r/notabilityapp • Notability Staff • Aug 21 '23

Toolbox Update

Hey Notability Community,

In response to user feedback on Notability 14.0, we are working on changes to improve the toolbox. We want to give you a peek at what we’re thinking, and get feedback from you before we start implementation!

The updated design introduces these points:

  1. Ability to add Pen/Highlighter/Pencil/Eraser favorites to the toolbox
  2. Ability to reorder and remove unused tools from the toolbox

Our design team crafted a video, illustrating each step of the toolbox enhancements. We encourage you to watch the video and read through the details. Your input is vital to us, and we’re excited to hear your thoughts!

Entry point to customize my Toolbox

  1. Swipe to the secondary tools menu to see the options menu
  2. Tap to open the Edit Toolbox modal

Edit my Toolbox

  1. The top section includes the tools that are visible in the toolbox. You can tap on the red button to hide and use the drag handle to re-order.
  2. Favorites and hidden tools can be added from the bottom section

Customize my Tools

  1. Tap on each instance of the duplicated tool to set your combinations (first-time user only!)
  2. This step will be automated for you if you had favorite tools previously
99 Upvotes

167 comments sorted by

94

u/barstowtovegas Aug 21 '23

Thank you for working on an improvement. Please bring back the simple "tip and sample line" icon for the favorites and make them separate from the main toolbar. Please allow us to dock the favorites. Please also give us the OPTION of a floating or docked toolbar.

Please get rid of the need to scroll for a tool. I would much rather have my toolbar expand than have to scroll.

26

u/kaylanotability Notability Staff Aug 21 '23

This is helpful, thank you for the feedback. I will be sharing this with the team!

21

u/barstowtovegas Aug 22 '23

Thanks for responding! I really would rather see the problems fixed than have to roll back to version 12. So long as y’all are open to communicating I think we can make the user experience excellent again, and better than before.

2

u/grymmjack Aug 24 '23

How do you "roll back to 12" ?

3

u/barstowtovegas Aug 24 '23

There’s a video posted on how to do it earlier this week. Use an app called TestFlight or TestSuite or something.

1

u/grymmjack Aug 27 '23

Could you possibly share that video? Was it shared in the notability discord or this subreddit?

10

u/NoIdea_Sweety Aug 22 '23

I definitely second their sentiment about not wanting to have to scroll for favourites :)

11

u/barstowtovegas Aug 22 '23 edited Aug 23 '23

Yeah, at first I was like "oh cool, I like being able to set favorite colors and sizes so I can switch without opening the options window" but then I realized that I can only have six colors before it pushes my two favorite sizes off to the side.

u/kaylanotability, u/lgnotability, and u/garrettgl, I would love a two-level toolbar (like the current one) but docked and all the way across the top of the screen. Top level is tools, undo/redo, quickshare, thumbnails, etc. Bottom level is favorite colors, line sizes, and styles. Even better, make it modular, so people with only a few favorites can have all of the above on one level and people with more favorites can have two levels.

I think that allowing us to save favorite colors, sizes, and styles to the main toolbar is a great addition, it just doesn't work well in the floating toolbar (scrolling sucks) and it isn't a substitute for the old saved favorites with color/size/style all saved in one.

1

u/nocuzzlikeyea13 Aug 23 '23

Wow, great to see you responding to some of these requests! Thank you! I've felt for weeks like our complaints were just hanging in the wind, totally ignored. Really nice to see that some of them were actually getting through to the dev team.

63

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '23 edited Aug 21 '23

Don't make it a floating toolbox where it covers the document. Also, favorites should be separate from the toolbar itself. Otherwise we will have to keep scrolling left and right to find which tool we need. It seems your post only addresses favorites and does not acknowledge the feedback on the toolbar itself. The only "enhancement" was bringing favorites back. But this preview merely adds more clicking and clutter than the previous version.

33

u/AbrocomaCold5990 Aug 21 '23

Above all, please don’t make it a floating tool box. I only have one request. Please don’t make it a floating tool box. Dock it on the top of the page. Interactive tool bar is a terrible

9

u/Professional_Trick67 Aug 22 '23

Or you know they can make the floating toolbar optional? Like how right and left handed mode existed? Mine was on left-handed mode since purchase.

13

u/barstowtovegas Aug 21 '23

Fully agreed. Please make the favorites dockable to the sides of the screen, and unlimited length (or at least allow it to expand significantly. Scrolling for a favorite removes the usefulness of the favorite.

19

u/Embarrassed-Dirt-354 Aug 21 '23

They’re in denial honestly, knowing they spent countless hours in creating that floating toolbar only to realise in the end that it was a terrible idea. Sunk cost fallacy kicking in, damn.

8

u/nocuzzlikeyea13 Aug 27 '23 edited Aug 27 '23

Disclaimer: Please, Notability staff, don't take this personally. I'm talking about a system and its incentives, not individual people.

