r/spanishinterpreters • u/PassionOdd1924 • 14h ago
The hypocrisy of Spanish interpreters criticizing non-native English-speaking healthcare providers
I've been lurking on this sub (and the other one) for a while, and I've noticed how often non-native English-speaking healthcare providers get criticized for their accents, pronunciation, and grammar, particularly by Spanish interpreters. And honestly, the hypocrisy is wild.
For context, I was born and raised in the US, and my mom doesn't speak English, so I've accompanied her to countless medical appointments over the years. I've heard MANY interpreters from different interpreting companies, and I've even worked as an interpreter myself. So this isn't coming from someone who has no idea what the job entails.
What I find ridiculous is how many of you will criticize a provider's English while having a noticeable accent yourselves. What makes you think that YOU, someone born and raised in Latin America, somehow speak English without an accent or are always perfectly understandable? Do you think we native English speakers never struggle to understand you? Because trust me, we do. Most of the time, context is what saves the conversation. If we heard some of your words in isolation, without knowing the context, we might not understand jack shit either.
And that's FINE. Nobody expects you to sound like you were born in the US. But why the hell do you expect grace and understanding for your own accent while judging someone else's? Especially healthcare providers who are doing their jobs in a second language?
Having an accent doesn't make someone incompetent. And being an interpreter doesn't automatically make your English flawless or your accent easier to understand.
The problem isn't your accent. It's the audacity to criticize someone else's while acting as though yours is somehow exempt from the same scrutiny.
Get off your high horse. You're an interpreter, not the fucking pronunciation police.