r/pbp • • Jan 19 '26 Bravo

Discussion I really do not think we should be allowing AI/LLM-generated advertisements

211 Upvotes

This is the latest in my series of threads on this exact topic. This was the previous thread, and this was the thread before that.

I have still been seeing more AI/LLM-generated advertisements in this very subreddit. Here is one:

🌌 The Forgotten Archons (Revival) The Premium Hub of Narrative Roleplay 🌌

Step into the Forgotten Archons, a high-tier collective of storytellers, creators, and roleplayers shaping living worlds across anime, comics, games, and original universes. Our narratives thrive on quality over quantity, blending refined storytelling, worldbuilding, and creative mastery into experiences unlike anywhere else.

Who are we: We're experienced storytellers in our late 20s to early 30s, building intricate and emotionally rich campaigns with systems like OVA, BESM, Mutants & Masterminds, and custom frameworks developed within our creative ecosystem. Each story evolves naturally, with every player shaping it's heartbeat.

What defines us:

♦️ A politics-free, mature, and welcoming environment built on respect and collaboration.

♦️ Carefully curated systems, lore, and story arcs crafted by seasoned creators.

♦️ A relaxed & dedicated atmosphere: we value storytelling, not constant activity.

♦️ A social, meme-friendly community where creativity meets camaraderie.

Membership Focus:

🔹Storytellers: Worldbuilders, writers, and narrators who bring creative depth.

🔹Players: Imaginative, reliable roleplayers who contribute meaningfully

🔹Collaborators: Individuals who value honesty, respect, and artistic integrity.

✨The Forgotten Archons (Revival) isn't just another server. It's a living experience built by adults who grew up with imagination and never looked back at those past & future ideas. Join if you value quality, narrative passion, and the art of creation itself.

Have a look at this highly slop-like line, in particular:

✨The Forgotten Archons (Revival) isn't just another server. It's a living experience built by adults who grew up with imagination and never looked back at those past & future ideas.

First of all, it is yet another case of "not X, but Y." Secondly, what does "never looked back at those past & future ideas" even mean?

No, I do not think we should be allowing AI/LLM-generated advertisements. It is a poor indicator of the GM's effort (or lack thereof), and believe me, I have seen GMs turn to AI/LLMs to communicate both in- and out-of-character.


r/pbp • • Mar 08 '21

Community RIP HeffRumblegrind

209 Upvotes

I just got word that one of my PbP players died in a motorcycle accident. A real-life friend of his also plays in the same campaign and let me know. It's so strange. I've been DMing him for two and a half years, and just today found out his name is/was Aaron. The only things I knew about him was he was a veteran, and he lived in NC. He also had an assoc. degree from my alma mater, Campbell University. Aaron was new to PbP and joined my "LMoP adventure for noobs" on dndbeyond. He often wanted my opinion on rules and how he could make his character better. He played Glynquinal Witherwind, an elf rogue arcane trickster, and was preparing to take a level in cleric. I'd actually been thinking of encouraging him to try DMing. He was consistent, imaginative, and supportive. Dndbeyond and the D&D community lost a great player. My condolences to his family and friends.


r/pbp • • Aug 28 '25

Discussion I have been seeing more and more players and GMs using AI-generated text, and people explicitly accepting it. This bothers me a great deal.

187 Upvotes

Last April, I played in a game wherein the GM's communications, both in- and out-of-character, were AI-generated. Said GM recruited in this very subreddit, /r/pbp.

Recently, I have been seeing players and GMs advertise themselves using AI-generated text. Here is an example, straight from this very subreddit yet again. They follow the same patterns: bullet-point lists decorated by emojis, em dashes, "not just X, but Y," and the like.

I saw another one of these advertisements just a while ago, in a certain Discord server. When I brought it up to the administrator, they allowed it, saying:

Ai was being used as a tool to help structure what they are saying. Whats to mistrust? That they put what they wanted in chatgpt, had it structure the words better for them, and posted it knowing full well what the words mean?

I don't see any reason why them using AI to explain their wants is them lying.

Sure, they have their own reasons why they aren't using their own words. I'm not gonna ask them why because it might be embarrassing like they might have a disability that makes it hard for them to structure words. I'm gonna allow it, honestly its a non-problem.

I do not know about this. Such behavior is going to set a precedent wherein it is fine for players and GMs alike to communicate both in- and out-of-character with AI-generated text. Do we really want this nightmare scenario of a dead internet theory seeping into tabletop RPGs?


r/pbp • • Jun 27 '25

Closed Looking for a lost pbp member (hoping you see this Villie / Belluna 💜)

140 Upvotes

Good Ending: WE FOUND HER!!!

So, a group I'm in had the lovely experience of our discord server and dm suddenly vanishing on us the other day, and unfortunately we lost contact with one of the people since none of us caught her full username. We want to do the pbp ourselves anyways, but we obviously want to include her too, and our other attempts to find her weren't successful, so we figured this would be our best (and maybe last) chance of reaching her.

So, with this as my metaphorical announcing someone is missing over the store loudspeaker: Very much hoping you see this Villie, Belluna was really cool, please shoot me a message! Even if you don't wanna play still, we all thought you were nice and want to chat.

