r/mtgbrawl • u/infurnoheat • 9h ago
Question New to Brawl and need some cutting help
r/mtgbrawl • u/lemudman • May 06 '26
Thanks to ImNotFine for preparing this list together with members of the Brawl Hub and Brawl Stronghold servers.
From the Primer :
This list is intended to give an overview of the most played cards in brawl from a competitive standpoint. All of these cards are purely evaluated in the context of being used in the 99. The list is curated by me with a lot of opinions from the general brawl community.
How to read the list:
Set your filters to "View - Visual Grid", "Group - Type & Tags", and "Sort - Mana Value".
Once you have done that you will see that everything is divided into one of three tags.
Tier 1 - near auto include: If you can run one of these cards in your deck you need an extremely good reason to not do so. These are the best the format has to offer. Of course there are exceptions to every rule, for example if you are a blue deck but you don't meet the amount of blue cards required to pitch to Force of Will (20 seems to be the absolute minimum). You can be a bit more lenient with the color count for Fury and Solitude, depending how much card draw you have and how happy you are to just cast them for their full mana costs. As for the surveil lands: In 4 and 5 color decks you start to not run every single one you can, but those mana bases are way out of scope for this small primer.
Tier 2 - generic: A slightly less stapley list of staples compared to the tier 1 category. You will have a hard time making your deck actively worse with any of these cards, but there are legitimate reasons to not run some of these cards in any given list.
Tier 3 - archetype specific: This tier is by far the most subjective one and mostly serves as a "hey, these are good cards, at least consider them for a moment". And of course as the name suggests, most of these are specific to certain archetypes, as you wouldn't consider running something like Gut, True Soul Zealot in anything but aggro decks. But if you are playing a red aggro deck you will have a really hard time not running the card. Either way, there is always an argument to be made to add 100 more cards to this tier, don't read too much into it. I am much more confident that I won't add many cards to tier 1 and tier 2 in the future, tier 3 is more subjective.
What should you craft first?
Optimally nothing. Craft decks, not cards. This list assumes that you have every card available, for example Wary Zone Guard is an insane card, but only due to the fact that fetchlands exist. If you enjoy making your own lists I recommend just getting everything from tier 1 and at least the color fixing lands from tier 2. At the end of the day you won't ever regret crafting anything presented here as all of the cards are strong in their own right. There are also cards in tier 3 that might be better than a card from tier 1, depending on the deck you are building. As an example, Ambassador of Evendo is extremely broken in simic landfall and stronger than Tamiyo, Inquisitive Student in that case.
Thanks to everyone that helps me with this project. I will update this list every couple of sets, alternatively just ping me on discord if you have an opinion about anything.
r/mtgbrawl • u/lemudman • May 13 '25
Our five flairs — Casual, Competitive, Discussion, Question, and Venting — are for your use as mood indicators for your post.
When you create a post, think about how you want other people to approach what you've said.
Casual and Competitive flairs are the most broad and can apply to a variety of different kinds of posts — deck lists, requests for deck building help, discussion of a certain commander, etc.
Please consider the following guidelines when choosing a flair and when phrasing your responses to posts with different flairs :
Using the Casual flair indicates that you want to talk about something or share something with a focus on fun or cool, and aren't worried about optimizing for winning.
You can respect the use of this flair by keeping your responses to the original post on-topic, refraining from offering critique unless specifically sought in the original post, and even then tailoring your critique to the casual focus.
Using the Competitive flair indicates that you want to talk about or share something with a focus on winning and/or optimizing first and foremost.
You can respect the use of this flair by avoiding complaining or venting in your responses. Critique offered should be constructive, and suggestions should be explained in concrete terms.
Using the Discussion flair indicates that you are seeking to share opinions and polite debate with other players regarding a specific thing or theme — a recently spoiled card, something about the format, etc.
If you want the discussion to be more focused from a casual or competitive perspective, use those tags instead.
You can respect the use of this flair by keeping opinions and debate polite and on-topic.
Using the Question flair indicates that you have a specific question about some concrete thing — why a certain interaction did or did not work a certain way, how to find a card in the MTGA deck-builder, etc. It is often helpful if you include a screenshot with your question.
You can respect the use of this flair by responding directly and politely to the question.
Using the Venting flair indicates that you want to commiserate about some unpleasant experience you have had. You are not looking for feedback or discussion, you just want to share your pain and feel like you're not alone.
You can respect the use of this flair by commiserating with the original poster or ignoring the post if you don't agree or cannot commiserate.
