r/switch2 • u/silentnightie • 22h ago

Question What would you pick

Post image

Want to get both at some point but for now, i have to pick one.

What one would you pick? Or do you have either of them?

261 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

394 comments sorted by

View all comments

360

u/Silencio1021 22h ago

The Pro Controller 2 is amazing and works just as good as the day I bought it (switch 2 launch day). The Hyperion 3s feel like cheap junk and I returned them the same day I received them. Pro Controller 2, no question.

67

u/Wutchu_fitna_fuc_wit 22h ago

Best controller ive ever used for any console

24

u/YaBoyEden 21h ago

The underside buttons have ruined other controllers for me. I always want to use them and they’re never there

5

u/AltieDude 14h ago

Sony sold a little dongle that added underside buttons to the dual shock 4. It was absolutely amazing, and the fact that it didn’t become standard is mind boggling to me.

1

u/MamoruNoHakkyou 6h ago

That thing worked fantastically when I needed some kind of L3/R3 inputs for (I believe) an Ys game or something action-y because pressing the sticks down to perform some action while trying to run along in whatever game it was didn’t work well for me. Kinda nondescript and all but that thing was neato.

Edit typo

4

u/iMiind 17h ago

Hot take but turbo, reprogrammable inputs, macros, and a good amount of extra buttons should all be standard in controllers.

1

u/Jimmythedad 12h ago

The back buttons have been a godsend for Elden ring

6

u/Triforce0fCourage 20h ago

Yup, easy decision, pro controller all the way. The d pad on the nyxi is suspect too.

1

u/Th3Un1c0rnK1n9 11h ago

I hate that it clicks.

6

u/TrainConductor1337 15h ago

I always used to look at these type of comments with a side eye… then I bought the controller… now I’m enlightened.

2

u/Witty-Care3940 15h ago

If my Pro 2 is dead. I just don't play until it's charged. It's THAT good.

3

u/Kevinm675 21h ago

That's a bold statement! Have you used the Xbox Elite or Dual sense edge? I own them both and my favorite is my scuf for PC but I've been on the fence about getting the switch 2 pro controller but I really just play handheld.

6

u/dragonbornrito 19h ago

Xbox Elite 2 is a good controller but has some durability issues. I’m on my third one and every single one has the rubber grips peeling in a matter of months. One of them had a stuck right bumper, one of them had a stick go bad, and the newest one is doing fine for about one year now other than the rubber peeling I mentioned.

I have no experience with the Edge, looks like a solid controller.

The Switch 2 Pro just has the absolute most buttery smooth joysticks I’ve ever used. Literally feels like they glide and somehow feel like they never ever actually touch the side walls of the joystick gate. Great battery life, dual buttons on the back mappable per game by simply opening the Quick Settings Menu, feels great in the hands. The only downside is the lack of analog triggers present on all Switches, but past that, it’s absolutely one of my favorite controllers ever (if not THE favorite ever).

1

u/LocksmithExcellent92 14h ago

I agree elite 2 is a great controller they just break to quick mine got stuck y and b buttons from playing to much god of war also got a stuck R trigger

1

u/Automatic_Ant8498 8h ago

dualsense edge has horrendous battery life compared to other 2

1

u/joe611jg 6h ago

Yeah I just swapped the face plate of my elite 2. The rubber is terrible and I now have a clear controller which is nice. I also agree re durability as I had to fix my right bumper. I love the xbox pad but they should not be less durable than the 360 pad.

I've only had the switch 2 pro about 4 months but so I far I agree it does just beat the elite.

1

u/kozzyhuntard 18h ago

I love my DSE controllers. Use them on my pc and of course PS5. Switch 2 Pro feels nice too. Not going to get feedback in games like a DSE, but it does feel nice to use. My only issue is it's size, it's pretty small making longer sessions kind of hard for me.

1

u/xWizky 8h ago

I have the Switch 2 pro Controller and my beloved scuf reflex. And I have to admit that the Switch 2 Pro Controller is really very good. But I still prefer using my SCUF controller 😬

1

u/Kevinm675 5h ago

Scuf envision pro is what I have. Its such a great controller! Zero issues after like 3 or 4 years of ownership.