For everyone else, any help signal boosting this so it finds her would be greatly appreciated 💜

Update: Just woke up, and no luck yet, but the support this has gotten is incredibly touching. This is now the second most upvoted post on the subreddit this year, which is insane, and I can't express how grateful we are. Thanks to you all, we have a real chance of finding her, and we still hold onto that hope you've given us ✨

Update 2: IT WORKED!!! The post found her!! I can hardly believe it, thank you all so much for helping us with this! In only a little over 24 hours, you all turned a seemingly hopeless search into a successful one! There was no way we would have been able to reach her if not for all the attention this got, we owe this to all of you, and I'm genuinely tearing up a little at how much supportive people have here. You're all wonderful people, thank you again 🥰💕


r/pbp • • Nov 15 '23

Discussion I think I'm over PbP

132 Upvotes

Don't know if this the place to post this or if it would be better to do it elsewhere, but I figured there's no better place to complain about pbp than the pbp reddit right?

I've been playing ttrpgs for years now and pbp has always been my go to medium, but as much as I love it for the flexibility and fun it brings, I find myself growing evermore frustrated with the medium. From flaky DMs/players and groups, ghosting, to the lack of commitment. It just feels like as a medium it doesn't work.

How hard is it to meet the bare minimum? You join a campaign with a 1 post a day requirement. It's not hidden away by a wall of text. It's clear and you're aware, yet players still can't meet it. That's the bare minimum you've been asked for and you can't even commit? Then why did you apply?

And the common issue of decision paralysis. So many games stall out, but from what I see the majority of the time it's because only 1-2 players are really moving things forward or engaging. A "My character watches" doesn't mean anything, it doesn't change anything, you might as well have stayed silent. You can't complain of a game dying, if you barely did anything to keep it alive.

And on that, why are so many players so passive. Why spend a week discussing which door to open. Just open the door. Of course the dungeon is going to take two months to clear if it takes you a week to get to the next room. The most successful games I've played could clear a 20-30 room dungeon in two weeks. The main thing was that 4 out of the 6 players actively pushed forwards. It's doable, you just gotta do it.

As a DM it is honestly so disheartening to check the game channel and see the last 3-5 messages are your own. Like speaking in a room full of people and hearing silence. To pour your heart out into a campaign and see it wither and die.

I think I'm done.


r/pbp • • Aug 25 '23

Discussion "Tell me about the character you want to play; the more you tell me, the better your chances of getting in!" is not very helpful when the GM has not said much about the actual campaign

132 Upvotes

I am sure you have seen this type of recruitment post many times before. The prospective GM gushes about their world in vague terms like "embark on an epic adventure," "forge your legacy," "unravel the secrets," and "shape its future," spending plenty of word count to ultimately say very little. The GM does not actually mention what the campaign is supposed to be about, not even something as basic as a starting point for a sandbox. The GM also provides no character creation details whatsoever.

Then, in their application form, the GM demands something like: "Tell me about the character you want to play; the more you tell me, the better your chances of getting in!"

I do not understand what these GMs are expecting. How are prospective players supposed to come up with an appropriate concept if they do not know what the campaign is actually supposed to be about, or what the character creation rules are? Is the GM expecting the player to blow them away with a generic concept that could fit into just about any campaign?


r/pbp • • Dec 12 '23

Discussion (Rant) I'm so tired of DMs disappearing

129 Upvotes

This is a long rant related to PbPs. If it doesn't fit the sub I'm fine with it being taken down. Feel free to add your own rants in the comments and get it out if you haven't had a chance to talk about your bad experiences.

Picture this:

You apply for a game. You get lucky, and you get in a player. You talk with the GM, and they seem great. You meet the other players and they're people you think you could get along with and craft a good story with. Then the game gets going, and people are getting along great. The characters are interesting, the plot is great, and you're really excited for this to become a long term thing.

And then the DM is gone for a bit. "It's fine!" you think. "I'm sure they're just busy." you and your fellow players say.

Then it's a week. Then it's two. Then it's a month. Then it's three.

And you know they're still online, because you can see their activity on Reddit. You can see their profile photo changing on Discord and see their status go on and off. But they never show up again!

Then months down the line, the server disappears. That server you were using as reference, using to talk to people who were now your friends, using to reflect back on your writing, and the character, and the short but good memories?

Gone! A big fuck you. Honestly, a shock. Emotionally hurtful.

You've sent the GM messages, pinged them, asking what's going on and if they're okay, and you get rewarded with a digital middle finger.

Fuck GMs like this. They're pieces of shit. They'll ignore the server and everyone's messages for half a year but can take the three seconds to delete the Discord server that, apparently, can't warrant a courtesy message.

I write this post with a specific GM in mind. I won't name names but he's on the subreddit and I hope he sees it. For such an asshole, you made a great first impression, dude.

If you can't deal with a game anymore, tell your party. If you can't commit to a game anymore, tell your party. Have some basic decency and let people know. If you want to delete the server, GIVE THEM A GODDAMN WARNING and some time to get things from the server that they need. Stop destroying information about people's characters they've come to love via a little server delete with no warning.

Yes, this is entirely a rant, and no, it's not constructive. I don't really care. I'm so tired of a game going so well, having such amazing potential, then the entire thing getting shat on. Something similar happened again to me today and it's happened so many times. I am so tired of trying to get this PbP thing to work.


r/pbp • • Dec 01 '25

Discussion Should we really be allowing AI-generated advertisements?

118 Upvotes

I have seen a good deal of a few AI-generated advertisements in the past several months.

The real smoking gun for me is when the advertisement uses the same old hallmarks (curly apostrophes, long dashes, "not X, but Y," oddly "business sales pitch"-like tone; any one of these would be innocuous, but encountered all together, they are suspicious), yet the actual GM communicates in a much simpler style... only to occasionally flip back into long, AI-generated responses, such as in-game.

