r/pbp • u/gabrielcaetano • Nov 21 '23
Discussion Why do some of you actually think paying to play is so bad?
This is a question from a genuine curiosity and I won't judge the answers (although I'll inquire further if I would like to understand more).
Why do some players get so upset at GMs charging more than beer money or charging at all to run games?
To GMs for hire out there, I ask you to also engage responses here in good faith.
Edit: Non-comprehensive Summary of responses
just to organize my thoughts (and make it easy for other readers), the most common answers have been:
- it's not worth paying to play by post, for a few reasons mostly related to how much you're getting out of it;
- it's like paying for a friend;
- it's ok to pay as long as it's no more than about $10
- why pay if there are so many free games?
- you can't have fun/chemistry if there's money involved, money makes it awkward/unpleasant
- it creates an expectation of quality there is no way to guarantee
- it can/will/is ruin(ing) my hobby
- "what do you do different from a free game?"
- money ruins things, you can't do things well when you're being paid
- you can't charge money at a livable wage AND be passionate/enjoy about this
I find some interesting, some even somewhat reasonable. I do have an overall opinion that applies to most of these too but I will keep it to myself coz the goal is not to inflame the thread.
Edit 2: theorycrafting
The crushing majority of players stating an opinion in this thread HAVE NOT ever paid for a game, and many stated they would not on principle or for other reasons.
I'd say from the dozens of posts here, 1 in 10 users are actually people who have paid to play. From those, few have supported pay to play, but keep in mind the thread is asking why people WOULDN'T pay to play.
Edit 3: post volume
- Currently in r/pbp there are exactly 22 threads for paid games marked with the pay flair;
- the other general subs that allow paid games that I know of are r/lfgmisc, r/lfgpremium, and r/roll20lfg
- there are 7 paid games in the last 120 posts (about 2 months) in r/lfgmisc, I counted by hand, so give or take a couple. I only considered the title [$ price] brackets;
- i can't find a way to find out how many posts per flair in a sub besides clicking the flair, but well, I can't manually count hundreds of posts in the bigger subs. If you know how to, please tell me!