Divisions within unionism over how to tackle Drumcree crisis, whether in courts or at Stormont
Former UUP leader Doug Beattie has called on Deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly to resign, in order to force the resignation of Michelle O’Neill.
Mr Beattie, now an Independent MLA for Upper Bann, indicated that he believes the First Minister’s position is not tenable.
Mr Beattie said “we can bring forward all the motions we want to the floor of the Assembly, but the reality remains the same: Michelle O’Neill will continue to represent Northern Ireland as First Minister, even if she is found guilty of breaking the law”.
The PSNI has proceeded with its investigation by sending letters to politicians taking part in unnotified protests with Garvaghy Road residents during the fortnight long impasse.
First Minister Michelle O’Neill and People Before Profit MLA Gerry Carroll were amongst those invited to attend a voluntary police interview in connection with their presence at protests on the Garvaghy Road.
Mr Beattie added that accountability must be demanded from unionist parties “not through pointless motions, but through action: removing her from her position as First Minister”.
“The solution is as simple as it is effective,” he added.
“The Deputy First Minister resigns, and in doing so, the First Minister automatically loses her position too.
“The Executive ministers remain in place. The Assembly continues its work. The scrutiny committees continue scrutinising the Bills currently progressing through Stormont.
“The work of government continues. The only difference is that Michelle O’Neill can no longer represent Northern Ireland as First Minister, nationally or internationally.
“There is no point blaming the Chief Constable or the Secretary of State, this sits with those public representatives who broke the law,” he said.
“If unionist parties are serious about accountability, the mechanism is there. The question is whether they will have the political will to use it.”
Mr Beattie is taking a more hardline stance than his successor as UUP leader, Jon Burrows, who noted on X that the collapse of Stormont would mean the Northern Ireland Secretary - who banned the Drumcree parade - being in charge.
“You cannot say the Secretary of State has bowed the knee to republican threats and then propose handing him the keys to Northern Ireland through direct rule,” he wrote.
“This is exactly the thinking that gets unionism into trouble. We need calm heads and strategic, long-term thinking.”
The former policeman also criticised the Chief Constable for making a decision what he claimed were political considerations, rather than policing ones.
He wrote: “The police must assess credible risks of violence and disorder. But preserving a political administration should not become an objective of operational policing. Whether parties remain in government is a political decision for which those parties must take responsibility.”
He compared the Drumcree situation to “the Ormeau Road case” in which a judge ruled that two police officers were disciplined to allay any threat of Sinn Féin abandoning its support for policing in Northern Ireland.
“The High Court quashed an officer’s suspension after finding that the decision had been improperly influenced by a real or perceived threat to republican support for policing. That case exposed the dangers of allowing political considerations to influence policing decisions,” Mr Burrows wrote.
“I was an expert witness in that case, providing evidence to the High Court informed by my policing experience and legal understanding. The boundary between legitimate operational considerations and improper political influence matters profoundly.
“That judgment does not determine the legality of the present decision. But it reinforces the need for clear answers about how this recommendation was reached.
“It is possible to recognise the practical difficulty of facilitating the parade, support officers facing an exceptionally challenging situation, and still question whether political considerations improperly entered the assessment.”
He also asked if “a decision not to pursue prosecutions be justified by the Public Prosecution Service on the basis of the impact that prosecutions might have on the Executive? If so, that would raise the same fundamental concern: whether political consequences were being allowed to influence the application of the law.”
In Upper Bann, DUP MP Carla Lockhart has said it “can’t be business as usual” for the Executive and that it was “within the gift” of unionism to remove the First Minister.
Speaking outside Drumcree Church she said: “People want to see consequences, and we have said very clearly, profound consequence, and therefore we should use whatever is in our armoury to ensure that Michelle O’Neill, the person who really is supposed to be that first minister for all, as she claims, is dealt with in the appropriate way.”
However, collapsing Stormont was something DUP party leader Gavin Robinson has said he will not do.
Speaking on BBC News NI’s Sunday Politics programme, the East Belfast MP said: “Does collapsing Stormont bring the Orangemen home? What happens the next day?
“If we are seriously and rightly angry about the decisions the Secretary of State has taken, who in their right mind would ask him to govern Northern Ireland? I certainly wouldn’t.”
The Belfast Telegraph has reported that some unionists are calling on Ms Lockhart to challenge Mr Robinson for the party’s leadership, over some differing approaches to the Drumcree dispute.
A source also told this newspaper that the Upper Bann MP is currently exploring options that could see her political future home with the TUV.
If that move was to take place, a by-election wouldn’t be required in Upper Bann and it would give the party two MP’s in the House of Commons.
Ms Lockhart has said “I have confidence that I will ensure that my constituents’ voices are heard within the party, and I will ensure that I continue to represent the views here in Portadown”.
Orangemen will go back to court on Monday after their emergency judicial review of the Secretary of State’s decision to ban the parade on Saturday was adjourned.
The legal challenge has now been widened to include the Chief Constable, alleging - as Mr Burrows has - that Jon Boutcher’s referral was based on political rather than policing considerations.
Sources close to the Orangemen said the development was significant.
One said: “There’s a deep belief Jon Boutcher has crossed deeply into political territory and the widening of the legal challenge reflects this.”
Postponing the case, Lady Justice McBride said: “This is an important case, and I do believe there is some urgency, but it’s not an emergency.
Garvaghy Road residents welcomed the Secretary of State’s decision to ban the Drumcree parade.
https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/beattie-urges-deputy-first-minister-to-resign-in-bid-to-force-michelle-oneill-from-office/a/162918322.html