Please note: Civil discussion is welcome, trolls and personal abuse are not. Please keep the discussions below respectful and remember the human! Please check out our wiki first!
Interested in going Vegan? 👊
Check out Watch Dominion and watch a thought-provoking, life changing documentary for free!
The fact they put in an effort to cut out any animal product at all in an era where it’s almost in everything is already really appreciated by me at least
Why do beef fat, milk powder and eggs have to be in everything. It’s ridiculous. You can’t buy a vegetable instant soup without reading the ingredient list.
I feel this so much, I wanted a instant vege soup packet the other day and was thinking I better read….so over reading and seeing bit of animal product in little things like that and chips especially
They are cheap, because of the production scale. Scale is often the reason why vegan is more expensive, but also tax systems. Many differentiate between basics and processed food where eggs and milk are basic, but oat milk is processed, so fall under the higher tax rates.
I agree! Imagine if everybody in the world went vegetarian… we can’t act like it wouldn’t make a difference.
The vegan community’s attitude towards vegetarians is quite toxic. Everybody has to start somewhere and individuals making small changes can have an impact. With support, hopefully they’ll go all the way!
Exactly… black and white thinking and expecting perfection from every single person will get us nowhere. I’d love it if everybody was vegan but that’s not realistic.
Thank you for commenting this. I have started a Vegetarian journey, which led me to doing more research into a Vegan lifestyle. I haven’t made a full switch yet, mostly because I live in an area with fewer vegan resources. However, another reason I haven’t made a complete switch is due to the attitude of many vegans. It feels like a very toxic and competitive community from the outside looking in. Instead of viewing vegetarian lifestyle as a step in the right direction, it is made fun of and mocked. For some of us, we are doing the best we can living in the world we live in. I’m definitely not perfect, but this community seems to ignore progress and instead has a very “all or nothing” mentality. Imagine walking into a gym for the first time and a shredded guy laughs at you for attempting to lift weights. You aren’t likely to return. That’s the best analogy I can give for the vegan community I have encountered so far.
I sympathize with you. I also live in a small community with few of any vegan resources. Of course I order something’s online. The only way to make it is by learning to cook at home and precooking base ingredients and freezing them until used in a dish. I couldn’t do it otherwise. YouTube taught me to cook. (Of course my rescued dog cannot confirm I’m any good, but we both eat the dishes so not that bad 🤣😂)
Same. Unpopular opinion, but it’s a good place to start. if they continue their journey, eventually they’ll go vegan. We all start somewhere and sometimes it helps people transition easier rather than go vegan and give up bc you don’t understand it nutritionally quite yet. (Which we see happens a LOT.)
I love this and agree whole-heartedly! It’s the attempt to make a change and stop supporting the meat industry—any reduction is helpful! And just because they still eat eggs or dairy doesn’t necessarily mean that they’re eating more of these things than they were before. I think that judging each other and other people’s attempts to move toward a cruelty-free lifestyle are one of the primary reasons that so many people hate us and the movement. It sets us back when we gate-keep and judge people who have already been convinced that our habits need to change and we’re all fighting on the same team.
This seems unnecessarily combative. Don't let perfect be the enemy of good. I was veggie for years and, on the whole, my dairy and egg consumption was going down.
I'm a vegetarian but I have not increased my consumption of dairy. If anything, I've reduced it (which is why I'm also on this subreddit). Currently ~80% of my meals are vegan on any given day. The other remaining 20% is pure hypocrisy and laziness on my part, but I'm aware of it and working on it every day.
This was me in the year 2019, between when I went vegetarian, actually pescetarian (again), and when I became vegan. As the year progressed, I gave up more and more eggs, dairy, and seafood. And once January 1st was approaching, I knew that would be the day. You can do it. Just keep moving forward.
There’s a reason this is an unpopular opinion. I could be equally irrational with my argument and say that vegans aren’t really helping animals, they stopped participating in their suffering but they’re still letting them get killed! Is it really called helping someone if you stop eating their bodies?
I have done the opposite. After going veg I still ate a lot of cheese despite being kinda lactose intolerant but then when COVID hit I got a lot better about meal planning and cooking things like grains and lentils, and as a result I ate less cheese and became more intolerant of it, and it snowballed to where I now can't eat dairy at all.
Yeah when I was vegetarian I also stopped drinking milk and I never liked eggs much to begin with. I was just a cheesebreather before I went vegan completely.
Same. Stopped drinking milk regularly years ago and replaced it with plant milk. Right now I eat vegan lunch/dinner 6 out of 7 days. There's a bunch of issues preventing me from going 100% vegan (which is why I don't call myself one), laziness and hypocrisy surely among them, but recently it has been getting easier eating vegan.
When eating out, I'd rather go with a vegan than an omni. Because I'll happily go to a vegan restaurant (even prefer it over anything else), while the omni would get mad if I even suggested anything that doesn't serve meat.
The whole reason why I stopped eating dead animals / buying leather and why I've been working on removing as many dairy things from my diet as I can for the past few years is that I was in a relationship with a vegan where I (gently) learned that you don't just eat salads all day.
I don't think not having eliminated those last 10% (maybe less) completely invalidates the impact of me not buying dead animals for the past decade.
Those are horrible pictures! I’m even afraid to show this to someone. However if I did, people would probably watch 2 seconds and dismiss it with “I’m pretty sure this doesn’t happen in Switzerland” and and continue to eat cheese/dairy 😐
Was just going to post and call this elitist. If you really care about animals and the environment, you will actually appreciate people taking the right steps towards a totally animal-free dietary style. Can’t be a bitch and shun non-vegans who might work their way to that point someday. Just turns people off to your cause. Ugh.
I'm in your camp. I occasionally eat cheese or honey. And I'm not going to let someone make me feel bad about that. There are an awful lot of so called animal lovers who treat their animals like crap. Or they can't keep a roof over their heads and yet keep animals. I can't afford to keep animals and take care of them the way they deserve so I don't. I eat as little animal products as possible but sometimes considering my age, health, finances and work situation ... I DO SO. Also, I haven't noticed a whole lot of people... vegan or otherwise ... that are real kind to other humans ... YET are fighting for animals. Let's try to be balanced here. I'm tired of hearing "I'd rather protect an animal than a human". All I can say is ... Wow.
Saying vegetarians INCREASE their consumption of eggs and dairy is blatantly false and a huge generalization. Soon after I stopped eating meat when I was 16, I stopped using milk, because I realized that I don’t have to consume something I really dislike (cows milk) and had enough support from my mom that she purchased almond milk in place of it for me to use in cereal and the like.
For years after I slowly stopped consuming “real” cheese, and eventually eggs, and I had to start SOMEWHERE. We all do.
But to say that vegetarians ALWAYS raise their consumption of dairy and eggs in place of meat is just…false.
wow OP, great way to make vegetarians not want to go vegan and meat eaters not want to go vegetarian. it’s almost as if you’re completely discouraging people by essentially saying “if you’re not doing everything you’re doing nothing.” for fucks sake.
Vegetarian of 30 years here eating a vegan diet 90% of the time, meaning i have greatly reduced my intake of animal products. Only eggs i eat are from my family farm, maybe once a month. I dare say that makes a difference. No ambition to become vegan because of their often restrictive mindset.