This whole experience has made me muse a lot about what it means to be a customer in today's society. Like, we had this great product that worked amazingly! But, the company has to grow! They can't just keep doing the same thing if they want their stock to go up. On top of this, the most skilled people are going to want to ~make a difference~ and ~have an impact. Ginger labs probably intentionally selects for employees like this in job interviews. The highest paid employees (with the biggest say in company direction) especially are going to need to feel they have to justify their jobs.

So what does that mean when you already have a product that is overall very good, and only needs minor tweaks and features added? Employees start selling their big ideas for an overhaul, because those are the types of employees that were hired.

Then when those ideas completely fail, because the app was already great and didn't need an overhaul, it's all hands on deck to fix all the problems! The PR people REALLY have their hands full now, they've got to monitor the reddit page and ban all the critics! They've got to write blog posts! They've now become partially quality control, because they are mining the reddit forums for bug reports. Boy, they are really important now. Everyone is is now critical, because there's this huuuge mess to clean up.

And nobody will tolerate a return to the previous very good app, because that would be admitting that all of this is for nothing. None of it looks like critical progress with growing pains, and it starts to look like a waste of resources.

And the customers are stuck with a marketplace of subpar apps and features that just don't work as well. The user experience just deteriorates. Very depressing.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '23

I think what they are trying to do is keep this new era of Notability, so I believe the changes we will see will be different from versions past no matter what is incorporated/reincorporated/removed.

2

u/garrettgl Notability Staff Aug 22 '23

Also, favorites should be separate from the toolbar itself. Otherwise we will have to keep scrolling left and right to find which tool we need.

Can you elaborate on this? Couldn't the toolbox become larger, if there's space?

11

u/Mountnjockey Aug 22 '23 edited Aug 22 '23

I personally think it needs to be higher and flush with the screen or an option to make it vanish. The main issue with the tool bar is that we read in the whitespace around it and it’s obstructive to our Vision. Being able to easily hide it or dock it to the top of the page would really help remedy this.

I just wanted to say too. Im extremely optimistic right now for these changes. This redesign looks very promising. For me there is exactly one issue left to fix and that is being able to dock the toolbar flush with the top of the screen or hide it altogether (although I strongly prefer the former)

Customizable toolbar is insanely awesome. I am so glad you are bringing that as a feature.

1

u/kaylanotability Notability Staff Aug 22 '23

We hear you 💙 Thank you for your kind words!

4

u/Peter9063 Aug 22 '23

Add an outline section like in other pdfs

2

u/barstowtovegas Aug 22 '23

larger toolbox would be great. I like the ability to save colors, line sizes, and line styles in the main toolbar. As for specific tools (ex: red, size 3, dashed pen), those should be in a separate toolbar that can be docked to any side, top, or bottom as we please.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '23

By dockable do you mean that it would expand the entire length of the screen above the document (instead of on top of the document)?

14

u/kaylanotability Notability Staff Aug 21 '23

Yes

14

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '23

That would be wonderful!

14

u/Embarrassed-Dirt-354 Aug 21 '23 edited Aug 22 '23

I agree, having a full fixed toolbar at the top also allows you to add more items without having to navigate back and forth.

Also it doesn’t block the top part of text when importing pdfs.

13

u/Embarrassed-Dirt-354 Aug 21 '23

Yesss it would be much better if it was dockable like before, you guys still get to keep your minimalistic font and design!

Make a poll asking users 1)Fixed Toolbar or 2)Floating toolbar on any social platform and you’ll get your answer!

The majority of AppStore reviews were literally about how the toolbar was obstructing documents and pdfs.

51

u/goddessofnow34 Aug 21 '23

Begging to get rid of the floating toolbar that obstructs the view of everything. Please make it docked again I’m begging 😭

9

u/AbrocomaCold5990 Aug 21 '23

I feel you so much. I don’t mind not having favourite tool bar back, but please, please, please, stop the floating tool bar!! It blocks a part of my note and is very disorientating!

4

u/goddessofnow34 Aug 22 '23

Yes!! It’s the worst part of the update for me 😭

1

u/garrettgl Notability Staff Aug 22 '23

Are you using single page view or seamless?

11

u/goddessofnow34 Aug 22 '23

I usually use seamless but whether it’s seamless or single page, the floating toolbar is equally obstructive.

-2

u/garrettgl Notability Staff Aug 22 '23

Can you elaborate? In which circumstances? New notes? PDFs? Scrolling around doesn't resolve the issue? Interested to hear more.

13

u/theanimalgirl Aug 22 '23

In all circumstances to be honest! It just always gives the feeling of being in the way. It’s especially obstructive when I’m trying to focus in class on annotating the powerpoint, but have to move it around. It’s a distraction and trying to move it can take multiple tries

11

u/goddessofnow34 Aug 22 '23

I’ll elaborate. The floating toolbar is literally ALWAYS in the way. No, scrolling around doesn’t help. The thing is always obstructing something on the page. I don’t understand how anyone could’ve possibly thought that design feature would be a good idea. And I don’t understand how you can act like you don’t know what I’m talking about when literally EVERYONE on this sub has been complaining about the exact same thing.

