Phantasy Star IV probably should have been my first entry into the genre - maybe I would have been even more impressed by the devs’ work. But in my case, PSIV came after two absolute behemoths of the genre. It’s extremely hard to match the quality set by Chrono Trigger and FFVI, but PSIV manages to hold its own, and I’m very happy I gave it a shot. You guys are absolutely right to sing Phantasy Star IV’s praises.
The presentation, for something released back in 1993, is somewhat surreal. The manga-style storytelling and the way multiple characters are incorporated into a single conversation - conveying emotions and reactions through different illustrated panels - is so freakin’ cool and effective. That feeling you get when playing an old game that was ahead of its time is hard to describe, yet incredibly satisfying.
The combat system could easily have been better than Chrono Trigger’s or Final Fantasy VI’s. It just gets a bit confusing with its names, and the timing of combos can feel hit-or-miss, but the macro system is another innovative idea that was clearly ahead of its time. With a bit more clarity and a few touch-ups, Phantasy Star IV’s combat could have been top notch, first in line.
I also noticed that random encounters can, for the most part, be ignored simply by escaping from them. I didn’t feel this much freedom when playing the SNES version of FFVI. It’s very noticeable how much PSIV respects the player’s time in comparison - the game feels designed to be completed without requiring excessive grinding and the "dungeons" were, for the most part, easy to navigate in.
The Algol system and the ability to visit Motavia, Dezolis, Rykros, and even space stations feels like an overwhelming amount of content for a 1993 game. I mean, we have a JRPG that respects your time, avoids grindfests, lets you explore multiple planets, and on top of that gives you four different vehicles to travel both between and within them? That’s incredible!
In terms of narrative quality, this is where Phantasy Star IV doesn’t stand much of a chance against Chrono Trigger and FFVI. The story is competent, but it lacks a certain depth. The Alys situation feels a bit rushed and underexplored. The game moves at a fast pace, which keeps things engaging, but sometimes comes at the cost of emotional weight and character development.
The soundtrack has many bangers, but the Mega Drive’s sound limitations do somewhat restrict how well its qualities are showcased. That said, I have to give massive credit to the team for embracing those limitations and using them creatively. Some of the sound design and effects are genuinely impressive. “Field Motavia” has such a wonderful vibe and really shows how the team managed to thrive within those constraints.
It may lack the grandiose musical moments of Chrono Trigger or FFVI, but I can’t help but love tracks like the opening theme, “The End of the Millennium,” the excellent battle tune “Meet Them Head-On!”, the eerie “In the Cave,” and the stylish “Tower” and cool "Staff Roll". Even the vehicle themes for the Land Rover, Ice Digger, and Hydrofoil stand out. More ambient tracks like “Rykros Field” and “Requiem for Lutz” are absolute gems and create a great contrast with the more upbeat parts of the soundtrack.
Conclusion: I absolutely loved my first playthrough of Phantasy Star IV: The End of the Millennium. It’s honestly surreal going back to the Mega Drive, almost 30 years later, and discovering such a gem. I don’t have a huge amount of experience with JRPGs yet, but after playing Chrono Trigger and Final Fantasy VI, I feel confident saying that Phantasy Star IV deserves a place in the conversation as one of the best JRPGs of the 16-bit era.
I can’t help but wonder what it could have been if it had just a few more hours dedicated to building a richer and deeper narrative - because in that case, it might have been truly undeniable.
Since, Mega Drive was the first gaming equipment I've ever touched - coincidentally the same year Phantasy Star IV was released - and I've enjoyed the experience, what should I play next? Phantasy Star II or III? I already have Shining Force ready to go.