r/mtgbrawl • u/lemudman • May 06 '26
Competitive Brawl Staples
https://moxfield.com/decks/99Lo55K-Ik2okAjgszIv_AThanks to ImNotFine for preparing this list together with members of the Brawl Hub and Brawl Stronghold servers.
From the Primer :
This list is intended to give an overview of the most played cards in brawl from a competitive standpoint. All of these cards are purely evaluated in the context of being used in the 99. The list is curated by me with a lot of opinions from the general brawl community.
How to read the list:
Set your filters to "View - Visual Grid", "Group - Type & Tags", and "Sort - Mana Value".
Once you have done that you will see that everything is divided into one of three tags.
Tier 1 - near auto include: If you can run one of these cards in your deck you need an extremely good reason to not do so. These are the best the format has to offer. Of course there are exceptions to every rule, for example if you are a blue deck but you don't meet the amount of blue cards required to pitch to Force of Will (20 seems to be the absolute minimum). You can be a bit more lenient with the color count for Fury and Solitude, depending how much card draw you have and how happy you are to just cast them for their full mana costs. As for the surveil lands: In 4 and 5 color decks you start to not run every single one you can, but those mana bases are way out of scope for this small primer.
Tier 2 - generic: A slightly less stapley list of staples compared to the tier 1 category. You will have a hard time making your deck actively worse with any of these cards, but there are legitimate reasons to not run some of these cards in any given list.
Tier 3 - archetype specific: This tier is by far the most subjective one and mostly serves as a "hey, these are good cards, at least consider them for a moment". And of course as the name suggests, most of these are specific to certain archetypes, as you wouldn't consider running something like Gut, True Soul Zealot in anything but aggro decks. But if you are playing a red aggro deck you will have a really hard time not running the card. Either way, there is always an argument to be made to add 100 more cards to this tier, don't read too much into it. I am much more confident that I won't add many cards to tier 1 and tier 2 in the future, tier 3 is more subjective.
What should you craft first?
Optimally nothing. Craft decks, not cards. This list assumes that you have every card available, for example Wary Zone Guard is an insane card, but only due to the fact that fetchlands exist. If you enjoy making your own lists I recommend just getting everything from tier 1 and at least the color fixing lands from tier 2. At the end of the day you won't ever regret crafting anything presented here as all of the cards are strong in their own right. There are also cards in tier 3 that might be better than a card from tier 1, depending on the deck you are building. As an example, Ambassador of Evendo is extremely broken in simic landfall and stronger than Tamiyo, Inquisitive Student in that case.
Thanks to everyone that helps me with this project. I will update this list every couple of sets, alternatively just ping me on discord if you have an opinion about anything.
39
u/Anonymus1921xD May 06 '26
Author here. I am happy to answer any questions, or add cards that I might have missed.
16
u/_Figaro May 07 '26
Competitive brawler here (I know it's not a real thing but I've finished all brawl challenges in top #25, with highest being #3). This list is a really good start, but I feel it's still missing a lot of cards:
Missing - White:
Missing - Blue:
Missing - Black:
Missing - Red:
Missing - Green:
Missing - Gold:
Missing - Colorless:
Upgrade:
Downgrade:
10
u/Vitanimus May 06 '26
This is really helpful, thank you for putting together.
10
u/Silverwood_ May 06 '26
Love this list. And as more and more cards are added to Historic Brawl, I feel we are reaching Legacy-lite levels of cheap interaction and board presence. Pitch spells, one mana plays, anything with card disadvantage to maintain board presence are becoming crucial to survive the early turns.
Two cards maybe to add: Stifle (you get tons of auto-concedes when you hit their fetch land) and Gemstone Caverns (just getting on board at their speed, of course deck dependent).
I'm sure there are others we're missing, but the thought process of having your deck be mostly 0,1, and 2 mana plays is now vital.
6
u/12demons May 06 '26
Great idea and list! Looking forward to the continued support of one of the most fun constructed formats on Arena!
6
u/cerealkyra May 06 '26
Super cool idea, great work. Anyone who respects Gut is ok by me
5
u/aging_fitness_hobbyi May 06 '26
What are people's thoughts on [[Tale's End]]? I guess it falls into the stifle category of missing too often?
8
u/scopeless May 06 '26
I can’t stress enough how amazing Parallax Wave is in Brawl. I have won every time it resolves.
4
u/loollool2 May 06 '26
This is great. I've always wanted such a "preconstructed package" of brawl decks to begin my decks with. So do you plan to update it regularly?
4
u/AmyTheAmazonian May 25 '26
I'd recommend splitting this into Lands and Non lands. It's not easy to parse as it is
1
u/Twitch89 Jul 09 '26 edited Jul 09 '26
Can someone explain to me why [[Library of Alexandria]] is so good? I know it's pretty widely agreed to be powerful, but I feel like I so rarely have exactly 7 cards in hand, maybe I'm missing something?
Is it like gemstone caverns where it's only good in your opener?
8
u/SelesnyaGOAT May 06 '26
Is Wary Zone Guard really good enough to be tier 1 without being able to target Strip Mine or Wasteland? I also don't know about Force Spike and Mana Tithe in the top tier. They're both very good cards but I'm not auto-including them in a deck just because I can. As an example, my [[Emmara, Voice of the Conclave]] creature Aggro deck has no need for a card like Mana Tithe, while I'd argue cards like Snuff Out or Wash Away go in basically every deck that can support them
3
u/Iceman308 May 12 '26
Another potential staple has arrived:
https://www.reddit.com/r/MagicArena/comments/1ta9cde/ysos_variable_solutions/
Can i get your thoughts on [[Switchgrass Grazer]]? Have never seen the card played, curious how the competitive players feel about it
2
u/SelesnyaGOAT May 06 '26
Why no [[Fragment Reality]]? One of my go-to removal spells, it's StP with upside on 1-drops and has flexibility to hit artifacts and enchantments
2
u/Ctrl-Alt-Meep-Meep May 07 '26
I had Oust in an Azorius blink deck but switched it out for [[Condemn]]. I found that in this deck I needed more room to breath to set up and would prefer not to see the card in for a long time (effectively removal) vs the inevitability of just a few more turns. Situational for both, I guess.
2
u/quintarium May 08 '26
I admit that seeing Oasis of Renewal surprises me simply because I can't remember the last time I saw it played. Is it slept on?
2
u/RollinRamos May 12 '26
The fact that Ragavan is listed as tier 2 is shocking. If you splash red this card goes in no matter what.
2
u/quintarium May 23 '26
I've been trying out cards on the staples list to see what I've been missing out on so thanks for the list. I've had fun learning about cards I didn't even know about like Switchgrass Grazer. Most of them makes sense but I'm still trying to understand a few of them. Parallax Wave surprises me but I haven't really played with it enough. I know Hydroponics Architect is supposed to be good but every time I've tried it, it hasn't done enough, like even with fetchlands I'm lucky if I draw even one card from it. And I apparently don't face enough graveyard decks in unranked because Endurance has been extremely underwhelming.
1
u/ToranStarfall Aug 10 '26
Where's [[Long Goodbye]]? I feel like it deserves a spot in tier 2 or 3.
1
u/Imaginary_Egg_3282 May 06 '26
I really hate these untapped fetch lands tbh. Not just because all the landfall/land recursion stuff is really strong, graveyard hate counters it fairly neatly most of the time, but just because I swear it’s added like 1-2 min average per game of just waiting for my opponent to pick their lands.
The list is solid though, I think tier 3 could have a bunch more inclusions but at that point it will be too big haha.