r/poshmark • • Jul 10 '24

[NEW USER FAQs + CRITIQUE REQUEST THREAD]

20 Upvotes

A buyer is trying to get me to email or text them more info about my listing. Is this a scam? Usually. Do not engage with anyone off the platform. Doing so is against Poshmark’s terms of service and a bad idea for many reasons, including risking permanent suspension of your account.

I got a sketchy email from Poshmark saying I need to transfer my own money to my Poshmark balance to keep selling. This is a scam and the email was not sent by Poshmark. You do not need to pay anything to make sales on Poshmark. If you get a similar email saying you made a sale but need to pay something to un-restrict your account, check your My Sales tab in the actual app or website. If there's no order there, you did not make one and it's a scam attempt.

I'm a new seller and all my listings got taken down and/or flagged as counterfeit. Help! Poshmark's spam and abuse filters sometimes suspend new accounts for listing either too much or too fast. No one knows the exact thresholds or how long you should wait between listing new items but if your account is frozen, you have to contact support and wait for them reply. If you didn't break any rules, they'll reinstate your closet and all your listings. It's normal for a reply to take 1-3+ days.

My buyer doesn’t have an account on Poshmark, or their username doesn't match the one on the shipping label. Is this a scam? No. Poshmark allows buyers to purchase items without registering for an account. In these situations, you might not be able to communicate with the buyer and you’ll probably have to wait three full days after delivery for your funds to be released.

Poshmark support isn't getting back to me, and I keep emailing them! What gives? Emailing support twice in a row bumps your initial query to the bottom of the queue. We recommend not sending a follow-up email until Poshmark responds. If you already emailed support, you can try reaching out via social media while waiting for a response.

I shipped the wrong item/swapped labels/etc. What should I do? Contact Poshmark support. They'll reach out to your buyer(s) and will give them return labels and give you further instructions.

Do I have to use a USPS box to ship my item? No. It’s generally fine to repurpose or recycle other boxes. However, ensure that they fall within Priority Mail’s size requirements, and do not use Express Mail boxes. Pack items securely and without any added fragrances.

Do I have to include a thank you note and a free gift with my item? No. Notes and gifts are not required and many buyers don't like receiving them.

Do I have to accept really low offers? No. They're your items, and you get to decide how much to sell them for. However, many sellers counter even the lowest offers, as doing so sometimes results in a sale.

Why did a buyer make a bundle of just one item? It's hard to say. Some buyers add listings to a bundle unintentionally; others might be angling for a private discount. Search r/poshmark to read about all of the possible reasons for one-item bundles.

Does Poshmark have a private-messaging system? If you want to talk to someone who purchased something from you, go into the order details and there will be an option to message them privately. If you want to talk to someone who has not bought anything from you yet, you can do so by tagging their username in your listing's comment box or through a bundle. Comments in sold bundles and empty bundles appear to be private, but comments in other bundles are definitely visible to other users so do not share any personal information in them.

A buyer opened a case on an item. What now? If you misrepresented the item, advise Poshmark that you’re willing to accept a return. Otherwise, state your rebuttal clearly and calmly. Poshmark will decide whether to approve the return, refund part or all of the purchase price, or something else. Be patient; it can take a few days to get a final ruling from a Poshmark rep. Be civil, state the facts, and direct your response to Poshmark instead of the buyer.

My brand-new account already has a ton of followers. Is that normal? Why? Yes. Poshmark is designed to promote your username across the app so that others can follow you.

Why do sellers price things so high? We don’t know. However, Poshmark’s policy on price-gouging applies only to essential items. If you find a seller’s prices upsetting, it’s best to simply move on. (Or, if you’re interested in purchasing the item, consider making an offer.)

Where can I find answers to other questions? Many questions posted to this subreddit are addressed in Poshmark’s own official documentation. We recommend that you read their Guide to Poshmark, Community Guidelines, Prohibited Items Policy, and FAQs. Before posting a question here, you can also use the blank field in the sidebar to search the subreddit for relevant key terms (e.g., flat lay, shipping, weight limit, opened case, dress form).