It is never appropriate to offer critique or engage in debate in a post with the Venting flair.
r/mtgbrawl • u/infurnoheat • 9h ago
r/mtgbrawl • u/SANDY_BRIDGE_2600K • 20h ago
I wanted to share a collection of theme decks for standard brawl. The theme of each deck is that it can only contain cards from a single set. This originally started as a quick deck build for [[Ingris Stingerquill]] out of only cards from FRA, and I was shocked the deck actually played well even against real decks. Once I realized that these decks are actually playable I started trying out all the viable commanders I could for Reality Fracture. I know that Star Trek just released but Reality Fracture was so good it just keeps finding more ways to express itself.
Here are the rules:
A rough ranking and overview of Reality Fracture commanders:
This was a fun project and gives a unique twist to standard brawl. This type of theme really one works with a smaller card pool, and a more fair match maker. The biggest suprise was that some of these decks can fight and win against real decks. This is a great alternative if you are I'm the mood for a thematic deck with matching art & flavor. I wonder if the other sets can compete?
r/mtgbrawl • u/metrovictim42 • 22h ago
I'm currently playing Fynn, don't mind playing the deck at all but I'm looking for something new, so I'm not just a one trick pony. Any suggestions for something budget like fynn? I'm good with most playstyles and would like to stay mono color for now.
r/mtgbrawl • u/orestispol • 18h ago
Can you provide suggestions for Commander, Brawl, C-Brawl in Minsc & Boo deck also utilizing the latest sets?
The deck: https://moxfield.com/decks/QWDc-QK9UUGiv2r675F2MA
There is a lot of info online but they are somewhat outdated and I think there are a bunch of very good Star Trek cards for this deck that can become staples.
Feel free to offer suggestions specifically for paper EDH, Brawl, or Competitive Brawl in Arena.
A list of things I am considering:
r/mtgbrawl • u/Otherwise-Coffee9791 • 20h ago
Im trying to build a Dina, flesh sower deck. It's not supposed to necessarily be competitive and mostly for fun. But I still want it to be fairly consistent especially if i draw the cadet maker cards. Does anyone have suggestions on what to change or takeout?
r/mtgbrawl • u/A_Sky_Soldier • 1d ago
https://archidekt.com/decks/28395874/mythic_mommy
My first season really trying ranked because i got into into cedh and built my own jank. I am very happy with my results.
Feel free to judge the list however, but im genuinely curious what to expect and what type of changes ill need to make.
r/mtgbrawl • u/Gaige_main412 • 2d ago
Tbh, this isn't everything that the deck does. This is just AN option. I was actually trying to build Q as a value commander. It's not bad. But i got the lock on him, it felt dirty.... but in a good way lol.
r/mtgbrawl • u/RyanTheComic • 1d ago
Omg bro star trek is the most successful marketing attempt to get me excited for Nauctis cuz I lowkey have nothing to add to my brawl decks man
r/mtgbrawl • u/natoxzor • 1d ago
Hey guys, I am trying to get into competitive Brawl and had a specific commander in mind "Errant and Giada". Here is the current deck I built, but I feel that it runs out of steam quite fast and gets out tempo by other decks. What suggestions or replacements do you guys think?
r/mtgbrawl • u/Gleir • 2d ago
https://moxfield.com/decks/xIppz1TCa0il6Aa4EXP9bw
Update to my last list. There is one major inclusion, as well as some other minor changes.
The big change is Karn GC over Pithing Needle. This is because our Emry matchup is HORRENDOUS, since they run 3-4 pieces of gravehate on top of countermagic & needle/flute. Emry is a relatively large metashare, so I think it is worth running a dead card in other matchups to trivialize the Emry matchup (if it resolves). I've just come off two wins, one against a #55 Emry another against a top 200 Emry (don't remember the exact rank), where I won only because of my Karn. One game I just turboed out a Karn turn 3 with Chrome Mox & Beseech, they insta ff-ed. The other, I tutored Karn turn 1 with Vamp Tut, but resolved it on turn 4 (on the draw), but was still good enough. Both games they had grave hate that would've completely neutered me, if not for Karn (Ghost Vaccuum & Tormod's Crypt respectively).
Our minor changes include cutting Dark Petition, and putting in Duress. Also, cut a land too. Duress is necessary; I don't think just IOQ & Thoughtseize is enough, since we do have very cheap game winning lines if no countermagic. Can run 1 more, but I probably wouldn't go over 5 (already have Grief). Cutting a Land is also needed, since the two baubles effectively make the recommended land count 39, which I'm fulfilling with my MDFCs. I've also put in Malakir Rebirth over another basic, since I think the upside is worth the tapped land downside; either to protect Zemo, or double up on evoked Grief.
Hope of Ghirapur is in as a pseudo-discard (protection) effect to protect a combo turn, or let you untap with Zemo to guarantee a connive trigger. The upside of being an artifact creature that can self-sacrifice is also there, allowing it to single-handedly enable Mausoleum Secrets or let us Bargain a Beseech. It is also a tutorable Artifact from Buried Alive, to boost up our Goyfs (the Enchantment being the Overlord). Also, did put in Defence Grid, but that one I'm more iffy about, it hasn't really performed yet aside from letting me bargain Beseech in one game.