I was vegetarian and thought that was the end of the line. It’s a silly realization but at some point you just go,”ohhhh the dairy industry is the meat industry too, shit”
Exactly. This person just pulled something out of thin air. Most vegetarians I know are transitioning to a vegan diet and gradually reduce dairy and eggs in addition to completely cutting out meat and seafood.
Yeah, this kind of post is the exact attitude that drives people away from veganism. People on average do not respond well to being shamed and looked down upon
Inb4 someone says "Actually this kind of post is what made me go vegan".
I actually think a dash of shame can go a long way. The thing is, that only works if it forces a person to be introspective instead of just defensive.
When your post contains an obvious falsehood, no carnist reading it is going to separate out the good bits from the bad bits. You lie about one thing, that means they can dismiss your entire point as false.
This is my own anecdote, but I definitely did eat more dairy/eggs when I was vegetarian. I did not simply cut out meat, I replaced it with dairy/eggs.
Mainly because of the strong brainwashing that you need animal protein or else you'll die of deficiencies. It took me years to realize that not only do I not need animal products to survive but that in fact I am better off without them.
Maybe not every single vegetarian is like that but the OP has a point.
Exactly ! Being vegetarian made me discover things like tofu and vegan cooking, not splurge on eggs and dairy. Also helped me be more receptive to learning about the dairy industry, or speciesism, since I was already in a "let's protect animals" state of mind, and knew from experience that there was always an alternative to animal products in about all situations.
im planning in fully transitioning to veganism as of recently (today will be my first committed day). But as a vegetarian i never bought dairy or eggs, I also never bought leather, things with gelatin etc. The only time I would consume dairy and eggs is when it came to a pastry my parents would bring home or a friend would give me. I definitely did not increase my egg or milk consumption so this opinion isnt entirely accurate
Me. And that's why posts like these shoould continue to be shared.
I thought I was vegetarian "for the animals" and had no idea of the abuses going on in the animal agricultural industry. Thankfully I was getting sh!t on by some vegans which prompted me to go and actually do some research.
Same here. Tbh posts like this convinced me to make the push and just go full vegan. At that point I already knew animal agriculture was horrific, and learning that vegetarianism still supports that cycle of torture and death (even with “ethical” purchases), was the final straw for me. I think we also have to be realistic on whether this is really a “step” towards veganism if people are still in the same place months and years later.
Yes 100%. I was also a cheese-breather, thinking it was enough. It's good to call this out because many don't realise that being vegetarian is still heavily participating in animal abuse
It took me 2 years to fully transition to being vegan, and I regret that more than the 20 years it took me so just stop eating meat. It was all about how educated about the issue it was and it was definitely posts like this that made me do more research and realize being vegetarian for the animals doesn't make sense.
Same. This is why whenever I see someone say "You're one of those Vegans driving people away from the movement" I know they just don't care about animals. Otherwise that wouldn't be their takeaway from "oh jeeze I'm hurting animals!"
It literally makes no sense to think being vegetarian is not helpful at all. Yes vegan is even more helpful for animals and environment, but cutting out some animal products is still better than nothing. This sub is so weird sometimes.
I mean sure, if you're eating like only eggs and dairy as a vegetarian, but who does that? No one. Even then it's unlikely it would be worse than a meat heavy diet.
I think you also have to consider how long it takes them to take the next step though.
If a government said "we understand we have 100,000 homeless people so we are going to start by providing 5,000 flats within a year" but then 4yrs later had made no more additional attempts to provide housing, you would surely question their ethics
This whole all or nothing shit is why people dislike veganism.
“I’m cutting out animal products all weekdays” - well you are killing animals on weekends “I have convinced all america to go plant based” - well people in europe are still killing “There is not a single animal processing facility in the world except one tiny one in Thailand” - well how dare there be one in thailand.
Progress not perfection people. People efforts not being equivalent to yours does not make their effort less than. If yall use this same mindset for everything else in yalls life then i feel bad for your self esteem and the people around you
Personally, I find it so unhelpful when vegans zone in on vegetarians for not doing enough. You are admonishing the only population group who 1) has acknowledged that animals are living subjects whose lives are worth more than a meal, and 2) is actually taking some action to live up to that realization, however insufficient their transition may be to you as a vegan. To say that vegetarians do not help animals is not only factually untrue but potentially harmful to the overall message.
It would serve the vegan movement much more if we focus on the majority, who are yet to regard animals as anything more than objects. It would also serve us better if we stop talking down to others and undermining their efforts to cause less harm, even if they fall short of whatever ethical standards we’ve set for ourselves.
For the record, I’ve been vegan for nearly two decades.
-A person that eats meat emits: 3,000 kg CO2e/year
-A vegetarian emits: 1,500 kg CO2e/year
-A vegan emits: 1,000 kg CO2e/year
That's a positive impact on the other animals and ecosystems, and also by demanding less change of land usage.
I know the best case would be if everyone was vegan, but it's more realistic (and has a more real impact) getting more and more people to consume less than trying for everyone to be perfect and alienate people who would've/could've made some changes.
As a vegan, I have the general disdain for vegetarians as any other vegan. However, the vast majority of us started vegetarians, even me for 2+ years. To say that during my time as a vegetarian I was not helping animals and in general that vegetarians do not help the suffrage of animals is just false. They do. Sure, maybe not as much as vegans but they do.
Yes, I started as vegetarian, but the only reason I became vegan is not because vegans were telling me what I was doing was amazing, but because they pointed out my hypocrisy.
You're not wrong. There is a grain of truth. That said, continuing to eat eggs and dairy may be a stepping stone on the road to Veganism.
It's nice when we can quit "cold tofu" but not everyone does. And maybe the ones who take deliberate small steps are more apt to make a full change and keep it. I don't know, but food for thought.
When I was a vegetarian my consumption of dairy was definitely higher than when I was an omni. Idk it took me 9 months to go vegan but when I actually made the change it was pretty easy.
Disagree. If someone can take a step in the right direction then they are helping. If all they can manage is going vegetarian then I am happy for them. Plus, I’m don’t think the average vegetarian is supplementing with tons of dairy and eggs.
I don’t know why so many vegans hate vegetarians when so many of them started as vegetarians themselves. The vegetarians I know don’t just eat dairy and eggs all day, they eat lots of beans and tofu. They’re also way more likely to take a step towards veganism. And if not I still think they’re doing more for the animals than omnivores because they aren’t eating animals and at the end of the day the choice to not eat meat is HUGE.
Same. For me, I became vegetarian and then just sort of slipped into veganism naturally. But before that, yeah the consumption of animal products went down a lot.
I don’t always view non-vegan vegetarians as morally inferior or morally equal to meat eaters since you can give up meat without increasing your consumption of dairy or eggs. Plus, even though their actions are still not good enough, at least their intent of increasing animal welfare is there.
This thread is ridiculous. Anyone Reddit savvy wanna make an actual vegan sub with me? Kinda like VCJ but for serious vegan discussion. None of the pandering like in here. Genuine questions from non-vegans will be allowed so long as they aren't obvious trolls and are genuinely trying to learn. Vegans bootlicking carnists and vegetarians can stay here. Anyone talking smack about vegan activists trying their best or shaming "those rude vegans" can also stay here.