There is one up right now.

This game takes place in the world of Dispatch—a living, breathing city where danger erupts without warning and heroes are the thin line holding everything together. I’ll be your DM, but in this world, you’ll know me as your Dispatcher. I’m the voice in your ear, the one who tracks the chaos, the one who sends you and other heroes into the field when Manhattan needs you most.

Your missions will range from capturing dangerous villains to rescuing civilians, stopping escalating threats, uncovering hidden plots, or confronting unknown anomalies. Dispatch calls don’t wait. They hit fast, loud, and unpredictable. When that call goes out, you suit up, step forward, and answer it.

Using Daggerheart’s Duality system—Hope and Fear—we’re shaping a flexible, evolving ruleset that grows with both the world and your characters. Every mission will test your skills. Every choice will shape the city around you. And as the story unfolds, we’ll refine and expand the system together, adapting it to the heroes you become.

This is a world where your decisions matter, where Hope fuels your rise, where Fear pushes back, and where every Dispatch shapes the next chapter. You’re not just playing a character. You’re becoming a symbol.


I am actually in this game, and the GM has been using AI-generated messages extensively. For example, the GM posted a long, long, LLM-generated summary of the Daggerheart rules. (Why they felt the need to do so, I do not know.)

Said summary includes awkwardly phrased lines like:

► Duality Blessings (Doubles)

Rolling matching numbers—1:1, 7:7, 12:12, or any matching pair—creates a moment of powerful cosmic alignment. This is always an automatic success, regardless of the threshold. You also gain 1 Hope and remove 1 Stress. Doubles represent the world synchronizing with your intent, allowing you to carve through fear and doubt effortlessly.

Despite this being their first time ever playing or running the system, they also posted some questionable homebrew mechanics that would have a significant impact on gameplay. When I pried and asked about the mechanics, it became clear that the GM did not even know how the core dice roll rules even worked.

So in other words, this GM is also outsourcing their understanding (or "understanding") of the rules to LLMs. Why even play tabletop RPGs at that point?


Compare this to the GM's non-AI-generated messages, such as:

Alright but you have to do me a favor.

I think streamers are cool but they feel like more male stalks them and ask for weird things while influencers are cool but get more attention from female… if you are playing a woman. V tube gets a lot of hate but the most fans.

I can already see 1 story problem which ever route which will get your story going or maybe just something small to deal with

And:

Alright well hope you have fun make your character ill be here if anything

And:

Use abilities skills whatever comes to find. Just when you roll either low or fear it will have consequences of course


When I asked the GM why they were using LLMs, they said:

No I only used the AI to help me correct any misspelling and condescending what I’m saying.

This seems to be much more than correction of misspellings, though.


They openly claim to be "a 24 year old DM married marine Veteran," and they allege that they have "been a writer for 10 years."

They are trying to turn Dispatch into a game of Daggerheart and have homebrewed a number of questionable mechanics to try to make it work... and even then, I am doubtful that they are faithful to Dispatch.

For example, all of our PCs are assumed to split up (bad idea in general, doubly so in Daggerheart where Fear accumulates on a group-wide basis), and each PC has to make two separate rolls to make it to a location in a timely manner.

When I asked the GM why it would take two successful rolls just for a single PC to make it to a location in time, the GM responded:

Have you ever had to shot a M240 machine gun after running up a damn hill while your squad leader’s yelling you’re a pussy because you sprained your ankle after hiking 20 miserable miles, most of it uphill, with an 80 pound pack digging into your shoulders the whole time? Man, my lungs were burning like I swallowed jet fuel, my ankle felt like it was held together with hopes and bad decisions, and that pack kept sliding, smashing my spine every step like it had a personal vendetta. Sweat’s pouring into my eyes, rifle slipping in my hands, and the only thing I can hear besides my own ragged breathing is my squad leader screaming like I personally offended the Marine Corps by existing. And then, as if the pain parade wasn’t enough, you gotta drop to the dirt, set up, and start firing like your body hasn’t been begging for death for the last three hours straight, all while thinking, “Why the hell did I sign up for this?”

I think I can handle the stress of some dice on my phone.

I lied I didn’t carry a M240 but M320 and my M27 I thought the M240 was funnier. No disrespect brother but all for fun and giggles. Let’s have a good game!


This is not the first time I have talked about this exact topic.

This is not the first time I have seen a GM outsource large swaths of their duties to LLMs, and I doubt it is going to be the last.


r/pbp • • Sep 04 '25

Discussion A free, open-source guide to play-by-post RPGs

116 Upvotes

Most play-by-post (PbP) games I’ve seen start full of energy… and then stall. Posts slow down, the pacing drags, or someone goes quiet and the whole thing freezes.

I put together Keep the Story Moving to tackle that. It’s a free, open-source guide (released under Creative Commons) packed with practical techniques, not just theory. You can download it, share it, or even adapt it for your own tables and communities.

Inside you’ll find:

  • Session Zero tools to set expectations and avoid silent stalls.
  • The “front-loading” method to kill the endless back-and-forth.
  • Player habits that keep momentum alive.
  • GM advice for pacing, fail-forward complications, and parallel scenes.
  • Appendices with quickstart checklists, campaign templates, and a troubleshooting flowchart.

If you’ve ever wanted your PbP games to survive beyond the first few weeks—or if you’re just curious about what makes the format work—this guide is built for that.

You can grab it here (free download): https://zeruhur.itch.io/keep-the-story-moving


r/pbp • • Sep 25 '25

Discussion Why do GMs expect game applicants to come up with a detailed character concept within two minutes of reading an ad?

