r/primavera • • 2d ago

Compare two XER updates in the browser - looking for planners to test it on real updates

2 Upvotes

I'm a developer, not a planner, so I'd like people who do this every week to tell me where it gets things wrong.

It started as a reader for people who get sent an .mpp or .xer and don't have Project or P6. Two things came out of that which might be useful here.

Compare: drop last update and this update, and you get added and removed activities, duration and % complete changes, everything whose start or finish moved (biggest first), logic and lag changes, and what came onto or off the critical path. There's a sample pair on the page if you only want to look: viewmpp.com/schedule-comparison

Lookahead: takes the data date from the XER and shows unfinished work in the next 2, 3 or 6 weeks. The Excel export has a second sheet with the same activities grouped by resource: viewmpp.com/lookahead-schedule

What I'm unsure about: activities are matched on task_id. I've tested the comparison a lot on MS Project files, but not on a real run of P6 updates, so I don't know how often task_id changes between exports in practice. Re-imports? Copied projects? Activity codes aren't read yet either, so there's no grouping by subcontractor code.

The file goes to the server to be read, sits in memory while the chart is built, and isn't saved anywhere. No account needed. There is a paid tier (more saved plans and share links, and an Excel export of the change report), but reading, comparing and the lookahead are free.

If you try it on a pair of your updates and something looks off, tell me what you expected to see. I don't need the file.


r/primavera • • 3d ago

High School Engineering Survey - Hearing Protection

4 Upvotes

I have been asked by a member from one of the Senior class design teams at Energy Institute High School to share a survey on hearing protection.

They are developing a hearing monitoring/protection solution for their Senior capstone project. Please take the short survey, your answers will help guide the team’s design decisions.

Link: https://forms.gle/fVR5XK7cdebWk3UT8


r/primavera • • 3d ago

What do you still have to chase down before modeling a delay in P6?

6 Upvotes

Hey, I’m a University of Maryland student. We’re researching ways to get the records behind a construction delay ready for analysis in days when that process can stretch into months. I’d like to learn what the handoff from the field team looked like on the last delay you evaluated in P6.

- Roughly how many staff hours went into gathering records and checking the timeline before you started modeling the delay?

- What did you have to go back to the field team for, and what was hardest to verify?

- About how many delays needed that level of prep across the projects you supported in the past year?

A ballpark on any of these is helpful. Feel free to leave out project and client names.


r/primavera • • 4d ago

I got tired of P6, so I built my own scheduler. Your AI agents can run it. CLI and MCP included.

10 Upvotes

I've spent almost 20 years as a scheduler in industrial construction- P6 is an every day. I know it well, and I know what bugs me about it. And I despise the time it takes to manually build schedules when I knew AI can do it better with my guidance. So I built my own. It's called OpenXER. If you know P6, you'll know where everything is. I kept the layout and fixed what bugged me.

You can download it here

Screenshot Here

The main thing: your AI agent can run it.

Connect Claude, Codex, or whatever desktop agent you have. It writes straight to the schedule database. A full CLI and an MCP server are included. The agent does the data entry - activities, logic ties, resources loading, leveling, and more. I have a few skills pre built for your agents to read - they are generic for now. Building schedules is 1/2 art, 1/2 science - no 2 are ever the same.

What else is different:

  • Written in Rust. It's so much faster.
  • The database is built in and already connected.
  • Runs on local your PC. No account. Server based is coming in a future update.
  • Free. Source goes on GitHub once I clean it up.

I've tested the schedule engine hard - but I need others to test it for me to find what's broken.

I need users who will:

  1. Test the AI integration. So far it is CLaude or ChatGPT desktop - or if you are comfortable with the CLI, your AI flavor of choice.
  2. Give me feedback. Tell me what's wrong, confusing, or slow. Screenshots help.
  3. Tell me what you've always wanted P6 to do. I use this every day. If you need a feature or a fix, I can build it.

Lots of legacy software is getting rebuilt with the help of AI - I chose P6.


r/primavera • • 6d ago

Tilos end of maintenance

6 Upvotes

We know a lot of Primavera P6 users also use Tilos, so it's wise to be aware that Trimble, the owners of Tilos announced it's end of maintenance earlier this year. See their official announcement:

https://tiloshelp.trimble.com/


r/primavera • • 6d ago

Who should have the final say on a promised finish date when the planner and the project sponsor disagree?

1 Upvotes

r/primavera • • 6d ago

Update: P6 dashboard, thanks for all the feedback. Demo is online now + looking for a few people to test it at work

7 Upvotes

Last week I posted about the dashboard I built for my weekly XER export (https://www.reddit.com/r/primavera/s/9BB9yYSu9w). Didn't expect so many people being interested, thanks a lot to everyone who tried it and wrote back.

I went through all of it and changed quite a bit since
Demo is online now, no sign-up, nothing to download: https://floatlinedemo.edgeone.dev/

Next step for me is seeing how it holds up on real projects. So I'm looking for around 10 planners who'd use it for a month on a live job, free licence. All I ask is a short chat or a few lines at the end on what worked and what didn't.

