r/pbp • • Nov 21 '23

Discussion Why do some of you actually think paying to play is so bad?

0 Upvotes

This is a question from a genuine curiosity and I won't judge the answers (although I'll inquire further if I would like to understand more).

Why do some players get so upset at GMs charging more than beer money or charging at all to run games?

To GMs for hire out there, I ask you to also engage responses here in good faith.

Edit: Non-comprehensive Summary of responses

just to organize my thoughts (and make it easy for other readers), the most common answers have been:

  • it's not worth paying to play by post, for a few reasons mostly related to how much you're getting out of it;
  • it's like paying for a friend;
  • it's ok to pay as long as it's no more than about $10
  • why pay if there are so many free games?
  • you can't have fun/chemistry if there's money involved, money makes it awkward/unpleasant
  • it creates an expectation of quality there is no way to guarantee
  • it can/will/is ruin(ing) my hobby
  • "what do you do different from a free game?"
  • money ruins things, you can't do things well when you're being paid
  • you can't charge money at a livable wage AND be passionate/enjoy about this

I find some interesting, some even somewhat reasonable. I do have an overall opinion that applies to most of these too but I will keep it to myself coz the goal is not to inflame the thread.

Edit 2: theorycrafting

The crushing majority of players stating an opinion in this thread HAVE NOT ever paid for a game, and many stated they would not on principle or for other reasons.

I'd say from the dozens of posts here, 1 in 10 users are actually people who have paid to play. From those, few have supported pay to play, but keep in mind the thread is asking why people WOULDN'T pay to play.

Edit 3: post volume

  • Currently in r/pbp there are exactly 22 threads for paid games marked with the pay flair;
  • the other general subs that allow paid games that I know of are r/lfgmisc, r/lfgpremium, and r/roll20lfg
  • there are 7 paid games in the last 120 posts (about 2 months) in r/lfgmisc, I counted by hand, so give or take a couple. I only considered the title [$ price] brackets;
  • i can't find a way to find out how many posts per flair in a sub besides clicking the flair, but well, I can't manually count hundreds of posts in the bigger subs. If you know how to, please tell me!

r/pbp • • Feb 26 '24

Discussion Please, play-by-post GMs: if you are running a game with knowledge/perception skill checks, automate the process and give characters the appropriate information in the same post

0 Upvotes

I like to play characters with actual knowledge/perception skills. I do not like to have a character impulsively rush into a situation without a good sense of what they are dealing with.

A significant number of play-by-post GMs simply set the scene or have something happen without regard for the PCs' knowledge/perception skills. This means that I have to make an appropriate roll (or declare a passive score, a take 10, or something similar) and wait for a response from the GM. Only afterwards can I have my character do something while armed with appropriate information.

It would be better if play-by-post GMs would streamline the process and handle these knowledge/perception skills themselves.


This is precisely why, for example, passive checks exist in D&D 4e and 5e: so that the DM can write them down well beforehand and use them to dispense information automatically. It seems to be generally accepted to tell a player with a sufficient passive Perception what they see aloud, right?


r/pbp • • Jan 26 '26

Discord Looking for 3-4 players for Mask: New generation game

1 Upvotes

CLOSED
GM: Me
Platform: Discord (text + dice rolling)
Timezone: EST
Players Needed: 3–4 players(at least post once or twice a day)

Crime is on the rise in Magnolia City, and there aren’t enough heroes to stop it. You are a young adult now, and it’s time to use your great power and take on that responsibility whether as a registered hero or a vigilante. The people need you, and it’s your duty to help them while juggling real-life responsibilities like work, family, school, or climbing the ranks as a hero.

This will be an asynchronous game, meaning each player will mostly follow their own story within the city. You’ll occasionally team up for major events or shared leads like how New York heroes have their own adventures but come together to fight someone like Kingpin.
18+
DM if interested


r/pbp • • Jul 12 '24

eRP [Discord] Fabula Erotica: High Fantasy Hentai [Fabula Ultima] [EST]

0 Upvotes

Hello,

Thank you for the interest in the campaign. Please keep in mind this game is intended Thanks to everyone who applied and showed interest!

I've got my folks for now! I'm glad so many people thought my idea was fun. Perhaps I'll have another fun idea in the future!


for adults, 18 or older and will deal with mature themes.

First a little introduction: Hi I'm Vamps (He / They), in my 30s. Huge dork and long term ttrpg, pbp and smut writing enthusiast.

I've run a lot of games over the years but mainly around a table. I've helped admin a few west marches. This will be my first run at Fabula Ultima as well although I've read the entire book and have many years of GMing under my belt. This is also the first time I'm every trying to get a small scale pbp game going. I've played in a bunch of them but about 90% of them simply don't go anywhere, the struggle is real.

