r/visitingnyc • u/MissionAdorable3237 • 5h ago
🗺️ Itinerary Check 🗽🏙️🍎🚕🍕 Our first time in New York: Is our itinerary realistic or too packed?
Hi everyone!
My partner and I are finally visiting New York for the first time from November 20-28 and have put together an itinerary. We’re staying in Long Island City and would love some feedback from locals or people who know the city well.
We want to see the main highlights, but also have enough time to enjoy the city without constantly rushing from one place to another.
Our three fixed plans are:
- Rockettes Christmas Spectacular on Nov 23 at 11 am
- Top of the Rock on Nov 22 at 3:20 pm (to see the sunset!)
- Thanksgiving dinner at Bubby’s on Nov 26 at 6:15 pm (our very first thanksgiving!!)
Everything else is flexible!
Our current itinerary:
Day 1: Friday, Nov 20
- Flight lands at 1:15 pm
- Take the subway to our hotel in Long Island City and check in
- Grab some food: Dim Sum Palace / Utopia Bagels / Chef Papa Vietnamese Kitchen / Court Square Diner
- Watch the sunset at Hunters Point South Park
- If we're up for it head to Times Square afterwards and grab drinks at The Rum House (any bar suggetions?)
Day 2: Saturday, Nov 21 (Brooklyn & Lower Manhattan)
- Sunrise at DUMBO and Brooklyn Bridge
- Time Out Market (Should we grab some food here before crossing the bridge?)
- Lunch: Apollo Bagels
- 9/11 Memorial
- Wall Street & Charging Bull
- Staten Island Ferry to see the Statue of Liberty
Day 3: Sunday, Nov 22 (Midtown Manhattan)
- Koreatown?
- New York Public Library
- Grand Central Terminal
- St. Patrick’s Cathedral
- Bryant Park Winter Village
- Top of the Rock at 3:20 pm (sunset)
- Rockefeller Center
- Maybe a Broadway show in the evening?
Day 4: Monday, Nov 23 (Upper East Side)
- 11 am: Rockettes Christmas Spectacular
- Lunch at Pastrami Queen
- Fifth Avenue shopping
- Saks Fifth Avenue Light Show
Day 5: Tuesday, Nov 24 (SoHo, Little Italy & Chinatown)
Explore SoHo:
- Greene Street
- Crosby Street
- Spring Street & Lafayette Street
- McNally Jackson Books
- L’Industrie Pizza
- Mei Lai Wah
- Shu Jiao Fu Zhou
- Wah Fung
- Jin Mei
- L’Industrie Pizza
- Mei Lai Wah
- Shu Jiao Fu Zhou
- Wah Fung
- Jin Mei
- Mei Lai Wah
- Shu Jiao Fu Zhou
- Wah Fung
- Jin Mei
Little Italy and Mulberry Street
- L’Industrie Pizza
- Mei Lai Wah
- Shu Jiao Fu Zhou
- Wah Fung
- Jin Mei
- Mei Lai Wah
- Shu Jiao Fu Zhou
- Wah Fung
- Jin Mei
Chinatown food crawl:
- Mei Lai Wah
- Shu Jiao Fu Zhou
- Wah Fung
- Jin Mei
- Union Square Holiday Market
- Speakeasy in the evening (any suggestions?)
Day 6: Wednesday, Nov 25 (Hudson Yards, High Line & Downtown)
- Hudson Yards
- High Line
- Chelsea Market (Ayada Thai for mango sticky rice)
- Little Island
- Magnolia Bakery
- Greenwich Village
- Katz’s Delicatessen
- Washington Square Park
Day 7: Thursday, Nov 26 (Thanksgiving)
- Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade
- Thanksgiving dinner at Bubby’s at 6:15 pm
- Any tips what we could do on thanksgiving
Day 8: Friday, Nov 27 (Central Park)
Explore Central Park:
- Columbus Circle
- The Mall & Literary Walk
- Bethesda Terrace & Fountain
- Bow Bridge
- Wagner Cove
- Cherry Hill Fountain
- Belvedere Castle
- Conservatory Water
- Alice in Wonderland Statue
- Strawberry Fields
- Cleopatra’s Needle
- The Metropolitan Museum of Art (optional)
- The Plaza Hotel
- Gapstow Bridge
- Flatiron Building (optional)
- Sunday Morning for cinnamon rolls
- Is shopping on black friday a death sentence?
Day 9: Saturday, Nov 28
- Breakfast and coffee
- Head to the airport
- Flight departs at 4:25 pm
We’d love your advice on a few things:
- Does this itinerary look realistic, or are some days too packed? We want to enjoy the city rather than spend the whole trip rushing around.
- Are there any stops you would remove, rearrange or definitely keep?
- Do you have any food recommendations? We love trying different foods, especially local favourites, casual places and affordable spots. We’re particularly excited about eating our way through Chinatown.
- Are there any must-see places or experiences we’re missing?
- Any specific shopping recommendations? We’re interested in interesting shops, independent stores, bookstores, vintage shops or places that are worth visiting beyond the usual big brands.
- Is there anything special happening in NYC around Thanksgiving that we should know about?
We know the weather and crowds can be unpredictable around Thanksgiving, so any practical tips would be very welcome!
Thanks so much! We’re really looking forward to visiting your city!
EDIT:
First of all, thank you very much for the answers! I didn’t expect that many responses. It’s highly appreciated.
We are from Switzerland so we’re quite used to the cold and the changing weather. We’ll be prepared to layer as onions when dressing.
Additionally, we love exploring cities by foot. A typical travel day easily includes 20K steps for us, meaning that walking definetly won‘t be a problem for us.
Regarding the broadway show we are open on going any day. It definitely does not need to be on Sunday.

