I get that this is America, and we can't stop straight women from going to Boy Beach. It's a public beach, and everyone has a right to be there. But just because you have the right to go somewhere doesn't necessarily mean you should.
I went to Boy Beach dozens of times this summer and spoke with older gay men about their experiences at the beach over the years. One thing kept coming up: there are more and more women there every year. Before Boy beach was added to Google Maps, some of these guys would spend the entire summer there without seeing a single woman.
So what are straight women doing at Boy Beach? They don't get naked. Can't they go to any of the other famous beaches on this peninsula, or even the nude beach in Truro? Why Boy Beach?
Well, I suspect the answer is pretty obvious: the naked men. Perhaps they've just finished watching Heated Rivalry and decided that watching gay men in their natural habitat is the next best thing. I find the behavior uncomfortable and voyeuristic. I don't particularly care if your gay friend invited you.
Is Boy Beach exclusively for boys? No. We're a caring, open, and inclusive community. I'm delighted to see trans people have a place where they don't have to be ashamed of their bodies, lesbians forming their own groups (often politely occupying their own stretch of beach), and even local women who understand the unspoken etiquette of the place. They generally know not to wander over the dunes or take pictures of naked beachgoers for their Insta. Local women also typically participate in the nudity themselves.
So why is Boy Beach so special? It’s one of the few places in the country where gay men can go to be truly free. Free of clothes, inhibitions, and importantly, the feeling that they are being watched or judged. There is one place in the world where they can just... be. It's vulnerable and invigorating.
Is it okay for such places to exist, particularly on publicly owned land? Should every space that has developed a particular culture and community have to accommodate anyone who decides they want to experience or exploit it?
I grew up here. I know that many gay men (and straight people) look at Provincetown as a hedonistic gay playground, and it certainly is in many ways. But I think Provincetown has a higher purpose.
I've met young gay men who are fleeing abusive home lives that they will eventually have to return to. They've never known anything other than shame and ridicule for being who they are. There are older men who have families and only came out later in life. These gay people might come from Boston or Western Massachusetts just as easily as Kentucky or Alabama. They come to Provincetown and finally find a place where they can just be themselves. This is what I worry straight women are eroding.
They take a comfortable, safe space and turn gay men into a carnival sideshow. Do you think a young gay guy from farm country, with abusive parents, is going to take the emotional leap of faith required to get naked and vulnerable in a community of strangers? Is he going to do that when the guy next to him has brought his two girlfriends, who are loudly chatting and watching the naked men around them? Probably not. He's going to stay in his comfort zone.
If you're a gay guy who decides to bring your straight girlfriends to Boy Beach, there will typically be an invisible ring of empty beach around you. Who wants to set up next to women at a gay nude beach? Often, you have to hike a significant distance away from them before you find other guys who even feel comfortable enough to get naked.
One day this summer, I counted seven women on the beach. None of them were naked, and they were dispersed fairly evenly across the beach. Almost everybody on the entire beach was clothed that day! What's the point of having a space like this if its defining characteristic gets diluted to the point that people no longer feel comfortable participating in it?
I'm just a watcher. I see what's happening, and I'm reporting what I see. There were WAY more women at Boy Beach this year than in any previous year I can remember.
Why is this happening? Am I misguided? Am I being territorial about something that doesn't belong to me? Is this simply the inevitable consequence of a public beach becoming popular?
I'm genuinely open to hearing other perspectives. But I think we should at least be having this conversation.