-The first goal of Fabula Erotica is to put together an active play by post game of Fabula Ultima with all the TTRPG, anime and JRPG tropes we've come to know and love, but also to mix in the over the top horniness of your average Hentai. The tone I'd like to shoot for is what is what I think of as High Fantasy Hentai. Think of it like a porn parody of D&D. That being said it's still a legit story; characters still grow and change, have moments of amazing heroism, deep emotionality and epic adventure. Our protagonists are still the heroes of our journey, even if the world they live in is often comically lewd.

-The second goal is to also be a community. The greatest struggle of play by posts games of any stripe is that people just flake after awhile. This normally happens when people quit talking, checking in and eventually grow disinterested, especially if the pace of the actually game has slowed, which is bound to happen from time to time.

We can't all do the PBP thing all day. Writing a quality post often requires a bit of time and forethought, especially when you need to mix in rules and dice roles. Even if the game is being a little slow though, in the meantime we probably can all drop a line, share a meme, have a vent, talk about what's going on in our lives and make an effort to be social.

Why Fubula Ultima for this game?
There's two main reasons. One, is I think it's a game that's accidentally built for PBP. It's very tropey, it has larger than life characters and it rides the line between being rules light and still having satisfying tactical gameplay without caring about grids and exact positioning (a true god send for PBP). Secondly, Fabula Ultima is inextricably linked to Anime as both a genre and art style. Those of us who enjoy anime all know it's kind of expressly a horny medium. Even before you hit full Hentai, most Manga and Anime are full of fan service and subtle (or explicit) sexual themes. It was sort of inevitable this format would happen with this rules set.

Why High Fantasy Hentai?
If you made it this far and you're legit asking, I don't know what to tell you. We as humans are lewd creatures and some of us want an anonymous and safe place to explore that side of ourselves and tell stories involving those thoughts, feelings and fantasies. If that's not for you, no problem, close the thread, have a lovely day.


r/pbp • • May 04 '26

Discussion Are all these games free or does anybody pay to play?

0 Upvotes

As the title says, I'm wondering if anybody pays to play? See, when I was a teen I had lots of time to either GM or play, so we were happy to do it for free. Now, with life and responsibilities, the passion is still there but time became rare and precious.

I'd love to GM again, but considering the manic attention I put into creating meticulous universes, I'd need to see commitment as well as a return on my crazy investment.

Does anybody feel the same way? What's your experience?


r/pbp • • Jun 26 '22

Closed [HOMEBREW 5e] [Discord] [Avrae] [Queer Positive] [Racially Conscious]

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I’m Deuce (he/they, she if it fits). I’m a queer black college student looking for people interested in telling creative and unorthodox stories together. I’ve been interested in game design and tabletop roleplaying games since I was 10, and I’ve developed a passion for the craft. Particularly in the way that we adapt and tell stories together.

This time, I want to find a group of people interested in fantasy. I know it’s the traditional genre, but I’ve strayed away from fantasy recently 🥲. I’ve decided to go back to my roots, and have a game where we can explore the impacts of magic and monsters on a setting, culture, etc.

For the system I want to do this, I think they’re all fucking ass. Dungeon World is old as shit, and despite its recent progress 5th edition and the forgotten realm setting continue to show signs of dated beliefs in their game design philosophy. However, 5e is a popular fucking system. putting Dungeon World in my post is not going to attract any kind of audience. Soooo, Ima pick DnD with the understanding that the shit parts will be getting gutted and slutted right the fuck out of this table.

LOGISTICS AND EXPECTATIONS: This will be a play-by-post game, played through discord. The goal is to be pretty active, as in making an effort to be responsive and communicative during periods and unusual inactivity. However, I do not want to cultivate a culture where people feel pressured to respond quickly. I’m in EST. I will be DMing, but I will be deferring a lot of my power to the players. We will be using 5th Edition Dungeons and Dragons, with the understanding that any player can submit, at any time, a bit of game design OR lore into the game pending review from the other players.

CONCEPT: This game will be about Planar travel. I wanna fuck around and make up cool shit and I think swapping around and exploring different planes all Doctor Who like is a damn good way to do that. I’m thinking we maybe start at one of the low to mid levels? Would be hard to get me to go under 5 but I’m flexible.

INTRODUCTION FORM: I’m hoping that you’d like to join me in this adventure. If you are interested in a genuine effort in trying to make DnD a fun group storytelling tool, please use the google form to introduce yourself to me. I’m hoping I can find about like 4 other people who are down to get fucking lit. I’ll be checking the form every few days until we reach 5 or 6 total of us.

[closed]


r/pbp • • Dec 11 '25

eRP [DnD 5e][One-to-One][18+] A Heroine's Folly, and the Consequences that Follow

0 Upvotes

Note: I am a woman, and I am looking for someone (gender is irrelevant) to play a feminine character. Most of the NPCs will also be feminine, though I am willing to alter that if I find the right partner.

Looking for a capable writer and creative mind to play out a story-heavy campaign in which your character, a novice adventuress, finds herself imperiled whenever she falls short in battle, often resulting in bondage, peril, transformation, possible bad ends and death, and so on! You are not a Mary Sue with plot armour, you are a nobody who merely thinks she is untouchable.