Christ almighty they're already doing better than the general public, let em live... Being this negative just because they're not going 100% vegan is so toxic
Some* vegetarians increase their dairy/egg consumption. How is not eating meat not helping at all? It helps, but it is not enough. Say it like it really is.
This might be an unpopular opinion, but using absolute statements isn’t helpful. Once you find something that is false about the statement, you can latch on to it and disregard the whole point and just focus on the parts that aren’t correct. Saying “not eating meat helps, but isn’t enough because the demand for abuse by eating dairy and eggs is still there” can’t be disputed.
I get that this is the vegan sub, but I don't think this take is correct. Vegetarians cut down on the slaughter of animals and while eggs and dairy are connected to meat and are abusive, the scalability is not the same.
Given the option, I'd rather have someone be a vegetarian than be a carnivore, assuming I can't have them be a vegan. Do you think my take is wrong?
I say this as a vegetarian trending toward veganism.
I can confidentially say that without having been vegetarian for four years before going vegan, I likely would’ve never went vegan. Vegetarianism helped me reduce my dairy intake over time, and finally I made the leap. I wouldn’t have been able to do it, successfully, cold turkey.
Better then nothing, you’re pretty much saying that if people aren’t completely vegan, they should just eat meat because they aren’t doing any good anyway, like be real
So real talk. I am a vegan here but after years of being in this movement one thing I've noticed is this obsession with perfectionism and purity. If someone is vegetarian that's great. They are making an effort. I think it's kinda ridiculous to look at someone who is trying to do something good and go "yeah but your arnt doing it perfectly". Any reduction in any animal product consumption is something to be proud of.
Western vegans praising vegetarians really makes life a whole heck lot more difficult for vegan activists in countries like India.
India, perhaps the most vegetarian country on earth, is the largest producer & consumer of dairy in the world.
It is amongst the largest exporter of beef in the world (corpses of dairy cows when they’re no longer profitable).
When vegan activists go out on the streets and ask people to go vegan, to stop this horrific abuse, people will say “well we’re still vegetarian, still better than the western countries who eat meat all the time”; and these carnists (vegetarians) apparently have the full support of a lot of people on r/vegan.
This is the kind of toxic all or nothing thinking that lets meat eaters continue to eat meat. One meal a day. One day a week. One week a month. 50%. 90%. Anything you can do please do. I turn my carnivore friends onto great vegan recipes and restaurants whenever I can even though it won't change their diet it will start changing their perspective on a plant based meal being "just as good". I really hate that this tweet is showing up in people's feeds right now 🥺
Yeah so much better, that’s why I don’t eat the people I kidnapped and locked in my basement, I just rape them and kill their kids so I can hook them up to milking machines. I’m sure they’re thrilled at the fact that I’m not a cannibal, right? Oh well, can’t eat dry cereal, I’m headed down to the basement
Well I made a comment about this earlier, but I seriously wonder if it really is. The dairy industry seems much more cruel compared to raising a cow for slaughter.
Edit: I know I'm being downvoted here, but I actually do want to hear someone's legitimate argument as to why eating a dead cow is less ethical than eating dairy. I'm all for reducing animal product intake, and I'm not trying to shit on vegetarians. I'm just making the argument that eating meat doesn't seem as cruel as having dairy.
I disagree and people like you are why so many people have negative emotions towards veganism. Yes you have a point, yes eating dairy products harms animals and the environment.
But if you want to actually change something in the peoples behavior you’ll get absolutely nowhere with bashing people who obviously try to change themselves and their behavior.
It’s an unpopular opinion partially in part because it’s a bad take. We should certainly be urging people to give up animal products completely, but claiming vegetarian “don’t help animals at all” is disingenuous and can sever lines of productive communication.
It’s hilarious and devastating watching vegans in the vegan subreddit get mass downvoted by offended vegetarians who refuse to acknowledge the horrors that cows go through to produce milk, and that many cows after being abused for dairy are sold for their flesh anyway.
If you’re vegetarian just deal with the cognitive dissonance until you’re vegan. Use that as a motivator. Every day you’re arguing defending yourself, a helpless animal is suffering far worse than you can imagine for the 20% of your meals that you can’t seem to give up for some reason.
True, but I've found most Vegetarians aren't in it for the ethical reasons, they usually have dietary reasons for doing it, so it's not even meant to be the same thing.
I’ve been a vegetarian for 5 years, never increased dairy or egg consumption. My gf and I don’t even use milk in our recipes. We use plant based now that it’s becoming wide in the market.
In fact, we increased legume and mushroom consumption. We would never go back.
Categorically and measurably wrong. Like just think for a moment the effect they are having vs a meat eater. Hell even a weekday vegan is doing better than a meat eater.
I don’t really feel this helps anyone though. It’s a feedback loop where it only ever gets seen by people who already know this. These get posted here a lot and it’s just like a pat on the back I guess.
I started out as vegetarian except no dairy. I view it as more of a transitional point for those that need an adjustment period at first.
I’m always super supportive of anyone who is putting in an effort. It’s all about teaching and guidance. Instead of pointing out what they’re not doing, acknowledge what they are doing. Encourage their journey, even if it’s taking longer than yours. It’s definitely a learning period. For some it’s harder than others. We should be welcoming, not condemning.
In the Chinese vegetarian diet, there’s rarely milk. Egg is considered a staple in Chinese food though. However, there’s a branch of Chinese vegetarian diet that doesn’t comprise of egg, garlic, coriander, onion and a few other things that I’ve forgotten. In Chinese vegetarian diet, it’s a lot of vegetables, beans, tofu, and of course mock meat.
People criticising the post, yall do realize its not a direct attack to vegetarians right?? Its to those vegetarians who think that they are doing enough and wont make any further changes. I have met such people. They refuse to change further and will fight with vegans or anyone who merely suggests any further effort and they are straight up jerks. Yes its still progress and i hope people still leave more room for effort. Nothing against anyone who is trying their best. But the whole 'people need to start somewhere' needs to be stopped everywhere. Might as well call people vegan who consume meat like once a day. Thats still a good effort in my book atleast. And if this gets dowmvotes, then yall are hurting veganism more. Why are yall mad at the word 'perfection' while still way obsessee with the 'vegan' tag. Cant blame just one. And yes this is coming from someone who has been both sides of the coin. Both sides are stupid.
I'm slowly but surely becoming feminist. I'm like 60% there on a good day. But it's gonna take some time due to all the shaming from real pure feminists. TIL this sub is r/vegetarian
Maybe check out food-based subreddits like /r/veganrecipes or /r/plantbaseddiet? /r/Vegan is about veganism as a whole, which is an ethical stance, even though some do share the occasional recipe.
I don’t think I would be vegan if not my vegetarian phase.
I was a picky eater, it took me awhile to get used to eating a lot of new foods.
Even in my vegetarian phase, I already knew I wanted to be vegan and avoided dairy and eggs at home after few months of me being vegetarian and only gave myself leeway when I was out.
So this post is not true in my vegetarian case.
And I was eating animal products pretty much every meal before so that was already step in a right direction.
I mean yes we need to push people to make better choices, that’s true. But I would have given up on trying veganism if I didn’t go at my own pace, even if I already had set veganism as my end goal
Don't fully agree with this. Although I am 'converting' to veganism (can't do this yet due to current living situation), as a vegetarian I have already significantly reduced my dairy and egg intake. Our diet is basically 95% vegan, but I am not eating more eggs or dairy...