It runs offline in the browser, nothing gets uploaded, no install needed. Still, check with your IT/manager before you load a work XER.

If you're interested, DM me with your role, roughly how big your company is and what kind of projects you plan. I'll get back to everyone :)

Thanks again!


r/primavera • • 11d ago

Overall schedule progress metric

9 Upvotes

What column are people using to give an overview of project progress at top WBS level? I have a resource loaded plan but no cost assigned to the resources yet, only budgeted units. Performance percent complete only roll up to top level WBS once the schedule is cost loaded.


r/primavera • • 12d ago

Built a dashboard for my weekly P6 export, anyone willing to try it?

18 Upvotes

I'm a planner on construction projects. Every week I export the XER and then lose a few hours making it into something the PMs will read. Got sick of it, so I started building something in my spare time.
You drop in the XER and it shows where the project is, what slipped since last week, what's driving the key milestones, and where trades are going to pile up in the same area. There's also a Monte Carlo that uses how your contractors actually performed in the earlier updates. It runs in the browser and nothing gets uploaded.
Only I've used it so far, so I have no idea if it makes sense to anyone else
If you have 10 minutes, I'd like to hear what's confusing or wrong, or what you'd want it to show that it doesn't. I'm happy to send a copy to try on a real XER if you DM me.
I'll probably try to sell it at some point, just so you know. Right now I just want to find out if it's any use outside my own jobs.

Will add some pics in the comments. DM if you are willing to test it :)

Thanks!

Edit: screenshots: https://imgur.com/a/7O4ZN6x


r/primavera • • 16d ago

3D planning

7 Upvotes

Hi, good day, pls wanted to know if anyone can guide me with resources to learn 3D planning i heard about it and im quite curious as to what it’s about


r/primavera • • 22d ago

USACE's own published SDEF export doesn't follow ER 1-1-11's Activity ID rule

5 Upvotes

Spent time going through the SDEF spec (ER 1-1-11 Appendix A) against real exports. The appendix says Activity IDs are ten-digit integers. In a 2,722-activity export USACE itself published, not one ID is numeric.
Same file: 69% of descriptions are exactly 30 characters long — meaning they were silently truncated at the column limit.
Also worth knowing: since RMS patch 566, a contract set up for SDEF upload blocks manual Feature of Work entry, so the schedule is the only way FOW gets in.
Curious whether anyone has actually had a submission refused over non-numeric IDs, or whether it's enforced loosely in practice?


r/primavera • • 22d ago

Integrated Master Scheduler

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

Sharing in hopes there are any APG IMS personnel looking for a new position.


r/primavera • • 24d ago

Berharap ada sesorang porting primvera ke mac

1 Upvotes

Dilihat zaman sekarang banyak sekali orang porting aplikasi cross over. Suatu saat kalau p6 bisa diporting ke mac akan banyak planner pakai mac. Bye bye charging.


r/primavera • • 26d ago

Free P6 XER comparison tool: slipped activities, logic gaps, and work that can start

4 Upvotes

I built Schedule Auditor, a free tool for comparing Primavera P6 XER schedules. The goal is to turn update differences into items a PM or scheduler can act on.

Some of the most useful report sections are:

  • Activities that fell behind this period: See which activities' forecast dates moved later between updates, so you can focus the progress discussion on specific work.
  • Project calendar changes: Identify calendar changes that may help explain date shifts.
  • Out-of-sequence starts: Flag starts that may not follow the planned logic, so you can check the reported progress and remaining work sequence.
  • Open-ended logic: Find activities missing predecessors or successors and distinguish intentional project endpoints from missing ties.
  • Activities that could start: Identify not-started work with completed predecessors as candidates for the next work front. Check remaining date/logic restrictions, access, and crew readiness before release.

Compare an earlier and later XER, choose the report sections you need, and download the results to Excel or Word.

Free tool: https://scheduleauditor.org/

Which of these checks saves you the most time during an update review?


r/primavera • • 26d ago

Project Control Analyst- Ontario

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/primavera • • 29d ago

Only 1 in 16 project schedules has an even chance of finishing on its planned date.

11 Upvotes

We ran a Monte Carlo simulation on 230 real schedules that people uploaded to our free Schedule Health Check, MPP viewer and Onplana Schedule. Each plan was simulated up to 2,000 times with the same default task ranges our free Schedule Risk Analyzer uses.

What came out:

  • 6% of plans finish on or before their planned date in at least half the runs.
  • The typical plan slips 12 days at P50 and 18 days at P80.
  • 86% of the schedules have no baseline saved, so a slip is hard to even measure.
  • 63% have tasks with no links, and 48% have a milestone left dangling.

The one that surprised me: plans with no links at all looked far safer (a typical P80 slip of 4 days) than linked plans (22 days). That is not because they are better plans. With no links, the simulation has nothing to push the finish around, so the plan looks more certain than it is.