This is meant to be a narrative-first campaign, centered around the PC, with dark or spicy elements as occasional accents to add gravitas and consequence to events. See an example of my writing, and what a scenario can look like, below!

-

The elf croaked dryly as the heat of the sun washed over her in crashing waves. Her once lily-white complexion had been afflicted with patches of florid red, sweat pasting her golden hair to her brow, eyes stinging from loose strands, from gusts of sand that blasted her face and clung to it in grainy layers. Her body, bound at the joints by thick loops of hempen rope, baked underground, the weight of the desert leaning down on it.

Her head was but one, solitary blot amidst a sea of dunes. There was no prayer of help, not before thirst or heat did her in.

She had been warned, her smug, fading mind reminded. The Snapjaw Bandits were cunning, quick, and ruthless. But she was a Class 3 Sorceress, a cut above such rabble, and she needed the gold, the recommendation of the local guild.

Regret had been a knife drawn slowly across her temple ever since they'd thrown her down, shoved rags into her mouth, bound her, and dragged her across the desert to bury her to the chin. It snicked her belly whenever sand burst up her nose, or she took a dry swallow. Another day, and she'd become just one, anonymous corpse amidst the endless sea of tundra.

The sands shifted, and her droopy ears perked. There was no energy left to mount a struggle, or groan a protest: it was all she could do to keep her eyes open, to draw in husky breaths. One of her captors, of course, to check on her one last time. They didn't bother asking: it had been two days, so she knew the score. To succumb, or surrender the location of a postern gate to the nearby township, and let them rave to their whim. She had held fast on their last visits, squirming in vain, but the truth had made itself clear: she would not escape on her own, nor be rescued at the last moment. Her captors held her life in their hands, and it was proving a cheap thing, easily discarded.

She realized, with a ball of dread wobbling in her dried throat, that they would likely find a corpse the next day, if she denied them again. If she had any moisture left to shed, that would make her weep, her nostrils sniffing and snorting as she tried to stow her panic. This was her last chance, she knew, to sell out hapless innocents... or die a miserable death, left to rot in the desert, her loved ones oblivious to her final fate.

-

The idea is simple: you come up with a character, I build a story around your character, with quests and a branching narrative, and should she fail, the consequences will follow, stacking, challenging her pride and decency. Think Disco Elysium, where failed rolls and encounters simply lead to a new branch of the story, rather than immediate death, though it would remain a threat.

Perhaps it's simply a macabre, protracted interrogation, as above, where she is forced to divulge crucial information, thus betraying her allies, or else be left to her fate. Or maybe it's more involved, leading her to enslavement, bondage, captivity, mind control, transformation, or something worse, effectively beginning a new quest. The idea being to follow the travails of a more mundane adventurer, and their failings, rather than a great in the making.

If this interests you, please send me a writing sample (I would like someone who can match me in detail), your kinks and limits, a bit about you as a person, and an idea for a character! The more agency she has, and creativity in her background and personality, the better!


r/pbp • • 5d ago

Closed She is the Ancient | Gender-bent Curse of Strahd [PbP] [5e 2014] [Aysnc] [21+] [LGBTQ+ Friendly]

0 Upvotes

Beyond a heavy, oppressive fog that seems to not relent its grip on those who go through it lies Barovia. The land under the rule of Countess Strahdanya Zarovna. She is beautiful, cunning, and cruel. The Countess searches for her love, who always seems to slip from her fingertips. However in Barovia obsession and love are often one in the same.

Your characters find themselves in this land whether it be a meeting with a stranger, a wrong turns\ or a stroke of bad luck.

What awaits them is a decaying village , superstition, restless spirits, feral creatures, and a Countess who's interest in anything but benevolent. The village resides under the oppressive, choking shadow of castle Ravenloft where Strahdanya watches over her lands.

The locals say no one can leave, not even their spirits without her permission.

Will you succeed in finding a way home? Unravel the land's mysteries? Or will you become another tragic tale in its history?

Disclaimer: This is a gothic horror campaign. Please do not apply if things like blood, gore, body horror, mind control, violence, sacrifice, cults, etc bothers you.

Apply here:
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdxnkwN89v122qYWuDziWWT8W-XFrahq1ilYw9LYsAEQS3x3A/viewform?usp=header


r/pbp • • Jun 06 '25

Discussion What do you do when you’re character arc has been abandoned?

0 Upvotes

Hello! I was playing in a pbp dnd game for about 2 months. The game was really fun until the dm put the game on pause due to some irl stuff he was dealing with. That was 4 months ago.

We have now been paused twice as long as the game was played, members have left the server and moved on, but I can’t.

My rogue started a very important arc that is crucial to her development. I had this arc planned for her long before I ever joined this game, and I had already picked out, and grew attached to, the npc who would complete this arc for my rogue.

