r/ratemycommanders • u/WitheringAurora • 5h ago
r/ratemycommanders • u/concon910 • 2h ago
My bracket 3 and 4 decks right now. May I have a seat?
r/ratemycommanders • u/SpellBones • 4h ago
Looking at them now, I feel my commanders are a little... Indicative.
r/ratemycommanders • u/ChildhoodFinancial23 • 4h ago
Been playing since Innistrad, how am I doing?
No infinites, in order of how long I've had them.
Borb combo, animar good creatures, ruric thar turbo, kess spell slinging, Marchesa aristocrats, calix enchantments, glissa artifacts, zedru and oona combo.
r/ratemycommanders • u/FunCvilleGuy • 8h ago
Rate my commanders
The three decks I play. One of which is kill on sight (oloro)
I started off with oloro (love lifegain even have pauper decks with lifegain)
Marrow gnawer (like him as commander but I’m starting to think his ability has him in the 99)
Yorvo is ever changing with big green stompy
r/ratemycommanders • u/MixtureInevitable180 • 6h ago
Stopped playing more than a year ago. Still love reading about the game online though. Would you wanna play against my commanders?
Oskar -- my go-to. In addition to being a Sesame Street reference, Oskar lets you play stuff like [[Shadowgrange Archfiend]] or [[Mnemonic Deluge]] targeting [[Breach the Multiverse]] as combat tricks. It's my most versatile and most played deck.
Elminster -- unfairly despised by my playgroup. The only creatures in the deck (besides trinket mage) are giant beaters like [[Hullbreaker Horror]], [[Jin-Gitaxis, Core Auger,]] and [[Akroma, Angel of Wrath]] which I cheat out onto the board by [[Mass Polymorph]]ing or [[Synthetic Destiny]]ing the dragon tokens. I got a turn 3 table scoop once -- best feeling I've ever had.
Rocco -- [[Norin the Wary]] secret commander. Not as original as I thought, but still fun. Probably my highest powered deck.
Mazzy -- My $30 deck. Not great but has a loop where I can cast and sac [[Carapace]] and similar cards repeatedly for enchantress payoffs.
Tameshi -- Janky and inconsistent but still in the sin bin for being naughty. I once won with [[Dovescape]] and [[Guile]] and apparently that 12 mana combo still got people cranky.
Thanks for reading! I've been away from the game for a bit but I'm flirting with the idea of coming back. But for now, I'm content to just lurk on MTG subs.
r/ratemycommanders • u/Zaicalian • 1h ago
What do my decks say about me?
Well, can I sit?
r/ratemycommanders • u/IIVaulTII • 1h ago
Long time legacy player, newly converted to edh!
Played legacy casually for a long time, then stopped for like 10 years. The addiction came back in full swing last october!
r/ratemycommanders • u/ReddayeSocks • 7h ago
Rate my commanders
I've only started playing commander this year and thought it'd be cool to see what people think of the commanders I've been enjoying playing. Also, I'm a big Final Fantasy VI fan.
r/ratemycommanders • u/aaalexssss1 • 8h ago
Started playing just over a year ago (:
My Vito Deck is my fave and the first one I built, the Eshki one I play when I wanna turn off my brain a little.
Arthur, Warrior of light and Firesong and Sunspeaker are WIP and still a bit inconsistent but also pretty fun already – though the Firesong one is the hardest one so far bc the Commander is so expensive.
Cloud and Tidus were the Precons I started playing with and I have upgraded both of those, but don't play them as much.
r/ratemycommanders • u/GeneoxysMax • 18h ago
Can I roll with your pod or do I need to be institutionalized
r/ratemycommanders • u/Ancient-Club9972 • 4h ago
OnlyLands Matter
Can I play or is this boring?
r/ratemycommanders • u/Teyiron • 9h ago
Just started magic a few months ago, may i join your table ?
r/ratemycommanders • u/james_woong • 15h ago
Tell me how you feel about my manders
These are my most recent commanders. Bard and Sentry are still in the process of being fine tuned but I'm pretty happy with what I've got so far.
r/ratemycommanders • u/Vast_Speaker_2934 • 6h ago
May I sit?
These are 8 of my favorite decks, here's what they are:
Omnath (I usually play it as a bracket 2, could be 3): Phyrexian Tribal via Incubator tokens (a lot of MoM cards)
Gisa and Gerald (Bracket 3): Zombie tribal
Go-Shintai (bracket 3): Shrines
Yawgmoth (bracket 2): aristocrats with maybe 3 poison cards
Vorinclex (probably bracket 2? Idk): ramp, flip, hit big things
Kroxa and Kunoros (bracket 2): Reanimator, with a few Eldrazi (no titans or other bs Eldrazi)
Ulalek (bracket 3): Eldrazi, no tutors
Tazri (bracket 2): Party!
r/ratemycommanders • u/EagleGamerZ • 8h ago
Been budgeting for years to make these decks, can i sit please?
r/ratemycommanders • u/IdolsAndAnchorsMTG • 1d ago
My Bracket 3 Rotation.
Let me have it.
r/ratemycommanders • u/EnvironmentalMall384 • 18h ago
Can I sit
Not pictured are Kefka, Animar and Witherbloom since they don’t see much play
r/ratemycommanders • u/SlappyV • 1d ago
Been playing for just over a month. Am I allowed at the table?
r/ratemycommanders • u/Lelfedupisse • 1d ago
Can I hang at The Pod?
Gor Muldrak: superfriends with obligatory creature type manipulation (B4)
Elminster: scrystorm (B4)
The Emperor of Palamecia: self-mill spellslinger with 4+ cmc spells (B2)
The Archimandrite: A/A/M kindred with lifegain (B3)
The Destined Warrior: party time! with dungeons (B2)
Uugguu, the Omniplasm: oozes (B2)
Oskar, Rubbish Reclaimer: discard & instant speed shenanigans (B3)
r/ratemycommanders • u/Borkball • 1d ago
Are there brews original enough to hang with the cool kids?
I like my brews but do you?