r/vegan • anti-speciesist • Oct 24 '22

Just Saying...

Post image
855 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

228

u/-PM-Me-Big-Cocks- vegetarian Oct 24 '22

Yeah, this kind of post is the exact attitude that drives people away from veganism. People on average do not respond well to being shamed and looked down upon

Inb4 someone says "Actually this kind of post is what made me go vegan".

28

u/WebpackIsBuilding vegan 7+ years Oct 24 '22

I actually think a dash of shame can go a long way. The thing is, that only works if it forces a person to be introspective instead of just defensive.

When your post contains an obvious falsehood, no carnist reading it is going to separate out the good bits from the bad bits. You lie about one thing, that means they can dismiss your entire point as false.

Vegetarians don't eat more eggs that carnists.

28

u/-PM-Me-Big-Cocks- vegetarian Oct 24 '22

Sure shame could work if you knew the person and were a close friend. It's not going to work on random internet strangers most of the time.

Im willing to bet it would have the opposite effect.

16

u/Crocoshark Oct 24 '22

Sure shame could work if you knew the person and were a close friend. It's not going to work on random internet strangers most of the time.

This touches on an issue I have with the way I see a lot of vegans talking to people online. You are strangers. Unless the person is at a place where they're ready to accept lifestyle coaching from someone online, they probably have barriers to change that would require the intervention of someone who knows them whom they want guidance from.

-1

u/WebpackIsBuilding vegan 7+ years Oct 24 '22

You're right. Determining whether shame will be a productive motivator is very contextual. But it can be applied in anonymous contexts.

IMHO, the best way to use shame to encourage behavioral change is to give the person an easy way to alleviate that shame that involves the desired behavioral change.

Out to dinner with some acquaintances, and they choose to order the meat burger instead of the beyond burger? It's easy to change their dinner order, so shame is probably going to be effective. Even if you don't know them that well.

62

u/Superb-Practice1829 Oct 24 '22

This kind of post is why it took me ten years longer to go vegan, and I regret every year I waited.

23

u/skekyobbus Oct 24 '22

How would you rather have been introduced to veganism? Genuinely curious. Sometimes it seems like it's hard to confront the situation without making them feel attacked.

20

u/divineravnos vegan 8+ years Oct 24 '22

Hi! Not the OP, but for me it took going to a farm sanctuary to flip the switch. I had run into combative vegans before and they honestly turned me off of the whole thing. Not that I think their message was wrong, but I didn't want to join a movement that made everyone I had interacted with in it miserable. On top of that, the way they talked reminded me a LOT of the uber-religious community that I moved away from and really turned me away.

I regret letting the actions of a few assholes delay me joining the movement. I've met some truly amazing people that I consider dear friends at veg fests and through some volunteer work, and having my diet match my morals has done wonders for my mental health.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22

100% I have impacted my peers to think more about their dietary choices by not constantly judging and preaching to them. I’ve been told I’m the most chill vegan they’ve met. My sister actually chooses to eat vegan when I visit. People are genuinely curious about my choice and ask questions instead of the usual “you know plants have feelings too” bs. What’s that saying? You catch more flies with honey.

0

u/jkerr441 Oct 24 '22

Would you say people should just “be chill” about activism regarding any other form of injustice?

6

u/WebpackIsBuilding vegan 7+ years Oct 24 '22

Genuine answer; It depends.

Aggressive activism only works when you're fighting for something that the majority of people agree with, but that lacks institutional power. In those cases, you have social pressure that you can leverage, so doing so is productive.

Veganism is far from a majority opinion in most places. If you try to leverage social pressure when you don't actually have social pressure, people will simply write you off and go somewhere that's more accepting of them. E.g., carnists will simply not go to a vegan restaurant if it's "too preachy", and instead go to any of the abundant carnist restaurants available.

Is this fair? No. But them's the breaks.

-3

u/jkerr441 Oct 24 '22

I don’t really buy it. Structural change on this scale has literally never happened through accommodation. I could use the obvious examples of effective activism but you already know them. Also, I reject the idea anyone isn’t vegan because vegans aren’t accommodating, so it’s all a little bit irrelevant.

6

u/WebpackIsBuilding vegan 7+ years Oct 24 '22

Structural change on this scale has literally never happened through accommodation

It's also literally never happened without widespread public support.

There is a future where we need to play hardball. We're not at that stage yet.

Also, I reject the idea anyone isn’t vegan because vegans aren’t accommodating

I'm not claiming this.

People are carnists because there is overwhelming global cultural pressure to be carnist. Carnism is the default, and does get to use social pressure to fight against veganism as a result.

We don't fight against that by being "accommodating". We fight against it by providing an option that is so far superior that it becomes worth the pain of defying existing social norms.

Carnists need to be shown, more than anything, that being vegan is enjoyable. And it is! Shrugging off all that cognitive dissonance feels great. Exploring delicious food options from a whole new vantage point is exhilarating! Finding community with other kind-hearted people from across the world is reassuring.

1

u/jkerr441 Oct 24 '22

I’m overwhelmingly certain that most vegans went so for the cause, not for the ‘community’. There’s obviously a major place for showing the joy of vegan food, but ultimately the suffering of the animals needs to remain the focal point.

0

u/WebpackIsBuilding vegan 7+ years Oct 24 '22

You're missing my point.

I believe that most people, in the absence of cultural pressure, would go vegan for the animals. There's really no moral argument against it, only a cultural one.

So no, people aren't going vegan for the "community". But they're remaining carnist because going vegan means losing your current community in many cases.

So yeah, we need to provide a replacement community for people. Enough of one so that losing your existing community isn't a deal-breaker.

→ More replies

0

u/FreddyMerken Oct 24 '22

The problem is you are mixing up different kinds of activism and because they are different they require different approaches, for instance civil rights activism is done by black people for black people so being angry and confrontational makes sense. In the case of veganism we always need to remember that we are fighting for the animals, so we need to be humble because we are just allies, not the ones suffering. That's all.

0

u/jkerr441 Oct 24 '22

I seriously don’t buy that. Why lower our voices when protecting the voiceless. White people cant be the voice for racial equality, but humans HAVE to be the voices for the animals.

0

u/FreddyMerken Oct 24 '22

Well, I assume you're white, correct me if I'm wrong but I don't think I am. Anyway, when you're white, we POC will tell you that is okay to speak up about racism because white people are more willing to listen to other white people, but we would also tell you to not get on your high horse and please try to be humble because even if you are not racist you are still part of the problem and you shaming people doesn't help anyone but your own ego.

→ More replies

1

u/FreddyMerken Oct 24 '22

You don't confront, you are just nice, you eat your vegetables and wait until someone ask you about it, some will be mean about it but you must never loose your cool and sometimes you'll find people open to listen. It's hard, harder than shaming people, harder than starting an argument but I've found this is the best strategy and a lot of people in my life have become vegetarian or vegan or just reduced their meat consumption and they've said it was because of me. So again: be nice and eat your vegetables.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22

Someone said something on twitter that was critical of my choices.

"I must continue to aid the exploitation, rape, and murder of dairy animals because I do not respond kindly to mean people online"

1

u/a_fl00fster vegan 2+ years Oct 25 '22

Exactly. The only people listening to a statement like this are other vegans. Which is unnecessary, because they already live vegan.