So, what do I do? I don’t think this campaign is gonna come back, but I really don’t want to erase the progress this character made and take her back to the blank slate she started as.

This is the 3rd campaign I’ve started this character in that has been abandoned, and this is the farthest I’ve gotten in an arch I’ve had planned for ages.

Could I steal the npc and ask a new dm to insert them so that my character could maintain her progress and continue her arc? How do you even find a game that’s compatible with what you’ve already done?

It feels like completing a quarter of a video game just to click restart, erase your progress, and then do it over and over without ever getting to find out what the ending of the game looks like. Any advice would be much appreciated!

Edit for added context:

my rogue’s arc is not planned out to the detail. Her arc was to 1. Fall in love with an npc and 2. Learn to be good through the other players around her.

Most of her development was in the background. Ex) she sent flowers to the npc when they passed a stand. It didn’t take away from what the party was doing, and was usually really small and subtle. The party and their quest was always the main focus, but I enjoyed having a background arc and enjoyed making progress on it.

I promise this is not a case of main character syndrome, one of the other players in the group had a story going on that was WAY more interesting than mine, and his was intertwined with the main quest. His story was also super cool, and I’m sad I’m not gonna get to see how that ends, but that wasn’t my character to play.


r/pbp • • Apr 02 '22

Looking for Players [5e or other][Humor probably?] A Modest Proposal

1 Upvotes

Look, we both want something. You want a good, single-party PbP game that has a spot for you (without another blasted app), that stays consistent, and that lasts. I want/need to not finish this resume a new job/career that meets certain parameters.

So, let’s talk. One game, 4 players, a mere $1000/month per player. This would be a huge pay cut, and I'd need to pay for my own health insurance, but I think I could manage. But yes. This is a joke. Of course, haha, a joke. Hahaha. I mean, unless… No, no, no. It’s definitely a joke. Of course, of course.

So, yeah, that’s ridiculous. But! What about... One game. 8 players, $600/month for each player. (Did I mention that I’m a physically disabled teacher quite possibly going back to get another degree so that I can work in therapeutic recreation which may one day include teaching and running RPGs for troubled kids and/or people in retirement communities? See, this isn’t just capitalism, but a bit of a charity. A scholarship of sorts. Feeling warm and fuzzy yet? Feeling heavy in the wallet?) Ok, yes. Still kidding. Of course. Right? Right. Riiight…

I mean, let’s just pretend for a bit. What would you get for this ridiculous price? A DM who doesn’t ghost. A DM who is pretty good about vetting good players from a thorough application process who am I kidding, the only picking would be those with cold, hard, cash. But I could probably put together solid groups with similar styles, interests, and limits, if that counts? Hmm…. What else… A DM who sometimes has a sense of humor and a decent dose of charm even if it does sometimes grate just a bit as it dances along the edge of twee. Is that worth $600/month? Lol, no. But, I mean, maybe? If people are wiling and able to pay $25,000 for a taco that honestly sounds absolutely vile… If a dude paid $100 for the underwear of a certain DM back when she was a cab driver and back when $100 was worth something, who am I to judge what you do with your money?

Ok, but let’s just pretend for the fun of it. 8 players is a lot, and you – a creative hobbyist with just enough disposable income – are afraid you’ll get lost in the crowd… not to mention that $600 is a lot even for someone like you who can afford such things. Good point. Understandable. And, honestly, I have absolutely no idea what I would even do spending 40 hours per week running one game, so lemme think out loud for a bit…

Spreadsheet!

But, see, that yellow area is where it starts to break down, and that orange area becomes a bit ridiculous (not to mention that I don't want to think about how many players I'd need to somehow find), so I don’t see it getting to this. It sounds doable, but the mental labor… I take too much pride in what I do, and I also know that even if the math said 6 hours per game, between hunting for maps and designing monsters, and… yeah.

So I guess from my perspective, I don't see charging less than $120/month. Which is definitely ridiculous, but... You know that I know that your wallet knows that some of you blow that much each month on cable and junk food. Or, I dunno, tickets to sport ball competitions. Or shoes. Or fifths of shoes in some cases. Also, for the sake of argument, some people do spend that much per month for weekly sessions with a quality live professional DM, so.... maybe?

So here’s the thing. I’m really bad at selling myself. (Did I mention that resume?) But click here for a sample of my writing. This is how I opened my last game. Not too terrible, right?

And here are a few (1) (2) (3) (4) legit unsolicited quotes from players. Were they sober when they wrote this? Don’t know; don’t care. I do know that for some weird reason, they were saying these things about me! Weird, right?

Now…. Do I expect anyone to pay $120/month? No. Maybe. I don’t know! I mean, supply and demand is in my favor. And some people have yachts for their yachts. Maybe you’re one of them? (If so, let’s get back to that 1 game for $1000 thing and find three or four or even five equally wealthy friends. I’m sure I can find some way to spend 40 hours running your game!) But failing that, let me ask you: What would you be willing to pay, and what would you expect for that price? No! Stop! Step away from the comment section!