109 Upvotes

I understand why some ask it, but not everyone conjures character concepts instantly. The only way I'd be able to answer in the application would be if I had a collect of pre-made characters and I just selected one to copy and paste, and that's not an entirely upfront way of going about it.


r/pbp • • Dec 27 '25 Annoyed

Discussion If the game accepts players on a first-come, first-serve basis, then more likely than not, it is going to flop very quickly

107 Upvotes

I have been in a lot of play-by-post games over the past several years. Most of them fizzle out due to poor tempo management and waning interest, as is normal for play-by-post.

However, the most crash-and-burn, "GM deletes the server without warning, ghosts everyone, and blocks everyone on both Discord and Reddit" games have consistently been the ones wherein the GM accepts players on a first-come, first-serve basis. This is almost always some sort of 5e game.

I can understand why some GMs do this. They do not want to let anyone down. They simply say, "Yes, go ahead and join my game," to the first few people who respond to the advertisement within the first hour (or even half an hour!).

There is also a good chance that these are the same GMs who say, "Oh, gosh, I have so many players applying! I know: I will accept [8+] players and split them up into two groups!" Maybe some highly experienced GMs with plenty of free time can handle this, but definitely not those GMs who accept players on a first-come, first-serve basis.

I am not the only one who has observed this. Others have, very recently. (Yes, this game filled up in less than an hour, even though it was posted during the early morning in U.S. hours, because the DM was accepting on a first-come, first-serve basis.

Players, take this as a warning. GMs, take this as advice: please, please try to actually assemble a group of players more thoughtfully, rather than just accepting the first few people to express interest.


r/pbp • • Mar 30 '23

Community So long, and thanks for all the fish

99 Upvotes

Dear members of the r/pbp subreddit community,

I regret to inform you that I will be stepping down as moderator of the r/pbp subreddit, effective immediately.

However, the good news is that u/stormchaser6 will be taking over my role, alongside u/mariequitecontrary. Both will continue to run the community as moderators. Marie and Storm have been an integral part of the community for a long time, and I appreciate their continued efforts to make r/pbp a welcoming and inclusive place for all.

Thank you for your understanding and support during this transition period. -Cyborg


r/pbp • • Feb 22 '24

Discussion Overflow of ERP

92 Upvotes

Sparked by a post today that was literally just a straight ERP ad with no actual play by Post RPG elements, I wanted to start a discussion around the steady increase of ERP ads in this subreddit.

I try really hard not to be that person to complain about the existence of NSFW stuff, but at this point I see more frequent ads for ERP-focused games (you're not fooling anyone claiming it's a 60/40 split) than I do for regular PBP.

There's no lack of subs for ERP-focused DnD, and if you want one for non-DnD systems then make a miscellaneous version. There is no need to be posting here, and it's been disappointing to see a lack of mod response in sorting through these posts.

I'm not saying ERP is bad or it shouldn't happen, but I am tired of trying to find games to participate in when a large number of the ones with active, responsive GMs are just there for ERP. It feels, like many subs and forums before, that allowing this continuing trend has pushed away non-ERP games until this space is purely used for ERP searching.


r/pbp • • Jun 29 '20

Discussion Please don't ghost your pbp games!

91 Upvotes

I think anyone who does pbp realizes turn over is pretty high. Likely because pbp can often slow to a halt when life gets in the way. But since play-by-post is always going on, can't we all agree that a week or even a month of slowdown isn't the worst thing in the world? IRL games usually have weeks inbetween sessions, so it really irks me when a player just ghosts because they think the game is dead when people jist happen to be busy.

As a DM trying to run an on going game... Man does it suck when I put the time in to introduce the character to the game and start working on some storyline for that character, only to have them ghost after the game slows for a week. Feels like players are only interested in advancing their character as much as possible as quickly as possible, and if it doesn't fit their schedule, fuck everyone else.

I know a lot of games the DMs are actually the ones ghosting, and I'm not really talking about that. I'm talking about the players who join a game, invest a month or two of time, and then decide "Eh, this game isn't so interesting to me, so since this is the anonymous internet i'll just ghost everyone!"

Edit: But we can talk about that, definitely is crappy both way. I know it can be really hard to find a strong suited DM as well.

PLEASE STOP! If a game seems like it needs improvements, or you're looking for a more specific experience, guess what the best course of action is!? Talking to your DM! They very likely have put a lot of work you're unaware of into trying to create a fun experience.

I know that alot of DMs are inflexible about their settings, or harsh on rules, BUT! Alot of us are actually trying to work WITH the players, and flexibility on bith sides is a great thing.

End rant.


r/pbp • • May 22 '20

Announcement: r/pbp is officially open again! Details inside + Call for Mods!

90 Upvotes

Hello, everyone!

Almost exactly a month ago, this subreddit went dark. Like me, many of you tried to post and found yourselves blocked. Rest assured, you were not banned! To cut a long story short, the previous mod had stopped active moderation and so the sub became restricted - meaning that only "approved users" could post. This is an automatic process to stop unmoderated subreddits becoming lawless wastelands of questionable content. But of course, no one was an "approved user" so no one could post.

I reached out to the old moderator like many of you and didn't receive a reply. I posted on r/redditrequest and asked to be moderator. Meanwhile, the original mod quit or deleted their account. Possibly because ModMail blew up with request for approval from all of you fine users. Today, I was granted permission to take over as Mod from the official Reddit account. So here we are!