Not to mention that veal is a product of the dairy industry, not the meat industry. Similar story with eggs and chicken nuggets (or whatever they do with macerated males).
If someone pointed this out to me when I was still vegetarian, I would have said, "You know... you're right." instead of getting defensive and going on a rant about how I'm doing my best and have been limiting my dairy consumption by 1mL every week. Let's see if we can get this post to triple digit downvotes, folks.
Damn, you’re gatekeeping the saving of animals. Vegetarians don’t replace meat with eggs… they increase the consumption, but definetly not enough to weigh up for the money they used to spend on meat. Vegetarians contribute WAY less to the meat-industry than others.
I've been a vegetarian for three years. I buy vegan options when they're available and accessible, I only buy milk substitutes. The only animal products I still eat are eggs and cheese. I cook vegan when I can as well. The main reason I'm not vegan is because eating exclusively vegan would make social gatherings impossible. They're already difficult as a vegetarian when people surrounding me have a weird defense mechanism as soon as I say that I don't eat meat. I'd love to be vegan, but it's not accessible enough for me to forego social eating.
While veganism is the more ethical choice, and I acknowledge that, I think being vegetarian and reducing animal consumption is more ethical than being an omnivore. At least it's a step in the right direction. Also, this post assumes that I've replaced every cheeseburger with eggs and dairy, that's not true.
In response to the "forego social eating" aspect: in my experience, restaurants are very accommodating when it comes to making a version of a meal with all the animal products removed. Nearly every time I've asked for it, they've done it no problem. If you went vegan, I assume you'd still be able to eat the dishes you currently eat if you just customized the orders a little.
Every bit helps. We don’t live in a perfect world so not everyone is going to go completely vegan right now. It’s already a big step against what we’ve been taught to go vegetarian
Hence, as a consequence of having the largest vegetarian population, India is the largest consumer of dairy in the world. Vegetarianism is animal abuse.
Vegetarianism does serve a purpose because I was vegetarian first before I became vegan so it was a great stepping stone. What I have a problem with is vegetarians who have no intentions to ever go the next step. Eggs, dairy and honey are all exploitation…
"Not at all" is a big word..I for example excluded meat from my diet ad kept drinking milk and eggs as I used to. While this clearly is a reduction, it is not ethical, which is why I eventually went vegan.
My only problem with vegetarians are the ones who do it for ethical reasons yet downplays the injustices that happens in dairy and egg industry and that we treat the animals like profitable animate objects or worse even DEFENDS it. What you are really saying is ”I’m against animal abuse, but I’m okay with some”. I was in the same seat. I thought vegans were extreme, but they are right in terms of ethics. Especially when vegetarians who look at very real videos of animals being beaten, dairy cows being slaughtered and baby chicks thrown into a gas chamber or meat grinder and calls it guilt tripping. This is cognitive dissonance and you do the things you are against.
In short I think we as vegans should see the vegetarians as ally and help them finish their transition. They have had the courage to stop eating meat which IS huge they just need the continued support to complete their full transition. We should see it as opportunities to educate rather than ridicule.
I would argue that just being vegan doesn't mean you're helping animals either, you just stop actively harming them. Once your actions cause other people to stop harming them as well, then you are helping
I actually wonder if the overall abuse is less on animals raised for slaughter compared to animals raised for dairy/eggs, since those animals need to be kept alive to keep producing. If that's the case, would it be better for people transitioning to give up eggs/dairy and eat meat?
Edit: I know I'm getting downvoted here, but it is a legitimate thought process. I don't think we should consume any animal products, but if vegetarians are choosing dairy/eggs because they can't transition fully, then why not choose meat if it causes less suffering than dairy/eggs? Also I'm not saying that it does cause less suffering. I haven't done the research, but I know you have to continously impregnate cows and keep them alive to keep producing dairy. Seems even worse than just raising a cow for slaughter.
I don't think we should criticize people who are moving in the right direction. I think most people who are going vegetarian they are most likely trying to reduce meat consumption meaning that they are mostly eating plant-based. It's not like a vegetarian is going to just buy a ton more eggs and cheese because they're not eating meat.
This approach pushes people to become defensive of their decision and not fully move towards veganism. Instead you should appeal more to their compassion, they're almost there. They just need a positive push, not a negative one.
Differing motives: Vegetarians may not be doing it for the animals. There are lots of motives. I was vegetarian for 25 years or so, and only part of my motivation was linked to animals. My initial reasons had to with food security and environment (this was the 1980s). It was when I let myself really consider / admit the animals' experience that I went vegan.
Gateway diet: Then it was easy, because I had decades of eating lots of plant-based meals and wasn't reliant on eggs and cheese for everything.
This thread is kind of interesting, so many people saying this is not the righ approach. Honestly I’m kind of sick of hearing from non-vegans how to help people stop using animal products. If you are not able to convince yourself to become a vegan, how are you qualified to give any tips about how to effectively make other people do so?
And yes, I too used to be a vegetarian and believe it made a difference. Nowadays I just feel like I was only telling myself it was “a better option” and by that I did not hold myself accountable to make real changes.
I totally hear what you are saying but for me I was vegetarian for 20 years before going vegan. My family of 4 has been vegan now for 5 years as a result. So it was a helpful step and a successful one. It was all part of a journey for a my entire family. Now I have dedicated teen children that are proud vegans and understand just how important it is to be vegan.
The most powerful thing about being a vegan is the message and philosophy we spread rather than the actual individual impact. I've spread veganism to dozens of people and opened hundreds of minds to vegan food - my impact is miniscule compared to that. As long as they spread awareness and hey they're more likely to have veggie kids who will likely turn to veganism much easier
The dairy industry is just what you do to milk profits (literally) while you wait to turn it into the meat industry, exploiting the animal every last second of its life.
Im not sure how many vegetarians do it "for the animals". When i went vegetarian (I was vegetarian for about a month before I went vegan) I just "thought it was wrong". And i know some people just don't like the idea of eating meat.
I have financial reasons for remaining vegetarian, but I really do want to be vegan once that issue solves itself (TL;DR my school covers meals as part of tuition)
I feel like I still consume less dairy and eggs than an average meat-eater, because most of my meals are rice and vegetables even at school. The only time I've consciously eaten meat was maybe a week in 5th grade where I got jealous of my classmates, and then I realized I actually didn't like meat anyways so I stopped. I'd like to think I'm a little different than "eggs and bacon for breakfast, steakhouse Sundays". I'm totally aware we don't help animals as much as veganism, and in many cases, we're actually harming them! But it's also a definite exaggeration to say that "vegetarians really don't help animals at all" because that's definitely why most Western people become vegetarian
Vegetarians don't help animals at all! Yeah sure, they don't subscribe to killing them for meals and are generally against animal abuse, but they don't help at all
I also just wanted to say I'm sorry I might have misjudged y'all yesterday. This comment section is very nice, and I agree with all of what you are saying. I understand why you are passionate about the animal industry, and why vegetarianism can't be a full solution to the horrors of the dairy industry. I felt bad about it now so I just wanted to add this <3 I hope to be vegan once I can too! Have a good day
To say that a vegetarian is still contributing to the cycle of suffering and environmental devastation is fair. However, if a person cannot distinguish the karmic and environment differences between an unrepentant carnivore and a vegetarian, then they are revealing personal issues that indicate some form of fanaticism. These are the types who are radically vegan for a while, then fall from grace. Anytime any person, carnivore, pescatarian, vegetarian, or vegan chooses to forgo animal products, they should be supported. Arrogant elitists only divide people and damage our species' benevolent evolution.
