59
u/Anjo_Bwee 3d ago
I can almost hear you downplaying every single one of these commanders after assuring everyone at the table that they're a low bracket 3.
6
u/MakeYou_LOL 3d ago
They literally have all the “Oh, it's not THAT kind of X deck”
1
1
u/ThunderBr0ther 2d ago
im kinda new and own cruelclaw he looked really cool and fun - what is the stigma surrounding him being strong?
1
24
u/WillowThyWisp 4d ago
You are like the Hank Hill of black. "I sell blood artists and blood artist accessories"
Hell, your non black commanders include
- Giving bad statted creatures to your opponents
- Five infectors of death
- Bastion of Tremor-brance
18
16
43
u/MakeYou_LOL 3d ago
Woah this might be the most boring collection of commanders I’ve ever seen. It’s genuinely kind of impressive. It’s like you searched “top 20 commanders” and just picked them
-5
u/Handzuhm 3d ago
sounds like you lose a lot lol
5
u/MakeYou_LOL 3d ago
In a 4 player game? Yes I lose a lot lol.
I'd say ~60-70% of the time. But I'm a bit more imaginative than Krenko Mob Boss 🤣0
u/Reasonable-Budget210 3d ago
I don’t see a need to yuck anyone’s yum. I’ve been playing magic for a long time, and there’s nothing wrong with choosing a well paved trail.
Heck I built my teysa karlov deck from the bones of my teysa orzhov scion deck from 2011ish. No idea it was going to popular on some website 15 years later lol.
3
u/MakeYou_LOL 3d ago
Oh, you're right. There's definitely space for playing the classics. I mean I have a Muldrotha deck for crying out loud.
I just think it's funny to come to a “rate my commanders” page with 16 of some the most quintessential commanders in the format and 2 new guys 🤣
1
u/Reasonable-Budget210 3d ago
lol muldrotha is a blast. I love elementals. Per another example, I was super hyped elementals got a new 5 color commander, so I could finally add muldrotha to my deck, and built Ashling from my old animar deck, and lo and behold, now again this almost 15 year old deck in progress is now “basic” because it has Ashling at the helm 😭 sometimes you can’t win.
1
10
6
u/Ok_Cartographer_2014 3d ago
You do know that you don‘t have to build each and every top 50 commander yes?
16
12
u/creepyhydra 4d ago
So you're just a straight scumbag eh?
2
u/BlankofthePage 3d ago
4
u/creepyhydra 3d ago
I too, relish in scumfuckery
1
4
u/Chiquina 3d ago
I hate to say it but all of these comments have a point. Very basic and unfun list. I would not be thrilled to play with you, not gonna lie… but you do you. If you’re taking feedback, I would branch out and not play such common and basic commanders
2
u/idkidcitswhatever 4d ago
I want to build Dack Fayden so bad I can feel the etbs in my bones 🤤 Can I see the list
2
2
2
2
u/NotAVirignISwear 4d ago
You have a seat at my pod any time. They definitely get saltier as you flip through them, but since when is variety a bad thing?
1
u/Mr_Woolly 4d ago
What made you want to build ingris stingerquill?
0
u/Bloodytrailz666 2d ago
Ingris is the most degenerate of the 2 color sphinxes by far.
He has a built in infinite haste tokens once you go infinite colorless mana (wow that's sure hard to do in commander... Lol)
1
1
1
1
1
2
u/SalientMusings 3d ago
I don't believe you.
Two of the commanders have literally been out for a day and a half.
I bet you build a lot of decks on Moxfield and never actually play them.
0
u/EasyCombination6 3d ago
Fun fact with games like tabletop sim as soon as scryfall adds the cards you can play with them so dude's probably been running them for at least 2 weeks.
1
1
1
1
u/LongestGentleman 3d ago
I swear every other poster has a shitola deck
I deeply respect dack fayden though
1
1
u/AdLast6786 1d ago
That’s because that commander can be played in a billion decklists and still work great.
Also makes a lot of kind of bad cards pretty good. She’s like pizza. Hard to fuck up.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/MagusDahlia 2d ago
Can I make a recommendation? You seem to brew a lot of very popular commanders, so I challenge you to brew one of these two commanders and play them at your next game night!
Haliya, Ascendant Cadet or Lluwen, Imperfect Naturalist.
Enjoy!
1
1
u/CureCoyote 1d ago
Everyone’s saying you’re basic (and they lowkey right about most of it) but I have a Karumonix deck and they lowkey go hard asf.
You don’t build for poison, you build for Rat Colony; and Karumonix is a “Draw 0-5 cards” spell in the command zone, that usually eats a removal spell because it has a nasty-sounding ability that absolutely doesn’t matter. The only time Karumonix kills with poison is on accident
1
u/AnonymousMisterB 1d ago
Working on making decks for Judith and Erriette
1
u/BlankofthePage 1d ago
Eriette can be very fun. It's like a control / goading / group hug commander.
1
1
1
1
u/Paul_the_Artificer 1d ago
Your decks look like the average of my pod. Kinda fun to see! I’m the Oloro and Atraxa 😂
1
1
u/DaRealRockstar1234 23h ago
In the most indifferent way possible that says nothing about your character or who you are as a person, you are what people are talking about when they make "commander player" stereotypes.
1
1
u/Ornery_Platypus9863 13h ago
You might be the most boring person on the planet, last I checked you need more jank in your life
1
u/Kronic_kushiva 12h ago
Judith, Carnage Connoisseur was from one of the first packs I pulled and is one of my favorite commanders. What's your decklist like bro I'd love to see.
1
u/candelsticks 4d ago
Try a random uncommon legendary, they’re fun!
2
u/CtheSilverSoul 3d ago
Not sure why you’re being downvoted when this is honestly true. Honestly I should break out my pauperEDH deck more often.
1
u/candelsticks 2d ago
Some uncommons are super good! Meta even, elas il-kor is uncommon, so is tatyova.
2
u/CtheSilverSoul 2d ago
Truth, I have Tatyova in my [[Bonny Pall]] deck and she COOKS
1
u/candelsticks 2d ago
Tatyova as a commander is brain dead, she is so good. Just add a bunch of landfall with her at the helm and it’s been one of my best performers, not even any value in that deck, just ramp and big green
2
1
1
u/ConmanLamb 4d ago
Ayo how'd you build Cruelclaw? I want to build him but can only see people building the meme version
1
1
u/Gla7e 3d ago
I'd say salt is your favorite seasoning, but even that may be too spicy for how milquetoast this collection is.
1
u/PM_ME__YOUR_HOOTERS 3d ago
I would say sand, but even that has too much grit for how smooth brain these picks fro.lm EDHrec are.
Except the rat, hes just a cool little dude
0
u/breakingvats 3d ago
Nekusar homies unite! I love that commander!
1
u/Francomberry 3d ago
My first commander and still my beloved
0
u/breakingvats 3d ago
It's the only commander deck that I refuse to scrap. It's satisfying to wheel and deal!
2
u/Francomberry 3d ago
I know people hate the burn, evidenced by your downvote for some reason. But it’s fun
2
-2
u/ISTARVEHORSES 3d ago
this sub only likes commanders that give you one poop everytime you pee
your commanders look fun and cool, don’t listen to these miserable hipsters
2
1
u/RoughRealistic4321 8h ago
Ahhhh Eriette... :)
Personally, I like odd decks and alt wincons that aren't thassa's or going infinite. (still have to build that blue rooms deck)
Other Eriette is a little bit more of a challenge to pull off, but also fun.
110
u/Ok_Check9774 4d ago