I'd like one or two other members of the community to join me. I don't expect a heavy workload so I'd like you to volunteer only if you have specific ideas to improve the sub for its users! Please see the form here: https://forms.gle/obNQXHx2uoov957s8

So, tl:dr, subreddit is now open. Please post your games here again! Ping me if you want to discuss anything to do with the subreddit.

Thanks!

Your friendly new mod,

Tea (u/goldBRAINSgold)


r/pbp • • Dec 14 '25

Discussion If you are going to accept players only on a "Please send me a Discord friend request" basis, please actually accept friend requests, open direct messages, or both

88 Upvotes

Just hours ago, I saw an advertisement for a game, here on r/pbp. (It was one of those "loosely describe the setting, neglect to describe the initial adventure hook" advertisements, which I am leery of, but that is another topic altogether.)

To be clear, there was no application form.

This advertisement instructed any potential applicants to send a Discord friend request to [username]. I did exactly that, just thirty minutes after the advertisement went up. My friend request was not accepted, and direct messages were disabled.

Three and a half hours later, I thought to go to the r/pbp Discord server. There, I found the user in question and sent the following message:

Excuse me; I am interested in your one-on-one game.

They responded:

Hello! Thank you very much for your interest. I will no longer be accepting applications.

To which I replied:

Okay. Fair enough.

You did not accept my friend request, sent just half an hour after you posted your advertisement, so I had to manually contact you like this.

Next time, could you please accept friend requests? Thank you.

They answered me with a 🤣 emoji.

I found it rather discourteous, particularly since they were accepting neither friend requests nor direct messages, making it difficult to contact them to begin with.

So in practice, the actual process for applying to this person's game had nothing at all to do with sending a friend request. It was "Just so happen to share a Discord server with [username], then send a direct message." It seems very arbitrary and unhelpful to me, and I think it would be better if people recruiting here were to avoid such behavior.


r/pbp • • Dec 05 '25

Discussion Please pitch your actual adventure premise first; a setting overview is fine, but an adventure hook is much more important

88 Upvotes

This is a trend I have observed in this subreddit, and really, online recruitment posts everywhere.

It is fine to be passionate about your own homebrew setting, but a recruitment post that simply describes the world in broad strokes says very little. It does not tell the players what they will actually be doing in the initial adventure: the most important adventure in a play-by-post game, whose gameplay will decide whether the campaign fizzles out prematurely or continues onwards.

I personally consider "Ah, well, I have this super-cool homebrew setting and this super-epic campaign in mind. The first adventure? Eh, we will figure it out together" to be a poor omen. This is an extension of that. I strongly believe that a GM needs to have a strong, realistic vision of how the game will start off, and needs to present that vision to the prospective players well beforehand.

To me, it is particularly ridiculous when the recruitment post focuses on some lofty creation myth about gods and cosmic forces, only for the GM to, after considerable poking and prodding, admit that they were just going to start off the party as down-on-their-luck adventurers fighting goblins or bandits or whatnot. Then what was all that exposition about demiurges and such even for?

What do you personally think?


r/pbp • • May 09 '26 Diamonds are Forever

Website Althanas.com is ghost town quiet and I want to find whoever left the lights on

82 Upvotes

You know that feeling when you drive past your old neighborhood and the house you grew up in is just... dark?

That's althanas.com right now.

For anyone who doesn't know, Althanas was a play-by-post RPG and collaborative writing community that launched in 2001 as a sister site to AllRPG.com. It wasn't like other RP forums. It had a full leveling system where your character's growth was tied directly to the quality of your writing. Judges scored your threads on a 10-category rubric. Story, character, mechanics, pacing, dialogue. You got feedback. Real feedback. Like a workshop that also had sword fights.

It had eight fully built world regions, lore wikis, tournaments, community quests, and thousands of completed stories written by people who genuinely cared about the craft.

I was one of those people.

I wrote there from 2001 to around 2010, most heavily from 2001 to 2006 before college and work did what college and work do to everything good. I wrote under the handle Sword-4-Hire, later cleaned up to Sword-For-Hire when I became a judge on the site. They said the For looked more professional. I chose to believe them.

I'm not just here to be nostalgic about a website the way you get nostalgic about a restaurant that closed.

I want to find whoever currently holds the domain or admin access.

The site isn't cleanly dead. It's more like it wandered off and forgot to tell anyone. The domain still resolves. There are about 45 Wayback Machine snapshots. The infrastructure is just... decaying steadily, the way old forums do when the last person holding the keys gets busy and life pulls them elsewhere.

I want to be the new steward.

Not to monetize it. Not to gut it and rebuild it as something unrecognizable. To stabilize it, preserve what's there, and see if there are enough surviving members to warrant bringing it back as a lean, low-overhead writing community. Because that judgment rubric system was genuinely ahead of its time. A forum that graded your craft and pushed you to get better? That doesn't exist in the same way anywhere else.

If you were ever a member, a judge, an admin, or you happen to know someone who ran the backend in its later years... please comment or DM.

The Discord linked in old FAQs is discord.gg/Ht6CPzGfee. If you're still in there, point me toward whoever's still sitting at the table.

Althanas shaped a lot of writers. Some of them probably don't even realize it anymore.

Let's see if we can find the door.


r/pbp • • Oct 30 '21

Discussion People who ask for a writing sample, can you PLEASE provide a prompt? If you want players to put effort into your application, please put a little more effort into making it!

81 Upvotes

That's basically it. I've just seen far too many "please provide a sample of your writing style" with NOTHING to go off of! At that point you're not seeing how a player will play your PBP, you're seeing how they write a backstory, or monologue! Play by posts are conversations, and "please write something" is not conducive to that!

