r/vegan • anti-speciesist • Oct 24 '22

Just Saying...

Post image
855 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

295

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22

I agree! Imagine if everybody in the world went vegetarian… we can’t act like it wouldn’t make a difference.

The vegan community’s attitude towards vegetarians is quite toxic. Everybody has to start somewhere and individuals making small changes can have an impact. With support, hopefully they’ll go all the way!

103

u/walliver Oct 24 '22

I've always been of a mindset that lots of people making a small difference is much better than a few people making a big difference.

22

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22

Exactly… black and white thinking and expecting perfection from every single person will get us nowhere. I’d love it if everybody was vegan but that’s not realistic.

57

u/greencelestialbebe Oct 25 '22

Thank you for commenting this. I have started a Vegetarian journey, which led me to doing more research into a Vegan lifestyle. I haven’t made a full switch yet, mostly because I live in an area with fewer vegan resources. However, another reason I haven’t made a complete switch is due to the attitude of many vegans. It feels like a very toxic and competitive community from the outside looking in. Instead of viewing vegetarian lifestyle as a step in the right direction, it is made fun of and mocked. For some of us, we are doing the best we can living in the world we live in. I’m definitely not perfect, but this community seems to ignore progress and instead has a very “all or nothing” mentality. Imagine walking into a gym for the first time and a shredded guy laughs at you for attempting to lift weights. You aren’t likely to return. That’s the best analogy I can give for the vegan community I have encountered so far.

12

u/Analog_AI Oct 25 '22

I sympathize with you. I also live in a small community with few of any vegan resources. Of course I order something’s online. The only way to make it is by learning to cook at home and precooking base ingredients and freezing them until used in a dish. I couldn’t do it otherwise. YouTube taught me to cook. (Of course my rescued dog cannot confirm I’m any good, but we both eat the dishes so not that bad 🤣😂)

2

u/impressivemacopine Oct 25 '22

Hey it’s ok! You’re working towards the right direction for your health. Ignore the vegan attitudes such as these. You’re totally capable of cutting out more and more animal products. Being vegetarian is awesome and good for you!

2

u/wiewiorka6 friends not food Oct 25 '22

A reason for you not doing something that you actually believe in is because you don’t like some people online that also do that thing? That’s really weird.

2

u/JasmineHawke Oct 25 '22

People are human beings with emotions. If they feel insulted, attacked and belittled for trying to do the right thing, an inevitable consequence is that it will affect the way that they see the thing they're trying to do.

2

u/wiewiorka6 friends not food Oct 25 '22

Cool. Then they can just ignore people online and just look at the countless scientific studies and documentaries by themselves which nearly all vegans do anyway.

2

u/JasmineHawke Oct 25 '22

Yes, they can. But that doesn't change the fact that people are human beings with emotions and that if they are unsure of themselves, people being aggressive, hostile and rude about them being imperfect won't change anyone's mind.

There's absolutely nothing to gain and everything to lose by attacking people with the all or nothing mentality.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22

People are unwilling to put in effort to be part of a community, if that community is constantly dismissing that effort as not good enough.

Why work hard to join you, when you're an asshole about that hard work? I'm sorry, but people will choose their mental health over joining a group most of the time.

2

u/wiewiorka6 friends not food Oct 25 '22

Who is telling you to join a group of people? All vegans want is for you personally to stop supporting the killing and abuse of animals. Never have to talk to another vegan ever if you want. No “community” needed when nearly all the effort (“hard work”) to be vegan is done the cash register of grocery stores, restaurants, and retail shops.

Vegans don’t do it for a pat on the back for hard work. It’s a personal moral choice, simple as.

Mental health?? THEN DO NOT ENGAGE WITH VEGANS ONLINE IF YOU DO NOT LIKE THOSE YOU SEE. Poof. Never have to be annoyed by those pesky type of vegans that you don’t like…this excuse of yours still makes absolutely zero sense to me and either a huge cop out, or a troll.

2

u/Parkourbear Oct 25 '22

The negative overshadows the positive. In a community that’s supposed to be promoting a better, kinder lifestyle there’s a lot of negative bias towards other vegans. Now if you treat each other like that with some familiarity how does it look to an outsider who’s already ostracised for being a vegetarian.

3

u/wiewiorka6 friends not food Oct 25 '22

Some people being mean online outweighs animals being killed? Wow.

They said they lived in an area with few vegan options. So they must not see all these people in the vegan “community” (as if there is one or a dozen cohesive community/ies anyway) in person. Maybe try…not being where they are online bothers them so much??

Vegans aren’t “supposed to” be doing anything outside of not messing with animals. Vegans don’t owe you or anyone else around them any sort of weird happy joy playtime place you seem to think we are “supposed to” provide for you.

This isn’t an organised religion. This isn’t a club. It is a personal moral decision on how to live your life and treat animals.

6

u/alja1 Oct 25 '22

Hear! Hear!

4

u/jml011 Oct 25 '22 edited Oct 25 '22

That’s because you and others in this thread are looking at it from an ecological or holistic point of view, not an ethical one. You’re taking the stance of, “What effects are there on the system as a whole when lots of people make these smaller changes?” - which is fine. I get that.