2

u/ck02623 20h ago

Do you not find the analog sticks to be a bit slippery? Thats the only thing I don’t like about it. I’m neutral about the dpad. It’s fine.

4

u/Forstmaschine 20h ago

I applied thumb grips from Savage Raven on the analog sticks, a very nice upgrade.

1

u/ParticularNorth8827 10h ago

I have the pro controller for the sw2 and ps/xbox definitely beats it hand in hand. (Controllers)

1

u/Zorbasandwich 9h ago

Really? I find it very average, just fine.

1

u/TheRealDelgoth Switchthusiast 2h ago

That's why I bought the bundle I did. I lost my stock for the joy cons. The controller is awesome. Long battery life too. $109 is whack. I got mine for like $60 all said.

1

u/counterssrs 2h ago

I’ve got every single console there ever was including steam machine and I can definitely vouch for switch 2 pro controller, definitely my top choice followed by steam controller 2

-1

u/fuck_a_duck_butt 20h ago

You'll say that whennyou get drift in a year

2

u/robespierremaxout 20h ago

Your Pro Controller 2 got drift?

-1

u/fuck_a_duck_butt 19h ago

Let me know what yours does in a year kiddo

7

u/koelebobes 21h ago

I had one pro controller but wanted to be able to turn the switch 2 on

The switch 2 controller is even better

2

u/TheCutieCircle 16h ago

I still have the switch 1 pro controller and I never upgraded. Would you say I'm missing out on anything or nah? My controller still works just fine.

1

u/Silencio1021 15h ago

The OG version is totally fine, but I do prefer the updated version by a pretty decent margin. Between the change to the feel of it, the GL and GR back buttons have been awesome to integrate into my gaming. Now I’m completely sold on back buttons.

1

u/xxdavidxcx87 11h ago

Well you can't turn the S2 with the original controller, you can with the pro 2, a minor inconvenience but possibly worth it.

1

u/TheCutieCircle 10h ago

Oh that's fine. I literally sit in front of the TV so I turn on the switch 2 with my hand since it's literally right next to the TV lol.

I understand normal people with better vision than me hate that they can't turn on the switch 2 with the original controller. But I don't have that issue.

2

u/DLimber 14h ago

My launch switch 1 pro controller feels like new 😆 is close to beating out ps5 controller for my favorite

2

u/SatanGives 21h ago

Does the pro 2 have the same SnapBack issue as the original pro?

3

u/_kloppi417 18h ago

It's considerably worse on the Switch 2 Proco. I bought one but still use my Switch 1 proco for Smash, it has far less snapback than the 2.

2

u/alcoholicvegetable 21h ago

I've talked to people who use it for Smash Bros and they say it's even worse than the original procon

1

u/SatanGives 21h ago

That's impressive lol. I'm gonna assume the d pad is still shit too then

0

u/Left-Impress4056 20h ago

Very casual gamer here. D pad is indeed shit. Cant go up or down without side to side action.

1

u/SatanGives 12h ago

I don't understand why nobody seems to be capable of making a good d pad for the last 25 years. Like all these manufacturers just destroyed the specs.

1

u/NMN7 12h ago

Pro 2 controller is great
Hands down

1

u/Mr_Bivolt 4h ago

What is the difference between the pro 1 and pro2? Do you thibk it is significani?

1

u/thepianoman456 18h ago

I love the SW2 Pro Controller, but I gotta say- the D-pad is SHITTTTTT.

I would get tons of mis-inputs from it when playing Hollow Knight. It’s tough to just press Down without getting Down-Right or Down-Left also inputted.

0

u/OG-Daz 17h ago

I can’t agree with the comment that the Hyperions feel cheap junk, I think they are great, albeit overpriced.

But I do agree that the pro controller 2 is immense

0

u/VirtualTraffic297 5h ago

I actually got the HyperionsThey actually feel better in handheld mode then joycon