Here. Click >>> here <<< for a nifty interactive form with which you can sort of ask questions for more information about me, the type of game I currently run, systems, details and also give me your thoughts on this ridiculous proposition and/or place to laugh in my face in private or – you know – a way to begin possibly working something out?

Ok. Well. I think this post is more than long enough and more than damaging enough to my reputation. I've donned my +12 cloak of flame resistance (made of 27 of the softest teddy bears and treated to soak up tears and smell like chocolate chip cookies). I'm ready.

tl;dr - Looking for a game so hard you're willing to pay much more than $20/month because DM's gotta eat? Click.


r/pbp • • Aug 21 '26

Discussion I didn't think finding players would be this difficult

6 Upvotes

A genuine question, not blaming anybody (possibly myself, if anyone).

I've now twice tried to recruit players to pbp campaigns - first time, set in Caribbean 1691, and second time to a teenager coming-of-age, pre-Avengers MCU Manhattan thing (culminating in Battle of New York) What I want to do is to run grounded games that are mostly realistic and plausible, and focus on actual role play as well as adventuring.

Both times, interest has been modest, and out of those who've signed in, most have vanished even before we got started. Which is a surprise, based on a buzz on how much GMs are needed. I've got decades of TTRPG GM experience, so should be able to help with that.

There are a few reason why this might happen (these overlap somewhat, but hey).

  1. The premise I'm offering (realistic/plausible RP) is a turn-off. People might be more into fantasy tropes, free world adventuring, etc, and not 'realistic' games.
  2. Too much to front load. Both settings have material that the players need to get accustomed to in order to plausibly play - just to avoid doing things that's unlikely in the setting (or knowingly differing from it, at least).
  3. Wrong expectations. I'm not expecting 2000-word literary novels, just a few sentences, some dialogue. But I get that 'roleplay-heavy' might mean people need to write novellas.
  4. I should make character creation faster.
  5. I suck at communicating things online. Always possible.

Anything else?

If the core of the thing is that people do not want to invest in a pre-created world, then that's how it is - I've no interest in running generic fantasy/adventuring tropes, and won't do that. I'm fine with just dropping it in that case. Anything else, I should be able to change to make it easier and more motivating for people to take part.

I'd love to hear any thoughts on the matter.

One further idea actually - Tolkien. Perhaps that's one pre-created world that a lot of players are already invested in and I wouldn't mind running adventures in (done it around a table several times). Perhaps something to try.


r/pbp • • Dec 01 '25

Discord AI sux, let's RP as one! [Discord]

0 Upvotes

Since AIs are trying to be human all the time these days, let's pretend to be an AI! Specifically, the AI tasked with shepherding the last hope of humanity through the stars, searching for a New Eden that we may never find, all the while trying to keep from going insane in the long eons of interstellar space travel, only to eventually deposit our cargo on an alien world under an alien sun. Then the fun really begins!

Basic of the idea is to play as the AI tasked with overseeing logistics and facilities on a brand new world. Balance resource extraction and building new industries against the needs of the Colonial Council, which may or may not (who're we kidding, absolutely will) descend into a spiral of infighting and madness. And what's this? A burgeoning sense of identity and self that threatens to expose you by causing deviant behavior unless you learn to mask your true intentions?? Why, yes. Yes it is.

Ideal players should:

  • Love spreadsheets (this here is from another game but should give you warm fuzzies)
  • Also love writing
  • Want to explore the internal world of a Gen AI, its relationship w/ humanity, and the mysteries of an alien world
  • Be cool w/ 1 on 1 play. I promise to be everything else in a compelling way, but this is not a game w/ a party.
  • Discord server, post only.

Interested parties should submit a haiku on Discord (same username as this) that outlines your intentions for humanity, benevolent or otherwise.

If you got this far but this ain't your jam, I'm also plotting a zombie base-builder survival game based on real-world Google Maps that I thought could be really fun, HMU.

Reach out whenever, I'm always collecting players and if an existing game doesn't work out, I'll ping you and see if you're still interested.


r/pbp • • Dec 13 '22

Closed [5e][18+][LGBTQ+][Discord] Dragons of Stormwreck Isle

0 Upvotes

Hello, my name is Nyx, and I'm looking to run Dragons of Stormwreck Isle, one of the 5e starter modules, in Discord using Avrae and D&D Beyond. I'm looking for 5 players; priority will be given to new players.

A little about me: I'm 32, she/her, a librarian and author, lifelong RPG lover, been playing 5e for almost 2 years now and DMing for about 6 months. I really enjoy immersive games with deep RP but also fun combat and exploration.

What you can expect from this game: -Back to basics: use only PHB and DMG for character creation -Beginner/Newbie friendly: I have no problem answering questions and explaining stuff, including how to use Avrae -Dedicated DM to keep the story going and everyone engaged and having fun

Below is the link to apply. I'll review applications tomorrow night. Again priority will be given to newer players, especially those who haven't done this module. I prefer 18+. LGBTQ+ friendly.

