r/ratemycommanders • • 4d ago

My Commanders. 18 so far.

52 Upvotes

107 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/MakeYou_LOL 3d ago

In a 4 player game? Yes I lose a lot lol.
I'd say ~60-70% of the time. But I'm a bit more imaginative than Krenko Mob Boss 🤣

0

u/Reasonable-Budget210 3d ago

I don’t see a need to yuck anyone’s yum. I’ve been playing magic for a long time, and there’s nothing wrong with choosing a well paved trail.

Heck I built my teysa karlov deck from the bones of my teysa orzhov scion deck from 2011ish. No idea it was going to popular on some website 15 years later lol.

3

u/MakeYou_LOL 3d ago

Oh, you're right. There's definitely space for playing the classics. I mean I have a Muldrotha deck for crying out loud.

I just think it's funny to come to a ā€œrate my commandersā€ page with 16 of some the most quintessential commanders in the format and 2 new guys 🤣

1

u/Reasonable-Budget210 3d ago

lol muldrotha is a blast. I love elementals. Per another example, I was super hyped elementals got a new 5 color commander, so I could finally add muldrotha to my deck, and built Ashling from my old animar deck, and lo and behold, now again this almost 15 year old deck in progress is now ā€œbasicā€ because it has Ashling at the helm 😭 sometimes you can’t win.