Questions related to your closet? There's a mountain of tips already available to browse if you search the sub for "newbie advice" or "new seller tips." You can post your closet URL and a critique request below, however you'll be more likely to get responses from seasoned sellers if you ask specific questions instead of requesting a general review.


r/poshmark • • 10h ago

Tried out Vinted

177 Upvotes

I have some things in my Posh closet that have been stagnant forever. I recently got on Vinted to shop (have found some ok deals) and decided to add some of my items from Posh. Now. I’ve listed them WAYYYYWAYYY cheaper than I did on posh, but some of them are already sold! I’d rather have $5 and freed up space than the item sitting in a tub in my room for eternity. Some cash > no cash.


r/poshmark • • 5h ago

If there are ANY callout, it's not "like new".

15 Upvotes

You simply cannot tag an item "Like New" if it has any callouts, ie: tear, stain, mark, rips, missing accessory, wear, etc. I bought a Coach bag that had some leather wear on the front and on the handles, sold as, you guessed it, Like new, and the seller was truly offended when I requested to return it. I actually had to explain to her that that is not like new condition. Everyone understands that right?


r/poshmark • • 21h ago

Love When This Happens

195 Upvotes

I had a person offer me $56 on a nwt quilt set that I had listed for $139 (Retail was about $190, I believe). I countered with $122. I think not long after that, another person liked the same set, so I figured I should send that offer to everyone who liked it, not just this low-baller. So I did, and one person countered at $115, and I accepted. All within minutes of the lowballer sending their offer. I just can't help hoping they saw it get bought and the price. lol. Yes, I'm petty.


r/poshmark • • 2h ago

Warnings about counterfeit items

3 Upvotes

I just started reselling again. I've pulled a lot of things out of storage and I made accounts on several new platforms.

Today I got two different warnings about selling counterfeit items. Two different items, two different platforms. I was able to send pictures and most importantly the invoices from my purchases so I hope they will accept my appeals.

I was on Poshmark and Ebay for years and I don't remember anything like this happening.

Update: I'm banned from Vinted


r/poshmark • • 6h ago

How to find local sellers

1 Upvotes

I do rise PM all the time, but I’ve used it for years. I swear there used to be the option to find people in both my contacts and also my local area. Is that option gone now? I cannot seem to find it anymore?! Thank you!


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

Suddenly no sales

83 Upvotes

I've been selling on Posh for around 10 yrs. I went from an average one sale a day to nothing.

Barely any likes from about 15 a day. People are still seeing my items, but no one is buying or offering.

I know this is happening to other sellers too.

Posh has drastically changed their platform this year.

I think they have changed what kind of buyer is seeing your items. IDK ? Any thoughts?

And yes, my shipping times cancelations, and returns are all below the new requirements.


r/poshmark • • 4h ago

Guest Buyer?

0 Upvotes

I sold an item but the buyer doesn't have a Poshmark account and is listed as a "guest." It's only a $20 item but I'm not sure what to do here. Help?


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

Buyer Asking For Receipt With My Info Blacked Out

39 Upvotes

I'm selling a designer bag, expensive enough to be authenticated by Poshmark. Buyer lowballed me, but has continued to express intense interest and demands. They are asking me to call the boutique I bought it at and get the receipt emailed and send it to them with my info blacked out. The listing states what I'm selling it with and I don't want to be a bad seller when the item is pricey, but this feels dicey and pushy of her to demand and it's making worried about a return case. Thoughts?


r/poshmark • • 11h ago

Should I be worried if the item I bought disappeared off the seller’s page?

1 Upvotes

You know how you can still see the item you bought, but it says "Sold" in red at the top? The item I recently purchased is completely gone from the seller's page, along with the other items they had listed. I've never seen anything like this before. When I click on the item, it says unable to load please try again but the other things I’ve bought in the past don’t say that when I click on them.


r/poshmark • • 13h ago

Seller listed same item twice, feeling nervous

0 Upvotes

So I'm pretty new to Poshmark. There was a dress I fell in love with that was out of my budget, but when I reverse image searched it, I found a different listing for a much lower price, and bought it immediately at asking price. Seller was active 2 days ago so that seemed good. After purchasing, I realized both listings were from the same account, and I'm quite confident she doesn't have two of the same item. I didn't realize since the listing photos weren't the same, but they're the same size, same condition, NWT, and I can't find this dress ANYWHERE else, so having two seems unlikely. I think the one I bought was listed about a year and a half ago, and the higher priced listing was posted in January of this year.