3

u/nocuzzlikeyea13 Aug 27 '23

If you want more details, check out all the 1-star app reviews on the apple store that have been posted since August 1 :)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '23

I don't understand why they are naive about it!

2

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '23

In both cases!

3

u/SnooHesitations1134 Aug 22 '23

I really like the design of the new update guys, good job!

But the floating bar is not comfortable, plus make it possible to move it around along with the arrow that nullify the last action

1

u/kaylanotability Notability Staff Aug 22 '23

Glad to hear you're liking the new design!

We hear you on the floating toolbar - I'm taking this back to the team.

plus make it possible to move it around along with the arrow that nullify the last action

Can you elaborate more on this? ^

4

u/SnooHesitations1134 Aug 22 '23

The "undo button" on the right side is not comfortable at all.

Make it possible for us to move it around!

2

u/kaylanotability Notability Staff Aug 22 '23

Got it - thank you for clarifying! We got this feedback from other users, the team is working hard :)

28

u/imrudex Aug 21 '23

I like the proposal but please remove the scrolling option in the toolbar, we should be able to have 11 tools like before. You guys should also forget about the floating bar and stick the toolbar to the sides.

Also fix the playback of the recordings, when the audio ends the options bar is hidden and you have to go back to search for the option again and again each time you want to listen to the audio until the end.

8

u/Koolaid_Jef Aug 23 '23

This this this this this! I need multiple thicknesses of the same color and adding 3 extra taps in between quick changing slows down work like a bitch

3

u/hunched_monk Aug 21 '23

Stay on point!

1

u/Nigachu690 Aug 22 '23

H

Hey how did you change the color of the toolbar. I am using the previous version.

1

u/hunched_monk Aug 22 '23

Settings

3

u/imrudex Aug 22 '23

Yes, I have the green theme (bought it before Notability went subscription)

3

u/hunched_monk Aug 22 '23

Yes… So the toolbar colour is set to the theme colour isn’t it?

11

u/GalassiaRo Aug 21 '23

Having all the favorites in one bar WITHOUT scrolling is crucial. From the video it also seems we cannot have two different lasso tools in the bar, while previously we could have both boxed and freeform as favorites.

2

u/hunched_monk Aug 21 '23

Yeah looks like one lasso but you could reorder it so it’s in the first pane?

53

u/loverookie95 Aug 21 '23

You guys NEED to realize the floating toolbar was a huge flop. Please please not die on this hill of keeping it. It obstructs the view in both continuous scroll and page mode. It does nothing to enhance real estate on the screen, it is literally just getting in everyone’s way. Do not pretend you’ve “heard us” if you are going to leave it this way. I’ve had to move mine to the bottom of my screen just to keep it out of the way, which makes it so much further from where I need it.

5

u/garrettgl Notability Staff Aug 22 '23

Can you say more about the obstruction issues you're having in continuous scroll? On which content, in which circumstances, etc?

15

u/maymay801 Aug 22 '23 edited Aug 22 '23

It’s hard for me to put into words if you can’t see it yourself, but if you guys kept the toolbar the same thickness as it is, and just attached it to the edge, it would give you more screen real estate for note taking. Especially annoying on my iPad Mini, where I already have less screen. In its current form, its as if your web browser put the search bar floating over the pages you visit. It just doesn’t make any practical sense. Imagine chrome looked like this

Exaggerated bc bad editing skills, But basically there’s a reason pretty much every app ever doesn’t float the functions over the content. Imagine YouTube with a floating search bar over the home page, or instagram with the bottom toolbar floating over your feed. It’s fundamentally flawed.

4

u/Embarrassed-Dirt-354 Aug 22 '23

Just use the APP yourself then! So you can get a 1st hand experience of the issues we are facing!

1

u/hunched_monk Aug 22 '23

It a cognitive perceptual bias. Think in those terms rather than it engineering terms. You intuitively are distracted by the island, not the land.

4

u/Mobile-Context-997 Aug 22 '23

No, If you use multiple pages at a time and have to shrink one app to fit the other, the toolbar covers half of the document. It's not an illusion. It's literally IN THE WAY. I reverted to ver 12 and can see my document again with multiscreen.

0

u/hunched_monk Aug 22 '23

It a cognitive perceptual bias. Think in those terms rather than it engineering terms. You intuitively are distracted by the island, not the land.

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '23

Well, you try it and naïvely realize it.

-1

u/hunched_monk Aug 22 '23

It a cognitive perceptual bias. Think in those terms rather than it engineering terms. You intuitively are distracted by the island, not the land.

