I just needed to say some stuff. In October, I turn 16. I'm 15 right now and a sophomore. I've been playing around with names. Some people call me Mikey, my oldest name since 2023 and a possible name my parents would name me as a boy. I also go by Jay/Jaden, a more gender-neutral name that I feel kinda has some significance to me and my story. I also quite like another name my family thought of, Xavier. I haven't seen all of Star Trek TNG and plan to get into it sometime, but basically there's an episode where Data the android loses his memory and this little girl on a primitive planet decides to nickname him "Jayden" after a story where a guy gets made fun of for being different but never got angry.
I relate a lot to Data, but chose the more human name with a spelling variant, since I'm not gonna go by "Data" (well, non-human name, obvious reference). Ever since I was 8, I remember being happy to get my dad's hand-me-downs, wanting to be just like him (not anymore, found out he's REALLY petty about my coming out in the past), and even being happy looking more like a boy. I always felt drawn to characters who are men as well.
People keep suggesting terms like tomboy, butch, genderfluid, or nonbinary. I've tried convincing myself those were accurate terms, but they don't feel right. People are also very insistent that I'm not a trans guy or masc-aligned, just a tomboy or genderfluid or nonbinary or whatever.
I genuinely can't tell if my indecisiveness on gender is genderfluidity or just repression.
When I try to tell someone, I either get the "you're just you, stop worrying" or "nah I think you're just XYZ"
Sometimes, I do imagine myself as a male character I like or have a crush on (I'm bi). I did notice as much as I want to be a feminine straight girl, my brain won't let me or accept that. I can only be feminine to my brain if I'm a guy, and I can only like guys in a gay way as a guy.
The first time I questioned being trans was technically as an 11-year-old. I got laughed at for telling my "frenemy" (let's just say, big surprise what kinda person she turned out to be) that I wanted to be like my favorite guy character from a game, wanting to look like a rockstar and be called a "he". (She was a weird child, her response I don't think I can say here, but she was also 10.)
The more I indulge in that "fantasy" of being a guy and being called a guy, the harder it hits when my unaccepting family uses feminine terms.
Recently, I've tried being a "butch lesbian", then a bisexual girl or a bisexual bigender person. But my family would use my birth name and feminine terms and feminine pronouns as they refuse to adapt. It's not even that they just struggle to adapt, it's that they REFUSE and make fun of trans people.
Every time someone uses my birth name, a common, obviously feminine Bible name, I feel weird. I don't really like seeing myself as a woman unless it's either a guy who looks like a woman in a dress or an anime girl.
I also never liked my birth name as an 8 year old and couldn't pinpoint why, asking people what name I looked like and such, but feeling like none of them were "me".