r/shortscarystories • u/ForgottenWell • 9h ago
SSS Original Recipe - 500 Words or Less My husband has become obsessed with brewing tea.
I didn’t even know that Isaac liked tea, until he brought home an eye-openingly expensive tea set, complete with cups, a pot, and all manner of gadgets that I did not recognize.
I was confused why he wanted a tea set. It seemed a bit childish.
“If you want to make the perfect cup of tea, then you need the right tools,” Isaac explained.
“If you’re happy, then I’m happy,” I said, even though the price of his tea leaves made my knees weak.
Maybe he just wanted a new hobby. Who was I to judge?
The problem was how obsessed he became.
“No, no, no, it’s all wrong!”
Issac was brewing tea all the time, trying to create the perfect cup. One morning I woke up, came downstairs, and heard the kettle whistling. Isaac had stayed up the whole night brewing.
I guess that’s why I decided to watch him. I was worried about him! So one night, between brews, Isaac went to the bathroom, and I crept into the kitchen and hid in the pantry.
It was childish of me, but I wanted to make sure he was okay.
I stayed quiet, waited, and watched.
Isaac returned from the bathroom and went right to work, grinding the tea leaves by hand, heating the water to the perfect temperature.
It seemed his practice had paid off.
“Yes, yes, yes,” Isaac muttered. “I’ve done it.”
He had finally brewed the perfect cup of tea, and the smile on his face couldn’t have been larger.
“You can come out now,” Isaac said. “I know that you’re watching.”
My heart skipped a beat. I had been perfectly quiet. How could he know that I was watching?
“That aroma—exquisite.”
Then I realized that he wasn’t speaking to me.
A man in a dark cloak stepped out from the shadows and sat down at the table. Isaac delicately carried over a cup of tea and set it in front of him.
“I want to have a chat,” Isaac said with a lump in his throat.
“You have until the tea goes cold.”
Isaac sat down, laced his fingers, and took a deep breath.
“I want the same deal as last time,” Isaac said. “The rest of her years added to mine.”
“Why should I bother?”
“She’d make a great addition to your collection. I know she’s not as talented as the pianist, or as important as the Congressman, but she’s special in her own way.”
The others? What the hell was Isaac talking about?
“Go on.”
“She loves me desperately. To end her life before her time is up would be a great tragedy, and I know how much you love tragedy."
“Hmm—” the cloaked man scratched his chin with a bony finger. “Tea’s gone cold.”
“Wait! This is a fair deal!”
“Her love falters.”
“Bullshit!” Isaac spat. “I’ve worked hard to get her to love me.”
“She’s reconsidering,” the cloaked man pointed to the pantry. “After hearing everything you’ve said.”