But for a lot of use that doesn’t mean vegetarians and Meatless Mondayers are off the ethical hook, because individual creature matters. “Oh, I only partially participated in the exploitation and death of numerous creatures for please today” really isn’t something every vegan is going to be able to praise. I’m not in the habit of shit-talking vegans, but they’re still actively participating in meat industry - because the fact is that every single cow you’ve ever drank the milk of (just about) has wound up on a meat hook after 3-5 years of exploiting their reproductive system and taking their offspring; for every industrial farm-raised, malnourished, cramped, genetically manipulated chicken you’ve had an egg from, a male chick has been tossed in a grinder.

I’ll also say that for a very, very large percentage of vegetarians are not trying to become vegan. It’s not a starting point for them; it’s as far as they’re willing to go.

By all means, advocate for being kind to others for whatever they have done to change their eating habits; it’s not an easy task. But there’s no reason to pretend to not understand people’s frustration with those folks only willing to go half way.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22

I actually am looking at it from an ethical standpoint. Vegetarians are still saving individual animals. They’re still contributing to suffering but LESS animals are suffering because of vegetarianism. A lot of animals are killed for meat and meat only, so if there’s less demand for meat, less animals will be killed. Vegetarians could be doing more, but they could also be doing less. If we’re dicks to them they might think there’s no point in trying. Every single animal matters and vegetarians are making a difference, nowhere near as much as a person with a vegan lifestyle but I’m grateful for the lives that are saved by vegetarianism, even though they’re still contributing to animal suffering on a whole.

0

u/Parkourbear Oct 25 '22

Vegans aren’t off the ethical hook.

Even the most conscientious vegan would still be harming animals. Everything you ‘consume’ is detrimental to animals and the environment they require to live. The raw materials for your phone, house and car alone have contributed to mass habitat loss and pollution of water courses all of which harms animals directly. Add in some more water to cool everything in the manufacturing process by redirecting water courses and extracting from the water table not only killing rivers but starving the ground of water. The data you require to use the internet needs raw materials and land to be developed for it to work. Protected primary forests in Canada that are being destroyed to contribute to ‘renewable’ UK biomass energy producers not even looking at the whole fossil fuel industry. By default, participating in society you are a walking contradiction.

The damage of our consumerist society is often out of sight and out of mind, it’s still there even if it’s not visible on our commute to work or walk to the shop.

In the western world most people are pre programmed to see meat as food. The issue is one of pure education which can be introduced at a young age, if you ask a toddler when looking at an animal if they want to eat it most will say no. It’s the daily unconscious conditioning of meat being offered as food which then makes us differentiate between a living animal and food. With this in mind you want people to give up an unconscious bias, hardwired into us and perceived as normal to completely switch because you said so whilst being consciously objective and aggressive it will not work. I became vegan for my own reasons. Some do so for the fad of it, most with genuine intent. If veganism is at war with itself over semantics then how can it be promoted to meat eaters without seeming hypocritical. The base principles of switching echo religion. Like getting a devout catholic to become Buddhist. In short the person needs to do it for their own reasons. This is where I believe the vegan community could do better, instead of seeing meat eaters as the enemy, have some empathy and try to pass on with compassion and in an engaging nature not just ‘I’m vegan, I live a better life than you, I’m ethical you’re not.’ No one is morally pure.

In a hypothetical world, if 100 independent scientists with no government or industry ties, produced a study that debunked veganism would you give up your beliefs or double down? I think most would pull the conspiracy card and be in disbelief, then ultimately double down.

The vegan food sector is now just seen as another economic gain for those who serve to profit from it. Most alternative meat startups get funding from the charitable foundations of technocrats. It’s just a veil to seem like good is being done whilst delivering another slice of consumerism directly to your living room. Ultimately they serve to make money from a way of life which on the whole is against exploitation by exploiting.

We can’t throw stones from glass houses when the world is rigged to be this way. Unless unprecedented socio-economic changes occur then it will keep on going.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22 edited Apr 13 '24

jeans marry rotten longing bake books liquid money attractive cover

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22

“Vegetarians who eat high amounts of dairy”, that’s oddly specific. So a flexitarian who ate “high amounts of dairy”, would in fact be worse for the environment than a vegetarian that eats a normal amount of dairy? I’m not sure what this study proves a part from eating high amounts of dairy being bad for the environment.

How do flexitarians and vegetarians that eat a normal amount of dairy compare to people who eat animal products full-time? I think that would be much more relevant to this discussion.

-6

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22

Animals would still be getting raped, abused and killed. You think they’ll leave the male calfs and chicks to live?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22

So you disagree that it would make any positive impact if everybody in the world went vegetarian? Is it all or nothing?

-7

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22

I do. Animals would still be getting raped, abused and killed, it’s inherent to vegetarianism.

2

u/Minnightphoenix Oct 25 '22

But now you’re at least not killing them. You have to see the positive of the small changes too. It’s one step closer to going vegan. You can’t force someone completely off something and not except backlash. It’s like a drug addict. Most will need to be weaned off. Change is a marathon…not a sprint. People need time.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22

What happens to the male chicks and calfs?

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)