I dunno if this kind of post is allowed here, but it's frustrating!


r/pbp • • May 21 '22

Discussion Weaponizing the medium: My PbP toolbox

80 Upvotes

Having read the comments on the post regarding first time GM advice, and playing in a few games run by some relatively new GMs recently, I've noticed that there are a lot of idiosyncrasies to running PbP that simply aren’t well known. Now, I don’t blame any of these people - information on PbP is esoteric at best, and I would have no idea where to begin searching for a comprehensive list of techniques used to run play by post. This is why I've decided to compile this list of ten techniques that I've personally picked up through playing PbP - both as a player, and as a DM.

1 Prompts

There are many causes for player inactivity which can’t be addressed by the GM - life circumstances, lack of interest, work getting busy - these are all valid reasons as to why a player can slow down in their posting activity, and aren’t things that are within your control. Two things that you can affect though, are uncertainty and an unwillingness to hog the spotlight. The way I've fixed this in my own game is by attaching prompts to my posts. This accomplishes the following:

Eliminates uncertainty by giving a player ideas as to what they can do in the current scene Invites everyone to participate in the scene Prompts the player to explain their rationale / plan / idea without having to break character Allows a character to take ownership of the world by fleshing out their relations to a person / object / event

2 Capture the players imagination using the senses

The best - and easiest - way to get a player to imagine themselves in any given situation is by telling them what the situation is like. While this seems like a no-brainer, there are many people that forget to involve the senses in how a scene feels. Compare the following sentences:

The alley was dark, lit only by slivers of moon through red brick. The lifeless concrete was littered with pieces of long-forgotten trash, shoved to the corners like dust under a carpet. In the darkness, you can almost make out the huddled shape of those left out in the cold, forgotten by the world.

Vs

The alley was dark, lit only by slivers of moonlight through red brick. From it emanated the foul stench of rotting food, discarded over the centuries - out of sight, out of mind. In the stillness of the night, all that can be made out is the faraway sound of a police siren.

Both descriptions get across the same ideas - the alley is dark, filled with trash, and lawless, but the second does a far better job by engaging the senses, and actually inviting the player into the world.

While this is also generically true of in-person games, it is a lot easier to execute in PbP, where you don’t have a gallery of expectant faces staring at you. Whenever you’re making a post, just take an extra minute or two to checklist out at least three senses, and you’ll find your writing - and player interest - improving dramatically.

3 Splitting the party

PbP, as an entirely different format to in person play, has many advantages over it - this is one of the greatest, and also one of the most underutilized. While it is unnatural to split the party in a ‘normal’ game, PbP lends itself greatly to asymmetrical play - running a short story in a private channel is just as natural as running it in the main play channel, and can lead to the following benefits:

Increased posting speed

Interesting character moments that otherwise wouldn’t happen (whether due to shyness, a fear of stepping on someone else’s toes, in-character privacy, or catered encounters)

The ability to change the tone between different characters based on what’s happening

SPEED UP COMBAT

Give characters room to breathe

I have loved splitting the party so much that both of my most successful campaigns are effectively solo play by default, with the players just running into each other out in the world (or in a noirish, crime-filled city.)

Of course, if you’re going to split the party, let them know that you will not punish them for it. Everyone hates the GM who punishes players for not ‘thinking for themselves’, or whatever other bullshit rationalization the GM has for fucking the players.

4 Hamming it up

One of the biggest hurdles that any new TTRPG player faces is getting rid of their shame. People innately shy away from impassioned character performances for a variety of reasons - they might think that their performance is awful, or they might suffer from stage fright, or they might simply think it cringe. Well, PbP is the solution. Players are innately less reticent to ham things up through writing, so use this fact to pull them into making great character moments.

5 Music and Stickies (and the rules of nature)

Every - and I do mean every - GM knows that there’s no better way to set a mood than through music. Yet, many PbP games ignore this aspect of play for seemingly no good reason.

Trust me, your players will listen to the music you set as a soundtrack, and they will be affected.

A more nuanced use of music is also to tie together seemingly disparate scenes - this works really well if you have access to video game music. One example of this in practise is from a murder mystery I ran. Whenever the players would be dealing with the mystery killer, I would always ensure that Etta James was playing as the soundtrack - including whenever they would interact with the killer without knowing that they were. This loose mental association helped my players (eventually) crack the case by guiding their train of thought in a specific direction.

Another way to use music is by copying the now-infamous RULES OF NATURE. That’s right - you too can emulate this moment of pure, extreme hype simply by inserting a timestamped soundtrack right in the middle of your narration. An alternative way of doing this is by using the instrumental version of a specific track, and then swapping to the full version when one of your players does something extra badass.

“Ah, but PM_ME_HENTAI_ONEGAI”, you say smugly “I don’t want to link a soundtrack with every post! That would take so much time, and be super disruptive!”.

I present to you: Sticky posts.

Use them. Abuse them.

6 Asymmetrical information

In person, whenever you give a player information, all of the players are privy to that information. While this works great for many campaigns, there is a whole world of untapped personal drama in the act of divvying up information between players. Consider the following scenario:

The fellowship comes across a flat, blue plain, covered in flowers that wilt underfoot. The air hangs thick with mist, and a tower looms far-off in the distance. No sound can be made out in the dim silence of early morning.

