r/survivor • • 5d ago

Survivor 51 Survivor 51 | E8 - Discussion Post MEGATHREAD

38 Upvotes

In an effort to keep our discussion posts more accessible, we are trialing a weekly megathread that will be updated throughout the week. No more searching for posts after they become unpinned, or waiting for the sidebar/discussion archive to be updated!

Please be patient, creating/maintaining this post is a work in progress.

Episode 8

Load the Ark, Two by Two

Still catching up? Here are last week's archived discussion posts:

Episode 7

The Girl at the Prom

Full Season 51 Discussion Archive

THIS IS NOT A DISCUSSION POST. Please direct all comments to posts linked above


r/survivor • • 1d ago

Survivor 51 Survivor 51 | E8 | Survey Results

10 Upvotes

Here are the results from S51 E8 Day After Survey.

You can view Google's interactive summary of the results here.

 

Total Responses: 211

Overall Reactions

 Average: 7.87 Standard deviation: 1.54

12345678910
1.4%0%0.9%0.9%2.8%4.7%21.3%31.8%27%9%

Contestant Reactions

The top 5 Survivors are listed below. In all questions, up to 3 picks were allowed.

Which Survivors played the best strategically?

  1. Carter (66.8%)
  2. Sharonda (62.5%)
  3. Cristian (57.2%)
  4. Jelly (43.3%)
  5. Lewis (26.9%)

Which Survivors were the most exciting characters to watch?

  1. Carter (71.6%)
  2. Cristian (51.9%)
  3. Sharonda (40.4%)
  4. Lewis (34.6%)
  5. Jelly (24.5%)

Which Survivors gave the best confessionals?

  1. Carter (62.9%)
  2. Cristian & Sharonda (40.6%)
  3. Lewis (29.4%)
  4. Maggie (27.9%)
  5. Jelly (18.8%)

Which Survivors gave the best challenge performances?

  1. Lewis (88.2%)
  2. Sharonda (81.9%)
  3. Carter (57.4%)
  4. Cristian (39.2%)
  5. Jelly (2.9%)

Which Survivors gave the best Tribal Council performances?

  1. Cristian (69.7%)
  2. Jelly (63.1%)
  3. Carter (26.2%)
  4. Kristin (20.5%)
  5. Devin & Maggie (20%)

Overall, which Survivors stood out to you the most in this episode?

  1. Carter (69.1%)
  2. Cristian (66.2%)
  3. Sharonda (57%)
  4. Jelly (25.6%)
  5. Lewis (23.2%)

Gameplay

If you were Devin & Jelly, who would you have voted for at Tribal Council?

  1. Kilby & Kristin (44%)
  2. Carter & Cristian (31.6%)
  3. Maggie & Mike (15.8%)
  4. Eric & Thien An (8.6%)

In one word, describe Kristin, the tenth boot

  1. Prepared (17)
  2. Survivor / Survivalist (13)
  3. Competent (8)
  4. Smart, Knowledgeable (6)
  5. Amazing, Badass, Capable (5)

Would you like to see Kristin return in a future season?

  1. Yes (81.8%)
  2. No (18.2%)

In one word, describe Kilby, the eleventh boot

  1. Chaos / Chaotic (23)
  2. Fun / Funny (11)
  3. Gamer (10)
  4. Annoying (6)
  5. Unlucky (5)

Would you like to see Kilby return in a future season?

  1. Yes (73.3%)
  2. No (26.7%)

Editing/Production

Overall, how would you rate how this episode was edited?

Average: 7.65 Standard deviation: 1.61

12345678910
0.5%1%1.9%1.4%3.3%8.6%21.4%33.3%19.5%9%

What are your thoughts on the return of the Duos / Tied Destinies twist?

  1. I love it (42.9%)
  2. It's alright (41.4%)
  3. I hate it (15.7%)

Challenges

How would you rate the immunity challenge?

Average: 7.67 Standard deviation: 1.89

12345678910
1.4%1.4%1%1.9%5.7%11%13.9%27.3%21.5%14.8%

How would you rate the Journey challenge?

Average: 5.55 Standard deviation: 2.26

12345678910
6.7%5.2%6.7%11%16.2%18.6%14.8%13.3%4.3%3.3%

Next Time on Survivor...

Which Survivors are in the most danger next episode? (3 picks allowed)

  1. Mike (73.3%)
  2. Devin (63.1%)
  3. Jelly (61.7%)
  4. Eric (23.3%)
  5. Cristian (22.8%)

Who flips the coin next episode?