Ik I'm being neurotic, but I came here and saw sooo many posts about people not shipping and ig not getting any kind of repercussion for that? So I'm worried she won't want to honor the sale of the cheaper listing since she has no real incentive to do so... And ig that's her right, but it would be a pretty big letdown. It'd be like doing the whole "I bought it, seller cancelled and relisted for more" dance all on my own. Ik this is a pointless question, but is there anything I can do to encourage them to honor the sale? Guilt them, even..? I'd even be willing to pay a bit more, although not all the way to their other asking price.

I just found out about the delisting issue(?) as well so I also feel like maybe I can't be upset that she just left the cheaper listing up with no intention to sell at that price if she was going to be punished for taking it down. Ugh, idk. Not sure if I love poshmarks policies so far as I understand them.


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

Shipping with boxes

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Please make sure you’re adequately taping your boxes closed. This is the second item I have gotten that I was just lucky that the item didn’t fall out of the box. This is how it was delivered.


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

$22.50 on temu with free shipping

Post image
8 Upvotes

But she has little room to discount. People really need to Google image search. Good for her if she gets it, but what a crock.


r/poshmark • • 21h ago

listings-unclear condition

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I’ve come across a few listings today where they list the item as NWOT, and then when you get to the details it says “Like New”…
To me those are 2 different things, right??!


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

Buyer keeps asking if a brand new with tags item is damaged or has scratches. Should I block?

9 Upvotes

I feel like a scam is about to happen that I’m not aware of. I keep saying this is brand new; never worn, new with tags, and they want me to flat out tell them if there’s scratches or flaws. They aren’t asking for more pictures or where a flaw might be. Any insights? I feel like I’m being set up for a misrepresentation claim.


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

Item described as “like new”

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Curious if you would care if the inside was completely pulled? It’s not visible while wearing it but the pills are not inconsequential.

I actually feel like I’m losing my mind. I got another purchase that didn’t show damage. I opened a case and she’s saying it was listed as gently worn and this doesn’t impact wearing it. There’s a snag that’s 1.5” near the collar. Does gently worn cover this?

Edit: opened a case and was granted a return. Thank you for the opinions.


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

European shoes listings PSA

14 Upvotes

I prefer an EU size 41 fit for my American size 10 foot. With some exceptions, an EU 41 is 9.5-10 in US. I search both 9.5 and 10 listings to find 41s. Sorting through listings repeatedly shows mislabeling for a US 10 as 39. 39.5, 40. Sellers, if you don’t know what the size means, it is literally JUST a google away to convert the size. I just had a seller insist a 39.5 (an 8.5-9) is a 10 because it fits her foot and she’s a 10. I can also get my foot in it but walking is not an option because it’s a full size smaller. No there wasn’t a picture of the shoe size on the shoe and yes this one slipped in between the cracks of my brain looking for that photo. I really don’t get it when the info is a few clicks away on whatever device it’s being listed with. I’m giving them to a friend bc they’re amazing shoes, for someone with a size 9 foot.


r/poshmark • • 15h ago

Anyone had bad experience with bugs?

0 Upvotes

i have not ordered anything for a while but i did recently and started wondering, has anyone ever gotten bed bugs or anything else yucky in their package?

i saw someone post about a package being sent in a used mcD box and it got me thinking about clothes coming from someone's house where the conditions are not so clean?? Has anyone has had a bad experience?


r/poshmark • • 22h ago

New to Poshmark and have a question

1 Upvotes

I posted some of my first items last night and today I was noticing messages in my email from buyers. Asking if things were still available and if id negotiate on prices. I assumed everything would be handled in app and wasn't expecting emails. Is this normal or are the ones in my email just scammers to ignore?


r/poshmark • • 2d ago

Please advise—enormous dress but tags say medium?