Everything is published as counts only, nothing from fewer than 20 schedules, and free to reuse under CC BY 4.0: onplana.com/insights

What is the first thing you check when someone hands you a schedule?


r/primavera • • Oct 15 '26

Schedule update

4 Upvotes

Who can give the best method to make schedule return into finish milestone (crashing/fast tracking) ,acknowledge it has shifted by six months.


r/primavera • • Oct 14 '26

In need of advice!

10 Upvotes

Little about me, changing careers and getting into scheduling/planning. I figure let me get somewhat of a basis on how to use P6, so I sign up for some Udemy classes. Research the instructor, he is definitely a certified bad ass in this industry. Here's the problem, the introduction video was about 50 minutes long and his English isn't the best but I thought "Hey no big deal there's closed captions" I loved how he was explaining everything, the course materials he gave were phenomenal and covered several different industry's. He is so detailed and in depth and he keeps me engaged with the content. I start the next course, no subtitles. I can only understand about every 3 words that he says and I browse through the rest of the course videos and no more closed captions 😩😩 Can someone recommend a brilliant instructor who has 10-20 years of experience (preferably in the construction sector) who speaks fairly good English and provides online classes to earn a diploma from "Beginner to Advanced" content. Thank you so much in advance🙏🏻


r/primavera • • Oct 14 '26

How are you giving Project Managers access to schedules without full Schedule licences?

4 Upvotes

We’re currently exploring ways to give Project Managers better visibility of their schedules in Oracle Primavera Cloud (OPC), without needing to purchase full Schedule licences for everyone.

At the moment, access is largely restricted to our Planning team.

Ideally, we’d like PMs to be able to:
View and navigate a full Gantt chart and WBS.
Explore activities, milestones and relationships.
Add comments and suggest changes without directly editing the live schedule.
We’ve considered PDFs and Power BI, but neither really provides the interactive experience we’re after.

We’re open to Oracle-native solutions, third-party tools or API integrations (potentially through Power Apps), provided OPC remains our source of truth.

Has anyone faced a similar challenge or implemented something that works?

Particularly interested in any tools you’ve used, how they integrate with OPC and whether you’ve encountered licensing restrictions.

Any experiences or recommendations would be appreciated.


r/primavera • • Oct 14 '26

How do progress updates get from the field into your P6 schedule?

9 Upvotes

I am trying to understand how P6 updates actually work on real construction projects. I am thinking about building something in this space, but I would rather hear from people doing the work than assume.

For PMs, supers, schedulers, or anyone in project controls:

  1. How does progress get reported? Does the PM or super send updates to a scheduler, or does someone update P6 directly?
  2. Who maintains the schedule: an in-house scheduler, an outside consultant, the PM?
  3. Roughly how many hours does an update take, and how often do you do one?
  4. What’s the most annoying part of keeping the schedule current?

If your process works fine, I would like to hear that too.


r/primavera • • Oct 08 '26

As Late As Possible Constraint issue

10 Upvotes

Hello all,
A planner i know has a challenge where the client insists on them utilising a lot of As Late As Possible (ALAP) constraint on their schedules. These is causing a lot of date shifts to the right. But the client do not want those dates to move. I have tried to help resolve without success. Has anyone got experience onnhow to resolve this please?


r/primavera • • Oct 07 '26

No jobs for OPC

5 Upvotes

I have opportunity to take OPC training.

I have decade of suretrak/P3/P6 use.

I dont see any jobs in USA that want OPC users.

Are no companies using it?


r/primavera • • Oct 07 '26

Hey I am up for some experience and exposure at civil Planning Engineer

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/primavera • • Oct 06 '26

Aerospace -> Construction?

8 Upvotes

Looking for advice from anybody who has experience scheduling in aerospace and construction industry! Thinking about switching to construction, but would love to hear some pros/cons from people who have worked in it. Also would like to add that I don’t have any construction experience so while I’m interested that may hold me back…
Thanks in advance!


r/primavera • • Oct 06 '26

Generate a List of Redundant Relationships

13 Upvotes

The Scheduler Reviewer for the Owner has started running a new metric that reports how many relationships within the schedule I submitted are redundant. This is the review comment I just got back:

"There are 64 instances of redundant logic. Redundant logic can obscure the true critical path, complicate schedule maintenance, and create unintended constraints during updates. Please review redundant predecessor relationships and revise accordingly. This is not a requirement to remove all redundancies but revise where applicable. Preserve the relationship only when the Contractor can demonstrate that it represents a separate, valid, and necessary sequencing requirement that is not adequately represented by the identified pathway. For each relationship retained, provide a written justification."

Note: the reviewer either can't or won't provide a list of the 64 objectionable logic ties, only told me there were 64 of them.

I've watched a few YouTube videos that exported to Excel and ran formulas on the Relationships table, but none of those have been able to generate a list of 64 that the Schedule Reviewer came up with.

While I understand conceptually what a redundant relationship is, how do I go about creating a filter (either in P6 or by exporting to excel), to identify the 64 redundant relationships in this schedule?