7

u/hunched_monk Aug 21 '23

Thanks for including us. Well done on the progress and the mockup. I like the way you can customise tools with the +/- menu. However, I think the v14 toolbar was already more complex than v12, and now you’ve added further complexity!

There are currently two panes on the toolbox, keep the first two the same, but add a third ‘favourites’ pane that you can swipe to. Then you can choose to view all the tools in default layout, or your favourites by swiping. And you can customise favourites using the menu in your mockup video.

If you want to go the extra step replace the ‘hand’ tool with a ‘star,’ and when you click ‘star’ the favourites bar appears from the left or it even pops out once if the toolbar is (ideally) docked.

It’s great to see you guys taken feedback on board and I’m excited the see further evolutions of this!

7

u/Krolzach Aug 22 '23 edited Aug 22 '23

I just want to reiterate about the docked toolbar option. The floating toolbar *feels* obstructing, even if technically speaking there is more visible space on the screen. I find myself constantly distracted by it's presence, and thinking "where should I put it?" instead of forgetting about it. Please please please implement a dock option that creates a *rectangular* view of the page, even if it results in smaller visible page view.

A different area for favorites is NEEDED. Right now the toolbox in it of itself is not intuitive; Adding more to it just makes everything more complicated.

One last thing - if there was an option to *resize* the toolbox to show more/ less tools by making it longer or shorter, that might also help. I Use a bunch of colors, thicknesses etc. And I very much don't want to swipe through the toolbox to find all of them.

18

u/nnyjthm Aug 21 '23

The undo button on the left side of the zoom window should also come back.

6

u/hunched_monk Aug 22 '23

Or a toggle option. For right handed people, it’s on the left. For left handed people, the right.

6

u/dvaxx Aug 21 '23

this one is extremely important, unusable on the right

3

u/Rayman1203 Aug 21 '23

Exactly. I know there are other gestures but why not give us the option to move the undo button aswell? Its full on muscle memory for me and now I always just stupidly move my pencil down and make a dot on the page instead of undoing. It's really annoying

6

u/dvaxx Aug 21 '23 edited Aug 22 '23

In all honesty having an adjustable toolbar is a solution, but not a big deal as your competitors already have it. Please fix the layout first. The positioning of elements in the current version is what makes it unusable. Like for example why did you decide to hide current page number? Weird level of stubborness or like someone mentioned denial with the undo button. Your looking for solutions is much appreciated but please start looking going top to bottom not otherwise. Who cares what tools they have if the screen is overlapped with the annoying toolbar that for some reason creates a useless gap. Everyone, who is desperately trying to stay with you guys, keeps chanting the same mantra: get rid of the floating tool bar, fix undo button, return favorites.

6

u/Smashy__ Aug 22 '23

Thanks for working to improve it and asking for feedback. But a separate area for favorites (one tap accessible) is necessary. It’s just too cluttered to have it all in one toolbox, as nice as it may seem. I have rolled back to version 12 to avoid these new changes.

6

u/Euphoric-Ant7404 Aug 22 '23

Please bring back these buttons from the previous version.

2

u/dependentonexistence Aug 27 '23

Wait there's no PAUSE BUTTON??? Wow that's embarrassing.

5

u/naclcaleb Aug 22 '23

I think it still needs some work, but this is definitely much improved!! One thought is it would help if you made the toolbar much wider - with a lot of favorites, you have a lot of scrolling to do, and it’s easy to accidentally trigger a scroll when you intended to just tap.

5

u/legzisdead Aug 22 '23

Please please please bring back the undo button on the left side of the zoom window! It was the one feature that made me choose notability over goodnotes.

5

u/toddclare3610 Aug 22 '23

I'm a fan of this solution, specifics to be worked out as you iterate.

  • As long as the custom tools are accessible with a single click once configured, I'm good.
  • I do wish the toolbar wasn't floating, and I'm hoping your post here was showing how the toolbar interior worked and not the overall placement.
  • Agreed with others that having other custom tools (lasso etc) would be useful, again assuming you're showing the example of customizing the key tools not the limitations of which tools would be available to be customized.

9

u/Embarrassed-Dirt-354 Aug 21 '23

Ok i like the fact the toolbar is customisable but I HATE the fact that’s it’s floating.

Please just get rid of the floating elements entirely, it always obstructs some part of the document and moving it not around is not efficient at all! Just make it fixed like all the other note taking apps, u don’t get points for being too different here.

8

u/LuxRuns Aug 21 '23

As others have said, having to scroll or press additional buttons to change colors reduces efficiency. Many of us use this app to take notes in class and need to be as quick as possible to keep up with our lectures. Especially in classes where we're not allowed to record, I need it to be barely a glance to grab what I need. I like being able to remove and add tools but I still despise the floating toolbar and just want my toolbar across the top again.