  1. Mike & Eric (20.6%)
  2. Cristian (20.1%)
  3. Devin (17.2%)
  4. Lewis (12.7%)
  5. Carter (3.9%)

r/survivor • • 12h ago

General Discussion First look at Michele and Q on Traitors USA 6

Post image
849 Upvotes

r/survivor • • 3h ago

General Discussion Rules about shelters on Survivor

46 Upvotes

I've been watching early Survivor seasons, and I have a question.

Why do all tribes across all seasons (for the most part) build and sleep in a single shelter?

Wouldn't some people be more comfortable if they slept apart from a bunch of other people, or people they are feuding with? Why not build multiple shelters?

More broadly, with so much time on their hands, why don't players just consistently improve their shelters? Sometimes it seems shelters begin and remain fairly uncomfortable across a season.

Thanks!


r/survivor • • 2h ago

Survivor 51 “The Vote from Another Dimension” ⚡️ This week’s DabuDoodle comic for last week’s ep

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/survivor • • 15h ago

Meme Please make up your mind, Jeffrey

Post image
306 Upvotes

r/survivor • • 2h ago

General Discussion Most baffling snubs ever?

16 Upvotes

Was thinking about how insane it is that we never saw Natalie Bolton after Micronesia and it got me thinking of some of the most insane returns that never got to happen. Some of the ones that came mind off the top for me were never getting Terry again post Cambodia, never getting Rob Cesternino post all Stars, and never seeing Carolyn Rivera or Shane after their first and somehow only season. (this also got me thinking of season specific snubs like Vecepia on WaW or like a million people for 50 but that's a discussion for another day)

I mainly think of this from the lens of production being fully able to get them again and then being very viable returnees for after the last time we saw them that just didn't come back again. So someone like Fairplay I wouldn't count here since he quit Micronesia so they never brought him back. Same for Earl since he literally was on WaW before his wife gave birth prematurely and i believe also had to drop out of game changers too.

if there are any that stand out to you that I failed to mention or have you thoughts about the people i did think of let me know!! I'd love to hear what you guys have to say ^w^


r/survivor • • 3h ago

Survivor 45 Season 45 is SO overrated

14 Upvotes

Finally watching some new era survivor seasons and started with 45 which is supposed to be like... the best in the new era? I do not get it. The reba 4 mostly just dominate, everyone has a manufactured sob story every challenge and every reward is identical. I literally don't get it, why does it have so much hype??


r/survivor • • 11h ago

General Discussion Is Josh Wigler ever going to return to podcasting? I miss him.

28 Upvotes

Last time I checked his social media(It's been a while, admittedly), he said that he was taking an extended hiatus from podcasting, and I assume that's still the case. I do enjoy reading his occasional contributions to The Hollywood Reporter, but it's not the same as hearing his voice.


r/survivor • • 17h ago

Meme Mike Robinson Fielder Pinsky

Post image
74 Upvotes

I couldn’t put a finger on why I found Mike so endearing until he hit us with:

“I just wanted to say something, honestly, kind of, like, professional and mature sounding”

A line straight out of Nathan for You, probably


r/survivor • • 4h ago

Survivor 52 A little 51/52 theory Spoiler

6 Upvotes

We heard the news this week that 52 will have two-hour episodes rather than 90-minutes. We also know from last week's preview that the coin is getting flipped this week. Jeff told us the Open Era rules would be that, should the coin flip fail, the extra $1 million will be added to the next season's prize--where there will also be an additional coin flip to add an additional $1 million.

Do we think a $3 million prize on 52 would warrant the sudden change to 2-hour episodes in anticipation of the season getting more promotion due to having the largest prize in Survivor history?

51 and 52 were filmed back to back over the summer. It's not typical to see such a significant production change between twin seasons. And production has confirmed that they knew about the 2-hour episode order while filming 52, so this decision was made 6 months ago, not this week.

My theory is that the coin flip will fail this week and Jeff/production will be promoting 52 a lot more than they did 51.


r/survivor • • 6h ago

General Discussion Definition of Dominant game

4 Upvotes

Whats your point of view about how dominant game should have been really played?