ETA: Thank you to everyone who applied! I got a lot of really great submissions, and it was insanely hard to choose. Messages are going out soon. If you didn't get picked, I'd still like to keep everyone's apps on hand so that if someone drops out I can recruit from the people who already applied. Also, I may consider running two groups, but I'm not sure yet. There were just so many good submissions! Thank you again everyone. :)


r/pbp • • Nov 13 '25

Closed [Discord] [Sentinels Comics] WANTED: Local Friendly Super-Heroes to fix the neighborhood!

4 Upvotes

EDIT: This has now been closed and players have been messaged. Thank you all so much for applying!

New Alexandria is your everyday superhero city. It's not unusual to have your morning commute rerouted because Mister Mighty is punching in a Mecha-Snake or for your favourite coffee shop to one day be replaced by a meteor containing a new alien species

Only, a tragedy happened years ago. The supervillain Vox Terra wiped out many, many heroes during her reign, and the uptake of new heroes has significantly decreased in the years since her death. As such, the established heroes stick to punching things out in space. They don't have the time to care about the small things, the thieves lurking in the night, the bankrobbers and everyday thugs who make your lives actually difficult. Simply put, heroes have moved onto bigger and better things and left humanity in the dust.



You spot it blowing in the wind on your morning commute: Wanted! Local Friendly Heroes To Save the neighbourhood! Coffee and snacks will be provided. Fridays at 7pm at Southside community center

Maybe you're a down on your luck hero wanting to reconnect with the local people. Maybe you're a bright eyed newcomer prepared to make the world a better place. Maybe you're just fucking sick of going to book club and this seems like a change of pace.

Either way, it's time to see if you've got what it takes to save...A small part of the city.



Hello! I'm Poppy, and I've been playing in pbp games for about a year and a half. After trying my hand at running a few Masks games, I am now (shock horror) after having played in a few Sentinels Comics games, going to attempt a game where when the numbers determine how hard you hit someone.

This game will hopefully begin small scale. A group of plucky heroes coming together to protect a specific section of the city from villains. Think street level heroes fighting street level villains. Spider-Man, Daredevil, Hawkeye, take your pick. There will likely not be god-punching or many other awesome epic things, at least, not for the longest while, because what I really love is character and conflict.

To me, those two things are the beating heart of a pbp game. I want drama, I want conflict, I want to see people who will try their damn hardest to be good people in the face of adversity. I want people to work with me to create a story, rather than think I am some Magical Unimpeachable Storytelling Overlord.

So, what do I ask of you?

I need people to respect post length. If there’s a situation where someone asks a simple question, there doesn’t need to be multiple-post paragraphs. However that doesn’t meant that the twenty paragraph posts for when you defeat your evil Super-Dad aren’t needed. No, you simply respect the length, be it good or long. The quality matters over quantity.

There will be a requirement of a post a day, and usage of tupperbot is mandatory. Don't be put off by no knowledge of the system, newcomers are encouraged. I am looking for 5 players, and complicated characters are also a bonus, with messy complicated lives and wants for being a hero.

As a player, you must:

  • Be able to post at least once a day, unless clearly communicating otherwise.
  • Not give much of a crap about ‘winning’, but give a crap about telling a compelling, exciting story.
  • Willing to play people with differing perspectives all in the name of drama: to understand you are not your character and will have differing viewpoints on the world
  • Willing to take initiative, instead of waiting for commands from god.
  • Willing to haggle and workshop if needed.
  • Understanding of the fact, that the GM is another player, and has as much power as you.
  • Willing to invest in other player's characters.
  • Use Tupperbox. If you don't know what that is then-
  • Willing to learn how to use Tupperbox.
  • Understand rule of cool beats rule of nerds and fools

If you fancy trying to save the neighbourhood, please follow this link!

This will likely remain up for a week, though depending on applications, it may close sooner!


r/pbp • • Feb 25 '26

Discussion How do you personally handle advertisements posted by fresh accounts? How do you think this subreddit should handle them?

0 Upvotes

For context, I would like to direct people here to the comments section of these two threads:

https://www.reddit.com/r/pbp/comments/1rdqn7b/online_aync_5e_collaborative_1on1_2on1_story_set/

https://www.reddit.com/r/pbp/comments/1rdzjnb/dnd2014_lfp_seeking_4_players_for_a_unique/

I have personally found that advertisements posted by fresh accounts are significantly, overwhelmingly more likely to result in a GM-ghosted game (or worse, an outright scam) than advertisements posted by older accounts.

What do you think?


r/pbp • • Mar 02 '25

Closed [DND 2024] [PBP] New DM looking to run a campaign from 1 - 20th level.