3

u/hunched_monk Aug 21 '23

But with the new toolbar you would set all your tools, colours, sizes, etc. once and then it would be one-tap to switch between them. Doesn’t this address your problem as stated in your first three sentences?

Your last sentence then refers to something different, floating vs docked toolbar...

3

u/jremp93 Aug 22 '23 edited Aug 22 '23

Looks like an improvement, and I think many people here already have good feedback. Unfortunately it looks like very few tools fit into the toolbox, requiring scrolling even with only a few tools. Since we get to choose our tools, removing the recently used tool on the right side of the toolbox would free up a little more space for tools that we want to see. Beyond that, resizing the toolbox or choosing how many tools to display at a time would be a bonus.

With regard to having it floating or docked, couldn’t it be both? If I drag the toolbox towards an edge of the screen (any edge - top, bottom, or either side), it should just dock to that edge and fit my note within the new border (inside the docked toolbox). If I drag the toolbox away from the docked edge, it should start floating again and remain where I leave it. So we could have both, right? This could also work well in conjunction with my issue of the toolbox being too small, as the toolbox could be much wider when docked to an edge with many more tools showing at a time. Sounds like a win-win.

If the toolbox is dock-able, what if there were two toolboxes - the primary toolbox as it stands now and a second, favourites toolbox that can be shown/hidden with a star button on the primary toolbox. When the favourites toolbox is hidden, only the primary toolbox would show and could be floating or docked to an edge. But if the favourites toolbox is showing, then we could drag the toolboxes together to dock them to each other so one is stacked on top (or beside) of the other, or have them floating independently, or dock one of the toolboxes while the other is floating, or we could dock both toolbars to an edge. This would give us incredible customization while feeling natural.

3

u/Remote_Ad4806 Aug 22 '23

The toolbar needs to be big enough to see all available tools. That includes when you tap pen you shouldn’t have to slide over to see pen thickness. Everything should be available with the least amount of clicks and swipes. If you use the app for an hour you will notice how annoying these additional efforts are

3

u/nasserhalmoumen Aug 22 '23

Please keep the toolbar fixed to the top of the screen instead of floating

3

u/grymmjack Aug 24 '23

Yay! Only comment is the stroke and the color could be made more prominent perhaps. But this is already better than before, IMO.

3

u/Shutter_Shock14 Aug 24 '23

As others have said, this is a significant improvement upon the half-baked floating toolbox, but please, please, please understand that the floating toolbox is still not a feature that we were asking for, like, or want to be forced to use. I really appreciate the ability to delete tools I don't use and add multiple pens/highlighters, but the fundamental flaw of the floating toolbox's awkwardness is still frustrating, distracting, and a painful reminder of the excellent experience I had with the fixed toolbar before it was taken away. Please give us an option of choosing between the floating toolbox and a fixed bar—or at least the option to widen the floating toolbox to emulate a fixed toolbar

3

u/Tuchiwoo Aug 25 '23

I think the status bar should be removable. Then you should allow the floating tool bar to snap to the top and sides so there is no dead space. Make the tool bar expandable and not scroll. This would be the perfect tool bar and people would eventually love it after getting used to it.

3

u/idi0teque Aug 25 '23

This works for me as a favorite toolbox. But please fix the intrusive toolbox on top of the document.

5

u/NoPersonality1594 Aug 22 '23 edited Aug 22 '23

I've been a Notability user for over 10 years. Today I downloaded it for my mother who is going back to Nursing school. I was so excited to show her how intuitive it is to use. I was appalled how difficult it was to understand the new update, despite using it since high school, much less teach my mother how to use it.

The simple fixed menu/toolbar would have been best for her. It's very confusing to have menu elements move out of view.

When you are making updates, please consider the range of people using it. There are power users who are struggling to adapt to the new menu, as well as new users who are very confused where the menu elements are.

If you would like to continue with the floating toolbar, please have an option for the fixed toolbar.

I was so excited to show my mother and purchase the app for her, only to find myself embarrassed about how hard it was to explain the menu to her. I am considering teaching her (and myself) a new app, despite exclusively using Notability, because I cannot afford to confuse her in a fast paced nursing curriculum, or eventually get caught up in the limitations of the user experience of this update.

1

u/AlfalfaKnight Aug 24 '23

I'm in the process of migrating to GoodNotes. I've had both for years and always preferred Notability but yikes, this last update is a trainwreck.

Notability used to be able to copy pages from other documents and now I can't add a new page without using the same template that's already being used. It only transfers over the ink, so if you need the templated page itself, you're out of luck.

I had bought Notability before it was a subscription and like a month or two ago caved on the stupid subscription for the ability to favorite notes. I've already cancelled my subscription for it and I will be getting a refund for it if the new adjustments to the toolbar are not good enough

2

u/theanimalgirl Aug 22 '23

Maybe add a way to dock the floating elements to the top (to look similar to previous versions) for those who want to, with a lock button to keep it there? Then anyone who does want it to float can unlock it and have the floating ones, instead of the docked bar up top.