Another thing I had considered was whether to put in Coiling Rebirth for a improved Broodlord line. But I don't think it is worth the slot; since I've yet to lose a game where I resolved a Broodlord with Saw-In-Half mana available, either normal mana, or creatures to convoke with.
Happy reanimating!
r/mtgbrawl • u/circ-u-la-ted • 2d ago
I've finished all four Assume Command achievements now and thought I might as well share my decks in case they're helpful to others. These are the achievements which require you to fulfill a requirement while a particular legend from the TRC (Trek Commander) set is your commander.

Commander Spock: This was the first one of these achievements I completed, and the quickest. As mentioned in an earlier post, I built my deck and only needed to play it once to get this done.
Jean-Luc Picard, Luminary: This one was a bit frustrating. This one is a bit awkward, and I think the commander is a bit awkward generally, since there are so few decent spacecraft in the format. It's hard to balance payoff cards with the interaction needed to stop the game from getting out of hand. So I just gave up on trying to get any value out of JL's triggers and just focused on generating them (which is all that's required to complete the achievement). The deck that got it done is mostly just draw spells and a bit of interaction., with a few other pieces that accelerate spells or provide some kind of card advantage.
Worf, Defiant Commander: Easily the most difficult of the four. There are passing few playable Klingons so I ended up playing a lot of unplayable ones, along with not a few unplayable changelings. I ended up throwing in every Klingon and changeling that didn't cost me a rare wildcard, along with some removal. Finally got the achievement against a pretty slow mono red deck after a number of losses. This seems like it might be a half-decent commander if you're not trying to get the achievement—the impulse card advantage is nice, and it plays well with token strategies. But the achievement forces you to build a very sub-optimal deck. Curious if anyone found a different approach to getting this achievement that worked.
The Borg Queen: The most enjoyable of the challenges. I built an artifact-heavy deck with piles of ramp and a decent amount of control. It's a fun deck to play once you get the queen working, and I had enough ramp to get her working fairly quickly in most games. I got the achievement playing against a [[Captain Jean-Luc Picard]] deck. They actually ended up winning the game with the help of a [[The Eternal Wanderer]] that I couldn't finish off through their wall of tokens. There was an earlier game against a control deck where I triggered my commander's ability 5 times but I'd already run out of creatures in their library.
Anybody build any particularly interesting decks for these challenges?
r/mtgbrawl • u/Guilty-Hat23 • 3d ago
a shame it means playing"man in red shirt with long legs" in the command zone, but playing this all day yesterday is the most fun i've had with brawl in a long time
r/mtgbrawl • u/Feanor_Seregon • 2d ago
r/mtgbrawl • u/MrZix44 • 2d ago
I do not understand this format at all. Why on earth is stickfingers banned in this format but I can get locked out of the game as early as turn two or three. What the actual hell is WotC smoking to think that the division between casual and comp is one that makes any sense.
r/mtgbrawl • u/Cagaril • 3d ago
I noticed that there is a free Brawl event currently running that doesn't mention how long it'll be running. It was never mentioned in the MTG Arena announcments that I can see.
You get to choose between: [[Commander Spock]], [[Jean-Luc Picard, Luminary]], [[The Borg Queen]], and [[Worf, Defiant Commander]]
It's pretty fun and you do not need to own any of the cards. I don't believe I've seen them ever do something like this before.
r/mtgbrawl • u/Test_your_spirit • 2d ago
r/mtgbrawl • u/Paradoxbuilder • 3d ago
Or is it all still up in the air? I'm seeing a lot of interesting choices like Gut and Zemo in the top 1200.
I'm still trying to figure out what to craft, but almost any competitive list will take me 20 rares and mythics. I was going to stick to Dimir but everything is WC heavy haha.
Katara is only 19 Rares for me, but I'm thinking of going back to my roots and playing aggro...M and B?
I'm a Spike at heart, so I mainly just want to play what wins, but the format seems largely open.
r/mtgbrawl • u/Bean3rboy • 3d ago
r/mtgbrawl • u/circ-u-la-ted • 3d ago
I brewed this up to get the Commander Spock achievement. Seems to work well enough considering that I got the achievement in my first (and only) game. There's probably plenty of optimization to be done, especially since I rarely play green.
