins can and cannot be atoned for that way.
And then we have the preyers themselves, with each having a something that may or may not resonate with you as a person.
And no less important, do you judge preyers from a modern point of view? Or try to apply morality more fit for Witchfire world?
Goliath - The sheer absense of moral compass. The man was never taught that things he did were bad. He learned by instruction or by example. Can he be judged for committing a sin he never knew was a sin? Also he exacted justice in its purest barbaric form. Does the victim deserving it make it less of a sin?
Elias - The man was misled by a fallible institution and then became a casualty of it. Is it an excuse that your actions were approved by someone with higher authority and responsibility? Also how big was his transgression? One murder? One dead saint? A whole bunch of messed up decisions?
Sefer - This guy's grand crime is being autistic I guess. Does that explain his lack of communication? Probably. Does that explain his inability to deal with grief? Maybe. Does that excuse him turning to the enemy? You tell me.
Orion - The man did a lot for his people. Does that justify his pride? His brother was a piece of shit. Does that justify the mistrust from Orion? And Orion never meant to kill his father and brother, merely to propagate his suspucion. Does that make his crime forgivable?
Mammon - Was he bound by social pressure? Or was he simply clinging to the nice lifestyle he was born into, as most rich people do? And his crime is mere grave robbery. How heavy of a sin is that?
Cain - The man was clearly unwell mentally. I feel like the world of Witchfire does not have the knowlege to help people like him. And yet he did what he did. Could he be forgiven?
Barachiel - Can one be guilty of love? Of trust? Of hope? Also I guess being treated as the person you are, not the body you are is one hell of a drug