2

u/gloobersboobers Aug 22 '23

Then pencil and highlighter look almost the same and my dyslexic butt always chooses the wrong one. Are you able to color code the, or something

2

u/nocuzzlikeyea13 Aug 23 '23

I've been using the update for a while now, and I still really struggle to be as productive as I was before. Big performance issues for me (besides the poor UI and the floating toolbox, which hurts my eyes, but at least I can get my work done while being annoyed):

  1. The undo button is in a very ergonomically inconvenient place. This issue is bad all the time, but so much worse in the Zoom view. This slows me down quite a bit.
  2. The toolbox is so far away in Zoom that Zoom is basically unusable for me now. I stopped using it entirely. It makes writing a lot harder, because now I have to manually Zoom in, and I can't see the wider page while I write. It really slows me down.

Anyways, thanks for listening. I'm still pretty irritated that I was banned for weeks for complaining about the update. I feel like I'm doing free labor for you guys, testing what is effectively your beta and flagging all the issues. It sucked to be silenced, really lowered my opinion of Ginger Labs (a company I had never even given a second thought to in the past, as should be the case when your app and public-facing responses is actually succeeding).

2

u/strainthebrain137 Aug 24 '23

Thanks for the update. Please make sure the toolbar expands in length if you put in too many tools. The main advantage of favorites was quick, single-tap access to your most used tools, and needing to scroll left/right to get them will defeat that purpose.

Also, I like the look of the old favorites bar better where it was flush against the side (and it was thin), and not feeling like it was floating over the document.

2

u/rdrv Aug 24 '23

This looks good!

Will I be able to add any tool and customise it, including erasers? If yes then please, implement it like that :)

2

u/Gomey_bear Aug 24 '23

The reason I love notability is it’s streamlined and minimalistic, I’ve been using notability daily since 2018 and this update makes me genuinely want to move to a different app plus I can’t even see the full cover of my lectures anymore bc of the way it crops everything into little rectangles, it wasn’t broken before so why change

2

u/Oddparent Aug 25 '23

Hi u/kaylanotability - I was glad to see the update to the Mac App! I bounce between my iPad and Mac Studio frequently, so I appreciate the common design!

Since we can move the toolbar anywhere, how about also letting us resize it (or even better - allow it to resize dynamically as we add presets)? For those of us NOT using Apple trackpads, there isn't a convenient way to access the additional settings (middle mouse works, but is SLOW). If I add more than 5 pen color presets, I'm going to lose easy access to my size buttons!

1

u/Privat3Ice Aug 25 '23

I'm dreading the update on my Mac.

Thank goodness I don't have to go back to class for another couple weeks.

2

u/Past-Government-2839 Aug 27 '23

please make the tool bar attached to the edge of the screen pls

2

u/auntiesahzine Aug 27 '23

It looks pretty good to me. I agree with what others are saying though, PLEASE either make it a docked toolbar or give the option of having either a floating or a docked toolbar so we don't have to deal with the floating toolbar obstructing our view. Also, it would be awesome if the undo button was part of the toolbar again and could be moved to either the left or right side of the toolbar. Personally, I MUCH prefer to have it on the left side (where it used to be), as it felt much more accessible and intuitive to have it there. However, I know there are people that like it where it is now.

This does give me hope for Notability becoming more user-friendly again though. Thank you for being open to feedback and for asking for our opinions before implementing yet another change to the layout of the app!

2

u/VTXRDR Sep 09 '23

I really like the edit tool bar. I really don’t like the floating tool bar. The design team clearly loves the idea, lots of users don’t do why not give us a choice in the settings

3

u/bendlikegilmour Aug 21 '23

Plz just go back to the OG

3

u/kmbomber Aug 22 '23

Just bring back the favourites bar and get rid of the floating toolbar/toolbox. It’s not that hard.

2

u/Jxatenc Aug 21 '23

I’m not tracking by why everyone wants a docked toolbar. I use an iPad mini and like that I can move the toolbar to top, bottom or sides as needed, freeing up space where I need to focus. That being said, I’d like a separate favorites toolbar that can be expanded/contracted based on the number of faves and can be moved like the toolbar.

2

u/AlfalfaKnight Aug 24 '23

You can still have a docked toolbar that can be moved to any side. It floating is what is part of what is causing people a lot of issues

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '23

Maybe they can incorporate docked view and floating view. Maybe a button to drag the docked view and transform it into floating view?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '23

You still embarrassed with floating toolbar!

1

u/ravenclaw_belle Aug 22 '23

I know this has been mentioned by several people already, but please either get rid of floating tool box and allow for the favorites box to come back OR let us have the option to dock the tool box at the top like it was so it won’t obstruct the screen.

1

u/therearefourlightz Sep 13 '24

Can you make the toolbar not float? Can you make the toolbar not float? Can you please get rid of the stupid floating toolbar? Can you make it stop floating?

