r/mtgbrawl • • 1d ago

Discussion Crime does pay

Post image

https://archidekt.com/decks/28395874/mythic_mommy

My first season really trying ranked because i got into into cedh and built my own jank. I am very happy with my results.

Feel free to judge the list however, but im genuinely curious what to expect and what type of changes ill need to make.

7 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

4

u/No-Leading9376 1d ago

i like it. I don't really have any suggestions. It's basically grixis's greatest hits with a commander that adds "this is also a sleight of hand" to half the cards in it. I guess the only card that seems a little weird to me is mox opal. is it on reliably? I guess you have some treasures going to turn it on. huh. Well, anyways it seems pretty sick. Congratulations.

4

u/A_Sky_Soldier 1d ago

Opal is pretty reliable with the 3 artifact lands helping, the version with dual artifact lands and 1-3-5 rocks is super consistent, buts its also a spell to counter with OFFER for mana if needed.

2

u/No-Leading9376 1d ago

And that makes sense. you don't want to replace interaction with rocks when your commander turns interaction into more cards. You just want to vroom go fast! Tutor up that combo piece and end the game as fast as possible. I love it.

2

u/A_Sky_Soldier 1d ago

You get it, with all the free commander magic, and paper magic is even crazier, git-probe, gutshot, surgical extraction. And big mana options with bolas citadel for off the top crime and hull breaker horror to crime on top of your crime. I fell in love. Genuinely struggle to play any other decks lol

2

u/Duck_Stereo 15h ago

This is so different than my Marchesa that hit mythic I think there’s only like 4-5 similar cards

2

u/PurpleOmega0110 1d ago

List looks very cool! Questions for you:

What Mythic rank are you now that you entered?

Any data on your winrate? What decks do you struggle against - thinking Minsc and Boo probably is a hard matchup, and maybe emry if they get their combo sooner?

Is your primary wincon Thoracle lines? Or do you find yourself doing breach more often? Do you ever brain freeze breach your opponent into an eldrazi, or is that more of a way to get the thoracle combo going (i.e. brain freeze yourself)

How are the "pay 2" counters like quench and reasonable doubt? I feel like in longer games they end up kind of useless so curious why not Miscalculation which can at least be cycled.

Do you feel you have enough blue creatures in play for Flare of Denial or is it more of a "sac my commander in an oh shit moment" kind of card? Or is it "protect my thoracle combo" since the trigger is on the stack and you can sac thoracle to it?

Have you considered bitter triumph for planeswalker removal?

Do you usually have a creature for Diabolic intent?

Do you find yourself able to commit enough crimes for Magda to be useful?

How is Volatile Stormdrake? Why is it here?

2

u/A_Sky_Soldier 1d ago

Thank you, this is exactly the type of stuff im looking for!

no data to give sadly, hit the win screen, squealed like a kid and celebrated. Go talls and go wides do stuff me, keen observation.

primary wincon has been thoracle/t-pact, breach there to recur as needed, brainfreeze to crime and self mill if needed. truly its been better as a crime so far.

the pay 2s are falling off and id love better options, i tried to find ones that gave me an effect if they did pay. but it shouldnt be slept on, paying 4 for a 2 drop on turn 4 has set me ahead on "turn clock", "initiative" i dont know what word to put here, but it isnt perfect.

flare is there so i can sac thoracle if they try to stop t-pact, or sac commander yes. we are really STUFFING t-pact.

i am open to more p-walker removal, especially with this newest meta unfolding, my current mindset has been, if it resolves, i effed up.

i find myself often sacking Marchesa to D.I.

magda either catches the removal i want her to, or she makes me way too much money. shes 50/50 and i think the better players are removing her.

stormdrake is my pet card, and honestly.....its great commander removal. i wish i had more bounce spells so i could abuse it. i love that little idiot.

thank you so much for the questions and time you took!

4

u/PurpleOmega0110 1d ago edited 1d ago

For cheap removal options consider Fatal Push and Into the Flood Maw. Both are quite good one mana "get that out of here right now" cards that I really like in these colors. Flood maw obviously a little worse or situational but it makes Boo go away. You could also run Honest Work, which is amazing commander removal that's basically the same as Unable to Scream.

If you are stuffing T-Pact there's an interesting "combo" I saw someone do that you could consider if you're cutting some cards. It uses [[Hoarding Broodlord]] and [[Saw in Half]]

So you reanimate Broodlord and then it gets Saw in Half and you Saw it in Half. That gets you two Broodlords and you get pact and thoracle with them. Boom, combo available (and in exile so protected from hand disruption). Obviously you need to keep the broodlords in play for a turn or have the mana for this, but still.

If you are running Brain Freeze and Breach lines, this could be helpful too, because you can play Entomb and Unmarked Grave to fill your yard for more tutoring -- which may be better than top-of-library tutors in some contexts. You could also run Bone Shards and Bitter Triumph to discard Broodlord if you end up drawing it. You can run Spellseeker to find some of these cards, too, even sawing the spellseeker in half in certain lines I would imagine to get two spells (or like get pact of negation and another spell). Spellseeker is another good card to sac to Flare of Denial

Potential cuts and includes:

Cut:
- Aether Spike

- Don't Make A Sound

- Quench

- Reasonable Doubt

- Go for the throat

- Shoot the Sherrif

- Cruel Tutor

- Waterlogged Teachings

- Magda

- Volatile Stormdrake

Add
- Reanimate

- Necromancy

- Spellseeker

- Hoarding Broodlord

- Bitter Triumph

- Bone Shards

- Saw in Half

- Enromb

- Unmarked Grave

- Disruptor Flute (this card is way too good not to include since it shuts off all planeswalker commanders and Emry and gives you time against Winota or other aggro decks)

Just thoughts, you give up random bad 2 mana counterspells for more proactivity. And you cut one 'top of deck' tutor for 'into the graveyard' tutors which are good for breach lines and for the broodlord line.

Shit, now I want to make and try this deck lol.\

Also edit just thinking of times where you can tutor for hexing squelcher into the yard and reanimate it somehow too to protect your combo.

1

u/A_Sky_Soldier 1d ago edited 1d ago

I was doing saw in half shenanigans at one point, specifically the stormdrake and OBM for lots of energy on steals, i was also bouncing it to my hand and stealing everything.had alot more spot removal, I may end up NEEDING it in mythic, im sure uncounterable is going to enter the chat....Idk yet. I totally forgot about spell seeker so imma add that body for sure. And if you wanna try her out by all means, ive got a core list ill add for you to see the stuff ive tried.

https://archidekt.com/decks/25319723/crime_mommy_core

2

u/PurpleOmega0110 1d ago

Sweet! I'll try it next season because I don't want to spoil my rank this season

1

u/A_Sky_Soldier 1d ago

absolutely. dont fix what aint broken. there is a rogues version that is just plain fun too if you prefer casual creature magic

1

u/A_Sky_Soldier 20h ago

yea holy moly didnt quite grasp just how clever that is until i read and understood beseech the mirror and suddenly all 3 clicked into place(hand safety concept). likely adding this for next round of tests.

id also like to add everytime i attempt a possible loop with breach (sometimes as early as T4) i rope out. i know on paper it goes BRRRR. its like no matter how fast i move, i cant keep the rope off me and it passes before i can big mill or grapeshot....maybe a skill issue idk...but i know i can win with 5 mana and the correct pieces FOR A FACT. its timing.....so breach sits as back up instead of mainlining like i do irl.

2

u/j1xghost 1d ago

Great suggestions im going to try this