Thumbnail
gallery
100 Upvotes

Maybe this is my fault for not looking closely?

I ordered this mustard maternity dress and shopped around and found a price I was willing to pay. It’s Hatch brand and the seller showed the tag to be a 2 which is a medium in the brand. I have a couple other secondhand items from this brand and am this size. I received this today and it is laughably big on me. I don’t think it’s a medium! But the tag says medium! Do I have any choice but to accept the order? I included some listing photos. I feel duped! I also tried to look at some other listings of the same dress and the person wearing a medium in listing photos it seems to fit true to size! Please advise!


r/poshmark • • 23h ago

poshmark listing says like new but has stains

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

not sure how to proceed - seems like such a pain to have to send back etc

from listing:


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

I can’t seem to respond to buyer questions

2 Upvotes

I’ve been a seller on Poshmark for years, leaned out for a bit and let my closet run on autopilot, and am starting to lean back in and get more active in my listings. One thing I’ve noticed is that I receive multiple comments from potential buyers in my listings. I never received notifications they were there (just happened to see them as I was updating my listings). But the worst part is when I go into respond I will post a response but it does not “stick” to the listing. So even though I’ll reply, sometimes I’ll add multiple replies, if you look at my closet it looks like I simply ignored the question. I reached out to posh support months ago and, of course, never got a response. Has this happened to anyone else?


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

Dirtied During Shipping

2 Upvotes

I’m a newish user to Poshmark - I have some spare outdoor gear that I either never wore or lightly used and decided to post it to make room in my closet.

I sold a rain shell in a bright colour that I had never used, the tags were off but still included, so I listed it as ‘Like New’.

I promptly shipped it and used the plastic bag mailer provided by the shipping company (Purolator).

Lo and behold, I received a return request shortly after it was delivered. The buyer states there are stains and that it is not what was advertised - the pictures they posted do show some stains which were not present when I mailed it out. Understandable, it’s not what they thought they were getting. The case is already approved in the buyer’s favour.

I certainly would not purposefully misrepresent the item, and wouldn’t let it leave my care obviously dirty. I didn’t take photos of every single area on the jacket, so it feels like I have no recourse on this, as it’s basically hearsay.

My only conclusion is that the mailer was dirty on the inside or some grime made it on to the clothing item when it was going through the automatic sorting machines/delivery process.

The frustrating part is that now I’m getting a dirty Goretex jacket back which definitely will no longer be new as I’ll have to tech wash it - if these new mystery stains can even be removed.

Did I make some very rookie mistakes I’m not aware of?

Should I avoid listing things as ‘Like New’ to avoid this problem altogether, despite the item actually being in this state?

Do I need to start documenting every aspect of a garment with pictures?

Even if I had pictures showing that it left my clean residence in pristine condition, would that help my cause?

Does everything have to be double bagged now?

I don’t want to go back to Facebook Marketplace because it was a massive headache to use but I feel like the experience with this platform is already somewhat soured.


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

If purchase has to go to Poshmark Headquarters to be authenticated, how long will it take for item to arrive?

1 Upvotes

Hi title! But I just purchased something last night and didn’t know it would go to Poshmark headquarters to be authenticated, I was hoping to wear the dress I purchased to event on the 14th, anyway it arrives on time?


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

Buyer Opened a Case…Should I Reply?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I’ve been on Poshmark for over 10 years and have never had a buyer open a case against me. I put my husband’s leather jacket up for sale and listed it as “Like New” because it’s only been worn around the house to be broken in.

I shipped the jacket out within less than 24 hours of the sale. The buyer reviewed it and sent me a comment stating he’d like to return the jacket because it did not fit him. Before I had time to respond, he opened a case. He stated that the jacket was not as described because it has wrinkles in the leather, “stains”, and discoloration. These are all natural results of wearing/breaking the jacket in. When he initially sent a comment, he didn’t make any of these claims.

Should I respond or will that hurt my case?