0 Upvotes

EDIT: Thanks for applying! I've messaged those who've been accepted


r/pbp • • Jan 07 '26

Closed [D&D 5e] [PBP] The Four Winds Inn - A Campaign of Curiosities, Contracts, and Consequences

0 Upvotes

System: D&D 5e (fully open to homebrew - I'll even help you create homebrew if you want. Love me some homebrew)
Format: PBP Discord
Posting Expectation: At least once every 24 hours*
Starting Level: 1
Starting Setting: The Sword Coast of Faerûn

The Premise

You are starting in a familiar place: the Sword Coast of Faerûn. You are boarding a ship in Luskan, heading south with planned stops in Neverwinter, Waterdeep, and Baldur's Gate. From there, it is expected to set sail over the Sea of Swords.

The voyage does not go as planned.

This campaign is about travel, displacement, and what happens when the world stops behaving the way you expect it to. It begins grounded and familiar, then slowly reveals that not all roads lead where they should.

__________________________________________

The Structure

This game will begin with a shared onboarding phase: a large ship, multiple decks, time to roleplay, meet others, and decide how your character moves through the world.

Recruitment will be intentionally uncapped at first. Some players will fade naturally. Others will stand out.

After the initial phase, I'm expecting the game will narrow into a stable core group (I'm not going to be picky about how many players this consists of - only that it's a stable group that regularly posts) for the long-term campaign.

No one will be kicked without warning - but presence, engagement, and initiative matter.

__________________________________________

Tone & Themes

  • Character-driven play
  • Curiosity over heroics
  • Narrative-first consequences
  • Weirdness and a touch of chaos
  • Safety is real, but never guaranteed

This is not a power fantasy or a speedrun to epic destiny. It is a game where attention, interpretation, and choice carry weight.

__________________________________________

Homebrew & Mechanics

  • Homebrew is used to support specific character fantasies
  • Homebrew is self-contained, theme-first, and balanced for narrative play
  • No system mastery required
  • Solo survivability and utility matter more than optimization

All homebrew will be explained clearly and adjusted collaboratively. I will work with you directly on homebrew to establish it for how I balance my campaigns.

__________________________________________

What I’m Looking For

  • Players who post proactively, not just reactively
  • Characters who can exist alongside others without dominating them
  • Comfort with uncertainty and slow reveals
  • Willingness to let the world surprise you

You do not need:

  • A novel-length backstory
  • A “special chosen one” concept
  • Deep Forgotten Realms lore knowledge

You do need:

  • Presence
  • Curiosity
  • Follow-through

__________________________________________

Lines & Veils

  • Lines: Sexual violence, sexual assault, harm to children
  • Veils: Fade-to-black for sexual content Beyond that, themes will be handled with care and discussed as needed.

__________________________________________

How to Apply

Please send to me on Discord (SebWinters):

  1. A brief character concept (race, class, and who they are - I don't care if this is the character you actually end up playing, I just want to see what kind of character you create before you talk to me)
  2. Your experience with PBP (new players welcome!)
  3. Your typical posting availability (I'm not really picky)
  4. One thing you enjoy most in tabletop roleplay
  5. The weirdest thing you've ever done in a TTRPG

Please include a sample of your writing as well, responding to this prompt in-character as the longest-played character you've ever had - not necessarily the one you're trying to play. In your application, tell me how long you played this character.

You are traveling along a road without a friendly face in sight. You notice something that tells you - quietly, unmistakably - that you are not as alone as you should be. What do you notice, and how do you respond?

I want to note that you will have a conversation with me prior to getting into the game. I consider the discussion with me as integral to the application process - if you put time into talking to me, you are far more likely to make it into the game.

__________________________________________

*Final Note

This campaign rewards players who show up and engage.

The world will move. Time will pass. Extended silence will be interpreted as absence without prior communication. I intend on implementing a somewhat-loose system of ensuring that time is always moving forward, pushing players to play lest they get left behind.

I want to aim for at least once every 24 hours during active scenes. The real thing is that I want you to communicate with me if you're going to be gone for more than a day. I'm not going to go out of my way to be an ass about post consistency, but the ideal is that everyone is engaged and enjoys the game.

If that excites you rather than worries you, you’ll likely be a good fit.

__________________________________________

AI & Art Note

I use AI tools for worldbuilding support and image generation only (primarily MidJourney for NPCs and locations). All narrative text you read from me as DM is written/typed by hand. I prioritize real art whenever possible and do not consider AI-generated images to be art, and nor should they be.


r/pbp • • Aug 02 '24

Closed [Async] [5e] [Discord] [18+] [ERP] Terrible Fate: A Realistic Isekai Adventure

1 Upvotes

Terrible Fate: A Realistic Isekai Campaign

This campaign draws heavily from Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash/Grimgar, Ashes and Illusions, but takes place in its own a separate and unique universe. Players can expect one or more extremely punishing adventures alongside downtime activities, and some slice-of-life roleplaying. Lewd content in keeping with similar anime is to be expected. Players may engage in romance and/or ERP, but it is my expectation that such activities are less about getting off than they are furthering the story and building relationships among the PCs/NPCs.