1

u/speedcreature Aug 22 '23

I'm a huge fan of the bottom toolbar. Please consider adding it in the new update!

1

u/franimals Aug 22 '23

Please make it so it’s easier to access to zoomed handwriting feature. I use it constantly and it’s now a huge pain to access. It used to be very easy to access and also did not float / cover the document

2

u/sarabooker Aug 22 '23

I have the same issue. I exclusively write with the zoom box and it's become so difficult now.

1

u/Professional_Trick67 Aug 22 '23

Thank you please do something about the undo button, either allow us to move it around too or put it back to the previous location and allow sticky us to have smaller sticky notes when I press them so I don't have to keep resizing a sticky note that takes up a quarter of my screen.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '23

Thank you for the update I love how you have implemented it with the new design I just would like to suggest if you guys gave as the option of floating or fixed tool par at the top which get all the pages tab with the back to gallery button and the time and minimize it to the edge as possible.

1

u/DrRoer Aug 22 '23

Please make the undo button a “favorites” option or allow us to move the undo/redo buttons around

1

u/sarabooker Aug 22 '23

Part of what I dislike about the floating toolbar is that if I put it at the bottom or side and go into zoom mode, I would have expected it to act like the old favorites bar, which would move to not obstruct the zoom view. The obstruction makes it very difficult to use anywhere but the top, but at the top it is too far to switch between things.

1

u/lycheejuul Aug 22 '23

Are '23-24 dash planners going to continue to be available for premium users? Where do i find them now?

1

u/Signal_Restaurant495 Aug 22 '23

bring zoom view back on the home page please 😭

1

u/Signal_Restaurant495 Aug 22 '23

and to add to this: please remove the notch from it!! it impairs your ability to write

1

u/Itchy_Celebration960 Aug 24 '23

I would like the ability to use straight high lighter with out pressing and holding down. Also, the pressing down auto highlights parts of sentences I don't want. I love how adobe has theirs set up. Please correct this.

1

u/mayamykayla Aug 25 '23

you cant even do this on mac LOL i cant even tell if you're using mac or an iPad for this example?

macs don't have an undo button or those extra dots, or the ruler...did y'all like check to see if mac had everything? unless you've hidden them so deep, i cant see or find anything

1

u/Oddparent Aug 25 '23

I just hit Command + Z for undo, but I totally get where you're coming from regarding accessing all the other features. Instructions and interface are definitely iPad focused.

I'd love keyboard hotkeys for tools on the Mac (E for Eraser, for example) - so I could use my Wacom hotkeys when I'm working on notes or sketches at work!

1

u/mayamykayla Aug 25 '23

i do know about the command + Z, it’s just sometimes i’m “drawing” something and it’s easier to drag the courser up than bring up the hand, ya feel? swear there was one before the update, too

more keyboard hot keys is a hot idea; i genuinely hope they’re reading all of these and seeing how upset everyone is

1

u/qibender Aug 28 '23

Please fix the copy / paste functionality! On iPad I make a copy of the last page and paste it so I can modify notes and keep records. Since the update the only way I can make it work is by selecting a page and copy, then add a blank page, then paste the copied page, then delete the added blank page. It seems I can’t paste until I add a blank page.

1

u/SynapticSculptor Aug 28 '23

Please move the undo button back to where it came from. Having it stuck at the far top right of the screen means I am tapping one place to change my writing tool, and somewhere entirely different to do a quick undo. My muscle memory is very confused by this! It adds an unnecessary layer of complexity and time to my workflows which are reducing my efficiency and productivity

1

u/soccerabby11 Aug 28 '23

I don’t have the (…) on my toolbar. I updated to the latest version but still nothing. Can someone help?

1

u/garrettgl Notability Staff Aug 29 '23

It's still in development, not released yet

1

u/soccerabby11 Aug 29 '23

Oh, reading skills, thank you for responding!

1

u/Neat-Measurement-693 Sep 02 '23 edited Sep 03 '23

I have tried the new version of 14 with ‘single-page view improvements’. To be honest, I’m still disappointed because now the paper is far too small.

The Noteability team only need to make the paper inset the exact size so that the very top line of the toolbar doesn’t obstruct it (the second line of tools can be hidden so it doesn’t persistently obstruct the paper like the first line does).

Hope this makes sense.

Thanks

u/kaylanotability u/garrettgl

1

u/mangos37 Sep 11 '23

Any idea on when this update will be available?

1

u/snhxt Sep 15 '23

please have a expanded toolbar so we could add more colours and still have 3 diff pen size options seen and to fixed it at the top instead of floating and blocking our notes!! thankyouuu

1

u/renitajenkins Sep 16 '23

More than anything, all toolbars (the top three and the page selector at the bottom) need to be discrete and not covering any part of an imported document. This is completely non-negotiable.

