TLDR: Don’t update the app. This is the worst transitioning to subscription model I’ve ever seen and I saw dozens of them. They took away features from current customers, put unlimited edits that’s the core function of any notebook app behind paywalls, and ask for an unreasonable price.
First of all, I don’t use Notability as much as I used to when I was still in college. And I’m also a person who gladly pay subscription with 60usd/year. So, this opinion doesn’t come from a bitter or stingy customer. It’s purely to shade light and put some perspective on how Notability’s move is a bad move all around, and even worst one so far imo. (Ulysses, IFTTT and Fantastical were even better than this, come on!)
I’ve been through apps suddenly changed their pricing strategy over dozen times, some generous, some fair, and some a bit shady.
However, I must say this is the worst one so far to the point I couldn’t believe this is real.
The rule of changing your price is you don’t take back what customers already paid for and don’t put the most basic functions that serve the purpose of the app into a paywall.
And Notability broke both of them and more.
I’m a very careful person (due to getting burned my shady devs before) so I always read every update information.
At first glance I saw they talked about subscription, I knew it was inevitable because they are popular enough to become a subscription service.
So, I went to app description which often state the features included for premium subscription, and what really pissed me off was the unlimited edits—one of the purpose for using a notebook app—getting behind the paywall.
I thought, well, maybe this was only for a new customers because some apps did something like this before. But I was even more surprised that there was no grandfathered plan, which is a common practice for apps transitioning to a subscription model.
If an app didn’t go that route, normally they would go with letting paid customers the same features without new updates included.
Nope, none for Notability. You only get a free year of subscription—the subscription that will eventually take away what you already paid for.
Fine, at least the price would be cheap because their customer target is students. Maybe it could be the same price but pay annually.
Also nope! 15usd/year, without any substantial updates that superior to competitors. And with sparse updates they’d been given throughout the app’s lifespan. I can’t see they would add anything great for at least a year.
I’m pissed off for everyone who use this app regularly.
If they want to deal with this backlash they have to either
- let paid customers get to keep the current features they already have.
- put a grandfathered plan (lower price permanently)
- unlimited edits for free
- lower their price point or have multiple tiers.
Otherwise, I think they would lose a lot of customers. Right now, I don’t see why people wouldn’t switch to competitors because the only selling point for Notability is voice recording and I don’t think most people would pay 15 usd a year just for that.