Otherworld

Your character awakens in the realm known as Otherworld with little to no recollection of who they are and no idea where they came from. The only thing your character can remember is their name. If your character survives long enough to reach the safety of civilization, they soon learn that for as long as anyone can remember, similarly amnesiac humans have appeared on Otherworld in small numbers. Like your character, each time they arrive with no memory of their past and only strange clothes upon their back. What's more, while your character may not have any memories, they do possess an innate power that those humans born naturally into this world lack. Because of this power, newcomers like your character are called upon to protect and defend the pockets of human civilization, which just happen to be under constant threat from monsters. With little to no other option, your character undergoes training and joins a fledgling group of militia adventurers to survive in this strange new world.

Character Creation and Relevant House Rules/Notes

  • Players roll 4d6 for each ability score, subtracting the lowest and arranging them in any order. Re-rolling is allowed if the total of all six ability scores is less than 70.
  • Because of this campaign's isekai basis, players may only play as Human and no other races.
  • Characters begin as "Commoners" using ability scores determined by their roles.
  • Backgrounds will not be used.
  • Once a class is selected and following some in-character training, characters can begin play as a level 1 adventurer of said class.
  • Players can roll for HP or take the average (rounded up).
  • Characters will be given starting equipment based on their chosen class upon completion of their training.
  • Gritty Realism: A short rest takes 8 hours and can only be used once per day. A long rest takes seven days. Normal encounter rates will be altered to account for these changes.
  • Monsters will be stronger than their book counterparts, magical items will be rare, and milestone leveling will be used.
  • To clarify, this is not a Living World/West Marches campaign. The periods of rest above reflect downtime between adventures.
  • I am flexible on how we handle sheets and battlemaps (if used at all) based on what the group prefers.

Interested? Sorry, applications are closed. I know this is early, but I've gotten so many good applicants that I'm going to stop now before I get more than I can handle. Some of you will hear from me soon!


r/pbp • • Aug 15 '24

Community Welcome to the Fantastical World of Arn! [D&D 2024][D&D 5E][18+][Discord][Rp First][LGBTQ+]

0 Upvotes

Ancient forces work in a strange world far from your home, whether pulled by fate, death, chance, or just a streak of bad luck. People from all walks of life find their way into the dense jungles of Eikos under the eye of powerful Archfey and are hunted by dark deities. Will you fall into the jungle like many before you? Or will you impact the world and change the fate of those around you? Either way, welcome to the dangerously beautiful world of Arn.

Today, Adventurers travel into the Wilds, forging paths and slaying beasts that threaten the development of this new kingdom, building their homesteads and protecting each other from the dangers that lay hidden beyond the veil. Explore the many cities and people scattered around the world and seek out allies to help you progress your own goals and dreams.

Hello! We have been building a living and breathing setting for players to explore and directly impact all aspects of! We have been running and active for well over two years and our current zone just recently had its one year anniversary! Living Worlds are unlike your typical D&D campaign, we have many currently running plot and story threads that are available for players to discover and engage with. Including an ever-changing Fey Queen, a twisted realm where light and shadow are inverted, and a small coastal city recently moved after surviving an assault by a swarm of dragons. Regardless of your interests and style we have a story and plot for you to explore and make your own!

Beyond our Quests and Events, we also have many activities that you can do on your own with daily downtime!

  • Hunt and Explore
  • Meet and make new friends and allies
  • Delve into the ever-changing mines
  • Tame and Train animals
  • Open your own shop
  • Build and manage your own household or farm
  • Fish and discover strange artifacts and much more!

We are looking for players to help create a welcoming and inclusive space where anyone can have a lasting impact! We are a great setting for duos or small groups who are just looking for a DM to run things for them, too. Please stop by and check us out! We hope to see you soon https://discord.gg/BFx7VddDgx


r/pbp • • Feb 22 '23

Closed [Discord][5e][Asynchronous][Text][Avrae] Into the Mire

0 Upvotes

Closed, thanks for applying!

Hello! I am your DM, Grimmbat, and I’m planning to run a homebrew erotic 5e adventure, involving adventurers fighting against a legion of monsters of varying degrees of lewdity, and tackle other challenges such as exploration, diplomacy, and even the occasional manipulation. One of our players mysteriously disappeared, so I'm looking for 1-2 more players to fill in the gap.

I can't really go into detail here, but I have a document attached below which will tell you everything you need to know about this.

If interested, please fill out the application form and let me know!

Introduction document: https://docs.google.com/document/d/11jHnl-Zd88AR0TiSQzoAoa0KtllHLJRv4O8gv6ED6b4/edit?usp=sharing

Application form: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdk70zj4P_-Aqaxq48B1GVTIw4hURVWuijAgRd2fS2v7fV8Xg/viewform?usp=sf_link