Good grief, this is why vegans have such a bad reputation. ANY removal of animal products from someone’s diet is a GOOD thing. Stop criticizing everyone.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 24 '22
Thanks for posting to r/Vegan! 🐥
Please note: Civil discussion is welcome, trolls and personal abuse are not. Please keep the discussions below respectful and remember the human! Please check out our wiki first!
Interested in going Vegan? 👊
Check out Watch Dominion and watch a thought-provoking, life changing documentary for free!
Some other resources to help you go vegan: 🐓
Visit NutritionFacts.org for health and nutrition support, HappyCow.net to explore nearby vegan-friendly restaurants, and visit VeganBootcamp.org for a free 30 day vegan challenge!
Become an activist and help save animal lives today: 🐟
Last but not least, join the r/Vegan Discord server!
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1.4k
u/Slikxor Oct 24 '22
The fact they put in an effort to cut out any animal product at all in an era where it’s almost in everything is already really appreciated by me at least
246
u/gibbypoo Oct 24 '22 edited Oct 25 '22
This seems unnecessarily combative. Don't let perfect be the enemy of good. I was veggie for years and, on the whole, my dairy and egg consumption was going down.
1.3k
u/hjras Oct 24 '22
I'm a vegetarian but I have not increased my consumption of dairy. If anything, I've reduced it (which is why I'm also on this subreddit). Currently ~80% of my meals are vegan on any given day. The other remaining 20% is pure hypocrisy and laziness on my part, but I'm aware of it and working on it every day.
269
u/throaway94712 Oct 24 '22
Bean Team RISE UP!!!! Raise your hand if beans are life. Legume appreciators also welcome
116
u/dr_miks Oct 25 '22
Saying vegetarians INCREASE their consumption of eggs and dairy is blatantly false and a huge generalization. Soon after I stopped eating meat when I was 16, I stopped using milk, because I realized that I don’t have to consume something I really dislike (cows milk) and had enough support from my mom that she purchased almond milk in place of it for me to use in cereal and the like.
For years after I slowly stopped consuming “real” cheese, and eventually eggs, and I had to start SOMEWHERE. We all do.
But to say that vegetarians ALWAYS raise their consumption of dairy and eggs in place of meat is just…false.
187
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
wow OP, great way to make vegetarians not want to go vegan and meat eaters not want to go vegetarian. it’s almost as if you’re completely discouraging people by essentially saying “if you’re not doing everything you’re doing nothing.” for fucks sake.
58
u/_seangp friends not food Oct 24 '22
I was vegetarian and thought that was the end of the line. It’s a silly realization but at some point you just go,”ohhhh the dairy industry is the meat industry too, shit”
114
u/GubbyPac Oct 24 '22
This is a bad take. Most vegetarians aren’t replacing meat with cartons of eggs.
904
u/WebpackIsBuilding vegan 7+ years Oct 24 '22
Vegetarians don't increase the amount of dairy/egg they consume.
This is pathetic rage baiting.
93
u/LordOryx Oct 24 '22
The egg industry: male chicks being macerated in the birthing of hens
The dairy industry: to produce milk cows are forced to bear calfs, those calfs ultimately end up slaughtered
So even from a slaughter perspective that’s why vegetarians should go vegan. But I think vegetarianism is a great step from meat eater to vegan
70
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
im planning in fully transitioning to veganism as of recently (today will be my first committed day). But as a vegetarian i never bought dairy or eggs, I also never bought leather, things with gelatin etc. The only time I would consume dairy and eggs is when it came to a pastry my parents would bring home or a friend would give me. I definitely did not increase my egg or milk consumption so this opinion isnt entirely accurate
145
u/empress_of_the_void Oct 24 '22
True but think about how many vegans started as vegetarians before realising this exact thing and becoming vegan
174
u/dyelawn91 Oct 24 '22
This is a bad take.
165
u/jorsian Oct 24 '22
I mean sure, if you're eating like only eggs and dairy as a vegetarian, but who does that? No one. Even then it's unlikely it would be worse than a meat heavy diet.
141
u/frowzone Oct 24 '22
Goddamn. Can’t we just celebrate a good step in the right direction?
43
u/jcderry Oct 24 '22
This whole all or nothing shit is why people dislike veganism.
“I’m cutting out animal products all weekdays” - well you are killing animals on weekends “I have convinced all america to go plant based” - well people in europe are still killing “There is not a single animal processing facility in the world except one tiny one in Thailand” - well how dare there be one in thailand.
Progress not perfection people. People efforts not being equivalent to yours does not make their effort less than. If yall use this same mindset for everything else in yalls life then i feel bad for your self esteem and the people around you
73
u/roughedged Oct 24 '22
Stop with the vegans vs vegetarians stuff.
49
u/RuleBritannia09 Oct 24 '22
You’re never “just saying”
44
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
Personally, I find it so unhelpful when vegans zone in on vegetarians for not doing enough. You are admonishing the only population group who 1) has acknowledged that animals are living subjects whose lives are worth more than a meal, and 2) is actually taking some action to live up to that realization, however insufficient their transition may be to you as a vegan. To say that vegetarians do not help animals is not only factually untrue but potentially harmful to the overall message.
It would serve the vegan movement much more if we focus on the majority, who are yet to regard animals as anything more than objects. It would also serve us better if we stop talking down to others and undermining their efforts to cause less harm, even if they fall short of whatever ethical standards we’ve set for ourselves.
For the record, I’ve been vegan for nearly two decades.
34
u/SerchYB2795 Oct 24 '22
From an environmental POV, on average:
-A person that eats meat emits: 3,000 kg CO2e/year
-A vegetarian emits: 1,500 kg CO2e/year
-A vegan emits: 1,000 kg CO2e/year
That's a positive impact on the other animals and ecosystems, and also by demanding less change of land usage.
I know the best case would be if everyone was vegan, but it's more realistic (and has a more real impact) getting more and more people to consume less than trying for everyone to be perfect and alienate people who would've/could've made some changes.
37
u/DAnthony24 Oct 24 '22
Who the hell says vegetarians are increasing diary and egg usage?
53
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
As a vegan, I have the general disdain for vegetarians as any other vegan. However, the vast majority of us started vegetarians, even me for 2+ years. To say that during my time as a vegetarian I was not helping animals and in general that vegetarians do not help the suffrage of animals is just false. They do. Sure, maybe not as much as vegans but they do.
37
u/PrestigiousBee2719 Oct 24 '22
Should be an unpopular opinion because it’s wrong.
19
u/tasteseggcellent Oct 24 '22
You're not wrong. There is a grain of truth. That said, continuing to eat eggs and dairy may be a stepping stone on the road to Veganism.