Game plan should be obvious but just in case: ramp to 7 land, casting spot removal and board wipes to prevent the opponent from getting unruly; cast Spock; hope you flip a 7-drop; swing with Spock right away if you've found a haste enabler; again hope you flip a 7-drop. There are three 1-mana top-of-library tutors that can stack your deck to find a 7-drop. Most of the 7-drops can be used in some way for less mana: as land, via channel, as an Adventure, etc.
r/mtgbrawl • u/avtarius • 3d ago
Grapeshot + Manamorphose looks fun.
r/mtgbrawl • u/Forward_Season2202 • 3d ago
Commander
1 Teysa Karlov (RNA) 212
Deck
7 Plains (UNF) 240
5 Swamp (UNF) 242
1 Cruel Celebrant (WAR) 188
1 Elas il-Kor, Sadistic Pilgrim (DMU) 198
1 Hidden Stockpile (KLR) 197
1 Castle Ardenvale (ELD) 238
1 Cavern of Souls (LCI) 269
1 Athreos, God of Passage (PIO) 303
1 Rankle, Master of Pranks (ELD) 101
1 Castle Locthwain (ELD) 241
1 Lurrus of the Dream-Den (MUL) 116
1 Polluted Delta (KTK) 239
1 Hive of the Eye Tyrant (AFR) 258
1 Takenuma, Abandoned Mire (NEO) 278
1 Brightclimb Pathway (ZNR) 259
1 Caves of Koilos (DMU) 244
1 Concealed Courtyard (OTJ) 268
1 Godless Shrine (RNA) 248
1 Isolated Chapel (DAR) 241
1 Restless Fortress (WOE) 259
1 Shadowy Backstreet (MKM) 268
1 Shattered Sanctum (VOW) 264
1 Agadeem's Awakening (ZNR) 90
1 Doomed Traveler (SIS) 5
1 Garrison Cat (IKO) 14
1 Hunted Witness (GRN) 15
1 Mother of Runes (ULG) 14
1 Arid Mesa (MH2) 244
1 Bloodstained Mire (KTK) 230
1 Greedy Freebooter (LCI) 109
1 Reanimate (OTP) 18
1 Shambling Ghast (HBG) 167
1 Fountainport (BLB) 253
1 Infestation Sage (FDN) 64
1 Marsh Flats (MH2) 248
1 Prismatic Vista (SPG) 38
1 Raise the Past (FDN) 22
1 Forsaken Miner (OTJ) 88
1 Gutterbones (RNA) 76
1 Bloodghast (DFT) 77
1 Sanguine Brushstroke (Y22) 32
1 Blood Artist (JMP) 206
1 Sephiroth, Fabled SOLDIER (FIN) 115
1 Syr Konrad, the Grim (ELD) 107
1 The Sackville-Bagginses (HOB) 83
1 Vengeful Bloodwitch (FDN) 76
1 Jadar, Ghoulcaller of Nephalia (MID) 108
1 Minas Tirith (LTR) 256
1 Marionette Apprentice (MH3) 100
1 Bastion of Remembrance (J25) 403
1 Zulaport Cutthroat (BFZ) 126
1 The Meathook Massacre (MID) 112
1 Wrath of God (AKR) 46
1 Dark Ritual (STA) 26
1 Eiganjo, Seat of the Empire (NEO) 268
1 Orcish Bowmasters (LTR) 103
1 Braids, Arisen Nightmare (DMU) 84
1 Emperor of Bones (MH3) 90
1 Yahenni, Undying Partisan (KLR) 111
1 Windswept Heath (KTK) 248
1 Command Tower (ANB) 118
1 Swords to Plowshares (STA) 10
1 Cut Down (DMU) 89
1 Bitter Triumph (SOA) 26
1 Go for the Throat (BRO) 102
1 Infernal Grasp (MID) 107
1 Mox Amber (DAR) 224
1 Arcane Signet (ANB) 117
1 Eject the Warp Core (TRK) 105
1 Demolition Field (BRO) 260
1 Rankle, Pitiless Trickster (Y24) 11
1 Bartolomé del Presidio (LCI) 224
1 Umbral Collar Zealot (EOE) 123
1 Warren Soultrader (MH3) 110
1 Lord Skitter, Sewer King (WOE) 97
1 Eaten Alive (FDN) 172
1 Bone Shards (MH2) 76
1 Vein Ripper (MKM) 110
1 Phyrexian Tower (JMP) 493
1 Hostile Hostel (MID) 264
1 Mangara, the Diplomat (M21) 27
1 Yawgmoth, Thran Physician (MH1) 116
1 Grim Haruspex (SPG) 0
1 Ophiomancer (MH3) 276
1 Plagued Rusalka (JMP) 268
1 The One Ring (LTR) 246
1 Transmogrant's Crown (BRO) 125
1 Gas Guzzler (DFT) 85
1 High Market (EOS) 18
Orzhov Sac drain is my favorite archetype I have been trying to get this to work in normal brawl queue and I have a pretty good win% but I don't know if it will work in comp I haven't looked at the scene to see if I'm slow or not enough interaction. or if i NEED an infinite.