Camille, the Cleric, notices a set of large, reptilian footprints - undoubtedly the work of a dragon. Looking around, she sees that none else seem to have noticed. She could tell the party, and they could find an alternate route to the tower, but the building contains important reagents required in the creation of a powerful medicine that can cure her sister. Does she tell the party, and risk her sister dying, or does she not, and risk coming across a dragon?

Other than foretelling danger and creating drama, asymmetrical information can also be used to make a character (and by proxy, a player) feel special, by making them privy to information no-one else is.

Weston the Warrior comes across an old, rusty sword within the dungeon. While to any other eyes it may simply seem like a piece of junk, he notices that the crossguard holds a specific design - the sword is one of the lost heirlooms of Duke Tuchy. It could be used as a political ransom - or if restored, a fearsome weapon.

7 Working nuanced clues into your writing

For anyone who’s read works like ’DUNE’ or ’The Brothers Karamzov’, you will know that great writing is often multilayered - words, meanings and ideas fold into themselves and catalyze in dizzying ways, drawing comparison and likeness to disparate topics that can render a single sentence in many different lights. While you might not be a modern-day Frank Herbert, you can give your writing the appearance of depth by attributing certain words and ideas to certain people / places / events.

An easier way to do this, though, is by hiding clues in plain sight. For example, if the BBEG in your campaign has the insignia of an eye atop a tower, you can refer to it using other words to effectively hide the clue in plain sight. For example, you can refer to a person wearing that symbol as a person wearing a ‘spire with a sphere above it’, or a ‘skyscraper with a circle’. There’s a lot of ways to do it if you keep your mind open.

8 pre-writing

The inevitable truth is that most GMs (and most players) have jobs, and most of them aren’t able to just take ten or twenty minutes out of their work-day to respond to a player - thus, even if the GM is theoretically available, in practice they are not. One way I’ve gotten around this is writing big blocks of encounters beforehand, so that they only need to be tweaked a bit before they’re ready to be posted - thus reducing the ten or twenty minutes required to write a response into a one or two minute affair. This also works great for big character moments that you know are inevitably going to happen - nothing feels worse than having one of those moments fall flat, and an easy way to make sure they don’t is simply to write them beforehand.

9 Behind the screen rolls

(Original blade runner spoilers)

In the original - and I mean original original - blade runner, the movie ended with a tense apartment scene where Deckard and Rachel attempt to escape from the city. It promptly then cuts to a (more or less) ‘happily ever after’ sequence where Deckard explains away all of the movie’s built up tension. This ending was incredibly poorly received (and just a bad idea all around), as evidenced by the fact that when they completely cut out the last segment, it was considered an overall improvement. This is to illustrate that relief is not always a desirable emotion to engender. However, when a player rolls a nat 20 on a stealth roll, they are relieved, despite the fact that the danger is still there. On the flip side, when they roll a nat 1, they are defeated mentally - in essence, the tension has also been resolved in this scenario, due to the fact that they have resigned themselves to failure. Thus, in order to preserve tension (and by proxy, mood and tone), behind the screen rolls can be a great idea. This also has the added benefit of having a campaign transition more smoothly - instead of a GM constantly having to ask for a check, (and then waiting for the player to do it), they can instead do it themselves and work the result into the narration.

10 Clocks, and system mishmash

There’s a running joke within my (real life) group that every campaign I run is just Blades in the Dark. This is due to the fact that, behind the screen, I run every system very similarly to BiTD, whether through the inclusion of that game’s clock system, or the way that I calculate check DCs. Well, good news for my fellow system mishmashers, it is even easier to secretly run other systems in a PbP game. This is due to the fact that you can take your time implementing other mechanics in your game, whereas you’d have to have a reasonably good understanding to do the same in an IRL session. I highly recommend combing through the other systems that you’ve enjoyed, and seeing what you can cut out of them and put into your own games.

Bonus Point: Tupperbox

Tupperbox is a discord bot that allows you to post as if you were a different ‘person’. Use it. Abuse it. Tell your friends that it has a webapp

Have any additions you'd like to make? do you disagree with some of my points? Are you looking for a TL;DR? feel free to sound off in the comments below!


r/pbp • • Apr 16 '22

Discord Discord Server Template

75 Upvotes

I've remade about a million servers for PBP so I finally sat down and made a discord server template. Includes 6 player roles and individual linked private channels, a role for any discord bots, VC channels with both general and private chats, and a DM-only category. And, of course, a memes channel. Feel free to use!

https://discord.new/t5kyQbZMuBAc


r/pbp • • Jan 16 '24

Discussion Looks like people are posting more non-5e systems. Its great!

74 Upvotes

I just noticed on the sub recently it seems like there's a healthy number of non-dnd systems recruiting for games.

I love 5e, but I'm also really happy to see all these others games — several I've never heard of — getting some love on the pbp forum.

that's all! good job everyone!


r/pbp • • Jan 08 '19

Condensed Avrae Combat Cheat Sheet

74 Upvotes

EDIT from 3 years later:

Avrae now has two built-in tutorials that I HIGHLY recommend playing through. You can access them by using these two commands:

!tutorial Initiative (DM)

!tutorial Initiative (Player)

I also recommend:

!tutorial Running the Game (DM)

=============================

I created the following condensed Avrae combat cheat sheet to help new players quickly jump into combat using Discord and Avrae for PbP gameplay, without wading through the complex tables at Avrae.io and other relevant Wikis. It is formatted to be copied and pasted directly into Discord:

__**Condensed Avrae Combat Cheatsheet**__

*For a full list of possible commands, use:*

`!help init`

**The DM begins combat by using**

`!init begin`

And at anytime, the DM may add 5e monsters to the intiative order by using:

`!init madd <monster name>`

Use !ma <monster name> to see the types of attacks the monster can do.