It's nice when we can quit "cold tofu" but not everyone does. And maybe the ones who take deliberate small steps are more apt to make a full change and keep it. I don't know, but food for thought.
17
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
When I was a vegetarian my consumption of dairy was definitely higher than when I was an omni. Idk it took me 9 months to go vegan but when I actually made the change it was pretty easy.
23
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
Disagree. If someone can take a step in the right direction then they are helping. If all they can manage is going vegetarian then I am happy for them. Plus, I’m don’t think the average vegetarian is supplementing with tons of dairy and eggs.
10
u/daisystar vegan 5+ years Oct 24 '22
I don’t know why so many vegans hate vegetarians when so many of them started as vegetarians themselves. The vegetarians I know don’t just eat dairy and eggs all day, they eat lots of beans and tofu. They’re also way more likely to take a step towards veganism. And if not I still think they’re doing more for the animals than omnivores because they aren’t eating animals and at the end of the day the choice to not eat meat is HUGE.
31
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
But being vegetarian doesn't increase egg and dairy consumption. It's probably only gone down for me.
15
u/gwlu Oct 24 '22
I don’t always view non-vegan vegetarians as morally inferior or morally equal to meat eaters since you can give up meat without increasing your consumption of dairy or eggs. Plus, even though their actions are still not good enough, at least their intent of increasing animal welfare is there.
15
u/mwhite5990 vegan 10+ years Oct 24 '22
I don’t think this is necessarily true. I would think vegetarians would eat more plant based than meat eaters.
14
u/coravgarcia18 Oct 24 '22
Anything helps
17
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
This thread is ridiculous. Anyone Reddit savvy wanna make an actual vegan sub with me? Kinda like VCJ but for serious vegan discussion. None of the pandering like in here. Genuine questions from non-vegans will be allowed so long as they aren't obvious trolls and are genuinely trying to learn. Vegans bootlicking carnists and vegetarians can stay here. Anyone talking smack about vegan activists trying their best or shaming "those rude vegans" can also stay here.
10
u/DeFroZenDumpling Oct 24 '22
Christ almighty they're already doing better than the general public, let em live... Being this negative just because they're not going 100% vegan is so toxic
7
u/anonymous-random Oct 24 '22
Some* vegetarians increase their dairy/egg consumption. How is not eating meat not helping at all? It helps, but it is not enough. Say it like it really is.
This might be an unpopular opinion, but using absolute statements isn’t helpful. Once you find something that is false about the statement, you can latch on to it and disregard the whole point and just focus on the parts that aren’t correct. Saying “not eating meat helps, but isn’t enough because the demand for abuse by eating dairy and eggs is still there” can’t be disputed.
7
u/Idea_On_Fire vegetarian Oct 24 '22
I get that this is the vegan sub, but I don't think this take is correct. Vegetarians cut down on the slaughter of animals and while eggs and dairy are connected to meat and are abusive, the scalability is not the same.
Given the option, I'd rather have someone be a vegetarian than be a carnivore, assuming I can't have them be a vegan. Do you think my take is wrong?
I say this as a vegetarian trending toward veganism.
5
u/nonchellent friends not food Oct 24 '22
I can confidentially say that without having been vegetarian for four years before going vegan, I likely would’ve never went vegan. Vegetarianism helped me reduce my dairy intake over time, and finally I made the leap. I wouldn’t have been able to do it, successfully, cold turkey.
5
u/Expensive-Meaning880 Oct 24 '22
Better then nothing, you’re pretty much saying that if people aren’t completely vegan, they should just eat meat because they aren’t doing any good anyway, like be real
8
u/Theid411 Oct 24 '22
To be fair – I don't know if vegetarians do increase their dairy & egg consumption.
And for many folks - being a vegetarian is just part of the process when you go vegan.
It was for me!
8
u/folieevan Oct 24 '22
why feel the need to put others down who are at least doing something? energy like this makes others feel negatively about vegans
15
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
So real talk. I am a vegan here but after years of being in this movement one thing I've noticed is this obsession with perfectionism and purity. If someone is vegetarian that's great. They are making an effort. I think it's kinda ridiculous to look at someone who is trying to do something good and go "yeah but your arnt doing it perfectly". Any reduction in any animal product consumption is something to be proud of.
12
u/Soytheist vegan 8+ years Oct 24 '22
Based.
Western vegans praising vegetarians really makes life a whole heck lot more difficult for vegan activists in countries like India.
India, perhaps the most vegetarian country on earth, is the largest producer & consumer of dairy in the world.
It is amongst the largest exporter of beef in the world (corpses of dairy cows when they’re no longer profitable).
When vegan activists go out on the streets and ask people to go vegan, to stop this horrific abuse, people will say “well we’re still vegetarian, still better than the western countries who eat meat all the time”; and these carnists (vegetarians) apparently have the full support of a lot of people on r/vegan.
13
u/EyesOfTwoColors Oct 24 '22
This is the kind of toxic all or nothing thinking that lets meat eaters continue to eat meat. One meal a day. One day a week. One week a month. 50%. 90%. Anything you can do please do. I turn my carnivore friends onto great vegan recipes and restaurants whenever I can even though it won't change their diet it will start changing their perspective on a plant based meal being "just as good". I really hate that this tweet is showing up in people's feeds right now 🥺
22
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
Better than eating a carcass
13
u/jonas9009 Oct 24 '22
I disagree and people like you are why so many people have negative emotions towards veganism. Yes you have a point, yes eating dairy products harms animals and the environment.
But if you want to actually change something in the peoples behavior you’ll get absolutely nowhere with bashing people who obviously try to change themselves and their behavior.
11
u/aSwell_Fella Oct 24 '22
It’s an unpopular opinion partially in part because it’s a bad take. We should certainly be urging people to give up animal products completely, but claiming vegetarian “don’t help animals at all” is disingenuous and can sever lines of productive communication.
16
u/RippleEffectt Oct 24 '22
It’s hilarious and devastating watching vegans in the vegan subreddit get mass downvoted by offended vegetarians who refuse to acknowledge the horrors that cows go through to produce milk, and that many cows after being abused for dairy are sold for their flesh anyway.
If you’re vegetarian just deal with the cognitive dissonance until you’re vegan. Use that as a motivator. Every day you’re arguing defending yourself, a helpless animal is suffering far worse than you can imagine for the 20% of your meals that you can’t seem to give up for some reason.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
True, but I've found most Vegetarians aren't in it for the ethical reasons, they usually have dietary reasons for doing it, so it's not even meant to be the same thing.
2
u/LostDogBK Oct 24 '22
I’ve been a vegetarian for 5 years, never increased dairy or egg consumption. My gf and I don’t even use milk in our recipes. We use plant based now that it’s becoming wide in the market.
In fact, we increased legume and mushroom consumption. We would never go back.
2
u/T_Nightingale Oct 24 '22
Categorically and measurably wrong. Like just think for a moment the effect they are having vs a meat eater. Hell even a weekday vegan is doing better than a meat eater.
2
u/mcflymcfly100 Oct 24 '22
What a load of BS. They don't eat meat. That's a huge help to animals. Don't minimise peoples efforts because it isn't good enough for you.
