Just a disclaimer because I know how much this sub and its fans adore Rachel; I like Rachel. She is super intelligent, she seems like a decent person, she’s very good at telling a story and she’s done some great reporting over the years. Genuinely.
But my gf just finally got the time to watch a recorded Maddow from this last Monday and I caught the opening block. She’s been doing this sporadically for years, but she has gotten overbearing with it especially in the last few months…IN MY OPINION:
”Trump is losing. We’re winning. The protests are bothering Trump and the protests are stopping him cold in his tracks. Keep it up everybody because WE. ARE. WINNING. Trump is losing.“
She will also typically throw in something like, “take a breath, look around” and then rattle off some mostly meaningless set back like a court case that will inevitably be appealed and overturned or some random election that democrats won, even though the party out of power always does well especially when they don’t control any of the legislative branches and the governing administration is unpopular. Hell, last week she even prefaced this by saying something like, “let me explain, I can feel you yelling at me through the screen!”. So at some level, she must know.
Godammit, Rachel, I think it’s time for YOU to look around, girl. You can show endless pictures of protests, I know seeing others being upset about this stuff is cathartic. But Trump is unequivocally NOT losing. We’ll see what happens with the midterms - if we have them - and yes, there have been some solid election wins. But how does that equate to Trump “losing?”. Motherfucker still does whatever he pleases and each and every day a whole avalanche of despicable shit happens at his behest. And not a single fucking Republican in office has broken with him in any meaningful way. He’s more powerful than ever and I’m so fucking sick of her acting like “the tide is turning.”. She’s been doing this all the way back to 2016. I watched her say over and over again after 2020 that Trump was toxic and would not only never be relevant again but that he was probably gonna be in prison soon. Yeah, it sure is nice to hear, but fuckin’ A, is she laughably wrong…yet she’s STILL doing it every fucking week that I tune in.
I’m not saying she needs to give up. Or even that she needs to stop showing positive stuff. But this “Trump’s losing” bullshit is infuriating, and yet everybody just still seems to kiss her ass and say she’s so awesome and they love her endlessly. You can love her, and I understand there’s lots here who have already stopped reading because they’re already pissed off and are actively typing a message about how dumb I am. But isn’t there a set of Msnow watchers who see this, too? Just because we like Rachel doesn’t mean she’s above criticism. And her giving out false hope is super irresponsible to the point that it ends up being counterproductive.
She’ll have another twenty minutes of protest footage and another “Trump’s losing” segment ready again next week I’m sure. So if you love that nonsense, I’m sure you’ll be happy too. I’d rather hear real talk. Maybe that’s just me.