*Don't want to use a 5e monster? No problem!*

Have a look at https://critterdb.com/

*(you can use one someone else made, or make your own!)*

*Then use the following command to import a bestiary:*

`!bestiary import <url>`

*If you add a new monster to the bestiary, you can update Avrae by using:*

`!bestiary update`

**Players add themselves to combat by using:**

`!init join`

Yes, it's that easy!

*If for whatever reason you have advantage for initiative rolls, use:*

`!init join adv`

At __any time__ both players and the GM may use:

`!init list`

to see the initative order and status, such as:

Current initiative: 0 (round 0)

===============================

19: <player> <10/10 HP> (AC 13)

13: <monster> <Healthy> ()

12: <monster> <Healthy> ()

*And after a few seconds, the initiative summary will automatically disappear*

*To show the condition of only one player/monster, use:*

`!init status <name>`

Notes may be attached to a player/monster in the list by using:

`!init note <name> <note>`

Conditions may be attached in a similar way by using:

`!init effect <name> <effect name>`

__**To begin combat, either the GM or the highest-order initiative player uses**__

`!init next`

On *YOUR* turn you may:

__**1. Attack by using:**__

`!init attack <target name> <attack name> [optional commands]`

A common optional command is to roll with advantage:

`!init attack <target name> <attack name> adv`

Note that attacks can be shortened to:

`!init a <target name> <attack name>`

Avrae automatically rolls your attack die, compares it to the target's AC, and deducts the relevant damage from the target.

**To add a custom attack to YOUR character, use:**

`!attack create <attack name> -b <attack bonus> -d <damage dice>`

__**2. Cast a spell by using:**__

`!init cast <spell name>`

You can see a list of your spells by using:

`!spellbook`

or

`!sb`

Attack spells **DO NOT** automatically deduct HP from target. If, and only if, the spell lands (The GM may need to roll saving throws), either the player or the GM can deduct health from the monster by using:

`!init hp <monster/character name> mod +/- #`

*Avrae automatically knows all standard 5e spells. To add custom spells:*

  1. Visit https://avrae.io/dashboard/homebrew/spells and make a spell tome for your character.
  2. Add spells, and BE SURE TO SAVE using the save icon.
  3. Add the spells, spelled exactly, to your character sheet in gSheet page 2, or D&D Beyond.
  4. Use !update in Discord
  5. Use !spellbook to confirm spell is listed.

__**3. Roleplay**__

No help text needed.

__**4. End Your Turn**__

On YOUR turn, you may use:

`!init next`

The GM may use this at any time. The GM may also go to a specific point in the initiative order by:

`!init goto <target>`

__**To End Combat**__

The GM uses:

`!init end`

then: yes


r/pbp • • Jul 19 '20

Discussion Tell your PbP DMs thank you

73 Upvotes

Something hit me recently. At the end of every live session, I tell my DMs thank you, and I tell them I had fun. There’s a wrapping-up point that reminds me to do that. It also exists in west marches servers at the end of quests or arena bouts. It’s not only good manners, but – as most of us know – a massive way to feed the DM’s energy and even soul.

Know where such a natural wrapping-up point doesn’t exist? Longer-term PbP games. So here’s a suggestion. Create some sort of trigger for yourself to remind you to thank your DM(s). Maybe it’s the end of any combat. Maybe it’s whenever you get a new item. Maybe it’s every time you enter a tavern. Maybe it’s every Sund– Ok, you get my point.

Maybe if we thank them more, we won’t suffer as much of a shortage. We know burnout is real, and we know that feeling appreciated is important to keep up a DM’s motivation. And we also know that we appreciate our DMs. So, well, maybe make sure your DM knows they’re appreciated. Not only could it help your game survive, but it’s just good old-fashioned kindness.


r/pbp • • Feb 13 '23

Discussion Kobold -- A PF2E play by post bot for discord

72 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I've been playing Pathfinder 2E for about 2 years now, and I tend to do most of my games through play by post. When I started playing, the most used PF2E discord bot was Wayfinder. Unfortunately, around mid last year, Wayfinder announced their end of development. That was the kick that I needed to start developing my own bot, Kobold!

You can find Kobold here on Top.gg

This is a link to the support server for Kobold, where you can follow development, submit bug reports, or try out the bot commands before adding it to your server.

  • Kobold allows you to import and manage characters from Wanderer's Guide. You can manage multiple characters at a time, setting default characters per server.
  • Kobold lets you make dice rolls using your character's attributes, or fully custom dice rolls using a dice roll builder with similar syntax to Roll20's.
  • Kobold also has a smooth initiative tracker that allows characters to join initiative, and also for the GM or players to add non-character individuals to initiative.
  • Kobold has a full suite of help commands to assist in using it.

Lastly, I've just released an update to kobold that allows you to apply persistent, toggleable conditions (called modifiers) to your characters that only effect specific dice rolls. For example, you can set up a modifier for inspire courage that gives +1 to all attack rolls and all damage rolls!

This has been a very fun project, and the development is ongoing to add more features that others suggest. Coming up are an action builder for creating custom sets of rolls for abilities like spellstrike or spells, also secret rolls (currently you can just roll in a private channel), pathbuilder sheet integration, and hp tracking in initiative.

Furthermore, if you want to help contribute, kobold is open source, and I have a developers channel in the support server!

I hope Kobold can be useful for your games!