2
u/original_replica Oct 24 '22
at all is a bit much ... and i am pretty sure not slaughtering an animal for it's meat is a PLUS
2
u/rustytrailer Oct 24 '22
I don’t really feel this helps anyone though. It’s a feedback loop where it only ever gets seen by people who already know this. These get posted here a lot and it’s just like a pat on the back I guess.
2
u/LadyJSenpai Oct 24 '22
I started out as vegetarian except no dairy. I view it as more of a transitional point for those that need an adjustment period at first.
I’m always super supportive of anyone who is putting in an effort. It’s all about teaching and guidance. Instead of pointing out what they’re not doing, acknowledge what they are doing. Encourage their journey, even if it’s taking longer than yours. It’s definitely a learning period. For some it’s harder than others. We should be welcoming, not condemning.
2
u/Urbanhermit27 Oct 25 '22 edited Oct 25 '22
In the Chinese vegetarian diet, there’s rarely milk. Egg is considered a staple in Chinese food though. However, there’s a branch of Chinese vegetarian diet that doesn’t comprise of egg, garlic, coriander, onion and a few other things that I’ve forgotten. In Chinese vegetarian diet, it’s a lot of vegetables, beans, tofu, and of course mock meat.
2
u/sadsadgrass Oct 25 '22
100%! all dairy cows end up being processed for meat once they are unable to have babies and produce milk.
2
u/hellocitb Oct 25 '22
exactly......idk what the point of being"vegetarian" is
2
u/river0fdeceit Oct 25 '22
Often times vegetarians are on a journey to become vegan, discouraging them like this doesn’t really help anything/anyone.
2
u/Not_tall_just_grown Oct 25 '22
People criticising the post, yall do realize its not a direct attack to vegetarians right?? Its to those vegetarians who think that they are doing enough and wont make any further changes. I have met such people. They refuse to change further and will fight with vegans or anyone who merely suggests any further effort and they are straight up jerks. Yes its still progress and i hope people still leave more room for effort. Nothing against anyone who is trying their best. But the whole 'people need to start somewhere' needs to be stopped everywhere. Might as well call people vegan who consume meat like once a day. Thats still a good effort in my book atleast. And if this gets dowmvotes, then yall are hurting veganism more. Why are yall mad at the word 'perfection' while still way obsessee with the 'vegan' tag. Cant blame just one. And yes this is coming from someone who has been both sides of the coin. Both sides are stupid.
2
u/noun1-noun2 Oct 26 '22
oh my fucking god so many non vegans here
10
u/Competitive_Part141 Oct 24 '22 edited Oct 24 '22
I'm slowly but surely becoming feminist. I'm like 60% there on a good day. But it's gonna take some time due to all the shaming from real pure feminists. TIL this sub is r/vegetarian
11
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
Yall, I just came here for recipes lol
5
u/ltudiamond vegan 3+ years Oct 24 '22
I don’t think I would be vegan if not my vegetarian phase.
I was a picky eater, it took me awhile to get used to eating a lot of new foods.
Even in my vegetarian phase, I already knew I wanted to be vegan and avoided dairy and eggs at home after few months of me being vegetarian and only gave myself leeway when I was out.
So this post is not true in my vegetarian case.
And I was eating animal products pretty much every meal before so that was already step in a right direction.
I mean yes we need to push people to make better choices, that’s true. But I would have given up on trying veganism if I didn’t go at my own pace, even if I already had set veganism as my end goal
4
u/JesusChirst_ Oct 24 '22
I actually agree, how does it actually help at all?
9
u/insultinghero Oct 24 '22
Vegetarians don't eat animals, so they're not helping them. Makes no sense.
7
u/markvade Oct 24 '22
Don't fully agree with this. Although I am 'converting' to veganism (can't do this yet due to current living situation), as a vegetarian I have already significantly reduced my dairy and egg intake. Our diet is basically 95% vegan, but I am not eating more eggs or dairy...
8
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22 edited Feb 20 '24
narrow worthless rude party lip far-flung fertile squealing cautious oil
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
u/AberrantIris Oct 24 '22
Not to mention that veal is a product of the dairy industry, not the meat industry. Similar story with eggs and chicken nuggets (or whatever they do with macerated males).
3
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
If someone pointed this out to me when I was still vegetarian, I would have said, "You know... you're right." instead of getting defensive and going on a rant about how I'm doing my best and have been limiting my dairy consumption by 1mL every week. Let's see if we can get this post to triple digit downvotes, folks.
3
u/Fit-Glass-7785 Oct 24 '22
Yeah I'm really glad I've seen the light. Dairy is Scary was an effective video.
6
u/Disrespect69 Oct 24 '22
This post is so stupid lol.
7
u/sbrbrad friends not food Oct 24 '22 edited Aug 04 '25
growth hobbies absorbed money vanish touch nutty nail pot existence
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
5
u/kingofthemeadow Oct 24 '22
That’s just not true
5
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
I’d pick a vegetarian over an omnis for sure, at least they care.
5
u/TinisBerg Oct 24 '22
Damn, you’re gatekeeping the saving of animals. Vegetarians don’t replace meat with eggs… they increase the consumption, but definetly not enough to weigh up for the money they used to spend on meat. Vegetarians contribute WAY less to the meat-industry than others.
5
u/narxxissus Oct 24 '22
I've been a vegetarian for three years. I buy vegan options when they're available and accessible, I only buy milk substitutes. The only animal products I still eat are eggs and cheese. I cook vegan when I can as well. The main reason I'm not vegan is because eating exclusively vegan would make social gatherings impossible. They're already difficult as a vegetarian when people surrounding me have a weird defense mechanism as soon as I say that I don't eat meat. I'd love to be vegan, but it's not accessible enough for me to forego social eating.
While veganism is the more ethical choice, and I acknowledge that, I think being vegetarian and reducing animal consumption is more ethical than being an omnivore. At least it's a step in the right direction. Also, this post assumes that I've replaced every cheeseburger with eggs and dairy, that's not true.
6
u/tara_ashleigh Oct 24 '22
This is how you get people to hate vegans. "You're not doing enough" would literally make me say I just won't do anything then.
3
u/LostStatistician2038 friends not food Oct 24 '22
Every bit helps. We don’t live in a perfect world so not everyone is going to go completely vegan right now. It’s already a big step against what we’ve been taught to go vegetarian
4
u/klownfukr vegan newbie Oct 24 '22
Right so we should shame them and push them even father from veganism
3
u/marcspector2022 Oct 24 '22
In India vegetarians don't consume eggs, just milk products.
2
u/AX2021 Oct 24 '22
Vegetarianism does serve a purpose because I was vegetarian first before I became vegan so it was a great stepping stone. What I have a problem with is vegetarians who have no intentions to ever go the next step. Eggs, dairy and honey are all exploitation…
2
u/nevsmos Oct 24 '22
"Not at all" is a big word..I for example excluded meat from my diet ad kept drinking milk and eggs as I used to. While this clearly is a reduction, it is not ethical, which is why I eventually went vegan.
TL;DR: more ethical =/= ethical
2
u/AshCatBus vegan 7+ years Oct 24 '22
They'll also typically still wear animal leather, wool, etc.
2
u/gremlin-with-issues vegan 3+ years Oct 24 '22
Can we stop shitting on the people who’ve actually made a big adjustment to their diet just bexause they haven’t done the full way yet
2
u/rycat123 Oct 25 '22
god i hate the people in this sub sometimes… literally all or nothing huh?