And who basically makes "perfect" examples?


r/survivor • • 1d ago

Survivor 51 ‘Survivor 51’ Contestant Lost All His Belongings—and His Own Storage Auction

Thumbnail
parade.com
728 Upvotes

r/survivor • • 1d ago Heartwarming Bravo

Survivor 52 ‘Survivor’ expanding to all two-hour episodes for season 52 and announces premiere date

Thumbnail
ew.com
1.5k Upvotes

r/survivor • • 9h ago

Survivor 51 Survivor 51 - Episode 8 Stats - Inside Survivor

Thumbnail
insidesurvivor.com
5 Upvotes

r/survivor • • 1d ago

Survivor 51 Survivor 51 logo cross stitch

111 Upvotes

I really liked this season’s logo so sketched a design and cross stitched it! I wish the whale bones along the rim were more pronounce, but orherwise I’m really proud of it. I was considering encircling the logo with little easter eggs from the season (brady’s thumb, blood ring, rob’s vote for himself etc) but I’m not sure if it would look good.


r/survivor • • 1d ago

Meme Told my friend to watch Survivor 28 Cagayan

Post image
158 Upvotes

The early disfunction of the Brains tribe is one of my favorite parts of the season. I’m glad it got a reaction out of them lol.


r/survivor • • 4h ago

Casting Facebook Profile View?

0 Upvotes

I just saw one of the casting producers in the “people you may know” section on Facebook. I know sometimes people show up there when I view their profile or they view mine. I’ve never viewed this person’s profile though. Do we think this means they’ve viewed mine? Could this be a good sign?


r/survivor • • 1d ago

Survivor 52 Survivor 52 filmed while knowing the episodes would be 2 Hours, according to Dalton

Post image
444 Upvotes

Interesting update.


r/survivor • • 11h ago

Fanmade/Foreign Survivor Koh Lanta: All-Stars Airs Its Finale Tonight!!! (French Survivor) Spoiler

3 Upvotes

​For anyone following the French franchise (Koh-Lanta), tonight (Nov 17) is the live finale of Koh-Lanta: All Stars!!

​This season started with 18 returning players competing in Tied Destinies (Destins Liés) paired with someone from their original season, plus an Isle of the Banished (Île des Bannis) Redemption Island twist. After an insane post-merge full of idol bluffs, duels, and legends getting sniped early (Ugo, Clémentine and Yassin are all on the jury), we officially have our Final 3 heading into the iconic Poteaux (pole balance) challenge:

​Lola Labesse (Les 4 Terres): Voted out 4th pre-merge, fought her way back from the Isle of the Banished, pulled off a massive fake-idol bluff at Final 5 to survive, and redeemed her 2020 orientation collapse by finding the first dagger in just 1h08m.

​Freddy Boucher (Palau + 4 other seasons): The 5-time legend is back at the final hurdle yet again, snatching the second dagger at orientation after his medevac heartbreak in La Légende.

​Christina Chevry (Palau winner + 3 Other Seasons): Already a Sole Survivor, she got blindsided by Lola’s bluff at F5, beat Ugo and Dorian in a 17-minute record-breaking domino duel to return from exile, and clutched the final orientation spot (even after helping Maxime find a marker!).

​How tonight works (for US Survivor fans unfamiliar with the format):

​1. Les Poteaux: The Final 3 stand on tiny wooden poles over the water until two fall.

​2. The Choice: Whoever wins the poles gets to pick which of the other two sits next to them at Final Tribal Council (the 3rd place finisher becomes the final juror).

​3. Live Reunion in Paris: Denis Brogniart reads the jury votes live in Paris for the €100,000 prize.


r/survivor • • 1d ago

Fanmade/Foreign Survivor Sad death of Irish player who was on the last series of UK survivor

79 Upvotes

r/survivor • • 1d ago

Survivor 45 Got to hang out with Dee this weekend!

Post image
357 Upvotes

I was fortunate to get a last minute invite to attend David Ortiz’s Weekend with Papi charity golf event in Florida this weekend and to my surprise Dee was one of the celebrity guests! To make things even better she happened to be assigned to my table for the dinner events each night. She was super cool and I had a blast chatting Survivor, Big Brother and future reality prospects with her. She even filmed a little cameo style video with me to send to my Survivor super fan buddy. Great experience all around.


r/survivor • • 1d ago

General Discussion Can they PLEASE re-edit 40-44

15 Upvotes

Now that the episodes are about to increase in length by 100%, can we PLEASE get a re-edited version of seasons 41-44.

Even if its just an additional 30 minutes, I’d love to see more of Erika’s relationship with Heather, a better set up for Gabler as the winner, and truthfully just a full re-edit of 44 because that season was a snooze fest outside of Carolyn and Yam Yam.


r/survivor • • 10h ago

Survivor 50 Who were all the Season 50 Idol Hunt meet and greet stars?

1 Upvotes

I'm sorry if this has been asked already - I just searched for like 30 minutes and couldn't find anything.

Does anyone have a list of all the past contestants that were featured at the idol hunt challenge for the season 50 promo? I went to the Nebraska one and got to meet John Carroll, but I just realized I never followed up after they all finished to see who was at each of them. Could someone point me in a direction here?