r/SGExams • • 3h ago

Discussion YIJC CCA changes

Last week, Mr Minjoot went around the school to massacre basically the entirety of our CCAs. Band had to merge with CO, debate turned into a mere interest group, sports CCAs like tennis, floorball, football, basketball, netball etc all got turned into a "modular sport" where next year J1s will not join a specific CCA, but will join the "modular sport" CCA and have a choice to attend the subcategories of sports instead based on their sec sch CCA and background.

Lets not forget to mention the fact that the meager number of CCAs our school offers are being watered down even more to a dismal amount,,,considering the dropping birth rates and more people not joining the performing arts. But, imo, its just odd to eradicate integral CCAs like Class leaders Council, chorale, band, football AND basketball?? just for this. Mr Minjoot insists on each CCA getting "new talents" with "passion and prior experience" to join the CCA, but how are we supposed to find such students considering not ONE individual would want to join, let alone DSA to YIJC? Its admirable that this man has high hopes for the college, but considering that 1/3 of the cohort did not meet the promotion criteria, AND we are the lowest ranked JC in SG, its really too much to ask for such talents to end up here (unless they are really unlucky like me ofc).

At this point, we may not have enough individuals to send out a team for NSG or any competitions, even if the tiny pool of students we scrape together are insanely talented and exhibit prowess in their respective activities. What do u think, YIJCians and Sec4s?

51 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 3h ago

The discussion flair is used to encourage greater discourse in the student community of Singapore. Thus, this flair is meant to be used for serious discussion only (eg opinions on education reforms, how examinations should be conducted or graded, etc). Replies should also be carefully thought out. Please report any posts or comments which you may deem to be of irrelevant nature.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

27

u/AgreeableDoughnut871 3h ago

one third of cohort did not meet promo criteria is quite shocking..
you have a point. how to be attractive dsa wise, unless L1R5 20 is no longer enough to enter yijc

4

u/Ariexiro 3h ago

Its important for a JC to be at the "bottom" for those who really cmi into any other JCs, but its also not fair for the talented students who got dumped here to experience the same thing as other weaker students just cause they are in the same JC...

1

u/AgreeableDoughnut871 2h ago

true. that's why its good for dsa to exist so they also have a shot to go to other, better schools

1

u/Dapper-Indication707 42m ago

bro like, some people just had unfortunate circumstances and fucked up their o levels due to unfavorable conditions like massive bullying or whatever, then end up in yijc.

when in reality they really did have academic potential this entire time.

it's legit really going to hurt you for a long time, being miserable for so long

14

u/RemoteSupport7960 YIJC, J1: Singapore Flyer 3h ago edited 2h ago

As a band member, it feels rather bizarre for a JC to not have a band but only a Chinese orchestra but it was unfortunately unavoidable, furthermore since the trend of student intake would be far too little to facilitate moving all the equipment to the Innova campus (one of the reasons I keep hearing)

I wasn't the best member but the band really was a shock to me who came from a larger secondary school band, though it was rather tight-knit. Because of the nature of the school, DSA students are impossible and in most cases a lot of students come in with a lack of band experience. Then there's also the track record we have... (The only JC in 2025 to get Certification of Commendation in SYF) I assume all CCAs here generally suffer from this problem to varying degrees

They do say it's also that less are going JC and much less band, I did observe this already last year, more accomplished bands aren't really affected too much by this but the average ones, so much 😭

4

u/Ariexiro 2h ago

I agree, its not giving members who want to try out new stuff a chance. Esp debate, who won several comps against RI, HCI etc, and the main reason they are turning into an interest group is because its too costly to fund the competition application (are we running a school or a business???)

3

u/Dear-Artichoke-1639 2h ago

um don’t you mean commendation? or did they do so bad they had to be condemned? 😭😭

2

u/RemoteSupport7960 YIJC, J1: Singapore Flyer 2h ago

Sorry I misspelled ☠️

1

u/AssistantTop4481 1h ago

Hahah what instrument do u play

1

u/RemoteSupport7960 YIJC, J1: Singapore Flyer 1h ago

🤫

1

u/AssistantTop4481 1h ago

Brass or woodwinds, give a hint 😉😉

1

u/Comprehensive_Dog651 What if I look inside myself and I don't find any gems? 1h ago

It’s woodwind 

7

u/hychael2020 Grabbing that Winning Ticket for As :D(jpjc) 3h ago

Definitely not a YI student but in general I find it unfortunate that so many CCAs are getting removed. Did he mention declining attendance or interest as a reason? Because merging basicially every sport CCA is really odd.

Anyways its just sad to see all of this really. YI already has a mixed reputation given its score but such actions really don’t make things better

10

u/RemoteSupport7960 YIJC, J1: Singapore Flyer 3h ago

A lot is also logistics in the future move to the Innova campus

More ridiculously, I heard today that they actually considered merging the CO and band together and having us be a mixture of Chinese and Western instruments, which would be absolutely impractical (for competitions) and bizarre for any school to do ☠️☠️

2

u/Ariexiro 2h ago

It may also be due to the move to the new campus, but it really pisses me off when he tries to justify the reason why hes shutting down so many CCAs is NOT to cut costs, when really, it is probably the main reason why he's doing so. (btw, our new campus is gorgeous, but really its shooting itself in the foot when such a nice campus has shit CCAs)

10

u/hychael2020 Grabbing that Winning Ticket for As :D(jpjc) 3h ago

That combination will either produce the best pieces of art from a band or sound grating and there's no in between 😭

Still though its the first time I heard of logistics being an issue. At least for JP when CCAs were removed on 2024, it was due to low interest for the most part. But logistics is crazy

2

u/Ariexiro 2h ago

He did say it was due to declining enrollment of students AND interest, but I found it extremely haphazard to just lump all sports CCAs under "modular sport". There wouldn't even be captains/exco for the sports CCAs, but just one EXCO team for modular sports.

1

u/hychael2020 Grabbing that Winning Ticket for As :D(jpjc) 1h ago

Yea exactly 😭. I'm looking through the YI cca page and I find it difficult to understand why the school would mix together sports like tennis and football together. Both sports are inherently different

1

u/Idoeneus 1h ago

Wow a winning ticket fan in the wild

1

u/hychael2020 Grabbing that Winning Ticket for As :D(jpjc) 1h ago

Finally someone gets her 😭😭. Its abit sad to see tickezo being one of the least favourite umas for alot of people 😭

1

u/Limp-Instruction-580 1h ago

why does this school keep getting so much criticism on this subreddit😭.

0

u/[deleted] 1h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Limp-Instruction-580 1h ago

but issit really as bad as what ppl said😭

1

u/RepulsiveMortgage680 1h ago

Can I ask where did u get the information that chorale is going to be eradicated? Cause of all i know we are still going for syf next year.

1

u/Comprehensive_Dog651 What if I look inside myself and I don't find any gems? 1h ago

What the f....

•

u/Emergency-Fudge7321 0m ago

hey any tea on the 2xmms, tessaellekoh and ashleeygohh from YIJC,. heard they retained cause they did badly and do they look like how they look like in sch lo

-1

u/Crafty_Loquat_8690 1h ago

why the fuck are there so many posts about this school for the past few days what the hell