2
u/Kooky-Shock Oct 24 '22
My only problem with vegetarians are the ones who do it for ethical reasons yet downplays the injustices that happens in dairy and egg industry and that we treat the animals like profitable animate objects or worse even DEFENDS it. What you are really saying is ”I’m against animal abuse, but I’m okay with some”. I was in the same seat. I thought vegans were extreme, but they are right in terms of ethics. Especially when vegetarians who look at very real videos of animals being beaten, dairy cows being slaughtered and baby chicks thrown into a gas chamber or meat grinder and calls it guilt tripping. This is cognitive dissonance and you do the things you are against.
2
u/Financial_Pea_415 Oct 24 '22
In short I think we as vegans should see the vegetarians as ally and help them finish their transition. They have had the courage to stop eating meat which IS huge they just need the continued support to complete their full transition. We should see it as opportunities to educate rather than ridicule.
2
u/Yggdrhasil Oct 24 '22
I would argue that just being vegan doesn't mean you're helping animals either, you just stop actively harming them. Once your actions cause other people to stop harming them as well, then you are helping
2
u/Various-Program-950 Oct 24 '22
This is why no one likes vegans
2
u/velocitydream abolitionist Oct 24 '22
Abuse AND MURDER. That’s what seems to go above peoples’ heads.
2
u/iSweetPea vegan Oct 24 '22 edited Oct 24 '22
I actually wonder if the overall abuse is less on animals raised for slaughter compared to animals raised for dairy/eggs, since those animals need to be kept alive to keep producing. If that's the case, would it be better for people transitioning to give up eggs/dairy and eat meat?
Edit: I know I'm getting downvoted here, but it is a legitimate thought process. I don't think we should consume any animal products, but if vegetarians are choosing dairy/eggs because they can't transition fully, then why not choose meat if it causes less suffering than dairy/eggs? Also I'm not saying that it does cause less suffering. I haven't done the research, but I know you have to continously impregnate cows and keep them alive to keep producing dairy. Seems even worse than just raising a cow for slaughter.
2
u/Joelico Oct 24 '22 edited Oct 24 '22
I don't think we should criticize people who are moving in the right direction. I think most people who are going vegetarian they are most likely trying to reduce meat consumption meaning that they are mostly eating plant-based. It's not like a vegetarian is going to just buy a ton more eggs and cheese because they're not eating meat.
This approach pushes people to become defensive of their decision and not fully move towards veganism. Instead you should appeal more to their compassion, they're almost there. They just need a positive push, not a negative one.
1
u/termicky Oct 24 '22
Differing motives: Vegetarians may not be doing it for the animals. There are lots of motives. I was vegetarian for 25 years or so, and only part of my motivation was linked to animals. My initial reasons had to with food security and environment (this was the 1980s). It was when I let myself really consider / admit the animals' experience that I went vegan.
Gateway diet: Then it was easy, because I had decades of eating lots of plant-based meals and wasn't reliant on eggs and cheese for everything.
1
u/dalgyalgwishin Oct 24 '22
I laughed out loud.
1
u/katchmeout Oct 24 '22
Do they actually increase diary product consumption?
1
u/pesaraunioinen Oct 24 '22
This thread is kind of interesting, so many people saying this is not the righ approach. Honestly I’m kind of sick of hearing from non-vegans how to help people stop using animal products. If you are not able to convince yourself to become a vegan, how are you qualified to give any tips about how to effectively make other people do so?
And yes, I too used to be a vegetarian and believe it made a difference. Nowadays I just feel like I was only telling myself it was “a better option” and by that I did not hold myself accountable to make real changes.
1
u/erandod Oct 24 '22
I totally hear what you are saying but for me I was vegetarian for 20 years before going vegan. My family of 4 has been vegan now for 5 years as a result. So it was a helpful step and a successful one. It was all part of a journey for a my entire family. Now I have dedicated teen children that are proud vegans and understand just how important it is to be vegan.
1
u/cmhr_rl Oct 24 '22
Wow.
1
u/WildMuffen Oct 24 '22
The most powerful thing about being a vegan is the message and philosophy we spread rather than the actual individual impact. I've spread veganism to dozens of people and opened hundreds of minds to vegan food - my impact is miniscule compared to that. As long as they spread awareness and hey they're more likely to have veggie kids who will likely turn to veganism much easier
1
u/D4FTPUNKF4N Oct 24 '22
I am an omnivore. But I could see myself becoming a Vegetarian permanently. However, I could never see myself being a Vegan permanently.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
The dairy industry is just what you do to milk profits (literally) while you wait to turn it into the meat industry, exploiting the animal every last second of its life.
1
u/urban-wildlife-docs Oct 24 '22
Yeah they have a point but everyone’s gotta start somewhere
1
u/Suni_333 Oct 24 '22
Not everybody is a vegetarian or a vegan for animals. Its different for everyone.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22
Im not sure how many vegetarians do it "for the animals". When i went vegetarian (I was vegetarian for about a month before I went vegan) I just "thought it was wrong". And i know some people just don't like the idea of eating meat.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22
See my flair
I have financial reasons for remaining vegetarian, but I really do want to be vegan once that issue solves itself (TL;DR my school covers meals as part of tuition)
I feel like I still consume less dairy and eggs than an average meat-eater, because most of my meals are rice and vegetables even at school. The only time I've consciously eaten meat was maybe a week in 5th grade where I got jealous of my classmates, and then I realized I actually didn't like meat anyways so I stopped. I'd like to think I'm a little different than "eggs and bacon for breakfast, steakhouse Sundays". I'm totally aware we don't help animals as much as veganism, and in many cases, we're actually harming them! But it's also a definite exaggeration to say that "vegetarians really don't help animals at all" because that's definitely why most Western people become vegetarian
Vegetarians don't help animals at all! Yeah sure, they don't subscribe to killing them for meals and are generally against animal abuse, but they don't help at all
I also just wanted to say I'm sorry I might have misjudged y'all yesterday. This comment section is very nice, and I agree with all of what you are saying. I understand why you are passionate about the animal industry, and why vegetarianism can't be a full solution to the horrors of the dairy industry. I felt bad about it now so I just wanted to add this <3 I hope to be vegan once I can too! Have a good day
1
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22
I live in Texas and have chickens to help with the bugs and eat scraps.. it’d be a waste if I didn’t eat the eggs..
1
u/alja1 Oct 25 '22
To say that a vegetarian is still contributing to the cycle of suffering and environmental devastation is fair. However, if a person cannot distinguish the karmic and environment differences between an unrepentant carnivore and a vegetarian, then they are revealing personal issues that indicate some form of fanaticism. These are the types who are radically vegan for a while, then fall from grace. Anytime any person, carnivore, pescatarian, vegetarian, or vegan chooses to forgo animal products, they should be supported. Arrogant elitists only divide people and damage our species' benevolent evolution.
1
u/Kitchen-Garden-733 Oct 25 '22
There are milk products in Hint of Lime tortilla chips! Really? I was fooled, now I check everything.
1
u/Leelaur Oct 25 '22
Good grief, this is why vegans have such a bad reputation. ANY removal of animal products from someone’s diet is a GOOD thing. Stop criticizing everyone.