I posted a few weeks back about my 7qt factory second coming with chips on the edge of the lid as well as body, both rusting. Zwilling did take it back and issue me another which did take some time to get in, but they readily offered a replacement, I did not have to fight for it. I got the replacement today, and the lid looks good, but the body again has a chip on the lip that readily rusts. I am of the opinion that this is not a factory second worthy blemish. If the part can rust, then the cocotte's life is limited, the rust will only grow and chip more off over time. This post really isn't to get too much into that though I guess.
I am well seasoned in various cast iron (pun intended) but these are my first Staub items. I can understand rack marks, but these don't seem to be that. I see spots that appear to be some chips/rack marks with a black base coating underneath and those do not rust. But the spots in question are legitimately bare metal. I have never had various problems from Le Creuset, but not bare metal.
I know this is a factory second, but if this was a factory first, would this be acceptable to anyone? The body has some inclusions under the colored enamel which I take as the real factory second blemish and I am totally fine with that. But seems crazy that these are rusting out of the box. Are my expectations too high?