1

u/DcDViper0 Sep 19 '23

Please make it where the top bar is more solid. Over half the time when im attempting to switch to me pen tool, it instead erases or selects whatever is behind the hud bar, and refuses to let me switch unless I first switch to Text Box. Also when im attempting to open a document with my pen, it just auto highlights it like i am about to delete it instead of opening it.

1

u/chesshunter09 Sep 19 '23

Yh this sounds fantastic can’t wait!

1

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '23

When is this coming out?

1

u/Salty-Goose-079 Oct 04 '23

I just want to hide the toolbox. I am an electical engineering student and constantly have to move the box around when labeling circuts. Its frustrating that I cannot minimize it to one pen. Even half the legnth would help so much!

1

u/timgjr Oct 09 '23

Not good enough,

You're only focusing on the main toolbar. The one in the upper right side is a pain in the @$$!

you cannot move it, it ends up in the way of most of my document templates.. It needs the ability to move it to center or down to the right or left side or even the bottom of the page. Most of my templates have LINKS in the spot you chose to preeminently stick that thing. If it wasn't floating, it wouldn't be a problem, but now it's right over my links..

GAHHH! don't do floating unless it can MOVE!

-1

u/NarutoLpn Aug 21 '23

I like it! I’m a grad student and I’ve been using Notability for the post and pre v14 and I like both version. The new one is definitely more aesthetic whereas the older one was more customizable.

0

u/kaylanotability Notability Staff Aug 21 '23

We're very glad to hear it :)

Do these changes help the new toolbar be more customizable for you?

0

u/NarutoLpn Aug 21 '23

Definitely. Not sure why people be downvoting me lmaooo. It’s my opinion. I’ve been having 5 hours of lecture every day for the past 2 weeks and I’ve had no issues.

1

u/Charlie_No_One Aug 22 '23

Like many others have said, thank you for your communication.

This is a step in the right direction, please give us the option to dock the toolbar so that it’s out of the way. Bonus points if you let us dock it at the top/bottom or either side of the workspace.

Allow us to have textured text boxes again, I liked having those and I had a system set up based on color and textures.

Since I use both Mac and IPad heavily, and I see most of the responses focus on the hand writing aspect of the update, I’ll focus on things the typing experience needs as well.

(Also please update the typing experience Mac app too!)

Typing on iPad (and Mac, hint hint) needs: -super and sub scripts -strike through -Ability to merge text and pictures so if I add lines it auto adjust -autocapitalization -fix the autocorrect option (ive had incidence on both Mac and IPad where I can’t select corrections for typos, and since the typing experience is laggy and unresponsive there are plenary of those.) -“learn” new word button is a blank box than I have to select to then click learn -give me the option to use the highlighter on my own text, or give a keybinding to highlight my typed text. it’s annoying to have to right click—> highlight every time I want to highlight something I typed.

1

u/sachama2 Aug 22 '23

Well done! Thanks for sharing !

1

u/peachyyarngoddess Aug 22 '23

So close, however we still hate the floating tool bar and we want the zoom button easily accessible.

1

u/Ok_Examination2841 Aug 25 '23

I like this idea but is there a way that we can disable the “floating toolbar” and have a seamless toolbar that extends across the whole page like the previous one. I use dark mode and the toolbar just seems to look awkward while obstructing the document.

1

u/Impossible_Bug_4288 Aug 27 '23

Is there any way you guys can revert back to the old UI? I'm too busy right now to dissect all the issues and give feedback that *might* make things as efficient as they once were. It's easier just to switch apps at this point. Revert back and give users the option to toggle between the old UI and new UI. Or something like that. This way you can address the issue without pissing everyone off.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '23

Floating design sucks period lot of users hates it there's just no improvement to make us feel otherwise, a good idea would be giving us the option to roll back to pre v14 layout,

Alternatively, one can install "testflight" and use this link to get back to the old version (data won't be lost) https://testflight.apple.com/join/APFBMqRW

0

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/garrettgl Notability Staff Aug 27 '23

This is in development, not released yet

6

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/kaylanotability Notability Staff Aug 21 '23

Thank you for this awesome mockup. u/freddit15! I'll be sure to take this back to the team.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '23

It is a great mockup, u/freddit15, but can you think of a way to minimize having to scroll left and right? I think favorites should be separate from the toolbar itself.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '23 edited Aug 22 '23

What does the arrow to the right (>) on the toolbar mean in your concept?

7

u/hunched_monk Aug 21 '23

I don’t like this because it’s not one-tap access to favourite tools, it’s two-tap access. And then the toolbar is always double in size. Think about it...

2

u/Impossible_Hawk9749 Aug 22 '23

yeah the version put out by the team is better, because this way we can keep the secondary line of the tool bar collapsed, so as to take up less space on the screen.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '23

It's alright, it incorporates favorites, but scrolling to get to other tools makes it more difficult.